Keldon & Herro did did not look anything like pros vs Auburn & in the tourney. The Auburn guards did look like pros evidenced by the bitchslapping they gave KJ & Herro.
SGA choked in 2018 against Kansas State, but it didn't hurt his stock.
I get both arguments. I'm just tired of losing any player of substance that our team features. To be honest, none of our returning guys showed me anything of substance last season (IQ, Baker, Hagans, Nick, EJ). We can talk about how great it is to get those guys back, and I hope they improve, but can anyone honestly look me in the face and tell me they performed better than most of the rotation returners for most other SEC teams? Their Mickey D credentials don't mean squat at this point.
Even PJ returning last year wasn't much of an incredible moment for our fan base because we knew he was probably getting drafted in the 50s last year. He might have even went undrafted like Gabriel.
The bottom line is that we haven't returned a kid who was projected in the top 40 of the draft the year he returned since Willie Cauley Stein back in 2014. That's a long damn time ago and it's why portions of the base, while understanding the Cal is right for the job, have also turned into cynics regarding player retention.
Deferring their "dreams" for one season would give UK a real title shot and allow some of these guys to improve. Seeing that none of that matters to the players is the type of thing that hollows out a fan base's optimism over time.