one and dones

mrdavisanddd

All-Conference
Feb 5, 2006
3,275
4,086
113
IKC, there are a lot of teams that don't recruit all players that leave in one year and still make the Tournament. If a player is a First round pick, maybe he should go, but if he's a 2nd round pick, it might be better to stay another year. Don't you think Briscoe did the right thing, by coming back?

OLD STOLL FIELD GUY!
You are correct recruiting like that you could make the tournament a lot of teams do but making the tournament here will get you fired you have to have a good chance to win it just read some of the posts in this thread , hell apparently we've never had a coach that could make a lot of these people happy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

mdlUK.1

Heisman
Dec 23, 2002
29,712
57,543
0
Haven't seen anyone post which of our 5 stars they would have passed on.

T Jones

WCS

The Harrison's

A Poythress

Willis

Hawkins

T Ullis

D Miller

Just a few multi year players.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

lkc1021

All-Conference
Apr 12, 2007
6,985
1,650
0
Let's see, in the seven years Coach Cal has been here, U Conn has won 2 NC's, Duke has won 2 NC's, Nova has won 1 NC, Loserville has won 1 NC, and UK has won 1 NC.
UK has had the No. 1 recruiting class all 7 years according to Scout, and 6 of the 7 according to Rivals.
Pointing out the facts, DOES NOT mean I want to get rid of Coach Cal, as some on here will start posting. It would be nice to recruit some high 4's who would stay more then one year to go with our "One and Done."

OLD STOLL FIELD GUY!
So where are the 3 and 4 star recruits that are playing for Duke? What about all the 300 other colleges that have all those 3 and 4 star recruits. How many titles have they won? How many final fours have they made in the last 7 years. So let's go back to recruiting like Billy G and maybe we can make the NIT once in a while. I like the idea of knowing that every year we are in the discussion with a chance to make a final four. Name one coach that has a better record of making final fours in the last seven years. You can't because there is none. You are just jealous because your team does not have the record in the last seven years that UK has. Good luck trying to sell your lemonade.
 

poppycat

All-Conference
Sep 23, 2006
3,757
1,467
0
The problem isn't the recruiting it's not being able to keep guys around who have no business putting their names in the draft

No business being in the draft says who?

The stigma on "being left behind" weighs heavily on some
"not ready yet" 1st/2nd year players.

Some like Teague and D.Johnson (IMO) could have helped
both UK and themselves with another year in college,
 
  • Like
Reactions: willievic

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
21,025
45,244
113
The stigma on "being left behind" weighs heavily on some
"not ready yet" 1st/2nd year players.

Some like Teague and D.Johnson (IMO) could have helped
both UK and themselves with another year in college,
Cal clearly tells them to stay if he thinks they aren't ready. It's their decision and a free country.
 

stoneycat_20

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2003
24,212
4,344
0
I'd like to see Cal bring in a couple 3-4 year guys that are very good college players that the NBA is not crazy about..someone like an undersized 5 like Meeks at UNC or the Purdue kid..maybe an Allen at Duke ..someone that has a flaw ..I'm just not sure we can win a title with 5 freshman each year..Next year will be younger than this one.
 

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
21,025
45,244
113
I'd like to see Cal bring in a couple 3-4 year guys that are very good college players that the NBA is not crazy about..someone like an undersized 5 like Meeks at UNC or the Purdue kid..maybe an Allen at Duke ..someone that has a flaw ..I'm just not sure we can win a title with 5 freshman each year..Next year will be younger than this one.
Hindsight is 20/20 but I would have rather had Swanigan than Skal as it turns out. Not every player is going to turnout like we think though.
 

Bellcat70

Junior
Sep 10, 2016
383
302
0
To me it's a two edge sword. One edge; How can you pass on the top talent and let your rivals divy them up? Answer: you can't. Any coach in his right mind will and should take the best talent that he can get.

The other edge; How difficult will it be to take the top but less experience players and get them to gel as a team? Answer: Somewhat to very difficult, but Cal is the best at it, although it doesn't happen every year. Its really a roll of the dice, but I really like our odds.

Before Cal got here with his "system", we were trending down to being a mediocre program. When he left Memphis, he told his team that U.K. was his dream job? Why? It was and is the pinnacle of CBB. Since his arrival, we are the most talked team in CBB. We are an elite program, with the most wins in CBB, and 2nd in titles.

Even when other top teams are playing, Big Blue comes up in the conversation. Big Blue nation could be a country of its own. I know we all want more than talk about the team. We want banners, and so does every other team in CBB. We will get ours!

Everybody can talk about that we should have more titles with the talent that we get, but there are so many variables that come into play, biggest of all is that you are dealing with 18-20 year old kids, who are still trying to figure themselves out. Root em on and cheer em up.

That's all I have to say about that.
 

stoneycat_20

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2003
24,212
4,344
0
Cal knows almost all the guys he brings in are OAD....I'd like a few mixed in that have an NBA flaw, maybe undersized,,too heavy,,something that the NBA doesn't like, but are good 3-4 year starters.I thought we had our 4 year PG in 5'7 Ulis
 

chattanoogawildcat

All-American
Jan 21, 2005
17,470
7,703
0
Love Kentucky basketball and was so happy when Cal came to coach. I still admire him but wish we could change the recruiting. Would love to see players stay so that we, the fans, could feel a real kinship with them...our boys, so to speak. I miss those days when we knew the guys and looked forward to seeing them back the next year.
All opposing fans wish this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

dstroya

Freshman
Jan 28, 2016
71
71
0
How many high 3-4 stars are willing to come off the bench their first 2-3 years and maybe get a chance to start as a senior when they can go somewhere else and not worry about a new #1 class coming in every year. Not very many. Plus whenever a player stays more than one year here there are morons who say they suck, case in point Briscoe this year people want him benched.
The twins get blamed for not winning in 15 which is bs, sometimes the best team doesn't win. Alex P was called inconsistent, a waste and a no heart player. Saw Willie called disappeario. Lee was constantly ridiculed until he left then people talked about how he was the missing piece. So with a fan base like ours, spoiled, even if you had other than O&Ds there would be those who not be happy.
 

MakinMusic_rivals

All-Conference
Mar 21, 2006
10,724
3,609
66
This is one area that doesn't really bother me. I feel a bond with these kids even in one year. They are in the Kentucky family. Is it nice to have a player or two stay....yes. I want the best players.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Viper1996

CHAMPCAT11

All-American
Jun 16, 2009
10,001
7,566
0
Whatever his paycheck is, it's a bargain. Now Pimptino on the other hand, who has one legit final four and no noncheating titles in 16 years at UL, has been severely overpaid.

Can't agree with you on this. 8 million plus dollars A YEAR to coach any sport is just wrong. I know he can get it and don't blame him for getting as much as he can but no human on this planet is truly worth 8 mil a year. Rip me if you like but I stand by my comment.
 

MegaBlue05

Heisman
Mar 8, 2014
11,133
22,623
66
 
  • Like
Reactions: blubo

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
21,025
45,244
113
Can't agree with you on this. 8 million plus dollars A YEAR to coach any sport is just wrong. I know he can get it and don't blame him for getting as much as he can but no human on this planet is truly worth 8 mil a year. Rip me if you like but I stand by my comment.
It's the market. And his monetary value and return to UK far exceeds his salary.
 

CatFanInTheBathtub

All-Conference
Jan 1, 2009
5,558
1,124
0
No business being in the draft says who?
well you might have got me. No business maybe wasn't the best phrase. Our guys who have left to play D league or overseas are still making more than an average American could hope for. For now.

A good question though is did they maximize their value ? Maybe some have but others maybe not. I guess what I meant is that there have been guys who have left when coming back probably would have increased their earning potential. Teague, Lamb, Goodwin, Johnson, to name a few.

Either way my original point is that the OP is way off. The recruiting is fine, absolutely astounding really.

The problem IMO is the culture being created. Similarly talented players at other schools are not leaving as early. I don't want unreasonable expectations for UK but at the same time I'd love to be the gold standard and it's pretty much proven itself that it's not going to happen with a team full of freshmen.
 

Molardawg2

All-Conference
Sep 22, 2006
1,631
1,378
61
Just my useless opinion but the game needs everyone to play until their jr year. Otherwise let them go straight out of highschool to the pros like they used to.
 

Snarks

All-American
Jan 31, 2005
8,548
6,975
93
Yeah, I really miss the Tubby years! Going to the occasional elite eight was a blast with seniors.
 

sefus12

Heisman
Dec 22, 2007
7,193
19,103
103
Cal knows almost all the guys he brings in are OAD....I'd like a few mixed in that have an NBA flaw, maybe undersized,,too heavy,,something that the NBA doesn't like, but are good 3-4 year starters.I thought we had our 4 year PG in 5'7 Ulis

And now he's making millions. How dare he!?!?
 

UKWildcats#8

All-American
Jun 25, 2011
30,327
9,338
0
Not really, I am not basing this on talent but play. Right now this team has no identity nor guts on defense. I think in a one game winner take all right now this team would lose to said squad.

And the team you mentioned socks and has no chemistry
 

jopo

Redshirt
May 21, 2002
2,865
19
0
We've had more elite players with Cal than anyone has ever had. (my opinion).
In 1945-1950 we had more skilled and All Americans then or will ever again have. UK had 2 or 3 previous All Americas on the bench. One of them had made all America twice. His name was Jim Jordan. I think 1-2 had made it at UK before entering the War.
I like Cal: Keep him as long as he will stay,
 
Feb 21, 2006
8,403
9,162
0
All you need to know about college basketball today and what OAD has done is that they are selling the coaches on the marquee.

Come one come all, see John Calipari potty train some kids nobody knows yet but maybe 6 years down the road they'll be a max contract face of some crappy franchise that won't make the playoffs and who nobody stays up late enough to watch...

Don't miss a chance to see K, he's getting close to retiring...

Look, Roy had an episode again...come see him next time out...

Rick Pitino...watch him squat in a nice Italian suit...maybe if you're lucky you'll get to see him act real tough with some opposing fans after the game...

Folks don't miss out on an opportunity to see Bill Self, have we mentioned that he wins his conference every year...
 

StubbornPenny

All-American
Nov 2, 2009
10,562
9,892
0
Some people just cannot resist being stupid. What more proof do you need than the most wins, most tournament wins, highest winning percentage, most final fours, and one title? Titles are rare, people. In fact, you should be looking less at the one title and more at how absurd it is that he's racked up so many Final Fours. Took two teams there that honestly had no business making it that far.

We have had a legit shot every year but one (two maybe) out of 8. You can't ask for anything better than that, and anything better than that is a lucky fall of the dice.

If you don't like the roster churn, then okay. That's legit. But you'd have to take that 6/8 legit shots and make it about 2/10, because that's generally the rate at which elite teams have a shot. That's a 75% rate of elite teams versus a 20% rate. Do you want to do that? WHY? So you don't have to remember new uniform numbers?

Don't come in acting like this way doesn't work at all, or that he can't coach... who even cares? RESULTS. HE HAS THEM.
 

Pygmy Sasquatch

Heisman
Mar 27, 2009
9,655
10,527
113
Love Kentucky basketball and was so happy when Cal came to coach. I still admire him but wish we could change the recruiting. Would love to see players stay so that we, the fans, could feel a real kinship with them...our boys, so to speak. I miss those days when we knew the guys and looked forward to seeing them back the next year.

"If you're old school and you've been following college basketball and you liked it as kids staying in school four years, and all that, then you'd probably say this has ruined what my game used to look like. Well the world has changed. It's changed in the NBA, it's changed in Europe, the game has changed the world has changed,"

Linky
 

BBNinSCar

All-Conference
Apr 23, 2013
1,593
2,790
81
I've always thought that the thing that goes unnoticed around the country is the quality of players that Cal has recruited to Kentucky.
I'm not talking about basketball skills but more quality of the person that wears our blue and white. Every player he's had here has proven to be a quality person that has played for the team and represented UK at the highest level.
If Cal is not recruiting a top 20 player, something is wrong with that player. That is why Kentucky does not have the behavioral issues that you see at Kansas, Louisville, Duke, or North Carolina.
Our coach does things the right way and the best players (both athletically and otherwise) want to be in Lexington.
 

lkc1021

All-Conference
Apr 12, 2007
6,985
1,650
0
I'd like to see Cal bring in a couple 3-4 year guys that are very good college players that the NBA is not crazy about..someone like an undersized 5 like Meeks at UNC or the Purdue kid..maybe an Allen at Duke ..someone that has a flaw ..I'm just not sure we can win a title with 5 freshman each year..Next year will be younger than this one.
We will have a better chance than Memphis. Tubby Smith was great about bringing in 3-4 year guys. You saw where that got us. Let's just see which team goes farther this year.
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
Can't agree with you on this. 8 million plus dollars A YEAR to coach any sport is just wrong. I know he can get it and don't blame him for getting as much as he can but no human on this planet is truly worth 8 mil a year. Rip me if you like but I stand by my comment.


That's an absurd point of view
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

brianpoe

Heisman
Mar 25, 2009
27,769
21,825
113

brianpoe

Heisman
Mar 25, 2009
27,769
21,825
113
Can't agree with you on this. 8 million plus dollars A YEAR to coach any sport is just wrong. I know he can get it and don't blame him for getting as much as he can but no human on this planet is truly worth 8 mil a year. Rip me if you like but I stand by my comment.


 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Wildcat Spotlight: Kenny Darby
  2. 02 KSR Kam Williams makes way-too-early commitment to La Familia in TBT: 'I just love being here.'
  3. 03 KSR Even as a high school freshman, Jerone Morton knew he could play at Kentucky
  4. 04 KSR Kentucky Football Schedule Posters available starting Saturday
  5. 05 KSR Get to know Ousmane N'Diaye a little bit better