Twitter discussion from yesterday - in it's current state...

00Dawg

Senior
Nov 10, 2009
3,353
620
93
Of course it would help. The question is if it would be enough to average....

10 wins. Given that I still don't think we'd beat Bama more than once in a blue moon while Saban's there, that means needing to go 9-2 or 10-1 the rest of the season, with a schedule that includes rotating visits to LSU, Auburn, and Texas A&M. I could buy getting the average to 9 in fairly short order. 10 is a big jump from there.
 

HD6

Sophomore
Apr 8, 2003
10,019
108
63
Yes, but everybody gets that money.....

it doesn't do anything to bring us closer to the top schools. They all get that paycheck.

Prior to the 2007 donation, Oregon had won the Pac-10 eight times. They went to 14 bowls from 1990 to 2007. MSU had been to 12 bowls in history prior to Dan Mullen. I think they were a little ahead of us.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,396
33,168
113
Okie State went from 60 wins in 10 years just before the big donation to 93 wins in the last 10 years since. So yeah, it would help us a lot.
 

MSUDAWGFAN

Senior
Apr 17, 2014
1,162
789
113
The next step is not to average 9-10, but to get 9-10 a few years in a 5-10 year span. Then increase that number of years that you get the 9-10. So we had 10 in '14. We haven't had that since. Maybe we hit it in '18. Maybe after that, we hit it in '21. The down years in between have to be a little better too. Like instead of just getting into a bowl by getting 6, we are getting 8 in our rebuilding years. Maybe get a SEC West Championship in there somewhere along the way.

It would certainly take time, patience, and the right coach. Maybe Mullen is that guy and maybe not. I'm not advocating firing him, because I think he has done wonders for our program and now with Mississippi going the way of the dodo bird, we can finally own our state in recruiting without having to worry about "Merry Flipmas." Let's just let Mullen do what he has been doing. Lately, he seems to be fixing a lot of our weak spots. We just had our FG kicker hit a 60 yard FG in a game. We have the #1 WR in JUCO committed in Guidry and we have another stud in Heath. We stand a good chance to get Carvin from what I hear and have Dolla Bill committed too. Factor in other big time recruits like Mayden, Murphy, etc. and our class we are building for '19 and we are possibly looking at something special.
 

HD6

Sophomore
Apr 8, 2003
10,019
108
63
You made me curious.

Oregon ten years prior to donation=82 wins.

Oregon nine seasons after donation=102 wins, and that includes only winning four last season. So from 8.2 wins to 11.3 wins.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,277
5,822
113
Is that 10 years per year including bowl game? Or 10 regular season wins. Huge difference.

Also, what time frame are you talking about?

Can we average 10 wins per year (including bowl games) for five years? Yes. Not likely we will do it, but it wouldn't take a crazy change from what we're doing now. We're a few players a year away. That's still a huge leap, but it's possible.

Can we average 10 regular season wins a year for a decade? Technically possible, but pretty much impossible unless we start playing 15 games a year or the blue bloods forming their own conference to leave us competing against UM, USM, ULL, UAB, etc (and we probably wouldn't even win ten a year against them if we didn't have the SEC advantage).
 

HD6

Sophomore
Apr 8, 2003
10,019
108
63
If he did, I can't find a link. The Seal Facility donation was $12 million.
 
Sep 10, 2016
391
0
0
I don't think we could do 10 but I do think we could do 9. If we win 8 this year that will give us 5 8 win seasons in 9 years. Just by avoiding having an explosive diarrhea season like last year and winning some of those nail biters (i.e. 2010 arky and 2011 aubie and scar) we could make a push for a 9 win average.
If we had won the aubie and scar games in 2011 and not crapped the bed last season then we would have had 7 8 win seasons in 9 years. Dan has done great but I do think he has left a lot of meat on the bone in some years. I think it is certainly possible for us to improve and reach a 9 win average.
 

philduckworth

Redshirt
Feb 20, 2015
2,228
0
0
Tennessee, Texas, Texas A&M all have unlimited resources but aren't where they want to be and haven't been for several years. Money is a big factor, but it's just one factor. Like Bud Fox asked Gordon Gekko, "how many yachts can you water ski behind? " So how many waterfalls do you need in your weight room.

We needed about 2 or 3 players and a different d-coordinator in 2014 and we could have won the West. We will never recruit like Bama, but we don't have to. You just have to sign 1 legit WR every other year, and 1 4star Corner every other year. We haven't signed either in several years.
 
Sep 25, 2013
1,627
0
0
Oklahoma State has not landed a recruiting class in the top 25 in half a decade, and that one was ranked 25th. Pickens' money is not helping them in that department. They have a great coach in a ****** league. That's it.


He made his first huge donation, $165 million, after the 2005 season. Three years later they were 9-4. Five years later they were 12-1. They have had a couple of missteps, but they've won 10 games each of the last two seasons, so four double-digit win seasons since 2010. They had enjoyed three such seasons in their entire history prior to 2010.

Phil Knight was already doing quite a bit for Oregon when he donated 100 million in 2007 to the Ducks. After that donation, Oregon, which was already enjoying success but not consistently, reeled off seven straight double digit win seasons before it came to a halt last year and they fired their coach. If Chip Kelly hadn't been stupid and got caught using a runner, they'd still be rolling, I have no doubt.

This is literally one of the stupidest arguments ever. College football is a business. What business doesn't do well when it receives a huge injection of capital and puts people who understand how to use that money effectively in charge? MSU is already doing that latter part, we are dead last in budgets but our sports are by and large in really good shape. I'm supposed to believe that a monster donation wouldn't benefit the athletic department immensely and help level the playing field with the traditional powers of the conference?
 

aTotal360

Heisman
Nov 12, 2009
22,674
16,708
113
Look. Everyone assumes the money is going to be spent wisely. If Bill Gates gave us an eleventy billion dollar check and we rehire Croom, we obviously aren't going to win.
 

BlueRidgeMtns

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2016
5,644
3,571
113
Oregon also started the alternate uniform craze with all of their money. Sometimes you've got to innovate better than the next guy.

Kind of like our hashtag in the endzone*
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,396
33,168
113
They're obviously recruiting better than the ******** recruiting sites give them credit for. Just because a player doesn't have 5 stars doesn't mean he's not a great recruit. To an extent the recruiting sites rankings are a foregone conclusion. If Alabama offers a player he's going to be more highly rated than if Okie St. offers the same player.
 
Sep 25, 2013
1,627
0
0
If you don't think recruiting rankings matter I don't know what to tell you. They very much matter. Look at the recruiting rankings every year compared to who has the better seasons. It really is not debatable. Ok State plays in a league that is extremely soft. If we played in that league we would have similar results (not quite as good because Gundy is a little better than Mullen but not that much better). If you don't think he would gladly take more blue chip recruits you are wrong.

They're obviously recruiting better than the ******** recruiting sites give them credit for. Just because a player doesn't have 5 stars doesn't mean he's not a great recruit. To an extent the recruiting sites rankings are a foregone conclusion. If Alabama offers a player he's going to be more highly rated than if Okie St. offers the same player.
 

mstateglfr

All-American
Feb 24, 2008
17,025
6,853
113
Boise State should not even be considered for this conversation. We would be averaging 10 wins per year in that league.
BS, at least if you consider Boise's schedule this past 16 years...which should be considered and not just the league.
 

bulldogcountry1

Redshirt
Jun 4, 2007
2,311
1
38
We could be close to 9 if we didn't have to play Bama every year. I think that's the best we could expect. We have to take advantage of UM's downturn by recruiting better and hope the SEC divisions get eliminated.
 

Willow Grove Dawg

All-American
Nov 3, 2016
8,568
6,388
113
Boise State has done a tremendous job of scheduling quality Power 5 non-conference games, but as long as they are playing an 8 game conference schedule consisting of Colorado State, Wyoming, New Mexico, Air Force, Utah State, Fresno State, San Diego State, UNLV, Nevada, Hawaii, & San Jose State - you just cannot make an apples to apples comparison of their average # of wins per season to any school in the SEC, ACC, Big Ten, Big 12, or Pac-12.
 

MSUDawgFan86

Redshirt
Aug 14, 2017
1,331
1
0
10 is ridiculously difficult. What about 9 though? I think we could do that. My biggest deal right now is stopping the blowouts and being competitive in every game. A loss isn’t a loss I don’t care what anyone says. Perception is reality and losing 49-10 is a lot worse than 28-21. Losing by a combined 80-13 to Auburn and Georgia in Year 9 shouldn’t happen. I’m not mad about the losses. It’s the way we got our asses kicked.
 
Sep 10, 2016
391
0
0
We could be close to 9 if we didn't have to play Bama every year. I think that's the best we could expect. We have to take advantage of UM's downturn by recruiting better and hope the SEC divisions get eliminated.

We would already be pushing a 9 win avg over the last 8 years if we had avoided last year's implosion and capitalized on a few opportunities such as:
1. 2009 LSU and Houston
2. 2010 arky
3. 2011 aubie and scar
4. 2012 ole miss (not really a close game but we were the better team)
5. 2013 aubie
6. 2014 ole miss (see #4)
7. 2015 LSU
8. 2016 south al, Mormon U and Kentucky
I like to call these types of games "opportunity games". In 10 of these 12 games we were in position to win late. The only two we weren't are the two ole miss games. We were the better team in those two and had no business losing those games.
If we had won just 1/3 of these games then that would be 7.5 wins a year over the last 8 years. If we had won half then that would put us at 7.75 over that span. With 2/3 of these opportunity games we would be right at 8 wins over that span.
I think it is reasonable to think we could improve and do a better job in these opportunity games moving forward in the next 10 year span. It won't be easy but you can look and see we have indeed left a lot of meet on the bone. Hell last year we left our whole entree nearly untouched.
I know you can look and do this for a lot of other teams in our position as well. But guess what? We ain't talking about everybody else. We are talking about MSU.
I find this little bit of number crunching to be encouraging, although maybe a little over simplified. What say you fellow packers?
ETA: I used regular season win totals in this daily ******* epiphany.
Double ETA: While it is true that some good pondering does come while pooping it is not the best time to do math evidently.
 
Last edited:
Sep 10, 2016
391
0
0
10 is ridiculously difficult. What about 9 though? I think we could do that. My biggest deal right now is stopping the blowouts and being competitive in every game. A loss isn’t a loss I don’t care what anyone says. Perception is reality and losing 49-10 is a lot worse than 28-21. Losing by a combined 80-13 to Auburn and Georgia in Year 9 shouldn’t happen. I’m not mad about the losses. It’s the way we got our asses kicked.

I agree about the blowouts. It seems like we were more competitive against the big boys in Dan's first 3 years than we have been the last 2 or 3.
 

codeDawg

Redshirt
Nov 13, 2007
2,102
0
36
So, I’m late to this discussion, but here is what I think.

There are 2 things that win football games: 1. Coaching, 2. Talent

I refuse to believe that coaching costs us more than a game a year. We have a good staff, that develops players, and generally has a good scheme.

So that leaves talent. MS is a small state with underdeveloped players and 2 SEC schools. It’s just never going to produce a base of talent sufficient to support a powerhouse program.

Ole Miss recognized this, which is why they were up to the schenanigans that have them in trouble. They knew they had to supplement their share of MS talent with national talent. They just wanted it all at once.

To be successful we need:
- A reliable, stable coaching staff that gets paid at a competitive level
- A staff (and network) that recruits outside of MS at a decent level, e.g. Fred Brown’s of the world
- A level playing ground in-state. That doesn’t mean that everyone is on the up and up, but we at least split the state on top talent.

If we do these things consistently, we are a 7-9 win team. If we can do this and on occasion hit a few very special talents, we can compete for a championship. It’s those very special guys combined with a competent staff that make the difference.

Our goal shouldn’t be 10 wins. It should be a bottom of 7 wins and championships on the top. Manage a consistent roster and go out on a limb and get the couple of guys that change a team from 9 wins to a championship when the conditions are right.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,277
5,822
113
So, I’m late to this discussion, but here is what I think.

There are 2 things that win football games: 1. Coaching, 2. Talent

I refuse to believe that coaching costs us more than a game a year. We have a good staff, that develops players, and generally has a good scheme.

So that leaves talent. MS is a small state with underdeveloped players and 2 SEC schools. It’s just never going to produce a base of talent sufficient to support a powerhouse program.

Ole Miss recognized this, which is why they were up to the schenanigans that have them in trouble. They knew they had to supplement their share of MS talent with national talent. They just wanted it all at once.

To be successful we need:
- A reliable, stable coaching staff that gets paid at a competitive level
- A staff (and network) that recruits outside of MS at a decent level, e.g. Fred Brown’s of the world
- A level playing ground in-state. That doesn’t mean that everyone is on the up and up, but we at least split the state on top talent.

If we do these things consistently, we are a 7-9 win team. If we can do this and on occasion hit a few very special talents, we can compete for a championship. It’s those very special guys combined with a competent staff that make the difference.

Our goal shouldn’t be 10 wins. It should be a bottom of 7 wins and championships on the top. Manage a consistent roster and go out on a limb and get the couple of guys that change a team from 9 wins to a championship when the conditions are right.

Coaching has cost us quite a few wins. Just Wilson and sirmon being D.C. cost us several games in individual seasons. But overall we've been pretty good on not having coachinngcost us wins.
 

Joe Schmedlap

Redshirt
Aug 11, 2010
1,334
33
48
No one other than Saban is averaging 10 wins a year in the SEC West. Really silly kwerstion imo. Any SEC West team not named Alabama should be pleased with 8 to 9 win seasons. Unlike the 70's sitcom though, 8 isn't enough for lots of rival fan bases, which is silly. The SEC Western Division is just one hellacious gauntlet.

in relation to fundraising, facilities, etc - would MSU ever get to a 10 win/year average?

What would it take to get there? Could it get to 10 wins/season average?
 

HammerOfTheDogs

All-Conference
Jun 20, 2001
10,856
1,708
113
If Jeff Bezos latched on to MSU football and moved to Starkville, we'd might have a chance.

How are we going to attract some wealthy entrepreneur, when you have a State of lawyers who prey on Private Enterprise and appeal to the poorest among us for Jackpot Justice?
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Jeff Lebby fires assistants Phil Loadholt and Cliff Odom after Auburn loss
  2. 02 Maroon and White Mississippi State PFF Grades from 41-9 loss to Auburn
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Lopsided analytics illustrate Mississippi State's collapse against Auburn
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football "Not good enough": Jeff Lebby answers questions of performance and job security following blowout loss to Auburn
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Rapid Recap: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State