Thornton transferring from Duke???

TheDude1

Heisman
Apr 15, 2010
8,726
11,199
0
I don't know why Duke fans are that bummed about this. Seems like addition by subtraction. That is if Allen stays as he is saying. Allen, Kennard, Jones and Jackson is more than enough.

You always hope that stuff works out between every kid and your school, and if the kid seems like a good enough kid, you always want them to stick around, you know?
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
Gary Trent Jr is not nor will he ever be a point guard. He's a 2G. And imo--an overrated one if placed in the top 15 of '17 class. He is a scorer more then shooter, struggles when forced to put it on the floor and you can run him off spots. Hard worker and nice kid--but he took advantage of a horrible Howard Pulley team last year where he could jack up shots and score at will-because it was needed. I'd take Diallo and Petty over Trent Jr 100% of the time.

Trent Jr is a good shooter from what I have seen of him. He shot 40% from three and 80% from the stripe in EYBL last season. I do agree though that he is not a PG, especially not at a high D1 college,
 

Mark Gastineau

All-Conference
Feb 26, 2009
88,761
3,103
0
Trent Jr is a good shooter from what I have seen of him. He shot 40% from three and 80% from the stripe in EYBL last season. I do agree though that he is not a PG, especially not at a high D1 college,
I'll dig around and find out which PGs we've extended offers to in the 2017 class. I do know, however, that Duke is very high on Tre Jones (Tyus Jones' brother) in the 2018 class.
 

UKserialkiller

Heisman
Dec 13, 2009
34,297
54,801
0
Tyus Jones

 

gracetoyou

Heisman
Apr 19, 2009
20,399
29,791
113
Why would he leave anyway? Any speculation?


Word is Papa Thornton has not been overly impressed with how Coach K used his son offensively. He hasn't felt like he's allowed Thornton has been as involved as he should be.

Let's remember something about Thornton. Coach K is a manipulative sorry butt anyway. He talked this kid into reclassifying (supposed to have been 2016 class) last spring because Brandon Ingram was not going to go to Duke unless they had a PG. Thornton's reclassifying & committing to Duke is what sealed the deal for Ingram. True story!

Remember Coach K visited Jamal Murray after Nike Hoop Summit but felt Thornton had a better shot at reclassifying & focused there.
 

turkeywildturkey

All-Conference
Oct 23, 2003
2,647
2,202
0
The biggest reason I think this is wrong is because they lack a point guard.

Here's the current roster with current classifications:
2 Chase Jeter F/C 6-10 240 Fr.
3 Grayson Allen G 6-5 205 So.
5 Luke Kennard G 6-5 180 Fr.
12 Derryck Thornton G 6-2 175 Fr.??
13 Matt Jones G 6-5 200 Jr.
14 Brandon Ingram G/F 6-9 190 Fr.
21 Amile Jefferson F 6-9 225 Sr.
??
30 Antonio Vrankovic C 7-0 270 Fr.
34 Sean Obi F 6-9 250 So.
40 Marshall Plumlee C 7-0 250 Gr.
45 Nick Pagliuca G 6-3 195 Jr.
50 Justin Robinson F 6-8 190 Fr.
53 Brennan Besser G 6-5 180 Fr.

Who's coming in?
Javin DeLaurier F 6'8" 215
Harry Giles F 6'10" 220
Frank Jackson G 6'3" 180
Jayson Tatum F 6'8" 205
Jack White F 6'7" 225

If they lose Thornton, that puts the ball in the hands of Matt Jones, Grayson Allen (if he returns), or true freshman Frank Jackson, who is also more shooting guard than point guard.

So, how's he got 15 scholarships available?
 

TheDude1

Heisman
Apr 15, 2010
8,726
11,199
0
Oh please with the manipulative.

Derryck was basically handed the starting PG spot at Duke University. That's pretty damn rarified air, and a great player could make that into a massive first step to the pros.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mark Gastineau

gracetoyou

Heisman
Apr 19, 2009
20,399
29,791
113
Oh please with the manipulative.

Derryck was basically handed the starting PG spot at Duke University. That's pretty damn rarified air, and a great player could make that into a massive first step to the pros.

Point is K didn't run to Thornton because he wanted him so badly. He wanted Brandon Ingram & Thornton was the ticket. If your a connected Duke fan then you know what I posted is true...with the exception of manipulation. You choose to see it as a golden opportunity but I see it as manipulation. And if K really still wanted Thornton he wouldn't be transferring. But he used him...got Brandon, got a year from Thornton & is now finished with him.
 

Cat Ballou

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2007
5,234
4,502
0
If this happens, I'm sure we'll hear cries of outrage about Thornton being recruited over. Opens up PT for Frank Jackson, a better-looking prospect, clears up backcourt logjam if Allen returns, and frees up a scholarship for Bolden.
 

UK’98UK’00

All-Conference
Mar 29, 2014
3,160
1,380
86
Why would you pick a school, re-classify, enroll early and then bail when you have 2 stud front court players coming in? Something else would have to be up.

This would be a huge loss to Duke.
Maybe douche is spelled with a "k"
 

TheDude1

Heisman
Apr 15, 2010
8,726
11,199
0
Point is K didn't run to Thornton because he wanted him so badly. He wanted Brandon Ingram & Thornton was the ticket. If your a connected Duke fan then you know what I posted is true...with the exception of manipulation. You choose to see it as a golden opportunity but I see it as manipulation. And if K really still wanted Thornton he wouldn't be transferring. But he used him...got Brandon, got a year from Thornton & is now finished with him.

No. Thornton was long expected at Duke, just a year later... Long before Ingram seemed likely to be pried away from UNC. Then, as Jones blew up, it got more and more likely DT would come early. Your speculation about "If K really wanted DT he wouldn't be transferring" is based on nothing. That isn't how it works. What, if Derryck Thornton (or his dad or whoeve) says "DT is unhappy that he wasn't the primary option at Duke this year, and if he isn't next year he transfers," then K is supposed to... Say okay, you are it?
 

GonzoCat90

Heisman
Mar 30, 2009
32,377
34,559
0
He's the only true PG on the roster, or coming in. Jackson is a combo. Allen is a 2. Kennard is a wing. A bunch of ball dominant guys at point doesn't work with Tatum and Giles and I'm not sure it allows Allen to be the scorer he is either.

They'll be super talented, and Jackson is a better prospect, but he isn't a real point. He's a better Quinn Cook, not Tyus Jones. Fit might be an issue.
 
A

anon_013cn8yrfncx2

Guest
What does Allen get out of coming back other than winning Coach K another title?

Next year's draft class will be loaded compared to the current. Makes no sense.

It's not everyone's goal to get to the NBA as soon as possible. Allen's draft position is pretty much going to be the same no matter what year he goes. He's not a transcendent talent that will be the next guy taken based on potential. He is what he is and will not get any better.
 

Aike

Heisman
Mar 17, 2002
75,453
46,423
90
It's not everyone's goal to get to the NBA as soon as possible. Allen's draft position is pretty much going to be the same no matter what year he goes. He's not a transcendent talent that will be the next guy taken based on potential. He is what he is and will not get any better.

Draft position is affected by the others in the draft. A guy like Allen could slip into the second round by sticking around and joining a stronger draft next year.

The transcendent talents are the ones whose position stays nearly the same regardless. But they usually want to cash a check before they blowout a knee.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hoskins21
A

anon_013cn8yrfncx2

Guest
Sulaimon was a transfer but I understood that one. He was selfish on the court and likely had some off-court issues as well. Thornton was OK, had some good moments but if his dad wants him to be "the man" at Duke, well that will never happen. Don't remember ever seeing the dad in the stands at Duke (maybe he wasn't at the games) which seems to be a sort of privilege thing as well.
 

Mike-D

Heisman
Jul 14, 2001
50,443
75,612
113
It's not everyone's goal to get to the NBA as soon as possible. Allen's draft position is pretty much going to be the same no matter what year he goes. He's not a transcendent talent that will be the next guy taken based on potential. He is what he is and will not get any better.

I know you tried to be smart, but you failed miserably.
 
Dec 12, 2007
68,157
14,860
0
It's not everyone's goal to get to the NBA as soon as possible. Allen's draft position is pretty much going to be the same no matter what year he goes. He's not a transcendent talent that will be the next guy taken based on potential. He is what he is and will not get any better.

Ask McAdoo if that's true. Went from possible lottery pick to undrafted. I would bet good money Allen is not a first rounder if he comes back.
 

billCgmx

All-American
Apr 9, 2015
3,060
6,725
0
Sulaimon was a transfer but I understood that one. He was selfish on the court and likely had some off-court issues as well. Thornton was OK, had some good moments but if his dad wants him to be "the man" at Duke, well that will never happen. Don't remember ever seeing the dad in the stands at Duke (maybe he wasn't at the games) which seems to be a sort of privilege thing as well.

Wasn't the off-court issues rumored to be rape?
 

Baller224

Junior
Feb 8, 2007
438
285
0
Wasn't the off-court issues rumored to be rape?
Was rumored to be a sexual assault at a camp or something. There was a story in the Duke Chronicle that addressed the alleged sexual assault but it never really grew legs because the girl didn't report it as such. Sulaimon's biggest issue was selfishness, attitude, body language on the court, wouldn't cheer for teammates when he was taken out of games. He was kicked out of practice multiple times and K had multiple meetings with him and it never seemed to get any better. The straw that broke the camel's back was after Duke's loss at ND, where Sulaimon did not play well or very much got into it with Matt Jones (who was playing over him) & K in the locker room post game.
 
Mar 23, 2012
23,493
6,068
0
It's not everyone's goal to get to the NBA as soon as possible. Allen's draft position is pretty much going to be the same no matter what year he goes. He's not a transcendent talent that will be the next guy taken based on potential. He is what he is and will not get any better.
His draft stock isn't going to go up if he enters the draft next year, it will only go down.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR SEC finalizes harsh penalties for rostering former pros
  2. 02 KSR A former SEC star has committed to play for St. John's, Rick Pitino
  3. 03 KSR The Kentucky Defensive Backs are Film Junkies
  4. 04 KSR KSR Show, 8/26: NCAA/SEC eligibility updates and remembering Dolly
  5. 05 KSR KSR Today: Eligibility Madness has arrived in August