What you're seeing here is the absolute, 100% corruption of the judicial system.
From what I've read (and if it's wrong, I'll adjust), the judge who heard the initial appeal is a Texas Tech booster. And then when the NCAA appealed, it went to a court that consists of 4 judges who all got their law degrees from Texas Tech.
These absolutely corrupt pigs might have gone too far here, though. It was a 15-0 (Texas Tech excluded, rightfully) vote from the other Big 12 schools that Scorsby shouldn't play.