Being a former scout for the Yankees, there are a few posters here who were on the other board that know how much I despise analytics. Me and bigs23 debated all the time over this. He loved analytics and I don't. Just read an interesting piece from a Scott Forbes interview from yesterday. Here it is:
The Role Analytics Play
Jackson: “It plays a role, but not the biggest role. There are some organizations in pro ball where it’s just centered around that. I think we do a really good job of looking at what’s there. We don’t really just strictly go off analytics. There are some tools you can ask it a question and it’ll tell you what your best run scoring line up should be and all. That doesn’t mean we’re going to use it, but at least maybe it starts to take you down a little bit different thought process as far as putting the lineup together.
“I think that’s one thing that gets lost sometimes in this day and age of baseball, is you don’t use your gut as much as you should. And that’s something Scott Forbes is really good at. If he’s got a gut thought, he goes with it, and he doesn’t look back.”
That is what I've always preached. Long before analytics you used your eyes and your brains. I did very well in baseball, as did thousands, for a long time before analytics was invented.