There’s always a certain amount of tension at tournament selection time between wanting to reward winning and the undeniable fact that not all wins are anywhere close to equal in college basketball. This Miami team really takes that debate to a new extreme though.
I’ll go on the record that they quite frankly aren’t that good. They were incredibly lucky to stay undefeated as long as they did when it seemed like they were having a game decided at the buzzer against a different underwhelming opponent every week, and the metrics back that up with them barely being top 100 despite the superficially impressive record. They definitely wouldn’t be favored head to head against Auburn or any other power conference bubble team you want to name. Probably not even against some teams who are below the bubble. The fact that there’s a reasonable argument for leaving them out at 31-1 is absolutely bonkers.