Example of why 24 team playoff is too many

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
Again...why would the SEC and Big Ten agree to that and allow the other two conferences to have an easier path to one of 4 spots? A conference playoff doesn't negate its a 4 team playoff...
You're not stupid...you know this would never happen or be considered
I never said it would happen, but I thought this was a board for discussion. And how would it be an easier path when the conference champion will get in any way? It would be a tougher path for every team because you have to get through a tournament with more teams.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
I never said it would happen, but I thought this was a board for discussion. And how would it be an easier path when the conference champion will get in any way? It would be a tougher path for every team because you have to get through a tournament with more teams.
This isn't a fantasy thread...its to discuss what actually is or could be. It's why anyone discussing less than 24 is being absurd unless you break FBS into 2 levels.
Obviously the path is harder for deeper conferences. Pretending that you aren't aware it would be tougher to make the F4 from the.Big Ten or SEC is laughable.
 

psu0408

All-Conference
Oct 28, 2004
501
1,309
83
Before this week, Ole Miss was ranked #19 and Oklahoma State was ranked 25th. Mestemaker might be the first QB off the board in the 2027 Draft and Chambliss is likely a 1st Round pick. With rookie contracts ranging from $20-$60M, agents will push for guys on lower ranked teams to opt out rather than risk injury on the road against a 2-loss Big Ten or SEC team. We're going to get a highly watered down product with 4-loss teams getting smoked in the first round.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobPSU92

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
This isn't a fantasy thread...its to discuss what actually is or could be. It's why anyone discussing less than 24 is being absurd unless you break FBS into 2 levels.
Obviously the path is harder for deeper conferences. Pretending that you aren't aware it would be tougher to make the F4 from the.Big Ten or SEC is laughable.
Isn’t that the same with every sport? Getting into the playoffs is always tougher for teams in a tougher conference or division. And it is a fantasy thread because nothing we say on here will matter. It will be 24 teams with almost every team from the SEC getting in. We’re not changing from the BCS, we’re just adding more teams.
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
848
927
93
Last year #17 played for the title in FCS
The won 4 true road games including at #1 then lost the title game by 1 point
You're saying the had no chance? Come on.
4 being right is laughable--see Ohio State winning a title.
Also, those games are very important still for seeding and home games--but countless others now matter
You can’t compare this to FCS. FCS has 11 conference champs as auto bids or 45%.
With 5 in FBS, that’s 10 to 12 teams. They need 24 because those teams don’t play each other. If there were 5 conference bids, FCS wouldn’t have 24 or 19 from the Same conferences to fill it out.
 
Last edited:

PSU89er

Junior
Nov 22, 2023
304
399
63
Last year #17 played for the title in FCS
The won 4 true road games including at #1 then lost the title game by 1 point
You're saying the had no chance? Come on.
4 being right is laughable--see Ohio State winning a title.
Also, those games are very important still for seeding and home games--but countless others now matter
I said almost no chance. Did they win? One other team pull off them same thing in 2016 when Youngstown State did the same before losing in the final.

OSU in 2024 was easily the most talented team in college football that year (possbly ever), but the fact is after the loss to Michigan in the regular season final. I dont think they should have been in the playoff, and had that happened when the regular season was really important in college football they would not have made the 4 team playoff, and they would have with a win over Michigan.

Also what does 24 team playoff do for OSU in 2024. I'll tell you what it may have done. Kids might have sat out that Michigan game, because why play when you might get hurt and the playoffs start in a couple of weeks, and that is what the 24 team playoff is going to start to do for a lot of the best teams
 
  • Like
Reactions: Psumatt85

PSU89er

Junior
Nov 22, 2023
304
399
63
Jesus--it's not about more is better. Eliminating the OPT OUT BOWLS and creating more meaningful games for everyone not just a handful of problems is the win here.
But people want it to be 1986
No, for years Id rather they eliminate all the bowl game and have a playoff with the best 4 teams. Does that sound like 1986?

The reason I would have argued that for years is because these were college students and subjecting them to a 16 and 17 game schedule was really wrong but they was before they were getting paid.

Now, what the hell but If I was willing to watch the Alamo Bowl one year. Ill watch a round of 32 playoff game, but I'll know that neither is really all that important regarding who wins the national title, and that has been true every year that FCS has had a 24 team playoff.
 

PSU89er

Junior
Nov 22, 2023
304
399
63
In 15 out of 16 years of the 24 team playoff in FCS. A four team playoff would have included the team that won it all and an eight team playoff would have made it 16 out of 16.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: KingLando

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
Isn’t that the same with every sport? Getting into the playoffs is always tougher for teams in a tougher conference or division. And it is a fantasy thread because nothing we say on here will matter. It will be 24 teams with almost every team from the SEC getting in. We’re not changing from the BCS, we’re just adding more teams.
Again--that's why they have widlcards
We're changing everything from the BCS
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
You can’t compare this to FCS. FCS has 11 conference champs as auto bids or 45%.
With 5 in FBS, that’s 10 to 12 teams. They need 24 because those teams don’t play each other. If there were 5 conference bids, FCS wouldn’t have 24 or 19 from the Same conferences to fill it out.
Then let's have all conference champs and 14 at large bids
FCS would still have 24 though even without the auto bids
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
I said almost no chance. Did they win? One other team pull off them same thing in 2016 when Youngstown State did the same before losing in the final.

OSU in 2024 was easily the most talented team in college football that year (possbly ever), but the fact is after the loss to Michigan in the regular season final. I dont think they should have been in the playoff, and had that happened when the regular season was really important in college football they would not have made the 4 team playoff, and they would have with a win over Michigan.

Also what does 24 team playoff do for OSU in 2024. I'll tell you what it may have done. Kids might have sat out that Michigan game, because why play when you might get hurt and the playoffs start in a couple of weeks, and that is what the 24 team playoff is going to start to do for a lot of the best teams
But they have a chance--that's all that matters--having a chance
Ohio State won as an 8 seed, right? Spin it all you want--teams outside the top 5 can win
No one is sitting out the Michigan game lol--you guys are so ridiculous it's laughable. Seeding matters.
 

PSUFTG

All-Conference
Nov 1, 2021
2,865
4,090
113
Watch the FCS playoff--it's amazing
So amazing, that no one watches it.

The last FCS championship game - which, IIRC, was the largest audience ever for an FCS game - was watched by about 2.5 million (It was a close game between 2 traditional "FCS Powers" that, IIRC, went into overtime).
Even though it was played on a Monday Night, on ESPN, on a day with NO OTHER FOOTBALL GAMES (It was the final week of the NFL season, so no MNF, and no other college games - zero other football competition)

That is about the same number of folks who watched Texas A&M vs South Carolina last week - in a "meaningless" regular season game, that was competing in the same time slot as: Alabama vs LSU AND Oregon vs Ohio State.


But, yep, that playoff football - because, by GOD, it is the "PLAYOFFS"! - is must watch TV.
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
848
927
93
Then let's have all conference champs and 14 at large bids
FCS would still have 24 though even without the auto bids
I could live with that. It’s too many and would have some bad games, but at least would be merit based and keep a 9th place SEC team out. Is that what you want?
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
So amazing, that no one watches it.

The last FCS championship game - which, IIRC, was the largest audience ever for an FCS game - was watched by about 2.5 million (It was a close game between 2 traditional "FCS Powers" that, IIRC, went into overtime).
Even though it was played on a Monday Night, on ESPN, on a day with NO OTHER FOOTBALL GAMES (It was the final week of the NFL season, so no MNF, and no other college games - zero other football competition)

That is about the same number of folks who watched Texas A&M vs South Carolina last week - in a "meaningless" regular season game, that was competing in the same time slot as: Alabama vs LSU AND Oregon vs Ohio State.


But, yep, that playoff football - because, by GOD, it is the "PLAYOFFS"! - is must watch TV.
People watch it--the fan base just isn't as large. 2.5M for the second level of college football is a ton of people.
South Carolina-A&M wasn't meaningless--South Carolina was still playoff eligible
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
I could live with that. It’s too many and would have some bad games, but at least would be merit based and keep a 9th place SEC team out. Is that what you want?
You cares if there's bad games. A 2 team playoff can have a blowout as we've seen.
This concern over "how many teams will the SEC get" needs to stop. I couldn't care less if the 9th team in the Big Ten or SEC gets in--we'll see how they do. I'm sure as hell not going to be angry if an 8-4 Penn State gets in one day
 
  • Like
Reactions: Waaaaaaaany

Wilbury

Senior
Oct 28, 2021
318
415
63
6-4 LSU would still be in the conversation, and probably in if they beat Tennessee.
They're essentially telling you that given the current NIL model, the universities need as much money as possible just to field a competitive team and they're willing to risk downgrading the regular season and abandon crowning a true national champion to do it. This isn't about making things more competitive or getting better matchups. It's a selfish move that they think they need if they're going to survive. And although they won't say it out loud, they're nervous about how it's going to go.
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
Again--that's why they have widlcards
We're changing everything from the BCS
Let’s see, the BCS was a bunch of people and a computer deciding which four teams went. Now it’s a much smaller group of people deciding who gets in. Yeah, that’s changing, but maybe not for the better.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MtNittany

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
Let’s see, the BCS was a bunch of people and a computer deciding which four teams went. Now it’s a much smaller group of people deciding who gets in. Yeah, that’s changing, but maybe not for the better.
That's what all college sports do as it almost impossible not to have a human component because of the number of teams and how different the talent level is
 

SleepyLion

All-Conference
Sep 1, 2022
2,972
4,611
113
This is an absurd conversation - there is no other NCAA-Sponsored Sport/Championship that "requires" Conference affiliation. Why should a team be required to do something the NCAA does not require just because "Ludd says it should be that way"???? Just a ridiculous statement that isn't even debatable - that is not an NCAA requirement for FBS Membership and likely never will be, so your supposed point is not a point in any real way other than to be self-serving drivel to support your pointless argument. And again, it is stupid to claim that all conferences should be treated as if they are identical in terms of quality and depth in terms of numbers of auto-bids and wildcard positions granted. Just utterly dumb and statistically unsupoorted.
Are there independents for other sports? I do not think there are. Maybe the conference membership is not required but everyone is a member so it might not matter. IDK.
 

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
I have said this from the start. There are never 24 very good football teams at the P4 level in college football. Sadly, this is what happens to a sport when greed and money become the top priority of universities.

The schools don’t care if the product becomes watered down as long as they continue to get paid their collective billions. Mediocrity is here to stay for the foreseeable future.
Yeah they know they will get a lot of people to watch the #24 vs #9 game whatever it is and more importantly get advertising sponsors to line up to pay and there you have it. We may see 36 teams or even 48 in our lifetimes. The good news about this is the more teams you have the impact these committee clowns have with their biases and and bad judgment gets minimized.
 

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
Look at the data--ignore opinion and deal with facts
Indiana isn't very good--kudos to Cignetti for finding ways to win but they're going to get trounced in the playoff if they don't correct a lot of things quickly.
This is a gem of a message worth pulling up after the playoffs. There is parity everywhere, no dominant team and that includes Georgia yet the best coach in the country is going to get "trounced in the playoff". Yet all he does is win. IU may very well not win it but to totally count them out as some unworthy imposter team is ignorant.
 

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
People watch it--the fan base just isn't as large. 2.5M for the second level of college football is a ton of people.
South Carolina-A&M wasn't meaningless--South Carolina was still playoff eligible
Nobody cares about the FCS playoffs, get real. People will watch the 24 team playoff but that doesn't make it right. I highly doubt any team seeded higher than #10 will ever win the 24 team playoff. But hey you're telling me we have a chance!
 
  • Like
Reactions: barry j fenchak

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
848
927
93

Yeah they know they will get a lot of people to watch the #24 vs #9 game whatever it is and more importantly get advertising sponsors to line up to pay and there you have it. We may see 36 teams or even 48 in our lifetimes. The good news about this is the more teams you have the impact these committee clowns have with their biases and and bad judgment gets minimized.
What I thi
Yeah they know they will get a lot of people to watch the #24 vs #9 game whatever it is and more importantly get advertising sponsors to line up to pay and there you have it. We may see 36 teams or even 48 in our lifetimes. The good news about this is the more teams you have the impact these committee clowns have with their biases and and bad judgment gets minimized.
what I think is the only thing that will keep the playoff from getting even larger, is as the payrolls continue to skyrocket, I don’t see more than 50 teams playing FBS football. Why will universities lose money on this long term.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
This is a gem of a message worth pulling up after the playoffs. There is parity everywhere, no dominant team and that includes Georgia yet the best coach in the country is going to get "trounced in the playoff". Yet all he does is win. IU may very well not win it but to totally count them out as some unworthy imposter team is ignorant.
Cignetti isnt the best coach
And I said if they don't fix things which they can
This is another prime example of not reading what was stated and making it something it isn't
As the biggest advocate for an expanded playoff I clearly believe upsets happen but Indiana's offense has to do a 180 to survive Utah Georgia Miami Notre Dame etc. And Cignetti may get that done.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
Nobody cares about the FCS playoffs, get real. People will watch the 24 team playoff but that doesn't make it right. I highly doubt any team seeded higher than #10 will ever win the 24 team playoff. But hey you're telling me we have a chance!
Again...who cares if they win. They'll get a shot on the field to prove it. And 8 already won in a 12 team so...
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
What I thi

what I think is the only thing that will keep the playoff from getting even larger, is as the payrolls continue to skyrocket, I don’t see more than 50 teams playing FBS football. Why will universities lose money on this long term.
You realize we have team moving up to FBS currently, right? But over 80 are just going to give up? Keep us posted when that happens. The only way it could is if FBS breaks into two levels but ot will still be FBS
 
May 11, 2016
473
280
63
What I thi

what I think is the only thing that will keep the playoff from getting even larger, is as the payrolls continue to skyrocket, I don’t see more than 50 teams playing FBS football. Why will universities lose money on this long term.
It is certainly trending in that direction.

The only fair thing to do is expand the field to include all FBS teams. Every one is a winner! LOL
 
  • Like
Reactions: Psumatt85

NoBareFeet

Senior
Oct 25, 2021
426
691
93
There is no reason that college football has to be just like every other sports league. The college football regular season USED TO BE the best regular season in all of sports. The college football post season with the bowls, traditions, and pageantry USED TO BE the best postseason in all of sports. That is all down the crapper now.

Eliminate the playoff. Go back to the old bowl system. Hell, even take a portion of the bowl proceeds and divide it up among the players if you are worried about quitters (opt outs). If you want to play ONE game at the end of bowl season between the top 2 teams (determined by a committee, polls, computers, or a combination of all of those), go for it. That would be a tremendous improvement over what we have now, and certainly an improvement over what will be in place in the future.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WDLion

CDLionFL

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2021
1,785
2,727
113
There is no reason that college football has to be just like every other sports league. The college football regular season USED TO BE the best regular season in all of sports. The college football post season with the bowls, traditions, and pageantry USED TO BE the best postseason in all of sports. That is all down the crapper now.

Eliminate the playoff. Go back to the old bowl system. Hell, even take a portion of the bowl proceeds and divide it up among the players if you are worried about quitters (opt outs). If you want to play ONE game at the end of bowl season between the top 2 teams (determined by a committee, polls, computers, or a combination of all of those), go for it. That would be a tremendous improvement over what we have now, and certainly an improvement over what will be in place in the future.
After all of this school's history with polls and committees, I never thought I'd see a Penn State fan advocate for going back to the way it used to be. I guess 1994 is far enough in the past.

I said for years that the college football season was as good as it got but the messy end game always tarnished it. I think they finally got it right with 12 teams and then they have to blow it up because ******** like Greg Sankey and Tony Pettitti are greedy POS's. Sometimes in life things don't go your way and you have to work your way out of it. That seems to be below today's generation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
848
927
93
You realize we have team moving up to FBS currently, right? But over 80 are just going to give up? Keep us posted when that happens. The only way it could is if FBS breaks into two levels but ot will still be FBS
We’ll see, but the economics have changed in the last two years. Struggle to see teams like Rutgers continue to deficit spend( though they are on the right track because they were competitive with UM) to be last in the big 10. Don’t see why they would be allowed to lose money, but colleges have done dumber things.

And if the are in different divisions of FBS and don’t play in the tournament, this dilutes the teams eligible for the 24/32/48 team playoff whether you call the FBS lite or not
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,211
4,814
113
We’ll see, but the economics have changed in the last two years. Struggle to see teams like Rutgers continue to deficit spend( though they are on the right track because they were competitive with UM) to be last in the big 10. Don’t see why they would be allowed to lose money, but colleges have done dumber things.

And if the are in different divisions of FBS and don’t play in the tournament, this dilutes the teams eligible for the 24/32/48 team playoff whether you call the FBS lite or not
1...the TV money alone will keep most programs in FBS which is why many are still trying to move up
2...if you split into 2 levels then the teams could be reduced to 16 but that's the only way we'll get less than 24...if there's 2 playoffs
 

Binder74

Senior
Nov 1, 2021
543
929
93
After all of this school's history with polls and committees, I never thought I'd see a Penn State fan advocate for going back to the way it used to be. I guess 1994 is far enough in the past.

I said for years that the college football season was as good as it got but the messy end game always tarnished it. I think they finally got it right with 12 teams and then they have to blow it up because ******** like Greg Sankey and Tony Pettitti are greedy POS's. Sometimes in life things don't go your way and you have to work your way out of it. That seems to be below today's generation.
I'd like to go to 16 teams with no byes. If the top teams can't win by playing the lowest seeds at home, then they don't belong. They don't need a bye as well. It also does away flat performance from going so long between games.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
Cignetti isnt the best coach
And I said if they don't fix things which they can
This is another prime example of not reading what was stated and making it something it isn't
As the biggest advocate for an expanded playoff I clearly believe upsets happen but Indiana's offense has to do a 180 to survive Utah Georgia Miami Notre Dame etc. And Cignetti may get that done.
Cignetti is the best coach and Indiana could win it the way they are playing now. It's hilarious that you advocate for a 24 team playoff with part of your rationale being that these teams seeded 20 or 19 or 21 or 17 have a shot to win it all yet you make a definitive declaration that Indiana the way they are playing now "will get trounced". So that is saying Indiana has no shot as a top 10 team yet you think #20 does have a shot?

You really think Utah or Miami or ND or Georgia would trounce Indiana the way Indiana's offense is playing now (no improvement and no change)? So indiana versus Georgia in a neutral site will be Georgia favored by 21? That would be a trouncing. You really think that would happen? Again Utah could beat them but they are not getting trounced. Their D is elite and will not let them get trounced. Plus who do you think will outcoach who? Cignetti out coaching the Utah coach or vice versa? I'll hang up and listen to your answer.
 

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
Again...who cares if they win. They'll get a shot on the field to prove it. And 8 already won in a 12 team so...
Didn't answer anything You just want to watch more college football but the reality is no team seeded lower than 10 is ever winning but money rules everything. At least cut it off at 16. No way #17 through #24 have any shot. Louisville, Houston Florida have legitimate shots to beat Georgia or ND? A waste.
 

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
After all of this school's history with polls and committees, I never thought I'd see a Penn State fan advocate for going back to the way it used to be. I guess 1994 is far enough in the past.

I said for years that the college football season was as good as it got but the messy end game always tarnished it. I think they finally got it right with 12 teams and then they have to blow it up because ******** like Greg Sankey and Tony Pettitti are greedy POS's. Sometimes in life things don't go your way and you have to work your way out of it. That seems to be below today's generation.
The ridiculous thing is they still can't solve the bs human judgement biasing everything like it did in 1968. The system is corrupt and completely flawed and now greed has taken over the sport. Let's pay a QB who has not even played in the NFL and supposedly goes to college $9 million. Because $8 million or $5 million is not enough. Is that Mississippi State QB the highest paid public employee in that state? What a joke.
 
May 11, 2016
473
280
63
1...the TV money alone will keep most programs in FBS which is why many are still trying to move up
But you said TV was disappearing:

"Viewership for everything is done--younger generations stream thing (hence games on Peacock)--and attendance is down for obvious reasons--same reason the Bills built a smaller stadium"

Were those not your words?

Still waiting on how more = better.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State's Audavion Collins on his final season: 'Don't second-guess yourself'
  2. 02 BWI Football Matt Campbell on Penn State's turnaround, Senior Day and two key return announcements
  3. 03 BWI Recruiting Three 2028 Rivals300 prospects confirmed for Penn State's home finale
  4. 04 BWI Football Ben Brahmer and Kooper Ebel returning to Penn State will help 'start to accelerate a little bit of that planning' for the 2027 season
  5. 05 BWI Football Penn State injury updates: Did Carson Hansen practice on Wednesday? Latest on Caleb Bacon, Jahmir Joseph