Example of why 24 team playoff is too many

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Have yet to see a valid objective argument that more = better.

I have noticed that attendance and viewership is trending downward in most markets. SEC and B12 has not suffered much but the rest of the field is down.

Waiting for the day when the playoff expands to 64 or more. May as well instead of nickle and dime expansions.
It will never go beyond 28--24 was always the end game
Viewership for everything is done--younger generations stream thing (hence games on Peacock)--and attendance is down for obvious reasons--same reason the Bills built a smaller stadium
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
It’s not at all. Not even close.
Explain...
Use your words
In a playoff, everyone is contending for a title regardless of if you think they have a realistic shot. They have a shot.
A bowl game, is a scrimmage kids that elect to play in get as a reward--and, many that choose not to play, still get all the SWAG while oping out.
 

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,055
21,624
113
Explain...
Use your words
In a playoff, everyone is contending for a title regardless of if you think they have a realistic shot. They have a shot.
A bowl game, is a scrimmage kids that elect to play in get as a reward--and, many that choose not to play, still get all the SWAG while oping out.

No. It’s dumb. End of story.
 
  • Like
Reactions: barry j fenchak

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,367
1,354
113
6-4 LSU would still be in the conversation, and probably in if they beat Tennessee.

You're argument is not good in that 12 teams excludes teams that are quite possibly contenders, but due to teams playing vastly different schedules, they are left out due to absolute record. Comparing simple W-L record of 135 teams playing VASTLY different schedules with almost no overlap is dumb and not statistically valid. The only answer is allowing the top teams from from P2 (6-8) / P4 Conference (12-16 teams) into the playoffs and the remaining top 8-12 teams from non-P4 teams and independents (which is on the order of a field of 75 teams). That is not too many teams for a Playoff. Beyond that, since the teams are seeded in the Playoff (with a top 8 seeds receiving a bye in first round), it's just dumb to claim that the #9 seed shouldn't beat the #24 seed AT HOME if they are truly the #9 seed (which is impossible to say just looking at records when the #9 and #24 seeds will generally have played a completely different schedule during the regular season). But again, it's dumb to claim that you can absolutely tell the difference between the lowest 16 seeds in a 24 team Playoff Format by simply comparing records when the #9 Seed could quite possibly have a much better overall record playing in the MWC or the MAC or the P12 or the AAC..... etc..... versus the #24 seed playing in the SEC or B1G. But again, if the #9 Seed can't beat that SEC or B1G team @Home, then they really weren't the #9 team in the country in the first place - were they?????
 

PSU89er

Junior
Nov 22, 2023
304
399
63
The problem with 24 is that the teams at the bottom stands almost no chance of a national title, and as we all know its a money grab.

You will be able to sell me on it when a team that plays in the first round wins the whole thing. FCS went to 24 teams in 2010. That year Eastern Washington won the whole thing as 5 seed, since then no team seeded outside of the top 4 has won FCS national title and of the 32 teams to play in the final 25 have been one of the top four seeds.

Goes to show that 4 probably was the right number. I didnt want them to go to 8 or 12 because I new it wouldnt stop. IF there were a 24 team playoff, PSU people could argue an 8-4 team this year should be in (we will have run off 5 in a row to get there) and this team shouldnt be anywhere close to a playoff spot, and it really does hurt the regular season in a way that the 12 team playoff does not.

ND plays SMU this week. SMU is fighting for a playoff spot (after Wake this week they are likely toast, but a win over ND, who knows). ND loses this game. They are in big trouble. 24 team playoff the game is not nearly as important.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wilbury

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
No. It’s dumb. End of story.
Got it--you don't like change and are upset so logic can't be used
It is simply a money grab by all involved. There are not 24 teams in any given year capable of winning it all. 8-10 maybe, but there will be 2-3 teams that have the inside track. The three I see this year are Georgia, Miami and N.D.
What were bowl games if not a money grab for ESPN?
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
The problem with 24 is that the teams at the bottom stands almost no chance of a national title, and as we all know its a money grab.

You will be able to sell me on it when a team that plays in the first round wins the whole thing. FCS went to 24 teams in 2010. That year Eastern Washington won the whole thing as 5 seed, since then no team seeded outside of the top 4 has won FCS national title and of the 32 teams to play in the final 25 have been one of the top four seeds.

Goes to show that 4 probably was the right number. I didnt want them to go to 8 or 12 because I new it wouldnt stop. IF there were a 24 team playoff, PSU people could argue an 8-4 team this year should be in (we will have run off 5 in a row to get there) and this team shouldnt be anywhere close to a playoff spot, and it really does hurt the regular season in a way that the 12 team playoff does not.

ND plays SMU this week. SMU is fighting for a playoff spot (after Wake this week they are likely toast, but a win over ND, who knows). ND loses this game. They are in big trouble. 24 team playoff the game is not nearly as important.
Last year #17 played for the title in FCS
The won 4 true road games including at #1 then lost the title game by 1 point
You're saying the had no chance? Come on.
4 being right is laughable--see Ohio State winning a title.
Also, those games are very important still for seeding and home games--but countless others now matter
 

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,055
21,624
113
The problem with 24 is that the teams at the bottom stands almost no chance of a national title, and as we all know its a money grab.

You will be able to sell me on it when a team that plays in the first round wins the whole thing. FCS went to 24 teams in 2010. That year Eastern Washington won the whole thing as 5 seed, since then no team seeded outside of the top 4 has won FCS national title and of the 32 teams to play in the final 25 have been one of the top four seeds.

Goes to show that 4 probably was the right number. I didnt want them to go to 8 or 12 because I new it wouldnt stop. IF there were a 24 team playoff, PSU people could argue an 8-4 team this year should be in (we will have run off 5 in a row to get there) and this team shouldnt be anywhere close to a playoff spot, and it really does hurt the regular season in a way that the 12 team playoff does not.

ND plays SMU this week. SMU is fighting for a playoff spot (after Wake this week they are likely toast, but a win over ND, who knows). ND loses this game. They are in big trouble. 24 team playoff the game is not nearly as important.

‘We heard fans hated this and decide to ignore them.’

All you need to know.
 
  • Like
Reactions: barry j fenchak

Bison13

All-American
May 26, 2013
3,898
6,528
113
I prefer 16. Top 4 in SEC and BIG, top 2 in ACC and B12, 4 others to include top two non power five conference winners.
 

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,055
21,624
113
I will enjoy it--you can cry about it while we get meaningful football games instead of scrimmage any intelligent kid opts out of instead of risking injury for pride

Continue to be dumb. Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind and all. So dumb.
 
May 11, 2016
467
275
63
But but but more is better.

More money for advertisers makes sure we are well informed about which beer/fast food we should shovel down our gullets. More drugs that produce side effects worse than the ailment. Which $120,000 trucks are superior bargains.

More announcers that are experts about the first CFB game they have ever called. Better quality officiating.

A never ending list of "new and improved"

All the while watching those two mules fighting over a turnip.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,055
21,624
113
But but but more is better.

More money for advertisers makes sure we are well informed about which beer/fast food we should shovel down our gullets. More drugs that produce side effects worse than the ailment. Which $120,000 trucks are superior bargains.

More announcers that are experts about the first CFB game they have ever called. Better quality officiating.

A never ending list of "new and improved"

All the while watching those two mules fighting over a turnip.

It’s good for dumb people too. Like Lando. So dumb.
 
  • Like
Reactions: barry j fenchak

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Jesus--it's not about more is better. Eliminating the OPT OUT BOWLS and creating more meaningful games for everyone not just a handful of problems is the win here.
But people want it to be 1986
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
Who cares that they lost 4 times? In what other sport is 4 losses unacceptable?
You all have this insane belief that the goal is to be 12-0 because it used to be--back when teams played 2 or 3 teams that had any talent a year.
What other sport only plays 12 games?
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
The best news is...you all can start a thread daily about how bad this is but it's here to stay...and thank God because the antiquated bowl system and horrible CCGs are ending.
Yet the bowls don’t seem to be going anywhere.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Yet the bowls don’t seem to be going anywhere.
Watch--there's already talk of moving them to week 1--they'll die
What other sport only plays 12 games?
And in sports that play more you can even lose double digit games. Georgia Men's basketball made the dance at 16-14 one year as an at large team. Yet you're upset about 8-4? Come on. That's before we even get to sub 500 teams winning their conf tournament.
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
Watch--there's already talk of moving them to week 1--they'll die

And in sports that play more you can even lose double digit games. Georgia Men's basketball made the dance at 16-14 one year as an at large team. Yet you're upset about 8-4? Come on. That's before we even get to sub 500 teams winning their conf tournament.
The basketball tournament has too many teams as well.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
If you all want to discuss how to make a 24 team playoff better then discuss it but we're going back to less teams--you have accept that--there's no other option.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
The basketball tournament has too many teams as well.
Yet the first weekend (Thurs-Sun) of March Madness is one of the biggest sports weekends...
I don't understand why people are so angry about a playoff being more inclusive. Worst case, some bad teams get blown out. Best case, we see runs like Illinois State made last year in FCS
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
If you all want to discuss how to make a 24 team playoff better then discuss it but we're going back to less teams--you have accept that--there's no other option.
Nobody said it is going back, but that doesn’t mean everyone has to like it just because you do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AvgUser

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
Yet the first weekend (Thurs-Sun) of March Madness is one of the biggest sports weekends...
I don't understand why people are so angry about a playoff being more inclusive. Worst case, some bad teams get blown out. Best case, we see runs like Illinois State made last year in FCS
And yet none of those teams ever win, so why bother?
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,367
1,354
113
Take your own advice--get off the shortbus
Find anyone to hug you yet or realized you're all alone?

In an extremely rare occurrence, I have to agree with you that saying you can simply compare absolute records of 135 FBS teams playing completely divergent schedules (with zero overlap relative to 90% of the other FBS teams) is a "statistically significant" method of selecting a field of teams that represents literally a handful of teams from the entire field (i.e., selecting them based on absolute record which is the same as saying selecting them based on subjective ranking which is based on absolute record biased toward P2/P4 teams) is dumb and simply not true. There is no statistical model that remotely suggests that the top G5/G6 teams record-wise will beat a 4th Place SEC or B1G team at a 99% Confidence Level (which is what is required in most models not to accept the null hypothesis) - they wouldn't even be accepted at a 95% Confidence Level (i.e., 2 SD) or even 67% Confidence Level (3 SD).......

Just dumb to claim that "absolute record" should be used to determine a Post Season Field that includes only 12 teams from among 135 teams playing completely disparate schedules and schedule strengths. Dumb and completely statistically invalid.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
And yet none of those teams ever win, so why bother?
They're given a chance--that's what you should want
It's creates a reason for teams to play games after they have a loss or two
This anti-playoff concept is so antiquated it's laughable.
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
They're given a chance--that's what you should want
It's creates a reason for teams to play games after they have a loss or two
This anti-playoff concept is so antiquated it's laughable.
I’m not anti-playoff….I’m anti-everyone gets a trophy playoff. I’m also anti- a group of guys with an agenda picking who gets to be in playoff.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
I’m not anti-playoff….I’m anti-everyone gets a trophy playoff. I’m also anti- a group of guys with an agenda picking who gets to be in playoff.
No one is getting a trophy unless you win a title
A 24 teams playoff is still under 18% of teams in getting--and that will continue to decrease as FBS grows and grows
You're still earning it. If everyone made the argument you'd have a point
Now, your last sentence is fair--I'm all for auto bids that make sense.
 

BillyPoe

Redshirt
Aug 21, 2026
12
10
3
Either a 24 team CFB playoff in December or watching the NFL with players dogging it
because they are locked into the playoffs.
Few NFL teams actually battle for the playoffs, it doesn't get good til January.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State TE Benjamin Brahmer announces he'll return for the 2027 season
  2. 02 BWI Football Penn State Transfer Portal Preview: Four Potential Quarterback Targets to Know for 2027
  3. 03 BWI Football Trimmings: Penn State's Senior Day list and what we're hearing on those who could come back for 2027
  4. 04 BWI Basketball Penn State set to add international point guard Savo Drezgic
  5. 05 BWI Football Matt Campbell says Penn State became a real team, now wants to prove it for 60 minutes