Example of why 24 team playoff is too many

Blair10

All-Conference
Dec 30, 2002
2,169
4,618
113
6-4 LSU would still be in the conversation, and probably in if they beat Tennessee.

I have said this from the start. There are never 24 very good football teams at the P4 level in college football. Sadly, this is what happens to a sport when greed and money become the top priority of universities.

The schools don’t care if the product becomes watered down as long as they continue to get paid their collective billions. Mediocrity is here to stay for the foreseeable future.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Thankfully--the powers that be are ignoring this nonsense
With an 8 team playoff, that some of you want, the season is over for almost every program
We have countless good games.
There's no reason an 8-4 team shouldn't be in consideration for the playoff
Stop thinking being undefeated is the goal--is was always ridiculous and encouraged weak schedules to ensure wins
That all changes now--and it's long overdue
You can all keep complaining about this every week but games like Arizona-Utah yesterday are exactly why expansion is needed--especially as parity has taken over due to NIL
 

Blair10

All-Conference
Dec 30, 2002
2,169
4,618
113
Thankfully--the powers that be are ignoring this nonsense
With an 8 team playoff, that some of you want, the season is over for almost every program
We have countless good games.
There's no reason an 8-4 team shouldn't be in consideration for the playoff
Stop thinking being undefeated is the goal--is was always ridiculous and encouraged weak schedules to ensure wins
That all changes now--and it's long overdue
You can all keep complaining about this every week but games like Arizona-Utah yesterday are exactly why expansion is needed--especially as parity has taken over due to NIL

Most of the CFB fans I’ve encountered enjoy watching a high quality product. There would be only a small number of objections or complaints if the product quality was maintained. Fans loved seeing teams loaded with tons of NFL caliber talent facing off on a Saturday.

However, what we are witnessing is more and more blue blood programs with average talent on their rosters and some just horrendous play. The product quality is the issue. Fans are charged enormous sums of money to watch a degraded product. This is not a sustainable model for college football.
 
May 11, 2016
467
275
63
Most of the CFB fans I’ve encountered enjoy watching a high quality product. There would be only a small number of objections or complaints if the product quality was maintained. Fans loved seeing teams loaded with tons of NFL caliber talent facing off on a Saturday.

However, what we are witnessing is more and more blue blood programs with average talent on their rosters and some just horrendous play. The product quality is the issue. Fans are charged enormous sums of money to watch a degraded product. This is not a sustainable model for college football.
Which do think you might prefer? A meal with an 8 ounce filet mignon or a 24 ounce hamburger?
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Most of the CFB fans I’ve encountered enjoy watching a high quality product. There would be only a small number of objections or complaints if the product quality was maintained. Fans loved seeing teams loaded with tons of NFL caliber talent facing off on a Saturday.

However, what we are witnessing is more and more blue blood programs with average talent on their rosters and some just horrendous play. The product quality is the issue. Fans are charged enormous sums of money to watch a degraded product. This is not a sustainable model for college football.
So, fans wanted a dozen or so good teams and everyone else to be garbage?
How are we not seeing NFL caliber talent facing each other now?
The product isn't downgraded--the competition is better than ever--some just want to see super teams apparently
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Ummm, except for the fact that they already lost four f@@@ing times!!!
Who cares that they lost 4 times? In what other sport is 4 losses unacceptable?
You all have this insane belief that the goal is to be 12-0 because it used to be--back when teams played 2 or 3 teams that had any talent a year.
 

Blair10

All-Conference
Dec 30, 2002
2,169
4,618
113
So, fans wanted a dozen or so good teams and everyone else to be garbage?
How are we not seeing NFL caliber talent facing each other now?
The product isn't downgraded--the competition is better than ever--some just want to see super teams apparently

Have you watched Penn State’s linebacker play this season? Aside from Rojas, can you seriously tell me the other linebackers are legitimate B1G linebackers? Answer honestly.

The entire defensive line is a disaster. No quality tackles and no quality defensive ends. Even with an easy schedule, the team still has some very bad losses to mediocre to poor teams.
 
May 11, 2016
467
275
63
Who cares that they lost 4 times? In what other sport is 4 losses unacceptable?
You all have this insane belief that the goal is to be 12-0 because it used to be--back when teams played 2 or 3 teams that had any talent a year.
What other sport of significance has a 12 game season? No one has said it requires a 12-0 season, 10-2 should be enough to weed out the crap.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AvgUser

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
845
926
93
Who cares that they lost 4 times? In what other sport is 4 losses unacceptable?
You all have this insane belief that the goal is to be 12-0 because it used to be--back when teams played 2 or 3 teams that had any talent a year.
They played scrimmages against la tech and mcneese. That 4-4 record with a win against Clemson deserves the playoff. I think 12 or 16 brings in several in worthy teams, but should be the max
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Have you watched Penn State’s linebacker play this season? Aside from Rojas, can you seriously tell me the other linebackers are legitimate B1G linebackers? Answer honestly.

The entire defensive line is a disaster. No quality tackles and no quality defensive ends. Even with an easy schedule, the team still has some very bad losses to mediocre to poor teams.
I have--what do you mean by "legitimate B1G linebackers"? All year, people have incorrectly stated Hansen and everyone from Iowa State can't play in the B1G which is utterly false. We've had bad LB play countless times under Franklin as well. Seems like for most of the season they've done well enough to compete.

You're not accepting parity exists--there's talent throughout the country now--not just a dozen teams. You liked when teams could hoard talent and their backups were better than most other teams starters--that's not how it works now and that's a good thing for those that like competition.

What "very bad losses" have we had to a "poor team"?
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
They played scrimmages against la tech and mcneese. That 4-4 record with a win against Clemson deserves the playoff. I think 12 or 16 brings in several in worthy teams, but should be the max
Did you read what I wrote? Why is no one comprehending this?
You're going to see more conference games and more quality non-conference games now that you don't need to worry about being 12-0
It wouldn't be shocking at all if the SEC and Big Ten go to 10 or 11 conference games
 

NEPA Lion

Junior
Nov 2, 2021
182
254
63
Every team that is not in the playoff that plays in a BOWL game will have multiple players sit
out see PSU vs Arkansas, Mississippi, and Clemson.
It's a good extension for CFB fans.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KingLando

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
The best news is...you all can start a thread daily about how bad this is but it's here to stay...and thank God because the antiquated bowl system and horrible CCGs are ending.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Waaaaaaaany

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Then only make it two conferences. The way it is can’t work. But I still say 9th in your 16 team conference means you aren’t good enough to be in playoffs
That's a great opinion but your opinion isn't relevant.
I'm also not sure who you think is getting in as SEC 9
You're taking the rankings with 3 games left and finalizing them. That all takes care of itself. See Mizzou, South Carolina and LSU yesterday.
Now if you want 10 auto bids (conference winners) and 14 at larges (which would go to ND/Big Ten/SEC/Big XII/ACC primarily if not fully) I fully support that
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
If IU isn't ahead of Bama, it's all wrong. Sorry. The goal should be to win games, not pass eye tests.
Ummm--Indiana has struggled almost every single week. Bama's played the 3rd hardest schedule--Indiana has played the 54th
Why is that a problem? The goal is to win games but sometimes 8-2 is more impressive than 9-1.
Does Indiana even have a ranked win? We'll see how far USC falls I guess
Kentucky losing hurts Bama's resume but it's still better than Indiana who's best bullet point on the resume is how they lost to Ohio State
 

Blair10

All-Conference
Dec 30, 2002
2,169
4,618
113
I have--what do you mean by "legitimate B1G linebackers"? All year, people have incorrectly stated Hansen and everyone from Iowa State can't play in the B1G which is utterly false. We've had bad LB play countless times under Franklin as well. Seems like for most of the season they've done well enough to compete.

You're not accepting parity exists--there's talent throughout the country now--not just a dozen teams. You liked when teams could hoard talent and their backups were better than most other teams starters--that's not how it works now and that's a good thing for those that like competition.

What "very bad losses" have we had to a "poor team"?

Penn State LBs (excluding Rojas) can’t shed blocks, can’t cover in passing situations, can’t tackle, and are slow and get pushed around when engaging blockers. To say ”they have done well enough to compete” is just mind-boggling and setting the bar to Purdue-level standards.

The horrendous loss to a much less talented Wisconsin team was a total embarrassment. Especially after Penn State squandered a big lead.

I am surrounded by Michigan fans and there is no question that the 2026 imposter version of the wolverines are the worst Michigan team since pre-Schemechler days. They are just brutal to watch. The Michigan fan outrage has reached epic levels.

Lastly, my bet is that a sizable number of CFB fans will show their displeasure against the mediocre and degraded product by not attending the games. The value case has eroded.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Ummmm. They win every week. That matters to me more than Herby's dog's opinion.
Look at the data--ignore opinion and deal with facts
Indiana isn't very good--kudos to Cignetti for finding ways to win but they're going to get trounced in the playoff if they don't correct a lot of things quickly.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
I only want 16 teams. Top 5 in sec and big ten and top 3 from acc and big 12. Other teams want in then they have to join one of those conferences. No use of rankings
I mean--I'm find with 2 levels of FBS and auto bids
I'd rather just take the top 48 teams--put them into 4 groups of 12--play 11 conference games and the top 4 from each make the playoff
They can even realign divisions every 4 years or whatever for balance.
But, again, I'd take this suggestion
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Penn State LBs (excluding Rojas) can’t shed blocks, can’t cover in passing situations, can’t tackle, and are slow and get pushed around when engaging blockers. To say ”they have done well enough to compete” is just mind-boggling and setting the bar to Purdue-level standards.

The horrendous loss to a much less talented Wisconsin team was a total embarrassment. Especially after Penn State squandered a big lead.

I am surrounded by Michigan fans and there is no question that the 2026 imposter version of the wolverines are the worst Michigan team since pre-Schemechler days. They are just brutal to watch. The Michigan fan outrage has reached epic levels.

Lastly, my bet is that a sizable number of CFB fans will show their displeasure against the mediocre and degraded product by not attending the games. The value case has eroded.
Then why aren't we giving up 80 points a game?
The loss to Wisconsin was literally a blown coverage--that Wisconsin team also embarrassed USC. I know most here haven't accepted parity yet but you're going to have to get used to things like this happening. See what UCF did to BYU. Or Auburn beating Georgia
Michigan fans are being overdramatic which I'm guessing you're used to--they also have a short memory if they don't remember bad years since Bo.
The value of the games has increased not decreased--what games are they skipping? I assure you good teams like Georgia and Utah don't agree with your assessment at all.
But attendance is going to drop regardless--younger generations don't care about it like we did and the experience is better from your couch, a bar, a friend's house, etc. than going to a game.
 
May 11, 2016
467
275
63
Have yet to see a valid objective argument that more = better.

I have noticed that attendance and viewership is trending downward in most markets. SEC and B12 has not suffered much but the rest of the field is down.

Waiting for the day when the playoff expands to 64 or more. May as well instead of nickle and dime expansions.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
It’s the same thing. With different branding.
It's not at all--the winner moves on
I'm not sure how you don't grasp one is contending for a title while the other is a reward--and the Pinstripe Bowl isn't a good reward--but at least they get SWAG--only reason they even go
 

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,055
21,624
113
It's not at all--the winner moves on
I'm not sure how you don't grasp one is contending for a title while the other is a reward--and the Pinstripe Bowl isn't a good reward--but at least they get SWAG--only reason they even go

It’s not at all. Not even close.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State TE Benjamin Brahmer announces he'll return for the 2027 season
  2. 02 BWI Football Penn State Transfer Portal Preview: Four Potential Quarterback Targets to Know for 2027
  3. 03 BWI Football Trimmings: Penn State's Senior Day list and what we're hearing on those who could come back for 2027
  4. 04 BWI Basketball Penn State set to add international point guard Savo Drezgic
  5. 05 BWI Football Matt Campbell says Penn State became a real team, now wants to prove it for 60 minutes