Example of why 24 team playoff is too many

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
No one is getting a trophy unless you win a title
A 24 teams playoff is still under 18% of teams in getting--and that will continue to decrease as FBS grows and grows
You're still earning it. If everyone made the argument you'd have a point
Now, your last sentence is fair--I'm all for auto bids that make sense.
Until there’s a set system and every team knows what they have to do to make a playoff, it’s not a real playoff, so it’s dumb to increase the number of teams.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
It is a license to be mediocre with no penalty.

Still waiting on how it makes things better.
The penalties include playing on the road and playing an extra game while not controlling your destiny of getting in.
Everyone wants the bye followed by a home game
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Until there’s a set system and every team knows what they have to do to make a playoff, it’s not a real playoff, so it’s dumb to increase the number of teams.
It's not--if anything without a real system to determine it you should have more because of the subjectivity of it
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
It's not--if anything without a real system to determine it you should have more because of the subjectivity of it
Let the conferences have their own tournaments then the winners play….that would be legit.
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,367
1,354
113
It's not--if anything without a real system to determine it you should have more because of the subjectivity of it

Not to mention that there is currently an auto-bid for the P4 Champion (which will persist in 24 Team Format - they will still have Conference Champs even without CCG just as they did prior to CCG). However, they need Wild Card slots so the top 4 of the P2 Conferences can be included (and at least top 2 from the other P4 Conferences). An autobid will remain for top CFP Ranked g5/g6 team (probably should be top 2 if we're going to include ND in this group) and there will still be enough Wild Cards to admit deserving teams from this 75 field group.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Let the conferences have their own tournaments then the winners play….that would be legit.
I'm sorry but that's horrible idea. Why are you valuing the champion of any other conference the same as the SEC and Big Ten.
Then all good teams should create their own conference to ensure that playoff spot
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
I'm sorry but that's horrible idea. Why are you valuing the champion of any other conference the same as the SEC and Big Ten.
Then all good teams should create their own conference to ensure that playoff spot
Because the key to winning a NC is to win, so the winners of the SEC and Big should end up playing each other in the finals if they’re that much better than everyone else.
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,367
1,354
113
Let the conferences have their own tournaments then the winners play….that would be legit.

Really? This basically says that all Conferences have the same strength. If they go to guaranteed slot for every conference, I'd immediately join the AAC if I were PSU and make them sign a deal where PSU gets to keep all their own media $$$ and Post-Season $$$ (i.e., similar to an ND model).
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,367
1,354
113
Because the key to winning a NC is to win, so the winners of the SEC and Big should end up playing each other in the finals if they’re that much better than everyone else.

Uuuuummmmm........, the key to running a legit 12 or 24 team Playoff is letting the most deserving top 12 or 24 teams in, not just the top 2 most deserving.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Because the key to winning a NC is to win, so the winners of the SEC and Big should end up playing each other in the finals if they’re that much better than everyone else.
Again, this is penalizing the top conferences
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
Really? This basically says that all Conferences have the same strength. If they go to guaranteed slot for every conference, I'd immediately join the AAC if I were PSU and make them sign a deal where PSU gets to keep all their own media $$$ and Post-Season $$$ (i.e., similar to an ND model).
First of all, no team would do that. Secondly, I think only P4 conferences should get in. There are hardly any legit programs left that aren’t in a conference.
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
Uuuuummmmm........, the key to running a legit 12 or 24 team Playoff is letting the most deserving top 12 or 24 teams in, not just the top 2 most deserving.
They would be in a playoff, for their conference tournament. Then the goal would be to win that tournament to get into the final four.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
How? They would have their playoff to determine their representative…how is that penalizing anyone?
Why would all conferences get 1 team--it doesn't make sense and doesn't exist in any American sport for a reason
It's illogical
The SEC and MAC shouldn't both get one team. Georgia shouldn't have to play 3 games against great/good teams to have the right to play a MAC team who battles other MAC schools.
You're not looking to have a real conversation with this kind absurd logic. No one would ever agree to it in ANY sport.
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,367
1,354
113
First of all, no team would do that. Secondly, I think only P4 conferences should get in. There are hardly any legit programs left that aren’t in a conference.

Well that may be what you "think", but the reality is that there are 135 NCAA FBS Programs, not just 59. So what you "think" would eliminate ND, Utah, BYU and TxTe;ch - all within the current Top12 of the CFP Rankings (i.e., fully one-third of the field), but this somehow makes perfect sense???? Really???
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
Why would all conferences get 1 team--it doesn't make sense and doesn't exist in any American sport for a reasons
It's illogical
The SEC and MAC shouldn't both get one team. Georgia shouldn't have to play 3 games against great/good teams to have the right to play a MAC team who battles other MAC schools.
You're not looking to have a real conversation with this kind absurd logic. No one would ever agree to it in ANY sport.
They get as many teams as they want. The tournament part of it is at the conference level and the conferences decide how many teams make it. Then the winners of the P4 conferences have a playoff. The non-P4 conferences aren’t included.
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
Well that may be what you "think", but the reality is that there are 135 NCAA FBS Programs, not just 59. So what you "think" would eliminate ND, Utah, BYU and TxTe;ch - all within the current Top12 of the CFP Rankings (i.e., fully one-third of the field), but this somehow makes perfect sense???? Really???
Then they should join a conference. And Utah, BYU, and Texas Tech are in a conference.
 
Sep 10, 2013
18,541
13,554
113
The problem with 24 is that the teams at the bottom stands almost no chance of a national title, and as we all know its a money grab.

this is my travel fun point. Would you go to South Carolina for a gamecock playoff first round game?that would be AWESOME! Would you go to same if it was a pinstripe type bowl game with 12 opt outs between both teams? Of course you wouldn’t.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
They get as many teams as they want. The tournament part of it is at the conference level and the conferences decide how many teams make it. Then the winners of the P4 conferences have a playoff. The non-P4 conferences aren’t included.
You have to be joking--why would the SEC and Big Ten get the same as the ACC and Big XII when they're significantly better.
Clearly you're not looking to have a real discussion
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
You have to be joking--why would the SEC and Big Ten get the same as the ACC and Big XII when they're significantly better.
Clearly you're not looking to have a real discussion
Obviously you’re not listening.
 

CDLionFL

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2021
1,785
2,727
113
Until there’s a set system and every team knows what they have to do to make a playoff, it’s not a real playoff, so it’s dumb to increase the number of teams.
I'm with ya on that one. There are 10 conferences. After the 10 conference champions get their automatic bid, then it's 14 at larges. If you're not among one of the best 14 at-large teams, then you really don't have a gripe. Will there be wipeouts in the first round? Of course there will be. That's the way it is in 1-AA as well. But it's football and people are addicted to it so they'll watch the games and the networks will make their money just like they want. Then, a team like UL Monroe or UTEP will know on the first day of summer camp that they have a chance to win a national championship in their sport.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bison13 and LionJim

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
I'm with ya on that one. There are 10 conferences. After the 10 conference champions get their automatic bid, then it's 14 at larges. If you're not among one of the best 14 at-large teams, then you really don't have a gripe. Will there be wipeouts in the first round? Of course there will be. That's the way it is in 1-AA as well. But it's football and people are addicted to it so they'll watch the games and the networks will make their money just like they want. Then, a team like UL Monroe or UTEP will know on the first day of summer camp that they have a chance to win a national championship in their sport.
Half the problem is including all 10 conferences.
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,367
1,354
113
Then they should join a conference. And Utah, BYU, and Texas Tech are in a conference.

This is an absurd conversation - there is no other NCAA-Sponsored Sport/Championship that "requires" Conference affiliation. Why should a team be required to do something the NCAA does not require just because "Ludd says it should be that way"???? Just a ridiculous statement that isn't even debatable - that is not an NCAA requirement for FBS Membership and likely never will be, so your supposed point is not a point in any real way other than to be self-serving drivel to support your pointless argument. And again, it is stupid to claim that all conferences should be treated as if they are identical in terms of quality and depth in terms of numbers of auto-bids and wildcard positions granted. Just utterly dumb and statistically unsupoorted.
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
845
926
93
Your argument is not good in that 12 teams excludes teams that are quite possibly contenders, but due to teams playing vastly different schedules, they are left out due to absolute record. Comparing simple W-L record of 135 teams playing VASTLY different schedules with almost no overlap is dumb and not statistically valid. The only answer is allowing the top teams from from P2 (6-8) / P4 Conference (12-16 teams) into the playoffs and the remaining top 8-12 teams from non-P4 teams and independents (which is on the order of a field of 75 teams). That is not too many teams for a Playoff. Beyond that, since the teams are seeded in the Playoff (with a top 8 seeds receiving a bye in first round), it's just dumb to claim that the #9 seed shouldn't beat the #24 seed AT HOME if they are truly the #9 seed (which is impossible to say just looking at records when the #9 and #24 seeds will generally have played a completely different schedule during the regular season). But again, it's dumb to claim that you can absolutely tell the difference between the lowest 16 seeds in a 24 team Playoff Format by simply comparing records when the #9 Seed could quite possibly have a much better overall record playing in the MWC or the MAC or the P12 or the AAC..... etc..... versus the #24 seed playing in the SEC or B1G. But again, if the #9 Seed can't beat that SEC or B1G team @Home, then they really weren't the #9 team in the country in the first place - were they?????
I don’t care if LSU can win it. A 4 or 5 loss team shouldn’t have a chance
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
I'm with ya on that one. There are 10 conferences. After the 10 conference champions get their automatic bid, then it's 14 at larges. If you're not among one of the best 14 at-large teams, then you really don't have a gripe. Will there be wipeouts in the first round? Of course there will be. That's the way it is in 1-AA as well. But it's football and people are addicted to it so they'll watch the games and the networks will make their money just like they want. Then, a team like UL Monroe or UTEP will know on the first day of summer camp that they have a chance to win a national championship in their sport.
I think most are on board with this set up
As long as new conferences aren't created so there's more auto bids for lesser teams
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
This is an absurd conversation - there is no other NCAA-Sponsored Sport/Championship that "requires" Conference affiliation. Why should a team be required to do something the NCAA does not require just because "Ludd says it should be that way"???? Just a ridiculous statement that isn't even debatable - that is not an NCAA requirement for FBS Membership and likely never will be, so your supposed point is not a point in any real way other than to be self-serving drivel to support your pointless argument. And again, it is stupid to claim that all conferences should be treated as if they are identical in terms of quality and depth in terms of numbers of auto-bids and wildcard positions granted. Just utterly dumb and statistically unsupoorted.
Lighten up, Frances. It would still be a playoff tournament, not sure why you can’t follow that basic premise.
 

Ludd

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,406
6,175
113
I am...your proposal would never be agreed upon in any sports league in the US...never. It's you valuing all conference champs the same.
Only the P4 conferences and don’t you think a 24 team playoff will include the champions of the P4 conferences? Don’t the champions of each division in the NFL get into the playoffs? So I guess they value all division champs the same- there goes your argument.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
Only the P4 conferences and don’t you think a 24 team playoff will include the champions of the P4 conferences? Don’t the champions of each division in the NFL get into the playoffs? So I guess they value all division champs the same- there goes your argument.
Who said it wouldn't include the P4 champs...it just shouldn't ONLY include them.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,204
4,811
113
It should after the tournaments have concluded and four champs have been crowned legitimately.
Again...why would the SEC and Big Ten agree to that and allow the other two conferences to have an easier path to one of 4 spots? A conference playoff doesn't negate its a 4 team playoff...
You're not stupid...you know this would never happen or be considered
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State TE Benjamin Brahmer announces he'll return for the 2027 season
  2. 02 BWI Football Penn State Transfer Portal Preview: Four Potential Quarterback Targets to Know for 2027
  3. 03 BWI Football Trimmings: Penn State's Senior Day list and what we're hearing on those who could come back for 2027
  4. 04 BWI Basketball Penn State set to add international point guard Savo Drezgic
  5. 05 BWI Football Matt Campbell says Penn State became a real team, now wants to prove it for 60 minutes