IOWA #15 in the 3rd CFP Rankings (Nov 17). "Clearly the decal matters quite a bit to this committee."

airhawk

Senior
Jan 3, 2023
324
517
93
Hawk fans I hate to say this but you guys need to drop the ISU game and start playing a quality OOC P4 team for once. You also need to drop 2 of the 3 conference rivalry games so when they schedule there is a better chance you get the good teams on your schedule to boost it. Having 4 trophy games every year against average to terrible teams is going to help you stack wins but they won’t be quality. Last year was Iowa’s first respectable schedule in what a decade?
You know that Big 10 controls conference schedule right? Iowa can’t just drop certain games.
 

Slappy Pappy

Senior
Nov 24, 2007
168
404
63
This is really like the TV networks/powers that be telling Iowa you are a #15 program(not team)/TV Market, we will include you when we go to 24 along with all 6-4 sec teams.
It's all about getting the right "brand names" in there for the ratings to up the price they can get for the new contract. Oregon, OSU, PSU, Michigan, USC, are the B1G Names that sell the conference to the TV channels. They're all down this year, which made a heckuva rare opportunity for Iowa to make it to the playoffs if we just take of business.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
Hope not, go Wake and Tech and BYU, ACC and B12 each get at least two...I can't even summarize how much of a joke all this is and the political nonsense of the committee, etc.

yep. we thought we would be at #13 with only 2 teams to jump.

unbelievable
 

yrunvs

Senior
Feb 18, 2012
331
552
93
One more time.
We have no big wins
We do have a bad loss.
Iowa is not making the playoffs.
Beating at the time a ranked Michigan and Wisconsin were big wins as far as I'm concerned. Also beating Washington and a at one time ranked NW felt pretty darn good. On the other hand some of those sec on sec wins don't look like "big wins" to many of us and I see many sec on sec "bad losses".
It all starts and ends with fake rankings controlled by fake voters.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
It's just bad luck that Iowa's schedule turned out to be as weak as it ended up with Wisky/NW/Michigan crapping the bed after those games.

I agree that a win vs Minnesota probably even wouldn't have been enough.
That said, the SEC bias is laughable.

but just 2 teams to pass instead of 4
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
Exactly, so Iowa playing the schedule it was dealt for the most part beats a ranked MICH on the road at the time, a ranked Wisky at home at the time and a road win vs NW who was about 26 plus a trashing road win vs Wash. Hell as mentioned a walk FG win over Gophers would not get us in Top 12 as now, I'm even more convinced now given that UCLA example...yikes

they're gonna find a way to get UCLA out of the top 4, I am afraid....
 

airhawk

Senior
Jan 3, 2023
324
517
93
It matters because it is used to artificially prop up the higher tanked SEC teams. A bunch of sh-tty SEC teams lose to each other over and over and remain ranked, giving their upper echelon credit for "ranked" wins. Meanwhile similar Big Ten teams like Illinois, Wisconsin and Northwestern can't even sniff the rankings, which in turn gives the SECFP Committee the ability to rationalize (for lack of a better word) downplaying Big Ten resumes as being bereft of ranked wins.

It's a self-fulfilling vicious cycle prophecy over which they alone have 100% control. They are quite literally making up the rules as they go along.
This sums it up
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
That’s exactly right. . there’s nothing Iowa could do if the fix is in.

and here we thought Oregon was the team to worry about when it came to getting passed.

good grief; a 6 spot jump for Ohio State for a 9 point HOME WIN for Northwestern???
 

RuggieC

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2014
648
1,286
93
Nobody left on our schedule is helping our résumé and at this point we have to count on like five teams to lose. It ain’t happening. The party is over.
HXYPCRuXMAAaejf.jpg
Who needs resume help when you have the BCS committee and ESPN! What a freaking joke this is. 4 6-4 SEC Teams being used to bolster the SOS for the SEC.
 

85Bears

All-American
Aug 31, 2019
6,345
7,040
108
It's all about getting the right "brand names" in there for the ratings to up the price they can get for the new contract. Oregon, OSU, PSU, Michigan, USC, are the B1G Names that sell the conference to the TV channels. They're all down this year, which made a heckuva rare opportunity for Iowa to make it to the playoffs if we just take of business.
It’s about west coast tv markets, and Iowa is not what they want.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
Still have flashbacks of that. :mad:

3 interceptions thrown. 1 lost fumble.

In addition, there were these fook ups:

COST US 3 POINTS: 1 blocked punt.

COST US 7 POINTS: Jaylen Watson lined up offsides on 4th and goal, where the defense held. This gave MN a 5th down, where they scored a TD.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Hawksfor3

BunchofAholes

All-American
Jul 9, 2025
2,645
5,001
113
Beating at the time a ranked Michigan and Wisconsin were big wins as far as I'm concerned. Also beating Washington and a at one time ranked NW felt pretty darn good. On the other hand some of those sec on sec wins don't look like "big wins" to many of us and I see many sec on sec "bad losses".
It all starts and ends with fake rankings controlled by fake voters.
So Wisconsin, Northwestern and Michigan were not "fake rankings"? SEC bias exists, sure. But like it or not, the teams above us all have better resumes. One problem is our schedule (which is largely out of our control). No Indiana, Oregon, USC, UCLA.
Losing at Minnesota knocked us out of the hunt. End of story.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
Who cares about the 4 loss teams? None of them are making the playoffs anyway.

IOWA playing a ranked Illinois team this week would have mattered

Instead, they ranked FOUR OF THE 7 of the 6-4 SEC teams

At least they showed some restraint and didn't rank 6-4 Auburn, 6-4 LSU and 6-4 Missouri....
 
  • Like
Reactions: DukeSlater

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
Well that took all the excitement away from these last two games. If there is any justice OSU and Oregon will lose again while Iowa wins out.

When you see those 6-4 SEC teams in the cfp top top 25 you this is just crap

Yeah, I don't think we will see ENOUGH chaos over the next 2 weeks for IOWA to pass 4 teams....
 

Palmerhawk

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,639
5,160
113
This arbitrary designation of quality wins as a top 25 stinks.
All 8 Iowa wins are vs non losing record teams outside of Purdue.
But non of them is considered a " quality win"?


Beating minny would not have helped us as minny is not top 25
The loss to OSU ended our hopes,period
Iowa had to go 12-0 to have a chance to leapfrog any sec team.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
All Iowa can do is win the last two on the schedule. That should be expected, the Hawkeyes have the better team. Everything else is beyond our control. It wouldn't hurt if we ground them into the turf and won by large margins.

Yep Minnesota cost us. The WTF game has happened and cost Iowa in the past- remember the clown game in 2002?

It could be argued that Oregon had not 1 but 2 WTF games....


 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,667
15,903
113
IOWA playing a ranked Illinois team this week would have mattered

Instead, they ranked FOUR OF THE 7 of the 6-4 SEC teams

At least they showed some restraint and didn't rank 6-4 Auburn, 6-4 LSU and 6-4 Missouri....
It doesn't matter. Nothing matters anymore. Certainly not the outcomes of the games. The committee made that abundantly clear last night.
 
  • Love
Reactions: DukeSlater

BunchofAholes

All-American
Jul 9, 2025
2,645
5,001
113
It could be argued that Oregon had not 1 but 2 WTF games....


True. They also won @ USC and @ Ohio State. The Boise St team they beat in the opener has won 9 straight and will likely make the playoff. We have no wins like those to balance out our bad loss.
 
Feb 25, 2008
33,182
32,558
113
How does osu jump 6 spots
*Iowa
 
  • Sad
Reactions: Franisdaman

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
And I was willing to concede having Oregon pass us as I also believed that Iowa would pass them over but there is no reason OSU should pass us over with losing their QB. Completely different team.

and Ohio State's unconvincing win over Northwestern made the committee think OSU should be jumped up 6 spots?

 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
College sports, and football in particular, imploded several years ago. Unfortunately it is taking this direct kick to the groin to really feel the impact. The CFP is a tv show for ratings and $$$. Oregon and Ohio State are more valuable than Iowa. Same with teams like Alabama, Tennessee, etc. The committee will find a way to draw the most eyeballs to their event, at the expense of teams like ours.

I am afraid you are right.
 

Passing Is For COMMIES

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2023
614
1,146
93
I’m fine with Iowa getting left out, the resume is not up to snuff compared to any other 2 loss P4 team.

But being behind 3 loss teams, Bama being above Tennessee and Texas? They lost to Tennessee, Texas beat Tennessee, and both those teams have more ranked wins than Bama. 4 6-4 SEC teams staying in the top 25? South Carolina got CRUSHED by a terrible Arkansas team but they only drop 4 spots? ND crushes Boston College, Texas barely survives an unranked LSU team, but they get to jump ND? Indiana moves down 4 spots on a bye because teams they beat lost. All 6 of Alabama’s SEC wins lost last week and they stay put?

The committee does not publish any of their metrics at all, we only get snippets explained in this dumb TV show, and their criteria changes every week. Basketball publishes the NET Rankings. Everyone knows what they are, how they work, and how they need to operate to make the Tourney. Why can’t we get that in football? How is it fair to any school in the country if the selection criteria is hidden?

If the committee refuses to publish their process, metrics, and how those metrics work, I’m pretty much forced to believe it’s because they want to put bigger brands and SEC teams in over other teams with better records. They aren’t giving any evidence to the contrary.

I think I’m just gonna have to switch to the NFL, this is bogus. Next year these crappy SEC teams are going to get in seeds 20-24 in the 24 team playoff too.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
OSU will beat Nebby because they like to beat themselves, but the Michigan game might be a first to 10 wins type game. Hopefully Mich pulls it out. Not sure Oregon loses again.

Also, none of us are panicking, we are realizing their is a very very large chance Iowa is left out for 9-3 teams come playoff seeding.

Yeah, I just don't see us passing 4 teams in the next 2 weeks....
 

DukeSlater

All-American
Jul 2, 2023
2,496
5,491
113
Embrace that pissed off vibe Kirk. Run up that ******* score from here on out just 'cause. Play some smash mouth pissed off ball Saturday c'mon.
I'm not sure the old man has it in him. Cignetti has called the committee out, finishing with, "I'm 65 years old, and I don't give a shitt."
I'm not sure KF at 71 has that kinda fire. I hope he does. And I hope the right teams lose the next two weeks so the committee will have no choice but to include Iowa. Mr. Pettiti and the Big Ten should be goin' nuts, at least behind the scenes. This bullshitt should not be allowed to stand. And every other college football outlet outside of ESPN should be calling out this corruption and bias.
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,667
15,903
113
I'm not sure the old man has it in him. Cignetti has called the committee out, finishing with, "I'm 65 years old, and I don't give a shitt."
I'm not sure KF at 71 has that kinda fire. I hope he does. And I hope the right teams lose the next two weeks so the committee will have no choice but to include Iowa. Mr. Pettiti and the Big Ten should be goin' nuts, at least behind the scenes. This bullshitt should not be allowed to stand. And every other college football outlet outside of ESPN should be calling out this corruption and bias.
The Big10 doesn't care about Iowa as long as 3 loss OSU and Oregon are above them.
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football Kelvin Bell talks Iowa defensive line development
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Basketball WATCH: Jan Jensen, Hawkeyes recap Vandy, preview Montana State
  3. 03 Rivals Basketball Recruiting Inside the recruitment of No. 12-ranked Grant Duggins: Where things stand with UNC, NC State, Kansas & more
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Basketball Recruiting Keller Daugherty officially signs with Iowa
  5. 05 On3 Football Kirk Ferentz: Iowa coaches bringing up style points in CFP race 'could be grounds for firing'