IOWA #15 in the 3rd CFP Rankings (Nov 17). "Clearly the decal matters quite a bit to this committee."

HawkBall23

Heisman
Oct 6, 2001
6,205
11,978
113
And it certainly didn't help Iowa's case when they "coasted" in the 2nd half of both NW and Purdue.

But that's always been a KG trademark with a Parker defense.
I honestly don't think KF is motivated by the CFP.
Then Iowa is never going to the CFP, even when it expands to 24.

KF will not run the score up for "style points". Never has, never will.
 
Jul 6, 2025
119
273
63
College sports, and football in particular, imploded several years ago. Unfortunately it is taking this direct kick to the groin to really feel the impact. The CFP is a tv show for ratings and $$$. Oregon and Ohio State are more valuable than Iowa. Same with teams like Alabama, Tennessee, etc. The committee will find a way to draw the most eyeballs to their event, at the expense of teams like ours.
 

WDSMHawk

All-American
Jun 30, 2019
1,969
5,158
113
And it certainly didn't help Iowa's case when they "coasted" in the 2nd half of both NW and Purdue.

But that's always been a KG trademark with a Parker defense.
I honestly don't think KF is motivated by the CFP.

Oregon beat NW by 8 at home
Ohio St beat NW by 9 at home
Iowa beat NW by 14 at NW

Margin of victory clearly doesn’t matter
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,176
29,208
113
ISU at least beat Oklahoma State, unlike Oregon.

Oregon's 3 losses, which apparently don't matter all that much....



 
Last edited:

JohnBeckwith

All-Conference
Apr 28, 2022
1,922
3,797
113
Good lord folks. Let’s take a deep breath and stop panicking like a bunch of ladies. When we beat Illinois, we’ve got another data point advantage on Oregon and I’m not convinced that OSU is winning out. Let’s let the games play out instead of whining like a bunch of Nebraska fans.
OSU will beat Nebby because they like to beat themselves, but the Michigan game might be a first to 10 wins type game. Hopefully Mich pulls it out. Not sure Oregon loses again.

Also, none of us are panicking, we are realizing their is a very very large chance Iowa is left out for 9-3 teams come playoff seeding.
 

7and5baby

Junior
Sep 22, 2018
142
236
43
Committee, driven by ESECPN, is playing chess....

--Everyone knows O$U frosh QB SUX, and they are a shell of the team they were to start the season.

--They know Oregon is playing their backup QB.

--They know they will get flack not including BIG teams with a chance to get into the Playoff

--By putting O$U/Oregon ABOVE Iowa, if any of the (NON-SEC) teams right above the BIG Teams lose(TxTch,WF), the BIG sends the weaker O$U and/or Oregon to the Playoff, setting them up to fail, and the committee can then 'brag' about including 3+ BIG teams, and also 'brag' about the $EC reclaiming they are the better conference.
 

10001110101

All-Conference
Sep 1, 2003
1,328
1,772
113
I would like to see the committee members go out for a nice steak dinner then get jumped and absolutely beat down as they leave the steakhouse while someone is filming. I wouldn’t want them to die, but I would like to see them get beat to the point they have permanent limps, loss of vision in one eye, and permanent loss of use of one or both hands.
American Housewife Angela GIF by ABC Network
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,660
15,885
113
The weird thing is that Iowa wasn't even mentioned on the show after they showed them at 15. They talked about 1-12 and then the 3 and 4 loss teams that were just outside that group. Iowa wasn't mentioned once after that.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
Don't trip on their dicks against Minn and Iowa is in. Gave the committee a reason to leave them out. Nothing Iowa can do to get in at this point. Is what it is.

Don't trip on their dicks against Minn and Iowa is in. Gave the committee a reason to leave them out. Nothing Iowa can do to get in at this point. Is what it is.
And people keep posting that, BUT that's not the issue. Many of these other teams have bad losses, certainly worse then Iowa losing at Minnesota, regardless of how bad we played. I can guarantee you if we had 4 losses we wouldn't sniff the top 25, maybe even 3 losses.
 

DaytonaHawk

Junior
Jul 28, 2025
94
217
33
This. That loss was unacceptable and even our once marquee win over Michigan looks less impressive every week. There are other teams with a more valid complaint about their ranking than us. Just keep winning and let the chips fall where they may.
Unacceptable??? Who the hell are you? Sorry, you are very important with your keyboard 😄😄😄
 

Anon1755405505

Freshman
Aug 16, 2025
68
87
18
FOUR 6-4 SEC teams make the Top 25.

The SEC bias and love fest continue.

3 LOSS Ohio State jumps 6 spots (from #20 to #14).

3 LOSS Oregon jumps IOWA, too.

This committee continues to prove that it is an absolute joke.

#14 Ohio State (7-3)
#13 Oregon (7-3)
#12 Texas Tech (9-1)
#11 Wake Forest (9-1)

The CFP Top 25:
  1. Georgia (9-1)
  2. Utah (10-0)
  3. Alabama (8-2)
  4. UCLA (10-0)
  5. Texas (8-2)
  6. Notre Dame (9-1)
  7. Miami (9-1)
  8. Indiana (9-1)
  9. Tennessee (8-2)
  10. BYU (8-2)
  11. Wake Forest (9-1)
  12. Texas Tech (9-1)
  13. Oregon (7-3)
  14. Ohio State (7-3)
  15. Iowa (8-2)
  16. Kentucky (7-3)
  17. Boise State (9-1)
  18. USC (7-3)
  19. Arizona (7-3)
  20. Houston (7-3)
  21. South Carolina (6-4)
  22. Oklahoma (6-4)
  23. Louisville (7-3)
  24. Florida (6-4)
  25. Ole Miss (6-4)


Scott Dochterman

45m ago
Scott Dochterman·
Staff Writer, Big Ten

Interesting that the committee moved Ohio State up six spots after beating Northwestern 28-19 at home one week after Iowa beat Northwestern 24-10 in Evanston. Clearly the decal matters quite a bit to this committee.
I live in Columbus and everyone was celebrating the win over Northwestern like they were a top 10 team. They were just happy to win the game. Even everyone Columbus thought they were done for the year, but now they're all excited again. The jump in rankings was like Iowa lost this week. Iowa didn't play bad enough for anyone to jump over them. Unfortunately, I think OSU will win out and make the top 12. Iowa will be on the outside looking in.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
How does osu jump 6 spots
Like Scott said its the decal. That and they know their not putting OSU in the playoff, so if they're above us, there's no way were getting in. They've already decided they're only going to put two B1G teams in this year. There was a lot of blow back after the B1G won the third straight title, and ESPN/ voters set the season up propping the SEC up even more than normal;.
 

85Bears

All-American
Aug 31, 2019
6,344
7,036
108
Like Scott said its the decal. That and they know their not putting OSU in the playoff, so if they're above us, there's no way were getting in. They've already decided they're only going to put two B1G teams in this year. There was a lot of blow back after the B1G won the third straight title, and ESPN/ voters set the season up propping the SEC up even more than normal;.
They are using OSU as a decoy to slide Oregon by Iowa. Everyone will celebrate saying OSU is out and forget all about the Oregon screw job of Iowa. They also aren’t talking about Tennessee losing to LSU which should eliminate them. I honestly think now Tennessee could lose and they will put them in because it was a “close loss” to a “great” lsu team.
 

iahawkeyes17

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2014
963
2,396
83
Like Scott said it’s the decal. That and they know their not putting OSU in the playoff, so if they're above us, there's no way were getting in. They've already decided they're only going to put two B1G teams in this year. There was a lot of blow back after the B1G won the third straight title, and ESPN/ voters set the season up propping the SEC up even more than normal;.
Sad but true. You flip our resume with Ohio st and Oregon zero chance we get in with 1 more loss than them let alone ever ranked higher. I bet if we had one of their resumes we’d be in the upper teens. Same if another big 10 school not a name brand like mich st or Wisconsin had their 3 loss resume they aren’t sniffing top 15 either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 85Bears

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
Don't disagree, at all. Just saying that nothing Iowa can do at this point matters, and some top 15 teams losing wont. They will just jump someone else up.
You were VERY clear that its Iowa's fault because they lost to Minny. Don't backpedal now. Should we have lost? NO. BUT its over the top obvious that every team is NOT being graded the same way. That's all were saying
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
2,376
4,218
113
They are using OSU as a decoy to slide Oregon by Iowa. Everyone will celebrate saying OSU is out and forget all about the Oregon screw job of Iowa. They also aren’t talking about Tennessee losing to LSU which should eliminate them. I honestly think now Tennessee could lose and they will put them in because it was a “close loss” to a “great” lsu team.
I’ve been saying that all week. There is no way in hell they’ll have the SEC have fewer than 4 teams.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Franisdaman

JohnBeckwith

All-Conference
Apr 28, 2022
1,922
3,797
113
You were VERY clear that its Iowa's fault because they lost to Minny. Don't backpedal now. Should we have lost? NO. BUT its over the top obvious that every team is NOT being graded the same way. That's all were saying
You arent the brightest bulb. Iowa shouldn't have lost to Minn, it is their fault they lost. Nothing they can do now will matter. I never mentioned any other teams. What they do is irrelevant, because the committee has made their mind up about Iowa. Thanks for tagging along.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
Don’t lose to Minnesota in embarrassing fashion, it was as easy as that.
Sorry, but no. What you, and the committee are saying is there's one set of rules for Iowa, and teams like them, and totally another set for the SEC teams and the blue bloods. Its not like that's a surprise, but CLEARLY we're playing into a stacked deck.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: Unclesammy

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
This. That loss was unacceptable and even our once marquee win over Michigan looks less impressive every week. There are other teams with a more valid complaint about their ranking than us. Just keep winning and let the chips fall where they may.
Its funny that even the talking heads ALL over the country are calling this out as ridiculous, while we have supposed Iowa fans on here saying we should be held to a different standard because we lost a road game to, a hated rival.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,061
8,622
113
Didn’t our HC just state in a press conference that talking about style points could get you fired? He doesn’t care if they make the playoffs. Would he “like” to? Yes. Will he do what he knows will help their case? No. He truly doesn’t believe results matter other than W-L.
Seriously? His message to his PLAYERS is we need to go win the next game. Control what we can. He knows he has NO control over what this dumb A---- committee does.
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football PFF Deep Dive: Illinois Fighting Illini
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Football PFF Deep Dive: Iowa Hawkeyes
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Basketball Four numbers to know ahead of Iowa-Montana State
  4. 04 On3 Football College Football Playoff Top 25: Third official 2026 CFP rankings revealed
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Football Kirk Ferentz updates injuries, talks Fighting Illini