IOWA #15 in the 3rd CFP Rankings (Nov 17). "Clearly the decal matters quite a bit to this committee."

WDSMHawk

All-American
Jun 30, 2019
1,969
5,161
113
Didn’t our HC just state in a press conference that talking about style points could get you fired? He doesn’t care if they make the playoffs. Would he “like” to? Yes. Will he do what he knows will help their case? No. He truly doesn’t believe results matter other than W-L.

If the committee is going to move Ohio St up 6 spots for beating Northwestern by 9 then no amount of style points is going to help Iowa.
 

BigOHawk1

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2001
671
1,227
93
An 8-4 SEC team or Ohio St/Oregon is going to beat out a 10-2 Iowa for the last at-large CFP spot.

That's how horse crap all this shid is.


F* that committee
Hope not, go Wake and Tech and BYU, ACC and B12 each get at least two...I can't even summarize how much of a joke all this is and the political nonsense of the committee, etc.
 

Anon1750875978

Heisman
Dec 26, 2018
10,439
17,985
113
It's just bad luck that Iowa's schedule turned out to be as weak as it ended up with Wisky/NW/Michigan crapping the bed after those games.

I agree that a win vs Minnesota probably even wouldn't have been enough.
That said, the SEC bias is laughable.
 

BigOHawk1

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2001
671
1,227
93
Even an undefeated UCLA is fighting to stay in the top 5 between 3 other SEC teams.... 2 of them with 2 losses :ROFLMAO:
Exactly, so Iowa playing the schedule it was dealt for the most part beats a ranked MICH on the road at the time, a ranked Wisky at home at the time and a road win vs NW who was about 26 plus a trashing road win vs Wash. Hell as mentioned a walk FG win over Gophers would not get us in Top 12 as now, I'm even more convinced now given that UCLA example...yikes
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,667
15,903
113
It's just bad luck that Iowa's schedule turned out to be as weak as it ended up with Wisky/NW/Michigan crapping the bed after those games.

I agree that a win vs Minnesota probably even wouldn't have been enough.
That said, the SEC bias is laughable.
It matters. The committee is ridiculous, but there's no way they put a 7-3 Big10 team ahead of a 9-1 Big10 team. I still believe that Iowa would've been in the field with only 1 loss at the end of the year. A 1 loss BIG10 team isn't getting left out given the number of 2 and possibly 3 loss teams in the field.
 
Last edited:

HawkBall23

Heisman
Oct 6, 2001
6,209
11,980
113
It's just bad luck that Iowa's schedule turned out to be as weak as it ended up with Wisky/NW/Michigan crapping the bed after those games.

I agree that a win vs Minnesota probably even wouldn't have been enough.
That said, the SEC bias is laughable.
The in-conference SOS argument is such a biased way to make sure the teams you want in get in.

How is it Iowa's fault that the schedule they were GIVEN by their conference schedulers is going be used against them because their opponents suck/ed??
 

BigOHawk1

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2001
671
1,227
93
The in-conference SOS argument is such a biased way to make sure the teams you want in get in.

How is it Iowa's fault that the schedule they were GIVEN by their conference schedulers is going be used against them because their opponents suck/ed??
Well at least give the benefit of the ranking AT THE TIME since we are in love with all these polls early in the season..boom! Then we played 3 ranked teams at the time most likely...
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
Manny Navarro

10m ago
Manny Navarro·
Staff Writer

More SEC bias?​

So, just to put a bow on this, here are the SEC’s nonconference wins over current Top-25 teams:
Texas 24-23 over Ohio State and Ole Miss 41-38 over Louisville.
That’s it. That’s the list.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
Scott Dochterman

12m ago
Scott Dochterman·
Staff Writer, Big Ten

What about 6-4 Big Ten teams?​

A tale of 6-4 teams:

Illinois won four games in a row, including 21-10 against Oregon, lost a one-score game at undefeated UCLA and couldn’t smell the rankings.

South Carolina loses by four touchdowns at the SEC’s worst team and falls only to 21st. The Gamecocks also lost by 31 points early to Alabama.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
Sam Khan Jr.

27m ago
Sam Khan Jr.·
Senior Writer, CFB

Dark omen for Playoff expansion​

Seeing a bunch of four-loss teams at the bottom of the top 25 is pretty disheartening. Not so much for this year, but looking ahead to 2027 when we begin the 24-team Playoff, because this week’s rankings pretty much solidify that we’re going to get four-loss teams into the field.

It makes me even more frustrated that the powers that be went to a 24-team format without giving every conference champion (Power 4 and Group of 6) an automatic bid. I would take the Sun Belt, Conference USA, American, MAC, Pac-12 and Mountain West conference champs over teams like a 6-4 South Carolina, who got its rear end whipped by a terrible Arkansas team.
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
2,378
4,219
113
Listening to the committee chairman makes me want to puke. Carrying the sec banner and talking out of his @SS. Lobe how mentions Tenn and already making an excuse for them if they lose this week because they beat bama and an over rated Kentucky.
I turned it off as soon as I saw Iowa still at 15. I wasn’t going to listen to their BS mental gymnastics.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
Scott Dochterman

28m ago
Scott Dochterman·
Staff Writer, Big Ten

Regarding Yurachek's Alabama answer ...​

Vanderbilt has 1 SEC win. This is a straight-up conflict of interest. If I’m Tony Petitti, I’m calling this out.


Matt Baker

29m ago
Matt Baker·
Staff Writer, College

Yurachek's defense of Bama is questionable​

Hunter Yurachek gives some credit to Alabama for avoiding a letdown at Vanderbilt. Mmk. Letdowns are at least somewhat real, but come on. Vandy is No. 80 in SP+ advanced metrics and 65th in ESPN’s FPI. Let’s not pretend like that two-score is that impressive.
 

Franisdaman

Heisman
Nov 3, 2012
19,219
29,239
113
Scott Dochterman

39m ago
Scott Dochterman·
Staff Writer, Big Ten

I’ll be straight up: this week’s rankings is the biggest load of absolute trash ever committed by any committee. South Carolina has lost 34-6 to a 3-6 team (whose AD is the CFP chair) and is still ranked. If ever there was a conflict of interest on a CFP committee, it’s this one. Duke absolutely should be ranked.
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,667
15,903
113
Scott Dochterman

12m ago
Scott Dochterman·
Staff Writer, Big Ten

What about 6-4 Big Ten teams?​

A tale of 6-4 teams:

Illinois won four games in a row, including 21-10 against Oregon, lost a one-score game at undefeated UCLA and couldn’t smell the rankings.

South Carolina loses by four touchdowns at the SEC’s worst team and falls only to 21st. The Gamecocks also lost by 31 points early to Alabama.
Who cares about the 4 loss teams? None of them are making the playoffs anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Iron Doc

Anon1750875978

Heisman
Dec 26, 2018
10,439
17,985
113
It matters. The committee is ridiculous, but there's no way they put a 7-3 Big10 team ahead of a 9-1 Big10 team. I still believe that Iowa would've been in the field with only 1 loss at the end of the year. A 1 loss BIG10 team isn't getting left out given the number of 2 and possibly 3 loss teams in the field.
It was supposedly for a different reason, but Florida State got hosed in 2023?, I believe.

Sometimes teams just get screwed.
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
2,378
4,219
113
Heather dimich pipes in
" The committee is using a new metric this year that measures conference strength in conference games only and I think that really boosted the SEC"

Ya think...keeps those 4 4 loss sec teams in top 25.
And that my friends is how create the perfect ecosystem. “We are the best because we can only beat each other.”
 

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,693
5,372
113
FOUR 6-4 SEC teams make the Top 25.

The SEC bias and love fest continue.

3 LOSS Ohio State jumps 6 spots (from #20 to #14).

3 LOSS Oregon jumps IOWA, too.

This committee continues to prove that it is an absolute joke.

#14 Ohio State (7-3)
#13 Oregon (7-3)
#12 Texas Tech (9-1)
#11 Wake Forest (9-1)

The CFP Top 25:
  1. Georgia (9-1)
  2. Utah (10-0)
  3. Alabama (8-2)
  4. UCLA (10-0)
  5. Texas (8-2)
  6. Notre Dame (9-1)
  7. Miami (9-1)
  8. Indiana (9-1)
  9. Tennessee (8-2)
  10. BYU (8-2)
  11. Wake Forest (9-1)
  12. Texas Tech (9-1)
  13. Oregon (7-3)
  14. Ohio State (7-3)
  15. Iowa (8-2)
  16. Kentucky (7-3)
  17. Boise State (9-1)
  18. USC (7-3)
  19. Arizona (7-3)
  20. Houston (7-3)
  21. South Carolina (6-4)
  22. Oklahoma (6-4)
  23. Louisville (7-3)
  24. Florida (6-4)
  25. Ole Miss (6-4)
Well that took all the excitement away from these last two games. If there is any justice OSU and Oregon will lose again while Iowa wins out.

When you see those 6-4 SEC teams in the cfp top top 25 you this is just crap
 

rchawk

Heisman
Oct 27, 2001
75,413
10,639
113
Manny Navarro

10m ago
Manny Navarro·
Staff Writer

More SEC bias?​

So, just to put a bow on this, here are the SEC’s nonconference wins over current Top-25 teams:
Texas 24-23 over Ohio State and Ole Miss 41-38 over Louisville.
That’s it. That’s the list.
All Iowa can do is win the last two on the schedule. That should be expected, the Hawkeyes have the better team. Everything else is beyond our control. It wouldn't hurt if we ground them into the turf and won by large margins.

Yep Minnesota cost us. The WTF game has happened and cost Iowa in the past- remember the clown game in 2002?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Franisdaman
Jan 3, 2004
493
985
93
FOUR 6-4 SEC teams make the Top 25.

The SEC bias and love fest continue.

3 LOSS Ohio State jumps 6 spots (from #20 to #14).

3 LOSS Oregon jumps IOWA, too.

This committee continues to prove that it is an absolute joke.

#14 Ohio State (7-3)
#13 Oregon (7-3)
#12 Texas Tech (9-1)
#11 Wake Forest (9-1)

The CFP Top 25:
  1. Georgia (9-1)
  2. Utah (10-0)
  3. Alabama (8-2)
  4. UCLA (10-0)
  5. Texas (8-2)
  6. Notre Dame (9-1)
  7. Miami (9-1)
  8. Indiana (9-1)
  9. Tennessee (8-2)
  10. BYU (8-2)
  11. Wake Forest (9-1)
  12. Texas Tech (9-1)
  13. Oregon (7-3)
  14. Ohio State (7-3)
  15. Iowa (8-2)
  16. Kentucky (7-3)
  17. Boise State (9-1)
  18. USC (7-3)
  19. Arizona (7-3)
  20. Houston (7-3)
  21. South Carolina (6-4)
  22. Oklahoma (6-4)
  23. Louisville (7-3)
  24. Florida (6-4)
  25. Ole Miss (6-4)


Scott Dochterman

45m ago
Scott Dochterman·
Staff Writer, Big Ten

Interesting that the committee moved Ohio State up six spots after beating Northwestern 28-19 at home one week after Iowa beat Northwestern 24-10 in Evanston. Clearly the decal matters quite a bit to this committee.
OSU is an SEC team..prove me wrong
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
2,378
4,219
113
Oregon lost to Illinois. If we beat them, we have a direct comparable data point. Lots of games left to be played. I’ll let it all play out before passing judgment on whether the best 11 teams made it or not.
And I was willing to concede having Oregon pass us as I also believed that Iowa would pass them over but there is no reason OSU should pass us over with losing their QB. Completely different team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Franisdaman

Anon1750875978

Heisman
Dec 26, 2018
10,439
17,985
113
And it certainly didn't help Iowa's case when they "coasted" in the 2nd half of both NW and Purdue.

But that's always been a KG trademark with a Parker defense.
I honestly don't think KF is motivated by the CFP.
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football Kelvin Bell talks Iowa defensive line development
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Basketball WATCH: Jan Jensen, Hawkeyes recap Vandy, preview Montana State
  3. 03 Rivals Basketball Recruiting Inside the recruitment of No. 12-ranked Grant Duggins: Where things stand with UNC, NC State, Kansas & more
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Basketball Recruiting Keller Daugherty officially signs with Iowa
  5. 05 On3 Football Kirk Ferentz: Iowa coaches bringing up style points in CFP race 'could be grounds for firing'