OT: Mets 2026 Season Thread

Doctor Worm

Heisman
Feb 7, 2002
30,854
22,662
113
Jorge Polanco is the absolute worst Free Agent signing in history! Congrats David!!!
I assume you are using hyperbole to make a point, and are not expecting to be taken literally.

Because Polanco is far from the worst free agent signing in METS history, let alone all of MLB.
 

RUBob75

All-Conference
Feb 5, 2003
1,044
1,239
113
Name me a $20 million dollar free agent who hit .144 in his first 97 at bats! Who is the worst free agent signing in Mets history Dr?
 

yesrutgers01

Heisman
Nov 9, 2008
122,630
38,385
113
OK- now Montas is 3 rows back at the bar waiting for a double shot of tequila lol
Though- Polanco- is a horrendous signing for so many reasons- Our brilliant leader who knows baseball better than anyone else- including HOF level players and coaches...Stearns had a plan- He knew he had Chris Tucker in the bag to be a NYM and he knew that Polanco could run prevent on defense at 1B as well as Pete and have a 25-30 HR season.

He banked on this brilliance- and imagine how bad it would be right now if he did get Tucker...
 

Doctor Worm

Heisman
Feb 7, 2002
30,854
22,662
113
Name me a $20 million dollar free agent who hit .144 in his first 97 at bats! Who is the worst free agent signing in Mets history Dr?
Well there's Jason Bay on a four year deal, and Ollie Perez on a three year deal. Granted, Ollie was good for the Mets before he signed his big money free agent deal. But after that, his performance fell of a cliff.

Of course there is Bobby Bonilla, whose memory we honor every July 1. And to a lesser extent, Vince Coleman. They were both on longer deals at bigger dollars, relative to their peers. They weren't horrible performance-wise, but from a chemistry standpoint they helped destroy that team.

You could even make the case that relative to expectations, and relative to the market at the time, George Foster and his five year record setting deal was the worst.

By definition, a bad two-year deal is not as bad as a bad multi-year deal. But if you want to talk two years, there's Frankie Montas as @yesrutgers01 mentioned. And who can forget Jed Lowrie?

I admit that come September 2027, I may change my tune if Polanco doesn't turn it around. But as you say, it's only been 100 at bats. Perhaps he will turn it around, if he can get healthy.
 

RuBird

Heisman
Jun 28, 2001
18,904
24,209
113
Why were Bay, Bonilla, Lowrie etc brought in, meaning who were they replacing? In that context Polonco free agent signing to replace Pete is the worst
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUBob75

yesrutgers01

Heisman
Nov 9, 2008
122,630
38,385
113
Well there's Jason Bay on a four year deal, and Ollie Perez on a three year deal. Granted, Ollie was good for the Mets before he signed his big money free agent deal. But after that, his performance fell of a cliff.

Of course there is Bobby Bonilla, whose memory we honor every July 1. And to a lesser extent, Vince Coleman. They were both on longer deals at bigger dollars, relative to their peers. They weren't horrible performance-wise, but from a chemistry standpoint they helped destroy that team.

You could even make the case that relative to expectations, and relative to the market at the time, George Foster and his five year record setting deal was the worst.

By definition, a bad two-year deal is not as bad as a bad multi-year deal. But if you want to talk two years, there's Frankie Montas as @yesrutgers01 mentioned. And who can forget Jed Lowrie?

I admit that come September 2027, I may change my tune if Polanco doesn't turn it around. But as you say, it's only been 100 at bats. Perhaps he will turn it around, if he can get healthy.
Bonilla really wasn’t horrible…just saying
 

yesrutgers01

Heisman
Nov 9, 2008
122,630
38,385
113
Why were Bay, Bonilla, Lowrie etc brought in, meaning who were they replacing? In that context Polonco free agent signing to replace Pete is the worst
With Bonilla- the Met's OF the prior year was McReynolds LF, Colman and Boston in CF and Hubie Brooks in RF
McReynolds not back in 1992. The OF was so bad, Hojo was asked to play CF in 1992.
 

yesrutgers01

Heisman
Nov 9, 2008
122,630
38,385
113
Looking around the league- I see many lamenting the Met's about Lindor and soto's contracts...And I am talking about our own fans as well. And justifying not signing Alonso.

Makes me wonder what fans of other teams are saying about Tatis, Tucker, Vlad, Naylor and of course- our own Bichette. Even Bellenger across town...

Lindor and Soto have been injured this year but they always perform.