Carl on PSU, "we follow the rules, there's not a lot of that going on right now"

cwobrien11

Heisman
Apr 22, 2009
19,933
34,263
77
@Misalorales I'm about halfway through the 26-50th ranked kids right now. I'm just going back 10 years...2016-2025 recruiting classes...but that's still 250 names to sift through on track. I can give you some of the data right now.

  • Only 18.4% of all recruits in this range ever made it to the podium.
  • The numbers are slightly skewed simply because any recruit from 2022-2025 still has multiple years of eligibility left.
  • If you only look at guys that have exhausted their eligibility, 22.0% made the podium at least once.
  • Of the 13 recruits from 2021-2025 who AA'ed, only 5 have made the podium more than once. That can obviously change since so many of those guys have a lot of eligibility left.
I should have the rest of this group done in the next 24 hours. I will tell you that this subset of recruits will have significantly better numbers than the two groups below them...significantly better. The 51-75 group has less than half of the total number of AA guys (notables-Mikey Caliendo, Kyle Parco, Zach Elam, Max Dean, etc.). 76-100 is even less. I'm not entirely sure how much value in going beyond that but we will cross that bridge when we get there.
 

Misalorales

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2025
1,200
3,665
113
@Misalorales I'm about halfway through the 26-50th ranked kids right now. I'm just going back 10 years...2016-2025 recruiting classes...but that's still 250 names to sift through on track. I can give you some of the data right now.

  • Only 18.4% of all recruits in this range ever made it to the podium.
  • The numbers are slightly skewed simply because any recruit from 2022-2025 still has multiple years of eligibility left.
  • If you only look at guys that have exhausted their eligibility, 22.0% made the podium at least once.
  • Of the 13 recruits from 2021-2025 who AA'ed, only 5 have made the podium more than once. That can obviously change since so many of those guys have a lot of eligibility left.
I should have the rest of this group done in the next 24 hours. I will tell you that this subset of recruits will have significantly better numbers than the two groups below them...significantly better. The 51-75 group has less than half of the total number of AA guys (notables-Mikey Caliendo, Kyle Parco, Zach Elam, Max Dean, etc.). 76-100 is even less. I'm not entirely sure how much value in going beyond that but we will cross that bridge when we get there.
Thank you.
 

OldGlory76

Redshirt
Mar 15, 2026
3
11
0
Beginning??? Getting Bobby Douglas axed and then leaving ISU should have been a HUGE red flag.
I'll refrain on making a judgement on whether or not it was a red flag, but it was pretty surprising how that all unfolded. Trust me when I say it left a bad taste in quite a few people's mouths close to the situation.
 

District 4

All-Conference
Feb 16, 2018
1,092
2,547
113
Sandusky wasn't a rumor. Star finger blasting his teammates wasn't a rumor. Go back to Ped Valley.
Really i will give you the sandusky nobody is defending that but star finger blasting. Why because bueas girl said so really. Lol. Like a i said rumor
 

District 4

All-Conference
Feb 16, 2018
1,092
2,547
113
Yeah, former high level and highly respected athletes are always super willing to detail abuse by former teammates, especially when it's sexual in nature. I'm sure he made it all up and the person he accused just so happens to not be part of the program anymore... all just innocent "rumors".
You guys are great at sweeping that stuff under the rug, must be something in the water up there.
Look up rumors in the dictionary its right beside the thesuris if you are struggling with that. How many times on this board was something said about an iowa wrestler doing something and its just someone hearing something and repeating it. Wtf already. I could just say iowa is cheating and start spewing that **** all over. Someone will pick it up and repeat it as truth. Get the facts jack or you are just like everyone else on here full of **** lol
 

District 4

All-Conference
Feb 16, 2018
1,092
2,547
113
Please tell us how, master

Most PSU fans still think Sandusky was railroaded and Joe Pa is a Saint.
Wow that went way over your head lol.and maybe you could use that as an example of the rumors you here about psu on here lmfao
 

Slim45

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2019
621
1,977
93
Really i will give you the sandusky nobody is defending that but star finger blasting. Why because bueas girl said so really. Lol. Like a i said rumor
Seems odd that a 5x champ, that they paid well over a million to return for that 5th year, wouldn’t be on the NLWC roster, doesn’t it?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anon1746362370

cwobrien11

Heisman
Apr 22, 2009
19,933
34,263
77
Thank you.
I have 90 names left from the 26-50 group. This exercise has reminded me how much I hate trackwrestling at times. Some of these guys have 2-3 track profiles with various years spread among them...and once I crossed into the classes that were on campus for 2020-21 things started to take longer. Going to track is still a helluva lot faster than going through each individual wrestlers school bios, but not by as much as I thought it would.
I'm just hoping I can get this one wrapped up by this time tomorrow. I'll probably just create a unique thread for it so that it doesn't get lost in all of this crap.
 

InTheCircle

All-Conference
Apr 3, 2018
407
1,441
93
Look up rumors in the dictionary its right beside the thesuris if you are struggling with that. How many times on this board was something said about an iowa wrestler doing something and its just someone hearing something and repeating it. Wtf already. I could just say iowa is cheating and start spewing that **** all over. Someone will pick it up and repeat it as truth. Get the facts jack or you are just like everyone else on here full of **** lol
The dictionary is next to the Thesuris? Dat you Jethro?
 

Misalorales

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2025
1,200
3,665
113
I have 90 names left from the 26-50 group. This exercise has reminded me how much I hate trackwrestling at times. Some of these guys have 2-3 track profiles with various years spread among them...and once I crossed into the classes that were on campus for 2020-21 things started to take longer. Going to track is still a helluva lot faster than going through each individual wrestlers school bios, but not by as much as I thought it would.
I'm just hoping I can get this one wrapped up by this time tomorrow. I'll probably just create a unique thread for it so that it doesn't get lost in all of this crap.
Ya anytime I've done anything I'm stuck going through the school specific bios and that's not all that fun. Lol I know this is naive, maybe, but wouldn't it be nice to have a legitimate free and easy to interface with statistical database? Like almost every other sport I watch I could just go to sports reference or even ESPN, sort by a few dozen different stats and see information going back decades. Wrestling I hit paywalls and it never seems well organized.
 

MSU158

All-Conference
Nov 20, 2014
1,199
3,174
113
I have 90 names left from the 26-50 group. This exercise has reminded me how much I hate trackwrestling at times. Some of these guys have 2-3 track profiles with various years spread among them...and once I crossed into the classes that were on campus for 2020-21 things started to take longer. Going to track is still a helluva lot faster than going through each individual wrestlers school bios, but not by as much as I thought it would.
I'm just hoping I can get this one wrapped up by this time tomorrow. I'll probably just create a unique thread for it so that it doesn't get lost in all of this crap.
What are you looking for that wrestlestat doesn’t have? I would think that site would be your go to…
 

cwobrien11

Heisman
Apr 22, 2009
19,933
34,263
77
What are you looking for that wrestlestat doesn’t have? I would think that site would be your go to…
It's a pain in the rear to navigate and/or find guys when you're looking for wrestlers that are not currently active. That's where I started before reverting to back to trackwrestling. It was just faster.
 
  • Like
Reactions: InTheCircle

cwobrien11

Heisman
Apr 22, 2009
19,933
34,263
77
Ya anytime I've done anything I'm stuck going through the school specific bios and that's not all that fun. Lol I know this is naive, maybe, but wouldn't it be nice to have a legitimate free and easy to interface with statistical database? Like almost every other sport I watch I could just go to sports reference or even ESPN, sort by a few dozen different stats and see information going back decades. Wrestling I hit paywalls and it never seems well organized.
It would be, but there's a ton of upkeep on creating/maintaining something like that...and there are far fewer people trying to search for it so the advertising revenue would be almost non-existent...not even sure it would pay for the web hosting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Misalorales

Mattski

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2022
998
2,638
93
Look up rumors in the dictionary its right beside the thesuris if you are struggling with that. How many times on this board was something said about an iowa wrestler doing something and its just someone hearing something and repeating it. Wtf already. I could just say iowa is cheating and start spewing that **** all over. Someone will pick it up and repeat it as truth. Get the facts jack or you are just like everyone else on here full of **** lol
A-hole fans said the same when Sandusky victims started coming forward. These accusations came straight from a decorated former wrestler. If you don't like it, take it up with him.
 

MSU158

All-Conference
Nov 20, 2014
1,199
3,174
113
It's a pain in the rear to navigate and/or find guys when you're looking for wrestlers that are not currently active. That's where I started before reverting to back to trackwrestling. It was just faster.
Depending on the browser you are using it really is only 1 extra step. Using google all you have to do is type in the person's name along with wrestlestat(.com) for those that are no longer active. Keep 2 windows open. 1 with wrestlestat and the other to "search". About as fast and easy as it gets...

Oh, and wrestlingstats.com has every bracket going back in time, so that is BY FAR the best source if you are simply looking for NCAA tournament results.
 

JoeBagobagels

Senior
Jun 24, 2025
780
941
92
Seems odd that a 5x champ, that they paid well over a million to return for that 5th year, wouldn’t be on the NLWC roster, doesn’t it?

A-hole fans said the same when Sandusky victims started coming forward. These accusations came straight from a decorated former wrestler. If you don't like it, take it up with him.
People actually have taken it up with him, as far as I know it happens something like this: he claimed that Carter Starocci took his stuff. An investigation could not confirm that which lead to no arrests. Like it or not something that amounts to petty theft does not get the same attention and scrutiny they say well a murder.

I've had similar experiences you believe it happened, you can't prove it well enough, no charges filed.

All of a sudden, this mystery story comes with unconfirmed allegations. None of these ladies filed complaints with law-enforcement, which would probably still be within a statute of limitations, nor did they file a civil suit.
It was straight up ********. And that's how the story ended.
 

Mattski

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2022
998
2,638
93
People actually have taken it up with him, as far as I know it happens something like this: he claimed that Carter Starocci took his stuff. An investigation could not confirm that which lead to no arrests. Like it or not something that amounts to petty theft does not get the same attention and scrutiny they say well a murder.

I've had similar experiences you believe it happened, you can't prove it well enough, no charges filed.

All of a sudden, this mystery story comes with unconfirmed allegations. None of these ladies filed complaints with law-enforcement, which would probably still be within a statute of limitations, nor did they file a civil suit.
It was straight up ********. And that's how the story ended.
There were a lot more allegations inside the wrestling program than just "he took my stuff" but again, this is what fanatics tend to do when their program comes under scrutiny.
What did Bartlett have to gain by just making this all up and if its all bullsheet as you say, why was Carter pushed out the door as soon as possible?
Common sense says Bartlett is the one deserving of being believed and frankly supported. Of course that's not in the DNA of your fanbase.
 

jimneffer

All-Conference
Jan 27, 2026
962
2,957
93
There were a lot more allegations inside the wrestling program than just "he took my stuff" but again, this is what fanatics tend to do when their program comes under scrutiny.
What did Bartlett have to gain by just making this all up and if its all bullsheet as you say, why was Carter pushed out the door as soon as possible?
Common sense says Bartlett is the one deserving of being believed and frankly supported. Of course that's not in the DNA of your fanbase.
i have no idea what carter did or didn't do related to those allegations

but based on his social media history alone (aj ferrari and the pink *****, "pissing on graves"), i can imagine some reasons cael, casey, and the rest don't want carter as a veteran leader for the young guys
 

huntinghawk

Junior
Feb 22, 2026
90
253
53
People actually have taken it up with him, as far as I know it happens something like this: he claimed that Carter Starocci took his stuff. An investigation could not confirm that which lead to no arrests. Like it or not something that amounts to petty theft does not get the same attention and scrutiny they say well a murder.

I've had similar experiences you believe it happened, you can't prove it well enough, no charges filed.

All of a sudden, this mystery story comes with unconfirmed allegations. None of these ladies filed complaints with law-enforcement, which would probably still be within a statute of limitations, nor did they file a civil suit.
It was straight up ********. And that's how the story ended.
You mean the investigation where the cops couldn't find Carter.. For the investigation that narrowed it down to being Carter or kasak as being the only two who entered the locker room. You're the typical Penn State cover up queen.
 
Last edited:

Misalorales

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2025
1,200
3,665
113
It would be, but there's a ton of upkeep on creating/maintaining something like that...and there are far fewer people trying to search for it so the advertising revenue would be almost non-existent...not even sure it would pay for the web hosting.
Ya that stinks.
 

Cali_Nittany1

All-Conference
Dec 11, 2019
695
2,976
93
Depending on the browser you are using it really is only 1 extra step. Using google all you have to do is type in the person's name along with wrestlestat(.com) for those that are no longer active. Keep 2 windows open. 1 with wrestlestat and the other to "search". About as fast and easy as it gets...

Oh, and wrestlingstats.com has every bracket going back in time, so that is BY FAR the best source if you are simply looking for NCAA tournament results.
@cwobrien11

This may help:

https://wrestling.guru/
 

Anon1746362370

Sophomore
May 4, 2025
57
121
33
I've always wondered why Carter never sought legal action during the sexual assault allegations. If I were him and innocent, I think I'd be speaking out more about all of it. His actions regarding all of it are strange to me. To me it just seemed like his plan was to shut up & "let the smoke clear". Definitely not a good look from my POV.
 

98lberEating2Lunches

All-Conference
Feb 11, 2018
784
1,364
93
I've always wondered why Carter never sought legal action during the sexual assault allegations. If I were him and innocent, I think I'd be speaking out more about all of it. His actions regarding all of it are strange to me. To me it just seemed like his plan was to shut up & "let the smoke clear". Definitely not a good look from my POV.
And I would hope I had enough self-restraint to do the opposite of your stated preference.

Surely in the times of social media, there is the potential for any public figure to be overwhelmed by accusations. Responding in kind takes time and energy. It also can be taken as adding a modicum of credibility to the accuser(s).

So I see it as neither a bad or good look. To me, a blind preference for one approach or the other smacks of confirmation bias, in the absence of due process.

I hope you're never on a jury where I am the accused and my lawyers advise me to neither make public statements nor take the stand, as would be within my rights.

I feel that had any real charges been brought forth, Carter's attorney(s) would've handled the PR campaign, and he would've been better served by allowing them to do so.
 
Last edited:

JoeBagobagels

Senior
Jun 24, 2025
780
941
92
i have no idea what carter did or didn't do related to those allegations

but based on his social media history alone (aj ferrari and the pink *****, "pissing on graves"), i can imagine some reasons cael, casey, and the rest don't want carter as a veteran leader for the young guys
Who is saying he didn't? We don't know if he talked to an attorney. And what was said if he did? If you've ever been in some kind of legal situation like this you'd know they don't move very quickly .

And even if you believe you have been wronged it doesn't mean you will necessarily win a lawsuit.
 

JoeBagobagels

Senior
Jun 24, 2025
780
941
92
You mean the investigation where the cops couldn't find Carter.. For the investigation that narrowed it down to being Carter or kasak as being the only two who entered the locker room. You're the typical Penn State cover up queen.
No , you're the typical idiot that sees a conspiracy everywhere. Talk to an investigator and see what they say? I've had situations where I know. Certain people did certain things to me, but there is no absolute proof.

You think police are going to hold two people in custody and do what water boredom until they admit what happened? You're an idiot.

Here's how it works, cop ask Carter if he did this he says no I didn't do it. They then ask kasak and he says the same. End of investigation. Do you have any idea how many petty theft crimes happen in a large university? Do you really think they'll spend more than an hour or so on something like this?
 
  • Like
Reactions: kingstown

WillieTheBrain

All-Conference
Jun 29, 2025
249
1,554
93
I've always wondered why Carter never sought legal action during the sexual assault allegations. If I were him and innocent, I think I'd be speaking out more about all of it. His actions regarding all of it are strange to me. To me it just seemed like his plan was to shut up & "let the smoke clear". Definitely not a good look from my POV.
you're just not aware of what everyone (including, and especially, lawyers) tells you how to handle these situations.

you're supposed to go dark and stfu.
 

Trapper85

Senior
Jun 22, 2020
189
667
93
On the one hand, Carl kind of brought this back to the limelight with his remark about the integrity of other programs, so fair game to keep this f*n debate going. On the other, I'm tired of hearing about CStar on here. Great wrestler, but never liked him for several reasons. If he indeed did what some have accused and others there knew but did little (neither which would shock me in the least), karma has a way of catching up with people eventually. Until then, I'll take the sage Cesspool advice I received and get back to prepping for open water walleyes and gobbling turkeys.....and hopefully good portal news.
 

Mattski

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2022
998
2,638
93
No , you're the typical idiot that sees a conspiracy everywhere. Talk to an investigator and see what they say? I've had situations where I know. Certain people did certain things to me, but there is no absolute proof.

You think police are going to hold two people in custody and do what water boredom until they admit what happened? You're an idiot.

Here's how it works, cop ask Carter if he did this he says no I didn't do it. They then ask kasak and he says the same. End of investigation. Do you have any idea how many petty theft crimes happen in a large university? Do you really think they'll spend more than an hour or so on something like this?
Great w.o.b. here btw.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dt21

Mattski

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2022
998
2,638
93
Look up rumors in the dictionary its right beside the thesuris if you are struggling with that. How many times on this board was something said about an iowa wrestler doing something and its just someone hearing something and repeating it. Wtf already. I could just say iowa is cheating and start spewing that **** all over. Someone will pick it up and repeat it as truth. Get the facts jack or you are just like everyone else on here full of **** lol
It's thesaurus btw. It's always a good idea to make sure your spelling is on point when trying to criticize someone's intelligence.
As for the topic you're so rabidly defending, have you reached out to Bartlett with your concerns? Seems like your gripe should be with him?
 

bnicolls

All-Conference
Jun 4, 2005
193
1,476
93
It's thesaurus btw. It's always a good idea to make sure your spelling is on point when trying to criticize someone's intelligence.
As for the topic you're so rabidly defending, have you reached out to Bartlett with your concerns? Seems like your gripe should be with him?
Thesaurus - is a genus of herbivorous four-legged armored dinosaurs from the Late Jurassic, characterized by the distinctive kite-shaped upright plates along their backs and spikes on their tails
 

Anon1746362370

Sophomore
May 4, 2025
57
121
33
And I would hope I had enough self-restraint to do the opposite of your stated preference.

Surely in the times of social media, there is the potential for any public figure to be overwhelmed by accusations. Responding in kind takes time and energy. It also can be taken as adding a modicum of credibility to the accuser(s).

So I see it as neither a bad or good look. To me, a blind preference for one approach or the other smacks of confirmation bias, in the absence of due process.

I hope you're never on a jury where I am the accused and my lawyers advise me to neither make public statements nor take the stand, as would be within my rights.

I feel that had any real charges been brought forth, Carter's attorney(s) would've handled the PR campaign, and he would've been better served by allowing them to do so.
Yes, I completely understand why he didn't speak out, I'm sure that's what he was told to do and probably let the news cycle run its course. I'm just saying it is odd to ME (you don't have to agree) that you're a star and on the road to an international career and now you aren't even on your college's RTC program, a program that apprently paid you a ton of money to come back and wrestle for an extra year. I obviously don't know if he has any guilt or not but I just think it's odd and I'm not sure I could keep my mouth shut if it were me and I was completely innocent. I don't think too many champions are used to not sticking up for themselves if they are completely innocent, it's not in their DNA. But then again, maybe the world is in the mindset now that you just "sit back and take it". Who knows, I'm glad this "scandal" wasn't a huge black eye for the sport, just mentioned I think it smells a bit fishy with his lack of rebutal to all the allegations.