The problem I have is people cherry-picking a couple positives, imagining that somehow a better QB shows up, imagining that somehow a couple better assistant coaches show up, and conclude that Frost could somehow win some games at some point in the future. And since nobody qualified would ever take the job, and since we suck at selecting head football coaches, we should keep Frost and let him learn on the job and grow. As long as that takes
But that ignores a lot.
Frost’s system isn’t suited to B1G play
Frost’s system can’t work with average QB
Recruiting is a dumpster fire.
Transfer portal will be net negative
No quality assistant coach wants to join
Frost sucks at calling plays
Frost sucks at managing game time
Frost plays favorites
Frost cant/won’t make adjustments
Frost teams are sloppy and undisciplined
Many would take $5 million to coach this team, and most would be more successful than Frost. Frost is dead last in Power5 win percentage among all current Power5 coaches with as much tenure in current job. Dead freaking last. And we can’t do better?
He should have hired a special teams coach. He should have recognized the OL is a problem that needs fixing. He should have real QB competition. And most importantly, all of this should have been apparent and fixed after the first or second season.
I agree with a lot you say, but some of this just lies in how you feel about Frost.
MY thoughts on what you bring up
But that ignores a lot.
Frost’s system isn’t suited to B1G play - The system itself is fine if it were coached well.
Frost’s system can’t work with average QB - I think it can, but similar to above it needs better assistants. Also, a QB who knows where the ball is going, but can also be smart enough to throw it away would be wonderful. From what I've seen all this system takes is a little bit of smarts and self awareness. AM is not that.
Recruiting is a dumpster fire - This year you are correct. His other classes haven't been too bad.
Transfer portal will be net negative - Probably.
No quality assistant coach wants to join - No idea if this is true, but also have we even reached out?
Frost sucks at calling plays - Does he? A lot of the plays he calls just require a semi competent QB. I don't think its as bad as people think.
Frost sucks at managing game time - True
Frost plays favorites - True, but every coach does
Frost cant/won’t make adjustments - Half and half (this year I have seen a lot more adjustments at half)
Frost teams are sloppy and undisciplined - 100%