What was it like between '99 and '08?

fredmanthecatfan

All-Conference
Apr 23, 2002
17,558
3,297
0
Initially we loved Billy Clyde. The perception of Tubby when he left was that he was a nice guy who didn’t have the passion to be a UK coach. The perception of CBCG was that he was a nonstop basketball junkie. Too busy being a full time coach to have a wife. He was going to outwork every other coach to recruit and develop talent.
Instead, the cheese slid off his cracker. He wasn’t basketball crazy, he was just plain nuts.
 

KYExtemper

All-Conference
Mar 6, 2013
4,471
4,618
0
I turned on Tubby after the 2006 season. It was clear that he just gave up recruiting and we had very little talent (and yet that Turmoil Team NEARLY upset UConn in the Round of 32, probably the best game we played that year). Now, according to who you talk to Tubby was about to turn things around with a few recruits for 2008 (e.g. Draymond Green) but by that time a lot of the fan base was no longer willing to give him any more time. I don't really consider his time here a failure but he was snake bit when we got to the Elite Eight.

Gillespie never seemed like a good fit. The national media tore us apart when Tubby left and I remember ESPN and Dick Vitale teeing off on us for letting him walk. Billy Donovan turned us down, Rick Barnes "took his name out of consideration," Mark Few told people he wasn't interested, etc. I was screaming from the rooftops at my dorm in WKU for UK to give John Calipari a call but he wasn't on the candidate list. And then we settled on Gillespie and I knew from day one things wouldn't work. Couple that with all the stories relayed above, and him telling Jodie Meeks he was a "selfish" when Meeks lit up Tennessee and got us a win with a record number of points, it was just awful.

I often wonder if we'd won the NIT in 2009 if Gillespie would've returned. Notre Dame did us a big favor by eliminating us. I remember we had to play UNLV at Memorial (and nearly blew it) and struggled to beat Creighton. Dark times.
 

KingOfBBN

Heisman
Sep 14, 2013
39,077
38,403
0
Initially we loved Billy Clyde. The perception of Tubby when he left was that he was a nice guy who didn’t have the passion to be a UK coach. The perception of CBCG was that he was a nonstop basketball junkie. Too busy being a full time coach to have a wife. He was going to outwork every other coach to recruit and develop talent.
Instead, the cheese slid off his cracker. He wasn’t basketball crazy, he was just plain nuts.

So red flags to look for down the road in life- a guy who doesn’t have a wife or any relationship, has two DUIs, loves to get trashed like Papa John.
 
A

anon_013cn8yrfncx2

Guest
Even though we had 3 straight 10 loss seasons from 2000-2002, everything was pretty much ok until the 05-06 season. Tubby quit recruiting, the team was not getting along and he just coached for a paycheck. .

This is absolutely false and agenda driven. Tubby's recruiting was up and down but he didn't quit. Do the names Jodie Meeks, Patrick Patterson, and Draymond Green ring a bell.

Recruiting was actually on one of Tubby's upticks but he had lost the fan base. That's why he left and why you still see agenda posts like the above.

KAZ leaving early hurt OTS and the lefty OAD who went to UNC instead of UK was the straw that broke the camel's back.

People got what they wished for and it came down on their heads for two years. It can be reasonably argued that the next six years way more than made up for those two. But now we're in another wait and see period.

The lifetime contract should put to bed those "Cal will never win another title at UK" statements. At least for the time being. If Cal doesn't get back to the FF in the next 5 years then he will retire early.
 
Last edited:

ruppcat

All-American
Jan 1, 2003
3,698
5,185
0
There were some great seasons during that time frame with Tubby. The 2003 season will always be one of my favorite seasons. It was a joy seeing them make that undefeated conference run with that crushing defense. I recall a 60 point something blowout win against Vandy that was fun. They had a stellar year in 2004 as well. 2005 was real good as well.

The Billy G seasons were just weird from Day 1. I won't list all of the things in this post that just made it weird. Head scratching things. There were red flags from the very first day he was hired.

Now, you didn't have the expectations then that you do now. So, you have to take that in account. Even the sunshine pumpers were struggling, but still trying, to find the silver lining in the Billy G years.
The BG years were about as bad as I recall outside of the probation years.
 

TNCatfanforever

Heisman
Apr 3, 2003
22,080
13,960
62
There were problems with the Crawford family. In his last year Tubby was in on Patterson and Green had committed but he was missing on the top 25 guys. Green was not a top 25 player as I remember Duke Kansas UNC Ohio State Mich State to name a few were owning him in recruiting. Tubby left for Minnesota and never met with his team which I still say was a classless thing to so. There were other rumors as well as to why he slipped out of town.
 
Jan 30, 2018
16,155
24,636
0
There were some great seasons during that time frame with Tubby. The 2003 season will always be one of my favorite seasons. It was a joy seeing them make that undefeated conference run with that crushing defense. I recall a 60 point something blowout win against Vandy that was fun. They had a stellar year in 2004 as well. 2005 was real good as well.

The Billy G seasons were just weird from Day 1. I won't list all of the things in this post that just made it weird. Head scratching things. There were red flags from the very first day he was hired.

Now, you didn't have the expectations then that you do now. So, you have to take that in account. Even the sunshine pumpers were struggling, but still trying, to find the silver lining in the Billy G years.
Yeah, but don't you also have to take into account the SEC is night and day compared to back then and now. Not much competition like now.
 

Estil

Senior
Mar 3, 2011
1,238
674
0
I may be in the minority here, but I thought Tubby was given a raw deal. We had ever chance in the world to make the Final Four in 1999, and 2003-05...sometimes the NCAA's just come down to pure dumb luck.

Frankly, we deserved what we got in the infamous BGC years. :p
 

CB3UK

Hall of Famer
Apr 15, 2012
65,357
110,224
78
See.....here we go.....this thread is about to devolve into another damned Tubby debate.

He was done people. Give it a rest.

Yes, things are divisive on here about Cal now, but thats because for 99% of the people who complain about an aspect of Cals tenure, we feel tweaking one or two things will have us absolutely dominating the landscape. That 1% who complain and want him fired are idiots.

For Tubby, the 99% who complained wanted him fired. His time was done.
 

cal=8

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2009
2,049
1,417
0
The greatest part was the trainwreck of Gillispie. If you are going to suck; you better really suck. Mediocrity is way worse.

Even from the start of his coaching tenure here, the rumors began to swirl.

Sleeping with Alex Legion’s girlfriend
Being caught skinny dipping with coeds
Being kicked out of restaurant after restaurant
Allegedly groping a donor’s daughter
The Miller incident
Putting Harrellson in the stall
Making the team have full practices on game days.

The losses his first year were hilarious and brutal. Off the top of my head

Gardner Webb
San Diego
UAB
Houston
Vanderbilt by 41

We had that embarrassing loss to Georgia in the conference tournament and then barely got into the tournament as an 11 seed (and were lucky to do so), and put out the worst starting five a Kentucky tourney team may have ever fielded. Lol

We scored 66, Crawford had 35, Bradley had 19, Perry Stevenson had 10, and Michael Porter somehow scored two free throws to round out. Three players scored all but two points.

Jasper played 40 mins
Harris played 22 mins
Porter played 22 mins

Not a single one of those guys made a shot. Ramon Harris didn’t even take a shot. Porter took and missed one and Jasper was 0-3.

Then we got the NIT the next year and watched Gillispie get chased by Cutler. Lol
How bout Billy Clyde having Perry Poptart Stevenson block a free throw in the game against Georgia during the SEC Tournament? I thought Stevenson had lost his mind! Weirdest coaching move of all times lol
 

KingOfBBN

Heisman
Sep 14, 2013
39,077
38,403
0
I may be in the minority here, but I thought Tubby was given a raw deal. We had ever chance in the world to make the Final Four in 1999, and 2003-05...sometimes the NCAA's just come down to pure dumb luck.

Frankly, we deserved what we got in the infamous BGC years. :p

Tubby’s recruiting was embarrassing. And his lack of success after leaving here has vindicated the fans who took a hit from the media.
 

ruppcat

All-American
Jan 1, 2003
3,698
5,185
0
Many many on here have a anti-Smith agenda, I'll give the truth. Until 2007 it was acrtually very good. Not Pitino good, or first five years of Cal good, but good nontheless. Smith's first 8 years, they were ranked single digits in the final AP poll 6 times, an
d were a solid threat for the post seaaon.

In mid 2005, Smith had brought UK's all-time winning percentage to .7671, the highest it's ever been. It hasn't yet recovered from the Gillispie years, but is still the best in the NCAA.

The 2003 Cats won 26 games in a row.

Smith's Cats set the UK record for the most consecutive wins against ranked opponents at 10 in a row in '99, then in a few years beat with 11. (Calipari has since beaten it with 12)

In 2003 the Cats pulled off the first ever complete sweep of the SEC, going 19-0.

In 2005, the Cats missed the FF with a double OT loss to Mich St they should have won in regulation (uncalled foul on Sparks who was automatic on pressure FTs)

Tubby had two down years in '07-'08, but never missed the tourney nor suffered a first round loss. Unlike some other very high profile opposing coaches.

Then he left an the wheels REALLY fell off. I'd rather not recount the Gillispie years. Truly bizzare.
I also seem to remember Tubby not being able to handle the 5* player mentality as well as Pitino and Cal can. Rashaad Carruth comes to mind....but I don't think he ever did anything after college. I don't remember him getting along with Rondo either.

I remember reading the forums lamenting the misses in recruiting vis-a-vis pUKe.

He did have great success against UNCheat though! Prince for five 3s at Rupp! That was fun.

He did win 7 conference titles and 5 conference titles.

He just couldn't get over the hump with his own players.
 

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,171
0
As someone who joined during the beginning of the BCG era, it was horrible and depressing. Also OP that was a really bad question.

Also people forget that when BCG came in EVERYONE was excited to have a "recruiter" signing Patterson and Orton was a HUGE deal. Hindsight is 20/20 but BCG sucked at recruiting. Ppl thought he was good bc Tubby was so bad at it. We are blessed to have Cal bc UK basketball could've easily gone to the ******* if we made the wrong coaching change after BCG. Instead we jumped right to the top of the mountain with Wall and company.

I first found this board in high school. Somewhere around 2002/3or so. In those days Tubby was competing at a good level and was coming off a title a few years prior, not to mention at that time we had just went to 3 titles games, 3 final fours and 2 championships within that decade. It was a very content place.

2004/5 the heat turned up. 2006 this was an unstable place and rightfully so. I’d say 2006 is when the board really took on the face of what is still present today.

Way less trolls back then. I guess as Rafters grew more and more people caught wind.
 
Jan 21, 2014
3,595
597
0
This is absolutely false and agenda driven. Tubby's recruiting was up and down but he didn't quit. Do the names Jodie Meeks, Patrick Patterson, and Draymond Green ring a bell.

Recruiting was actually on one of Tubby's upticks but he had lost the fan base. That's why he left and why you still see agenda posts like the above.

KAZ leaving early hurt OTS and the lefty OAD who went to UNC instead of UK was the straw that broke the camel's back.

People got what they wished for and it came down on their heads for two years. It can be reasonably argued that the next six years way more than made up for those two. But now we're in another wait and see period.

The lifetime contract should put to bed those "Cal will never win another title at UK" statements. At least for the time being. If Cal doesn't get back to the FF in the next 5 years then he will retire early.

It's not agenda driven it's fact. I was always a big Tubby supporter, but starting in the 05-06 season we had so many head scratching losses, were beat down in games against big name opponents and he just sat there on the bench dumbfounded. If his recruiting were up to par he'd have been here much longer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: stuway and ukfan041

LadyCaytIL

Heisman
Oct 28, 2012
33,078
34,751
113
You think there are melt downs now... you've never seen a melt down then because it was BBN war 1 around here.

98% of this board loves Cal and wants him to get another title............ back then it was completely split between the tubby super friends and what they named us the Legion of Doom (we were right so suck it TSF) only back then the trolls actually came out to defend Tubby because they knew keeping him held us down... same with BCG.
 

TFCat11

Heisman
Mar 25, 2019
6,479
12,099
108
Given the recent meltdown by some on this message board, I was just curious what is was like for the 10 years before Cal became the coach. We've had an absolutely great run in the last decade he's been here, and yet there is still a very vocal minority of people that think he's either a bad coach or has massively underachieved.

I have only been following the board for maybe 5 or 6 years, so I was just curious what it was like when we were actually underachieving and not in the hunt to win it every year.
To answer your question OP, nowhere close to as fun as it is now! At any rate, I’m a HUGE fan, so I still loved UK basketball just as much. TFA
 

BoulderCat_rivals187983

All-Conference
May 22, 2002
7,871
3,227
0
Given the recent meltdown by some on this message board, I was just curious what is was like for the 10 years before Cal became the coach. We've had an absolutely great run in the last decade he's been here, and yet there is still a very vocal minority of people that think he's either a bad coach or has massively underachieved.

I have only been following the board for maybe 5 or 6 years, so I was just curious what it was like when we were actually underachieving and not in the hunt to win it every year.
Interesting that you left out 1998. Should we leave out 2012 as well? I love Cal. But I loved Tubby to. That didn’t sit well with some. 10 years. One title. All the rest is just noise.
 
A

anon_q409idbs5m40a

Guest
Yes we won the title in 1998 and got back to maybe 2-3 more elite 8’s We lost to Mich state I think twice once in overtime after the miracle Patrick Sparks shot and Marquette with the Bogans injury but having Saul at point guard was a disaster because we lost several recruits who knew he would play over them and by 2005-6 we had team turmoil discipline problems and Tubby had to start taking players like Bobby Perry Sheray Thomas and yes he got lazy and by this time AAU had gotten really big and Tubby didn’t want to play the games with 18 year old kids. He lost touch with the game this his failures at Minnesota Texas Tech and Memphis
The first loss to MSU was in the Elite Eight and it was brutal. We actually led that game something like 18-3 before MSU rallied to beat us. Yep, thinking back, it was pretty sad that we were excited about players like Bobby Perry and Sheray Thomas. I remember when the LHL was building them up prior to the season and kept wondering how we got Bobby Perry from Durham if he was any good at all. He had an ok career at UK but not an elite player.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ukfan041
A

anon_q409idbs5m40a

Guest
I turned on Tubby after the 2006 season. It was clear that he just gave up recruiting and we had very little talent (and yet that Turmoil Team NEARLY upset UConn in the Round of 32, probably the best game we played that year). Now, according to who you talk to Tubby was about to turn things around with a few recruits for 2008 (e.g. Draymond Green) but by that time a lot of the fan base was no longer willing to give him any more time. I don't really consider his time here a failure but he was snake bit when we got to the Elite Eight.

Gillespie never seemed like a good fit. The national media tore us apart when Tubby left and I remember ESPN and Dick Vitale teeing off on us for letting him walk. Billy Donovan turned us down, Rick Barnes "took his name out of consideration," Mark Few told people he wasn't interested, etc. I was screaming from the rooftops at my dorm in WKU for UK to give John Calipari a call but he wasn't on the candidate list. And then we settled on Gillespie and I knew from day one things wouldn't work. Couple that with all the stories relayed above, and him telling Jodie Meeks he was a "selfish" when Meeks lit up Tennessee and got us a win with a record number of points, it was just awful.

I often wonder if we'd won the NIT in 2009 if Gillespie would've returned. Notre Dame did us a big favor by eliminating us. I remember we had to play UNLV at Memorial (and nearly blew it) and struggled to beat Creighton. Dark times.
Gillispie seemed to be a "rush" hire and not a lot of thought was put into it. One of the worst hires in UK history.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cindog28 and CB3UK

buster3.0

All-Conference
Aug 10, 2009
5,237
1,849
113
I often wonder if we'd won the NIT in 2009 if Gillespie would've returned. Notre Dame did us a big favor by eliminating us. I remember we had to play UNLV at Memorial (and nearly blew it) and struggled to beat Creighton. Dark times.

If you believe the talk on this board, Billy G was a goner even if they won the NIT, or hell even went to the NCAA and won a few games. Wasn't the story that the players were fed up and the program would suffer from a mass exodus of transfers if he stayed? I recall hearing several of the parents (Patterson and Miller) meeting with Mitch and threatening transfer or fire him. Maybe Billy knew this and that is why he started offering scholarships to just about damn high school player with a pulse.
 
Nov 15, 2008
38,645
57,515
0
The pro and anti Tubby debates are the stuff of legend. Different handle on here back then.

The Gillispie era was mostly unified, though there was one guy who refused to give up on him. WTF was his name? GillispiesGhost or Billys something or other.

OTS was great until he wasn't...got his big pay day and then mailed it in...

Tubby's backers were referred to as Super Friends... [laughing]

 

CB3UK

Hall of Famer
Apr 15, 2012
65,357
110,224
78
Gillispie seemed to be a "rush" hire and not a lot of thought was put into it. One of the worst hires in UK history.
Mitch has done a lot of great stuff since then, but he still gets hell for it, and deservedly so. If theres one hire you cant half *** here, its the basketball coach. Im a football first guy, but theres no excuse for us to ever not "get our man."
 

buster3.0

All-Conference
Aug 10, 2009
5,237
1,849
113
One of the most funny things to come across during the last days of Billy were the homemade animated videos everyone created. I forgot the application where you made the videos but it was something anyone could do. There were a ton of these made about Billy. Billy meeting with Mitch, Billy and Tom Leach. Below is an excerpt of the Billy G show with Tom Leach.
 

YouKay

Heisman
May 15, 2002
35,671
31,767
113
Surprised no one has mentioned Billy Donovan yet.

Donovan lucked into a Final Four in 2000 while UK went out in the second round that year, and started recruiting well. Reached #1 in the country in 2003 before Tubby's Cats ***** slapped them in Rupp. But the feeling was growing that UK had hired the wrong Pitino assistant. We all laughed when Donovan signed Al Horford and Joaquim Noah, then he went and won back to back championships with those guys in 2006-7 and much of the BBN wanted Tubby fired and Donovan hired. The UK-Florida games were like World War III every year.

Then Roy Williams returned to UNC and although Tubby beat him the first couple of years (I went to the 2004 game and it was awesome) he started taking what seemed like every big 5 star recruit that Tubby went after. Brandan Wright, who was from Tennessee and grew up a UK fan. Deon Thompson, who supposedly had verbally committed to UK and then Roy flew out to California to visit him and got the commitment. The feeling was that Roy was using Tubby's slower style of play vs. his faster pace to lure recruits away.

After his stellar class of 2004, Tubby never signed another McDonald's All American. We had to watch the game every year watching recruits who were going to UNC, Kansas, Duke, Florida, Florida State, etc. It sucked.

I was one of Tubby's fiercest defenders here, named a TSF (Tubby Super Friend) by our great poster Deplion. The LOD (Legion of Doom) were the chief Tubby detractors. Some epic threads happened. It was enervating. I was glad when it was over.
 

KYExtemper

All-Conference
Mar 6, 2013
4,471
4,618
0
I remember after 2006 most conversations with fellow UK fans would start with "What are your thoughts about Tubby?" It was like you had to show your loyalty to advance the conversation forward.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MegaBlue05

barryn2000

Senior
Dec 8, 2006
21,194
642
0
I seem to remember it was something similar to now bit I don't recall if there was that many on the old messageboard

They don't show # of fans online anymore but it wasn't unusual to hit 15k + after a loss and 25k + at times. Seems to me like there were actually more people posting back at the end of Tubby's time than now.

The fighting was epic and mod's did their best to keep up. People were getting put in time out for words used every day here like idiot & stupid.
 

TNCatfanforever

Heisman
Apr 3, 2003
22,080
13,960
62
See.....here we go.....this thread is about to devolve into another damned Tubby debate.

He was done people. Give it a rest.

Yes, things are divisive on here about Cal now, but thats because for 99% of the people who complain about an aspect of Cals tenure, we feel tweaking one or two things will have us absolutely dominating the landscape. That 1% who complain and want him fired are idiots.

For Tubby, the 99% who complained wanted him fired. His time was done.
Absolutely
 
Nov 15, 2008
38,645
57,515
0
They don't show # of fans online anymore but it wasn't unusual to hit 15k + after a loss and 25k + at times. Seems to me like there were actually more people posting back at the end of Tubby's time than now.

The fighting was epic and mod's did their best to keep up. People were getting put in time out for words used every day here like idiot & stupid.

Actually they do...it's just not at the top of the RR forum anymore...

Go the the combined forum page and scroll down, on your bottom right in a frame is users & guests online...

 

Pygmy Sasquatch

Heisman
Mar 27, 2009
10,086
11,622
113
I was out of CONUS and touch until about 2006, but was encouraged by some of Tubby's teams during that time. That turned to discouragement - anyone remember firetubbysmith.com? yikes. Though BCG was a clown from his first press conference but tried to give him the benefit of the doubt.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  2. 02 KSR KSR Today: Prepping for Indiana and Missouri, GTA VI is out, and end-of-season honors
  3. 03 KSR Football Kentucky vs. Missouri Availability Report: Starting WR Could Return
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Jerone Morton nears Kentucky debut, Trent Noah officially week-to-week
  5. 05 KSR Football Will Stein Show Recap: Who's Improved the Most for Kentucky?