I believe that was a joke referencing one BCG and his infamous retort to a sideline reporter
Yep, I eventually got it. I'd cleared my hard drive of BCG memories so it didnt immediately register.
I believe that was a joke referencing one BCG and his infamous retort to a sideline reporter
I forgot about Saul. He cost UK some key point guards in recruiting.It was a lot of “Tub-ball sucks, I miss Pitino magic” and “Pitino is a has-been, Tubby is on the verge of recapturing the spirit of ‘98”. Rinse and repeat. Also Saul.
While we didn’t “contend” as much with Tubby as we have Cal, I was actually less stressed and pissed during Tubbys time. With him my expectations were never high since the teams weren’t loaded with nba talent. If we made a run in March it was awesome but if not then oh well it was expected. But with Cal every March has turned into a swift kick to the nuts because the expectations are higher.
...
Then Roy Williams returned to UNC and although Tubby beat him the first couple of years (I went to the 2004 game and it was awesome) he started taking what seemed like every big 5 star recruit that Tubby went after. Brandan Wright, who was from Tennessee and grew up a UK fan. Deon Thompson, who supposedly had verbally committed to UK and then Roy flew out to California to visit him and got the commitment. The feeling was that Roy was using Tubby's slower style of play vs. his faster pace to lure recruits away....
Coming from one of Tubby's biggest supporters (me) that's a pretty fair assessment.98-05 Wasn't as bad.
Tubby won his title and got to 4 Elite 8's in 4 years. It hadn't been too far removed from the title....we weren't dominating....but we were consistently top 10-15 and in the running for top seeds. Rick was at UofL...but they weren't among the elite yet. Florida hadn't yet reached their peak. We were still the class of the SEC...recruiting wasn't bad. We had just come off a run from 96-98 of 3 straight title games.
2000-2002 weren't exciting....but Tayshaun gave us some good memories.
The 2003-2005 run was the peak. The 2003 team bought Tubby some good will as that was a fun/dominant team...one of the best the school has ever seen. 2004 was disappointing...but we were SEC champs and the #1 overall seed.
2005 was the peak...but that night in Austin ended the Tubby era.
That year changed everything. Louisville just reached a Final 4 under Rick. Carolina and Roy just won a dominating title and were killing it in recruiting. Duke was Duke. We went from the gold standard...to just another good program. Had we won that game in OT...Tubby would've had his Final 4 and that Sparks shot would've been the greatest shot in Kentucky history. But we didn't win...we knew Tubby wasn't gonna get us to that level we wanted.
2006-2007 was just a wash. Tubby's recruiting had caught up with him...the coach em up guys weren't cutting it...he couldn't click with the 5 star guys. We became just an above average program. Florida and Donovan went back to back. We were approaching 10 years without a Final 4. It was time for a change.
2008-2009 was just pure delusion. We kept covering for Billy and his awful losses and weird behavior. We thought the big recruits would come and the program was on the way up. The end of the 2008 season gave us up...we were clicking down the stretch and playing as good as anyone until Patterson got hurt. 2009....Meeks distracted us a bit...but finally we demanded an elite coach and Mitch finally delivered.
I'm a Tubby guy myself...but your comment basically agrees with my point. You said that you believed Tubby would've made another final 4 eventually and maybe a title.....The only part of the above assessment I really can't agree with is the "knew" in "...we knew Tubby wasn't gonna get us to that level we wanted." "We believed" would have been accurate, but I can't accept "knew". To this day, I believe with UK's resources Smith could have yet made a FF and even another title. Never mind what happened afterwards at Gopher Heaven or Texas Tech (and Smith actually built up TT, Chris Beard is building further on what Smith revived - the Raiders hadn't beaten a ranked team in 4 years before he arrived, they did that his first year, and by 2016 he had them in their first NCAA tourney in 9 years)
If you're referring to the attitude of the fans after the 2005 Regional Final loss, well, in reality, it took 6 years and eventually two different coaches to surpass Smith's '05 Cats. 4 years after Smith was gone. BCG sure as hell wasn't the answer. If Smith had stayed, I think he might well have made it past the E8 in that period. (Not suggesting he'd equal or surpass Cal's first 5 years however)But that's not the level we wanted to be at....we didn't want to hope that maybe Tubby could turn it around in another 3-4 years. We wanted to compete for titles on a consistent basis...that was the level we wanted.
Now we know Roy lured those recruits away with promises of cars and fake classes.
If you're referring to the attitude of the fans after the 2005 Regional Final loss, well, in reality, it took 6 years and eventually two different coaches to surpass Smith's '05 Cats. 4 years after Smith was gone. BCG sure as hell wasn't the answer. If Smith had stayed, I think he might well have made it past the E8 in that period. (Not suggesting he'd equal or surpass Cal's first 5 years however)
Of course things did work out very well in the end, after a strange detour through the BCG swamp. Just think if BCG hadn't been quite so crazy and we'd have been stuck with him for several more years! <shudder> Smith might have looked very good in that kind of hindsight.
I'm the opposite, maybe cause I'm way younger but I grew up during the Pitino run. I think I'm more invested now than I ever was. I did refuse to let a game bother me as much after 2015. That loss affected me physically. I felt like I was in shock for 2 weeks. But Damn 2017 hurt me bad because I'll go to my gave thinking we were the best team in the country. And this year just killed me but that's for very personal reasons. It's interesting though how our views are different.I'm 55 years old and I've followed the Cats as long as I can remember. The days under the other coaches were quite different from how they are under Calipari. Even though the Cats didn't win frequent championships, you were able to be more invested in the team. You had players who came to UK and stayed beyond 1 year. You got to know them and were able to follow them and root for them for years. Senior nights were always SO special. All of that has been missing over the last 10 years. I still love the Cats. I watch every game and I still get upset/mad when they lose; just like I always have. It's just more frustrating now, when every year is almost a new team filled with kids who don't seem to really care about Kentucky; they just see it as a one year stop to the NBA. That's frustrating for a lot of fans and doesn't make them "fair weather fans" as so many people like to throw out now if they don't agree with your stance. I'm not saying fire Cal. I think he's a great recruiter and good coach, but I do wish he would change his pitch and stop selling everyone on the one and done piece. These kids aren't failures if they aren't ready for the NBA after one year, but that's now the culture at UK and I would like that to change.
Given the recent meltdown by some on this message board, I was just curious what is was like for the 10 years before Cal became the coach. We've had an absolutely great run in the last decade he's been here, and yet there is still a very vocal minority of people that think he's either a bad coach or has massively underachieved.
I have only been following the board for maybe 5 or 6 years, so I was just curious what it was like when we were actually underachieving and not in the hunt to win it every year.
Who is the real Tubby Smith? A great coach that just had a couple of bad years (as some are suggesting) or just an average to mediocre coach.
Perhaps a quick peek at his NCAA success since leaving UK might bring some of you back to real life.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tubby_Smith#Head_coaching_record
Bonus:
How Tubby Smith made a gigantic mess of Memphis' program in just one year
One thing that hurt me about Tubby was being the overall number 1 seed and losing second round to that scrub team.
^ Its a BCG call back and this was the straw that broke the camels back for a lot of UK fans. Insulting a Sideline reporter is asinine
This is absolutely false and agenda driven. Tubby's recruiting was up and down but he didn't quit. Do the names Jodie Meeks, Patrick Patterson, and Draymond Green ring a bell.
Recruiting was actually on one of Tubby's upticks but he had lost the fan base. That's why he left and why you still see agenda posts like the above.
KAZ leaving early hurt OTS and the lefty OAD who went to UNC instead of UK was the straw that broke the camel's back.
People got what they wished for and it came down on their heads for two years. It can be reasonably argued that the next six years way more than made up for those two. But now we're in another wait and see period.
The lifetime contract should put to bed those "Cal will never win another title at UK" statements. At least for the time being. If Cal doesn't get back to the FF in the next 5 years then he will retire early.
It’s so funny seeing all these posts on Tubby about how he started out hot then eventually cooled off and then later bottomed out. Cal is 2/3rds of the way to completing that cycle.
While we didn’t “contend” as much with Tubby as we have Cal, I was actually less stressed and pissed during Tubbys time. With him my expectations were never high since the teams weren’t loaded with nba talent. If we made a run in March it was awesome but if not then oh well it was expected. But with Cal every March has turned into a swift kick to the nuts because the expectations are higher.
As for this board, it wasn’t much different during Tubby years than it is now. There was a vocal part of the board that hated Tubby but the majority defended him all the way. Hell even up until BCG was fired there was a big chunk here still defending him. A large portion of the board will blindly support whoever the coach is regardless of how clear it is that they aren’t working.
It was a lot of “Tub-ball sucks, I miss Pitino magic” and “Pitino is a has-been, Tubby is on the verge of recapturing the spirit of ‘98”. Rinse and repeat. Also Saul.
2005 for me, right after the Elite-8 loss against MSU in Austin. I attended that game, and sat up in the stands heartbroken, mumbling to myself this guy is in over his head.When did you start to give up on Tubby?
Personally, I thought (and still do) that's there's room between "great" and "just average to mediocre" and that's where Smith fits. Not great, but certainly better then "average to mediocre". I'm in the Very Good camp. Which combined with the resources/tradition at UK could and did lead to success.Who is the real Tubby Smith? A great coach that just had a couple of bad years (as some are suggesting) or just an average to mediocre coach.
There were, unfortunately, a large number of LOD members who made many a negative post about Tubby that was simply factually untrue, and collectively they probably swayed the opinions of more than a few fans. ....
Good point. I’ve always used the argument against duke in relation to UK, unc and Kansas that they’ve only been successful with one coach. We’ve done it with several, more so than unc and Kansas but they both have had longevity with other coaches. We’ll see for sure in a few years howeverI thought about it another way... Think Duke, when K retires. Unless they get Brad Stevens.
Deplion and legal beagle were our (LOD) leaders. kybassfan and pepsi man led the TSF bunch.Ahhh yes, the days of The Legion of Doom vs. Tubby Super Friends. LOL!
I remember seeing some warning flags about OTS as early as Jan of 1999 when we lost to Tennessee in Rupp Arena 46-47. "Plowhorse basketball" was first used around that time.
It was pretty obvious that when all of Pitino's players were finally out of the program (after the '99 season I think) we just didn't compete as well. Sure there were a couple of strong years under OTS but, remember he also had some limited success at Tulsa and Georgia before coming to UK. The mental toughness on the whole just wasn't there.
Do I think OTS would have won the '98 Title without so many former RP players on the team? No I do not.
Tubby's biggest fault was he hated the AAU circuit and refused to play the kind of games necessary to build a consistent AAU pipeline with certain camps. For example; OTS would never have even given WWW the time of day. Not sure what the problem was but, he just wouldn't recruit like that and it ended up hurting the program severely.
Notice that in a hotbed of talent at Memphis he did no better?
Let's also not forget that before OTS was talking to Minnesota he also instructed his agent to negotiate with Virginia. Whether that was real or simply a ploy to get a contract extension/raise, who knows? But, it did happen.
These and other reasons are why I don't have the same stellar opinion of OTS as others seem to have.
The BCG years were just a experiment gone totally wrong. MB refused to pay for a professional coach search service to help make the right choice and we got burned.
KSR Basketball Recruiting
5-star C Cherif Millogo signs with Kentucky
KSR Football
Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
KSR Basketball
KSR Show, 11/19: Matt is back in Lexington, live from 10 (a.m.) to noon (p.m.)
KSR
KSR Today: Prepping for Indiana and Missouri, GTA VI is out, and end-of-season honors
KSR Football
Kentucky vs. Missouri Availability Report: Starting WR Could Return