The NCAA couldn't care less about UL but they love UNC. They will only hand out a token penalty and that will be it.
UNC should get the death penalty, flat out and full stop.
Why? Other programs have received it and UNC has offended beyond any of them as far as I'm concerned.
Hell, they should have their entire athletic department nuked from space.
Remember how hard we were hit? That was nothing compared to this utter fraud that pisses dead in the eye of even the basic concept of student athletics.
If the NCAA doesn't come down like a ton of bricks then they negate their entire argument to exist and I'd strongly support just blowing the thing up.
There is no such thing as "ineligible benefits." There are benefits, impermissible benefits and extra benefits. This issue is clearly beyond your ken.
Not surprisingly, your questions are irrelevant. This has nothing to do with credit.
Was a general student able to request that Crowder add a course to the bulletin so that they take a course that semester? The answer is no. However, athletes could. That makes this an extra benefit that impacts eligibility. The AFAM courses could've all been legitimate and UNC would still have violations.
Except the ASPCA at UNC was guiding athletes into the fake classes. They were not helping joe student as Deb Crowder's email illustrates by stating the frat crowd had found out about the fake classes and she didn't know what to do about it but to accept them into the classes.@UKnCincy, why spew the hate? "Your questions are irrelevant." "This issue is clearly beyond your ken."
Dude, lighten up. We disagree on what we expect the NCAA will do. This issue doesn't have to be Hatfields & McCoys.
Using "ineligible" rather than "impermissible" may prove the topic is beyond my comprehension. But, I like your use of "ken." Wish I could blame my blunder on an erratum.
I'm assuming (rectify my error if I'm incorrect) that like me, you find Cunningham's statement laughable at best when he states,
"The courses were available to all students; that athletes were treated no differently than the other students enrolled in the courses; that the courses originated in the AFAM department as a means to assist students with a wide variety of challenges and interests; that no coach or athletic department employee were involved in steering athletes to the courses; and that the issues involved with the courses were academic in nature and not “the result of inadequate athletic oversight.”
Whereas, I think his statement, “The fundamental issue in our case is that the NCAA bylaws cover athletic matters, not how academics are managed.” is a pile of hot dung, I also expect this topic to be the reason NCAA slaps UNC on the wrist.
No reason to be combative if you have a different opinion or disagree.
Except the ASPCA at UNC was guiding athletes into the fake classes. They were not helping joe student as Deb Crowder's email illustrates by stating the frat crowd had found out about the fake classes and she didn't know what to do about it but to accept them into the classes.
That may be the straw that breaks the camel's back and causes the house of cards (no pun intended ;-) to fall apart. That's the only way I see UNC receiving harsh sanctions.
http://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/north-carolina-academic-scandal
Among non-athletes, the courses were favored by fraternity members, to the point where Crowder expressed worry in an e-mail that word had gotten out on the “frat circuit.” (The report notes that some students were genuinely interested in the subject of the courses and took them seriously, even as the people administering them did not.)
In addition, the report states that several counselors within the Office of Academic Support Program for Student Athletes not only had direct knowledge of the shadow curriculum but also, in some cases, steered students toward these courses in order to help them secure academic eligibility.
Actually the ASPCA guiding the athletes to fake classes is what will their bacon fried as the ASPCA did not guide non athletes to the classes. I know it is difficult. Your school is in trouble. Maybe they won't get burned but they sure deserve too...This sounds crazy, but the fraternity members finding out about the shadow classes and other students taking the classes thinking they were serious classes may be what keeps their bacon from getting fried. These non-athletes taking classes may have expedited the public finding out. But, it was just a matter of time before someone listened to the whistle-blower. Now, UNC is pointing to these non-athletes as proof the classes weren't just for athletes.
If (and that's a big 'if') UNC dodges severe sanctions, non-athletes attending the classes will be the reason.
Actually the ASPCA guiding the athletes to fake classes is what will their bacon fried as the ASPCA did not guide non athletes to the classes. I know it is difficult. Your school is in trouble. Maybe they won't get burned but they sure deserve too...
@UKnCincy, why spew the hate? "Your questions are irrelevant." "This issue is clearly beyond your ken."
Dude, lighten up. We disagree on what we expect the NCAA will do. This issue doesn't have to be Hatfields & McCoys.
Using "ineligible" rather than "impermissible" may prove the topic is beyond my comprehension. But, I like your use of "ken." Wish I could blame my blunder on an erratum.
I'm assuming (rectify my error if I'm incorrect) that like me, you find Cunningham's statement laughable at best when he states,
"The courses were available to all students; that athletes were treated no differently than the other students enrolled in the courses; that the courses originated in the AFAM department as a means to assist students with a wide variety of challenges and interests; that no coach or athletic department employee were involved in steering athletes to the courses; and that the issues involved with the courses were academic in nature and not “the result of inadequate athletic oversight.”
Whereas, I think his statement, “The fundamental issue in our case is that the NCAA bylaws cover athletic matters, not how academics are managed.” is a pile of hot dung, I also expect this topic to be the reason NCAA slaps UNC on the wrist.
No reason to be combative if you have a different opinion or disagree.
The portions of my post that you quoted are statements of fact, not hate. Viewing that as "hate" or combativeness is an incorrect inference on your part.
That said, you should be aware that passive aggressiveness is not an effective camouflage when debating. So you're not fooling anyone.
To your question, if Cunningham is right, then why were the athletics counselors fired?
You are an anonymous poster who defends a school which has robbed young men and women of an education. The only thing UNC cares about are those national championship banners and their brand. You ignore facts presented to you and continue to use the talking points spread by the UNC folks.Come on. UNC is now "my school" because I've expressed reasons I think NCAA will not give a harsh penalty? What kind of moderating is that? If I blamed my expectations on ESPN, Vitale or other emotional reasons would it make me a better fan? When did agreement on what actions we expect NCAA to take become the litmus test for being a fan?
I'm not a UNC fan at all. I do try to take off my blue tinted glasses, which I promise is not easy. I didn't expect a moderator to take a shot at me.
When did I ever say Cunningham was right? I said his statement was "laughable."
If you think anywhere in my posts I think UNC is innocent, then you've missed my point. All my posts have been about what actions I expect NCAA will take.
You are an anonymous poster who defends a school which has robbed young men and women of an education. The only thing UNC cares about are those national championship banners and their brand. You ignore facts presented to you and continue to use the talking points spread by the UNC folks.
FYI I can have an opinion just like anyone else. My opinion is you are a ram trying to spread their view point.
I understand but he continues to repeat the same statement over and over as if his point is the only point to be made. We have had multiple UNC posters come here with the same talking point and the same argument style. They simply want to get the word out how UNC can get off not discuss why UNC can get punished.See tho, (not being abrasive ) I don't think he's "defending UNC " he's expressed many times that he thinks what UNC did was WRONG and he thinks they SHOULD be punished.
He's just saying he doesn't THINK the NCAA will/ will be able / etc ... to punish UNC severely / more than a slap on the wrist.
You are an anonymous poster who defends a school which has robbed young men and women of an education. The only thing UNC cares about are those national championship banners and their brand. You ignore facts presented to you and continue to use the talking points spread by the UNC folks.
FYI I can have an opinion just like anyone else. My opinion is you are a ram trying to spread their view point.
We communicated back and you simply repeat the same statement. Is there anything more to add than UNC will get off due to offering the classes to the general populace? We know that fact is untrue due to Deborah Crowder's email.Please point out one single post or statement where I defend UNC. I will point out numerous posts where I say their AD's statements are laughable, the classes were a sham, and UNC created a system for cheating.
My point has always been what actions I EXPECT NCAA to take. I communicated reasons why I expect NCAA to make their decision.
I understand but he continues to repeat the same statement over and over as if his point is the only point to be made. We have had multiple UNC posters come here with the same talking point and the same argument style. They simply want to get the word out how UNC can get off not discuss why UNC can get punished.
I agree I keep making the same point.
Others keep interpreting my point as being a UNC fan. I didn't expect NCAA to make UL forfeit games. Does that make me a Cards fan?
Which we know is a talking point which UNC fans use to claim they will not be busted and is Bilas's claim as well.I agree I keep making the same point.
Others keep interpreting my point as being a UNC fan. I didn't expect NCAA to make UL forfeit games. Does that make me a Cards fan?
We communicated back and you simply repeat the same statement. Is there anything more to add than UNC will get off due to offering the classes to the general populace? We know that fact is untrue due to Deborah Crowder's email.
Which we know is a talking point which UNC fans use to claim they will not be busted and is Bilas's claim as well.
I expect nothing from the NCAA but since the COI has gone for impermissible benefits they could rule a different way. Do you accept the fact UNC could get punished? So far you have ignored those who state it is a possibility or just repeat your talking point. So I am not sure there is any reason to keep discussing this with you.
The President of the University of Maryland stated pretty clearly how he feels about the UNC scandal but I am sure he should be discounted, right? The power 5 will pull out of the NCAA due to money not some scandal by the worst offender in the history of the NCAA. We already know that UNC did not offer the fake courses to students. The students found out through the grapevine likely from a poorly educated athlete who could not keep his mouth closed.Plenty reasons that I listed in the OP.
The UNC scandal is a mess. UNC will/has turned this into schools -vs- NCAA. Presidents will not be public, but privately will not want NCAA getting involved with academics. Presidents will make their thoughts known to NCAA. Fear of P5 schools having a reason to talk about pulling out of NCAA will lead to slap on the wrist.
UNC luckily had non-athletes get into these classes. They may not have been happy when it happened, but it will help them argue their defense.
I'm not happy with what I expect will happen.
Your argument for why the NCAA won't punish UNC harshly is based on a factually incorrect assessment of both the scope the NCAA's authority and the nature of the allegations.
Further, this same line of reasoning was generated first by UNC and is nothing but spin.
Thirdly, when presented with the facts that refute your rationale, you have doubled down and continued to repeat what is in fact, a dishonest assessment of how the NCAA is adjudicating this.
That means either you're not able to understand the glaring logical flaws in your argument or you are pushing talking points.
The basis for my thesis is mainly based on previous NCAA decisions. Today changed my thoughts some, but I want to see the banners come down before I believe too much.
Allegations against UNC are a no brainer to me. They even acknowledge embarrassment over the classes.
Scope of NCAA Authority - I'm saying this is the sticky point. Please hear me when I say Cunningham's argument, "We know these were sham classes, but the quality of classes is not a NCAA issue." is very close to the "I was drunk, so it's not my fault" defense. It's a joke. Everyone knows they're guilty. I'm just not certain NCAA wins that argument.
I'll celebrate with everyone else if I'm wrong.
Calling it a night. Peace!
The NCAA has never weighed in on the quality of the classes as the basis of a violation. The NCAA has made it crystal clear that assessing the quality of a class is the responsibility of the member institutions.
It is exceedingly dishonest to argue that the NCAA is overstepping their bounds here when none of the allegations in the NOA have anything to do with the quality of the courses.
Many UK fans are licking their chops this afternoon after NCAA dropped the hammer on UL. NCAA is now viewed by many as Wyatt Earp. The Cardinals and Tarheels are the evil Outlaws. A dream for many UK fans is to hear NCAA say to both programs, "Tell them I'm coming after them, and hell is coming with me."
Well, I'm guessing the group from Indy will blow some smoke at UNC, but it'll be nothing more than Earp blowing threatening smoke at the poker table. Here's why I think it happens this way.
1. NCAA cannot decide if a class offered by UNC is valid. That's an accreditation and school issue.
2. Everyone and their mother (including UNC athletics) knows why the program existed. Having an entire program designed that your typical 2nd grader can pass is not a problem as long as the school made classes available to other students.
3. NCAA can't punish an academic program for athletes taking classes that the university approved. Other schools know that a sham was created. But, they'll not stand by if NCAA tries to step into "what schools should and should not teach." No one wants the Indy group to have that much authority.
4. They'll be more punishment for a teacher/asst coach doing someone's homework or test than for all the athletes that participated in the classes.
Was it a sham? Absolutely! Will NCAA punish them for it? Don't think they have the legal reach to do so.
Here's more bad news for those who want to see the NCAA continue chasing the programs we label as "Outlaws" (I'm glad no one views our program or coach in this way ;-) ... I don't think the UL 2013 banner comes down. UL will appeal. NCAA has never taken down a title banner. FinalFour banner will come down, but title banner will stay up.
These are just projections. Some (ones who thought Higgins deserved to be harassed and threatened) will interpret this post as anti-UK. I didn't say I wouldn't have a slight smile if all the banners come down. I just doubt anything of significance happens to UNC and that UL title banner comes down.
Many UK fans are licking their chops this afternoon after NCAA dropped the hammer on UL. NCAA is now viewed by many as Wyatt Earp. The Cardinals and Tarheels are the evil Outlaws. A dream for many UK fans is to hear NCAA say to both programs, "Tell them I'm coming after them, and hell is coming with me."
Well, I'm guessing the group from Indy will blow some smoke at UNC, but it'll be nothing more than Earp blowing threatening smoke at the poker table. Here's why I think it happens this way.
1. NCAA cannot decide if a class offered by UNC is valid. That's an accreditation and school issue.
2. Everyone and their mother (including UNC athletics) knows why the program existed. Having an entire program designed that your typical 2nd grader can pass is not a problem as long as the school made classes available to other students.
3. NCAA can't punish an academic program for athletes taking classes that the university approved. Other schools know that a sham was created. But, they'll not stand by if NCAA tries to step into "what schools should and should not teach." No one wants the Indy group to have that much authority.
4. They'll be more punishment for a teacher/asst coach doing someone's homework or test than for all the athletes that participated in the classes.
Was it a sham? Absolutely! Will NCAA punish them for it? Don't think they have the legal reach to do so.
Here's more bad news for those who want to see the NCAA continue chasing the programs we label as "Outlaws" (I'm glad no one views our program or coach in this way ;-) ... I don't think the UL 2013 banner comes down. UL will appeal. NCAA has never taken down a title banner. FinalFour banner will come down, but title banner will stay up.
These are just projections. Some (ones who thought Higgins deserved to be harassed and threatened) will interpret this post as anti-UK. I didn't say I wouldn't have a slight smile if all the banners come down. I just doubt anything of significance happens to UNC and that UL title banner comes down.
Maybe my memory has failed me but didn't the NCAA look into Eric Bledsoe and a math class he had in high school to determine if it was a legit grade? If so why do they concern themselves with High School classes and grades but not college classes? I thought the C in NCAA stood for Collegiate.
KSR Basketball
Sources Say goes LIVE to talk Grambling State win and take an early look at Indiana
KSR Podcasts
11 Personnel, No Huddle! with Kyle McAreavy from MizzouToday
KSR Women's Basketball
Emily McDonald named SEC Freshman of the Week for record-breaking performance
KSR Football
Kentucky Football unveils uniforms for Missouri game
KSR Women's Basketball
Kentucky WBB has more 'opportunities to challenge' themselves with goals of playing in April