NCAA - student athletes must have a minimum GPA.
NCAA - Cheating to obtain said GPA is none of our business.
Lol
That is absolutely the simplest and clearest example of the sham that is UNC's defense I've seen. Kudos
NCAA - student athletes must have a minimum GPA.
NCAA - Cheating to obtain said GPA is none of our business.
Lol
Looks like preacher's post sailed right over your head.
Ok Mr. Wizard, since you pointed it out yourself, let me highlight it for you.
"No one is arguing whether it was created to create an unfair advantage for athletes. That's a foregone conclusion."
That is the issue. It is impermissible to make classes like that. It was clear from Wainstein that the only reason these classes existed was to help athletes and that putting other students in the classes was meant to make it look legitimate. That is a violation. You just typed it. Do you think you can finally wrap your head around it? UNCheat is screwed.
Ok Mr. Oz hiding behind the curtain, let me point it out again for you for the third time.
I am just predicting what decision I think NCAA will make and the reasons for the decision.
Do I think they committed a major violation ... Yes!
Do I think they used a loop hole ... Yes!
Do I think UNC expected players to get angry and give details about 1 paragraph answers ... No!
But, DO I EXPECT NCAA to give serious sanctions to UNC ... NO!
Minor sanctions ... yes.
Have you always expected serious sanctions? If you have, then kudos for sticking to your guns. If you have expected UNC to get a slap on the wrist, then please explain to me why you expected this "slap on the wrist." I'm fine with a person disagreeing. I think people are weak debaters to say, "Nothing will happen to UNC in one post, then argue why they'll be punished in this post." Today's decision against UL may cause some people to change their minds, which is fine.
I expect NCAA to leave UL title banner hanging and to slap UNC on the wrist. So far, this belief has caused some to say, "Clueless, head in the sand, not a UK fan, closet UNC fan." Those who disagree and give logical reasons for their position make good points.
I'll wait for your response regarding what you have previously said the NCAA will do to UNC.
You don't seem to be able to grasp the topic at hand , is all I'm saying.
No hard feelings.
No, that isn't what you've been saying. You've been saying the NCAA has no grounds to punish UNCheat based on the classes. You are still wrong in that. Your opinion on what may happen is fine. Perhaps you should stick with that.Ok Mr. Oz hiding behind the curtain, let me point it out again for you for the third time.
I am just predicting what decision I think NCAA will make and the reasons for the decision.
Do I think they committed a major violation ... Yes!
Do I think they used a loop hole ... Yes!
Do I think UNC expected players to get angry and give details about 1 paragraph answers ... No!
But, DO I EXPECT NCAA to give serious sanctions to UNC ... NO!
Minor sanctions ... yes.
Have you always expected serious sanctions? If you have, then kudos for sticking to your guns. If you have expected UNC to get a slap on the wrist, then please explain to me why you expected this "slap on the wrist." I'm fine with a person disagreeing. I think people are weak debaters to say, "Nothing will happen to UNC in one post, then argue why they'll be punished in this post." Today's decision against UL may cause some people to change their minds, which is fine.
I expect NCAA to leave UL title banner hanging and to slap UNC on the wrist. So far, this belief has caused some to say, "Clueless, head in the sand, not a UK fan, closet UNC fan." Those who disagree and give logical reasons for their position make good points.
I'll wait for your response regarding what you have previously said the NCAA will do to UNC.
Ok Mr. Oz hiding behind the curtain, let me point it out again for you for the third time.
I am just predicting what decision I think NCAA will make and the reasons for the decision.
Do I think they committed a major violation ... Yes!
Do I think they used a loop hole ... Yes!
Do I think UNC expected players to get angry and give details about 1 paragraph answers ... No!
But, DO I EXPECT NCAA to give serious sanctions to UNC ... NO!
Minor sanctions ... yes.
Have you always expected serious sanctions? If you have, then kudos for sticking to your guns. If you have expected UNC to get a slap on the wrist, then please explain to me why you expected this "slap on the wrist." I'm fine with a person disagreeing. I think people are weak debaters to say, "Nothing will happen to UNC in one post, then argue why they'll be punished in this post." Today's decision against UL may cause some people to change their minds, which is fine.
I expect NCAA to leave UL title banner hanging and to slap UNC on the wrist. So far, this belief has caused some to say, "Clueless, head in the sand, not a UK fan, closet UNC fan." Those who disagree and give logical reasons for their position make good points.
I'll wait for your response regarding what you have previously said the NCAA will do to UNC.
Don't want to sound like an a@@. But, I started the topic. Think I have a good grasp of the topic.
I don't have any problem with posters who have logical reasons why they expect NCAA to respond differently then I do. At the end of the day, I'll be happy if I'm wrong and you're correct. But, I won't be surprised if I'm correct and it sounds like you'll be surprised with anything other than severe sanctions.
Peace
You being so invested in this is a dead give away to your true feelings. Go love UNCheat on another board. We dont want to give any f**ks about how UNCheat might get off the hook. So dont bring that weak as sh*t here
Def wasn't referring to you bud...
@Wildcat-in-STL Why am I a fan of another school because I expect NCAA to make a particular decision? How is this even about being a fan of any school?
Btw - I've spent more $ traveling to follow UK over the years than I care to calculate. I was riding in the car with Sam Bowie when I was in grade school. I've travelled just to listen to Cawood give a speech.
You're better than accusing someone of not being a fan because you disagree with them. It's simply a weak argument when you can't make a logical argument.
Share with us what you expect NCAA to do and why you think they'll do it. (Don't give us emotion.) Give us your logical reasons for why you think the NCAA will make their decision.
You don't seem to be able to grasp the topic at hand , is all I'm saying.
No hard feelings.
Well looking there. I knew you were really a good dude. Good to be on the same side as you for a change! LolBased solely on utter ignorance.
@Wildcat-in-STL Why am I a fan of another school because I expect NCAA to make a particular decision? How is this even about being a fan of any school?
Btw - I've spent more $ traveling to follow UK over the years than I care to calculate. I was riding in the car with Sam Bowie when I was in grade school. I've travelled just to listen to Cawood give a speech.
You're better than accusing someone of not being a fan because you disagree with them. It's simply a weak argument when you can't make a logical argument.
Share with us what you expect NCAA to do and why you think they'll do it. (Don't give us emotion.) Give us your logical reasons for why you think the NCAA will make their decision.
People who say you're a UL fan or not a UK fan based on your opinion above are idiotic. Don't let them get
Sorry, but you must have missed months and months of this same UNC fan saying the same thing over and over under different aliases.
Not to speak for the guy but just like me I didn't expect the NCAA to hammer UL and based on the punishment and severity and the much more sever crime of academic fraud and in light of how arrogant towards the NCAA UNC has been I fully expect. The hammer to fall just as hard now. So as circumstances change so do opinions@Wildcat-in-STL - I'm still waiting to hear why you expect NCAA to severely sanction UNC. While waiting, I did a 30 sec search and found where you agree that you also don't expect NCAA to do much to UNC. You recently posted ...
The difference between UL and UNCheat is ESPN's head honcho John Skipper.Maybe, I'm misunderstanding your intent, but it sounds to me like you don't expect NCAA to punish UNC. (You've actually posted about this topic quite a bit.) You must be a UNC fan ;-)
ESPN has a habit of using its money to control sports. Dont believe me? Go read up on former ESPN employees who have hinted or just out right called ESPN out for its bull crap.
Still waiting to hear why you've changed you mind and why you now expect NCAA to drop hammer on UNC.
@Wildcat-in-STL - I'm still waiting to hear why you expect NCAA to severely sanction UNC. While waiting, I did a 30 sec search and found where you agree that you also don't expect NCAA to do much to UNC. You recently posted ...
The difference between UL and UNCheat is ESPN's head honcho John Skipper.Maybe, I'm misunderstanding your intent, but it sounds to me like you don't expect NCAA to punish UNC. (You've actually posted about this topic quite a bit.) You must be a UNC fan ;-)
ESPN has a habit of using its money to control sports. Dont believe me? Go read up on former ESPN employees who have hinted or just out right called ESPN out for its bull crap.
Still waiting to hear why you've changed you mind and why you now expect NCAA to drop hammer on UNC.
No, that isn't what you've been saying. You've been saying the NCAA has no grounds to punish UNCheat based on the classes. You are still wrong in that. Your opinion on what may happen is fine. Perhaps you should stick with that.
I see, you are going the troll route now aren't you. good luck buttercup . But I'm putting your rear on ignore now and skipping all of your dodge and deflect tactics to come
Ohh. Perhaps. I'm still "new" so to speak. So... this guy is a UNC fan? With different accounts ? (Honest question)
But for the record.. if you put a gun to my head... I expect UNC to get hit by the NCAA and then fight it in a legal battle for years and years until the NCAA members have all changed over and it finally fades away.
And thats only expected because my cousin, a Rams Club member said thats what they were told to expect from the higher ups.
Put it this way....this guy is the one who stands in the middle of the parking lot during a night time laser tag game and thinks nobody will see him because it is TOO obvious.
You are FOS. We are not talking about easy classes, this is about non-existent classes.Many UK fans are licking their chops this afternoon after NCAA dropped the hammer on UL. NCAA is now viewed by many as Wyatt Earp. The Cardinals and Tarheels are the evil Outlaws. A dream for many UK fans is to hear NCAA say to both programs, "Tell them I'm coming after them, and hell is coming with me."
Well, I'm guessing the group from Indy will blow some smoke at UNC, but it'll be nothing more than Earp blowing threatening smoke at the poker table. Here's why I think it happens this way.
1. NCAA cannot decide if a class offered by UNC is valid. That's an accreditation and school issue.
2. Everyone and their mother (including UNC athletics) knows why the program existed. Having an entire program designed that your typical 2nd grader can pass is not a problem as long as the school made classes available to other students.
3. NCAA can't punish an academic program for athletes taking classes that the university approved. Other schools know that a sham was created. But, they'll not stand by if NCAA tries to step into "what schools should and should not teach." No one wants the Indy group to have that much authority.
4. They'll be more punishment for a teacher/asst coach doing someone's homework or test than for all the athletes that participated in the classes.
Was it a sham? Absolutely! Will NCAA punish them for it? Don't think they have the legal reach to do so.
Here's more bad news for those who want to see the NCAA continue chasing the programs we label as "Outlaws" (I'm glad no one views our program or coach in this way ;-) ... I don't think the UL 2013 banner comes down. UL will appeal. NCAA has never taken down a title banner. FinalFour banner will come down, but title banner will stay up.
These are just projections. Some (ones who thought Higgins deserved to be harassed and threatened) will interpret this post as anti-UK. I didn't say I wouldn't have a slight smile if all the banners come down. I just doubt anything of significance happens to UNC and that UL title banner comes down.
Don't want to sound like an a@@. But, I started the topic. Think I have a good grasp of the topic.
You are FOS. We are not talking about easy classes, this is about non-existent classes.
No offense, but just because you started the topic doesn't mean you have a grasp on it.
Ohh. Perhaps. I'm still "new" so to speak. So... this guy is a UNC fan? With different accounts ? (Honest question)
Would be fun to see them bring a flame thrower in and set the banner on fire where it hangs, just to make a point.
Feel free to share your expertise on the topic.
Couple questions (I'm not trying to bait)
What do you think NCAA will do and why they'll do it?
Has this always been your position? Some people have changed their opinion beacause of today's announcement. No problem with change of mind. Today's announcement makes me think twice about NCAA decision. I still expect minor sanctions due to reasons I listed in OP.
Common ground at last.Well looking there. I knew you were really a good dude. Good to be on the same side as you for a change! Lol
So that people can ignore posters like bballcat, here's what the NCAA case is about.
The NCAA has two issues with the classes, neither of which have to do with whether they were easy or not.
Allegation #1 on pages 2 and 3 lays out these issues which are:
Those are the issues. It has nothing to do with course quality. This is also why UNC fired the counselors.
- AFAM delegated management of key aspects of these courses to athletics counselors when athletes were involved (see B.1.a in the NOA)
- AFAM worked with athletics counselors to make special arrangements for athletes that were not also available to general students (see B.1.b in the NOA)
Anyone who argues that this is about the NCAA evaluating easy courses simply has no clue what they are talking about.
@UKnCincy - Anyone who's read the NOA knows what's listed. Again, I think it's a foregone conclusion these allegations are accurate.
The reasons I've stated for my prediction doesn't have anything to do with the $ UNC has spent to put a "Spin" on their predicament. Nor have I bought into their
@nssdigitalchumps gave logical reasons why he expects NCAA to give severe sanctions. (I agree with him why they SHOULD do it, but have given my reasons why I DON'T EXPECT THEY WILL do it.
Did tennis and golf players receive ineligible benefits for taking these classes. (I have no clue what athletes outside of the major sports took classes or made this their major.)
Here's the real kicker and why I think other schools will support UNC. "Did non-athletes who majored in AFAM receive a real degree that the school is standing behind? Did non-athletes who attended these classes ("Attend" may be too strong of a word, but you get my point ;-) receive credit towards graduation?" If the answer is "yes" then how can NCAA legally say athletes received ineligible benefits?
Everyone knows the classes were a sham. (Reality will not be the issue.) If Program/Classes are deemed improper benefit by NCAA then it opens up a huge can of worms and a slew of lawsuits. Imagine getting a letter today that your college degree is deeemed to be a farce. I don't expect other schools to allow it to happen.
My prediction is NCAA makes some threats and will punish the other violations as severely as possible. If so, banners will stay up and Ole Roy may sit for a few games.
KSR Basketball
Sources Say goes LIVE to talk Grambling State win and take an early look at Indiana
KSR Podcasts
11 Personnel, No Huddle! with Kyle McAreavy from MizzouToday
KSR Women's Basketball
Emily McDonald named SEC Freshman of the Week for record-breaking performance
KSR Football
Kentucky Football unveils uniforms for Missouri game
KSR Women's Basketball
Kentucky WBB has more 'opportunities to challenge' themselves with goals of playing in April