Tubby's bubble about to bust..

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,171
0
With us getting turned down by a player that chose prep school over us to get a better offer, I'd say we were definitely on a downward trend. Plus finishing his last 2 years at 22-13 and 22-12 and losing in the second round 2 straight years was a bad situation. He knew it and was out the door before he was shown the door.

Exactly. Hard to believe we've got some who weren't aware how bad our situation was. Tubby left because he knew it was over. Period.
 

saxonburgcat

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
4,437
4,151
0
Obviously you don't know what you're talking about. PP committed to Billy G and did so because his family said his in home visit blew them off of their feet. Lots of people felt at the time PP could have followed Lucas to Florida if Tubby had stayed.

It is hysterical that Tubby danglers always give Tubby the credit for winning in 98 because he was the "coach on record" and also try to claim that Tubby landed Patterson even though he never signed him. [roll]Shows how desperate they are!
 

saxonburgcat

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
4,437
4,151
0
Exactly. Hard to believe we've got some who weren't aware how bad our situation was. Tubby left because he knew it was over. Period.

ALMOST everyone on this board admits that "it was time for Tubby to go" except for a few. I don't think some of them ever really let go.
 

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,171
0

Big John Stud

All-American
Jan 14, 2003
23,281
8,876
0
That may be true, but Tubby actually deserves it. He almost destroyed UK basketball. The only time in my 50 yrs of following UK that I almost quit watching and I certainly quit paying to go to the games.
Yup, I remember the Kentucky's Shame SI that came out after Tubby went 22-10 and list in the 2nd round. The program was teetering on the edge of destruction at that point. You can't say the same about Sutton who left well oiled machine for Pitino.
.
 

Aike

Heisman
Mar 17, 2002
75,427
46,317
90
Yea I remember it being a verbal, but I'm not sure he was a guarantee here. Some think so that's fine.

We were still in a very bad position and I don't believe Patterson would have committed to UK especially with Green here. UK was headed or dark times. I just remember is seeming hopeless in Tubby's last year.

Pretty much.
 

IHATEUAVEL

All-American
Aug 11, 2015
5,618
5,761
1
The point is too many people claim without Tubby that championship wouldn't have happened. I've even see people say they were glad Rick left (in hindsight) so Tubby could coach them. That's ridiculous. He just came off of 2 title games and a championship, and they WERE HIS PLAYERS. Does that really make sense to anyone?

What we know, is that Tubby Smith had never been to a final four before that, and will never make a final four run in his career after. Rick Pitino left that team on the table.

And these aren't mutually exclusive. Could Tubby had won a title with '15? Maybe so, it's definitely possible, but 1998 could have been won by other guys including their real coach, Pitino.
The players on the 1998 team to a man declared Pitino would not have won the Title they should know more than the dweebs on this post most of who never played College basketball
 

kevcat

Heisman
Feb 26, 2007
27,686
32,625
0
Tubby will do a solid job there.

He's never going to be a top tier coach, but he's above average IMO.

He's never going to be a great recruiter because he doesn't communicate articulately, and he doesn't want to put the time and effort into it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: crpoore

yoshukai

Heisman
Dec 21, 2002
29,880
42,393
102
Damnit, some of you hold grudges worse than my wife.

Tubby has been gone nine years and 11 months. Let it go already. We've been back to the top of the mountain. Any damage he caused has long been erased. Pettiness is a bad look.
When you've been called racist for no reason ,other than complaining about not going to a final four for the longest stretch in history , wounds heal slowly. I NEVER make a negative comment about tubby until some tubby nut hugger gets on here and acts like he was a great coach. He was not .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rush2112 UK

Estil

Senior
Mar 3, 2011
1,238
674
0
As fashionable as it may be to bash/pick on Tubby for winning only one championship, that's still something only 48 other people have ever done. To put that in perspective, more men have went into outer space in the Mercury/Gemini/Apollo programs (1961-72) than have won a D1 NCAA men's basketball championship. So I may be in the minority here but I liked Tubby even up to the end and he served the highest office in the state of KY well and with distinction and class. I hope in 2018 he gets a jersey retired just like the other three non-active coaches that have won us at least one title.
 

Randy Bob

All-Conference
Jun 14, 2009
7,279
4,020
113
I always wish Tubby the best of luck where ever he has coached he won alot of games at Ky, but I thank it was time for Tubby to leave when he left, to bad we did not get Cal. at that time instead of Billy G..
 
  • Like
Reactions: *CatinIL*

Estil

Senior
Mar 3, 2011
1,238
674
0
He mainly just had bad luck, especially in 2003-05. Remember how in 24's sixth season Noah Daniels learned the hard way just how different things are when you're the one in the big chair? I doubt even the harshest Tubby critics would really know what to do if they really were in that big chair. Remember, that big chair is a LOT bigger than even the governor's!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Randy Bob

yoshukai

Heisman
Dec 21, 2002
29,880
42,393
102
He mainly just had bad luck, especially in 2003-05. Remember how in 24's sixth season Noah Daniels learned the hard way just how different things are when you're the one in the big chair? I doubt even the harshest Tubby critics would really know what to do if they really were in that big chair. Remember, that big chair is a LOT bigger than even the governor's!
Bad luck? I heard Jay Williams say out of his own mouth that he was all set to come to Ky until his father asked the tubster a question. "What percentage of your players graduate?"Ole tubster stammered around a bit and finally said "I'll have to get back to you with that" . As soon as they were gone Jays dad told him ,"you aren't going to play for that man ". That's just one instance of tubby not being prepared or organized . It wasn't bad luck .
 

Estil

Senior
Mar 3, 2011
1,238
674
0
And how many times has any of our coaches (besides our current one) actually known off the cuff what % of players graduate?
 

saxonburgcat

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
4,437
4,151
0
forget titles y'all - we all know how hard it is to win a title.

But, what about final fours? TS never made one after 1998; if he was the coach he's being made out to be by some, here, he'd have made at least one during his 10 years here, right?

After Pitino's players graduated, OTS had 2 Elite 8's in the last 18 years! Amazing stat considering there were threads on this board after he left claiming that Minnesota would go to a FF before UK would. The Tubby Danglers have a ton of egg on their faces but they are too dumb to know it.
 

saxonburgcat

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
4,437
4,151
0
Its always going to be that feeling towards Tubby. So many hatters. Cal is good at getting the best players but if the real Trump hatters had it there way they would have all W---e players and trust me you can't win like that and we all know it.

Serously, is English a second language to you?
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

*CatinIL*

Heisman
Jan 2, 2003
24,651
40,237
113
I liked having TS at UK for the first 6-7 years...then I felt he started "mailing it in" and lost interest. That is when I felt that he needed to move on. Then we got this guy!

Boy those were some FUN years!!![laughing]
 
  • Like
Reactions: lonnie boyd

willyclyde

All-American
Feb 25, 2007
5,917
8,898
0
Tubby had some awesome teams that gave me a lot of good memories. Sometimes the tournament is a lot of luck and tubster definitely had none of that. I hated where he had the program his last few years, but have grown to respect and appreciate him now that it's been almost a decade since he left.
 

ScrewDuke1

Hall of Famer
Jul 29, 2016
41,589
155,854
113
For all you Tubby haters out there, think back to the 1998 team that Tubby coached to the National Championship.

IMHO, no other UK coach, not named Adolph Rupp (and only the younger version of Coach Rupp), could have coached that team to a National Championship!!!! :sunglasses::sunglasses::sunglasses::sunglasses::sunglasses:

I'll take it a bit further and add: IMHO, no other National Championship coach, aside from Coach Rupp in his prime, could have won the Title with that 1998 team. :sunglasses::sunglasses::sunglasses::sunglasses::sunglasses:

As a floor coach, IMHO, Tubby was simply the best ever!!!!!!!! :sunglasses::sunglasses::sunglasses::sunglasses::sunglasses:
What in the ever loving hell is this nonsense? Never do drugs and post. Its not good.
 

Big John Stud

All-American
Jan 14, 2003
23,281
8,876
0
forget titles y'all - we all know how hard it is to win a title.

But, what about final fours? TS never made one after 1998; if he was the coach he's being made out to be by some, here, he'd have made at least one during his 10 years here, right?
He did make 1. You mean he would have made one other than the one he made?
 

Big John Stud

All-American
Jan 14, 2003
23,281
8,876
0
These people think Tubby was worse for UK than Eddie Sutton, nothing else needs to be said about them.
 

Big John Stud

All-American
Jan 14, 2003
23,281
8,876
0
What makes it worse was Tubby was wayyyy too long.
Still laughing at your insinuation that Tubby was worse for UK than Eddie Sutton. Tubby almost destroyed the program but Sutton didn't. This goes to show your bias and everyone sees it.

BTW, I'm not gonna let you change the subject.
 

nickhorvathsuxazz

All-American
Jul 21, 2015
5,777
8,938
0
Rick couldn't win with those same players plus Mercer, Anderson, and Epps. Blah blah blah, same lame talking points over and over again.
No...Rick had Mercer, a legit 5 star, Epps, a consensus 3 star who he developed into the sr. p.g. you remember, and no Anderson, who was recovering from an ACL
 

Chuckinden

All-American
Jun 12, 2006
19,000
5,953
113
Still laughing at your insinuation that Tubby was worse for UK than Eddie Sutton. Tubby almost destroyed the program but Sutton didn't. This goes to show your bias and everyone sees it.

BTW, I'm not gonna let you change the subject.
You obviously didn't comprehend my post. We only had to put up with Sutton for 4 yrs and BCG for a couple years before they were sacked. We had to endure Tubby ball 10 yrs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: morgousky

Big John Stud

All-American
Jan 14, 2003
23,281
8,876
0
You obviously didn't comprehend my post. We only had to put up with Sutton for 4 yrs and BCG for a couple years before they were sacked. We had to endure Tubby ball 10 yrs.
Oh I comprehended that nonsense. Im laughing at you for comparing that to the man who literally brought the program to its knees. I'm talking losing season, players leaving, postseason ban, no TV, Kentucky Shame, and you compared that to Tubby. That's ridiculous to anyone with a lick of common sense.
 

IHATEUAVEL

All-American
Aug 11, 2015
5,618
5,761
1
You obviously didn't comprehend my post. We only had to put up with Sutton for 4 yrs and BCG for a couple years before they were sacked. We had to endure Tubby ball 10 yrs.
Get a life Tubby will be in the Naismith Hall of Fame and UK will hang a jersey it's already in the works..Book Em Danno
 

saxonburgcat

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
4,437
4,151
0
Get a life Tubby will be in the Naismith Hall of Fame and UK will hang a jersey it's already in the works..Book Em Danno

Hopefully, those HOF voters will ignore his last 10 years (counting this one). 4 NCAA tournament appearances with ONE win. 3 NIT's and 3 years without a postseason.

Maybe he will get credit for having his first winning season in conference in 10 years. Of course, the teams behind him in the AAC may not qualify for the NIT.

Tubby's HOF resume continues to look worse and worse each year. He needs to retire sooner than later so his overall record can look better.
 

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,171
0
The players on the 1998 team to a man declared Pitino would not have won the Title they should know more than the dweebs on this post most of who never played College basketball

First of all, those players wanted Billy Donovan to begin with. That was in the open.

on top of that, of course they'll say that. Rick will say that. Actually he's the one that got the nonsense started.

If you don't believe a two time national champion coach, who's been to 8/9? final fours, couldnt win a title with the 1998 Wildcats but Tubby freakin Smith can you're an idiot with an agenda. He had just made back to back title games, winning one, and that was HIS TEAM he left on the table. Don't be ridiculous. You're making yourself look foolish. In what universe does that even come close to making sense?

Wake me up when Tubby can compete and make a final four on his own, without the aid of another coach. He's going in the HOF, and I'm glad, but that's because they'll induct a ham sandwich.
 
Last edited:

IHATEUAVEL

All-American
Aug 11, 2015
5,618
5,761
1
I know all the players on 98 team and Billy Donovan is ******** you read too many sports magazines.i probably know more about U.K. Basketball than you can dream up in your small mind but that's your problem..Also did you know that SCUMtino met Larry Ivy in Florida and tried to buy out Tubby's contract I thought so. Here's your ham sandwich don't choke on it Mamma Cass ...