For some people, it's like all memories of that team are erased except for names, vague recollections of spectacular plays and stretches of dominance, and the West Virginia loss.♫One of these things is not like the other♫
Whole lot of people here just rattle off names of superstars without remembering how much more badly '12 and '15 demolished their opponents. Hint: it's not close.
The numbers.
The numbers, you dunce.
I already told you guys the order, and since I'm always right, you'd think that would be enough, but I thought I'd go consult with my buddies Ken Pomeroy and Jeffrey Reginald Sagarin XIV, esq.
And of the teams we've been discussing, exactly as I predicted, here is the order:
(year)
(kenpom)
(sagarin)
1. 2015
36.91
99.19
(big drop off)
2. 2012
32.59
95.72
(big drop off)
3. 2017
27.72
92.88 (higher sag)
or
3. 2019 (they still have a lot of room to improve, since the other teams all enjoyed the full stats boost that Cal produces in March)
28.97 (higher kenpom)
92.35
5. 2010
26.54
92.35
One more time for the deaf guys in the back - you have rosy memories of '2010 because they pulled us out of our biggest slump since Pitino's arrival and because they had the most star power of any team in CBB in the decade prior.
But if you actually go back and look at the game outcomes and compare them to '12 or '15, you are a basketball ignoramus.
Give me a 2010 accomplishment that was 1/4 as impressive as '15 holding UCLA to 7 in an entire half. Or how about defeating top 10 Kansas by 32?
Get serious.
The fact is that team did not play particularly well in Nov/Dec, and was probably lucky that the 2 highest profile games were against big brand name teams (UConn and UNC) having very down seasons (neither made the tournament). And UL finished that year 20-13.
When conference play started, the team did get better (like almost all Cal teams), but it's not like they were blasting teams off the floor. 10/19 SEC games were decided by 10 points or less, and there were only 4 wins by 15 or more. There were numerous games where they just looked unfocused.
That team would put together incredible stretches of play, but it rarely lasted long enough to blow the opponent off the floor. The UNC game is probably Exhibit A, as they had a 28-2 run, led by 15 at halftime, and yet barely hung on to win by 2.