Exactly. As has every other coach at every other top program.UK has lost to inferior teams under Rupp in his later years, Joe b hall, sutton, pitino, tubby, etc. UK coaches have sucked at winning national titles since about 1960
Exactly. As has every other coach at every other top program.UK has lost to inferior teams under Rupp in his later years, Joe b hall, sutton, pitino, tubby, etc. UK coaches have sucked at winning national titles since about 1960
At @UK90 , you're one of our more thoughtful posters in my opinion. What do you think needs to happen to revamp the program going forward?
I asked you a question. Name a coach that hasn’t done EXACTLY the same things Cal is apparently doing. Just one. The reason you didn’t answer the question is because there isn’t one. Not Coach K. Not Roy. Not Wright. Not Self. Also tell me when Cal has lost to a team like Mercer? Northern Iowa? Etc.?
Pitino lost to a lower seed 3 out of his last 4 years at UK. He was a huge choker and should have won the title 93, 95 and 97. 1997 was a huge choke job as Bibby and Simon abused our guards and Arizona was a five seed. He never did adjust in that game.I'll give you one. His name is Pitino. Just once did he lose in the tournament to a team he wasn't overwhelmingly favored against: Marquette in 1994. You could make a case for 1993 against the Fab Five or 1997 against Arizona, but he went to OT against both without Brown in 1993 or Anderson, in the 1997 title game. I'm not sure there's a UK fan alive who would blame him for either loss, given the reality of injuries. Pitino never changed his regular season strategies in those years either. He wasn't perfect, obviously, but he usually bear the teams in the tournament he was supposed to beat, and even surpassed expectations a few years.
Now please answer my question. What is your position on critique and when, if ever, do you think it's appropriate?
I'm not smart enough to know for sure, and it's a bit too complex a question to answer in one post. But one thing I'll mention with Cal's recruiting that's kinda bothered me is how he'll leave schollies unused (or give an extra to his son) that could've been offered to the type of kids we've been seeing lead team to titles over the last decade.
My observation in recent years is that what really seems to make the difference in the tournament is savvy guard play, but NOT generally from one and done type guards, but instead from older kids who were a bit lower ranked in HS. Look at the kids who've been Final Four MVPs over the last decade or so, they're nearly ALWAYS tough-minded guards (except for AD in 2012) and nearly always older kids who've played three or four years of college basketball (except for AD and Tyus Jones in 2015). But we do NOT recruit those kinds of guards, instead our best guards are always in and out the door in a year or two, and Cal won't offer the type of prospects who often develop into those kinds of guards.
Just look at the best guards in the country this year (Carsen Edwards, Ja Morant, Markus Howard, Cassius Winston, etc.). Is there a single one Cal even considered recruiting?
And just look at the starting guards in this year's Final Four (Winston, Matt McQuaid, Jared Harper, Bryce Brown, Morretti, Mooney, Kyle Guy, Ty Jerome, etc.). I believe they're ALL either seniors or juniors who've been playing for several years, and they're ALL guys that Cal would never have considered recruiting (except maybe Kyle Guy, who was a McD AA).
I tend to doubt we're gonna win more titles by processing through a whole new tandem of turnover-prone freshmen guards every year. So, instead of leaving spots unused, maybe Cal should take a chance on some lower rated prospects of the sort that've actually been winning titles in recent years.
I think this is the last year that I'm going to keep my hope's up just to be disappointed. Kentucky is becoming the biggest choke team in basketball
Unfortunately, I think this is true. Cal isn’t going to change it up and our current model isn’t good enough to get over the hump. I don’t want another coach, WE JUST WANT A CHANGE IN PHILOSOPHY!!! Cal is stuck between a rock and a hard place with the culture he’s created. The youth and inexperience is wearing him out and will cause him to coach less years than he ultimately could have if he would build a program the way UNC, Nova, Michigan St, and Virgina do. Herro would fit into the Luke Kennard/ Grayson Allen mold at a school like Duke, but he’s almost a guaranteed lock to leave here. It’s frustrating to fans that want continuity, experienced talent, realistic chance to win titles, and want Cal to put our program FIRST instead of this succeed and proceed bs. Catering to freshmen pre-madonnas that are just going through the motions for 9 months before they mail it in and move on to where they really want to be is not how we built the winningest tradition in college basketball and it sure as hell isnt going to be how we catch UCLA in titles.You can’t change the culture under Cal. It’s an uncontrollable beast now. We are the one and done school; and not even the premiere one that gets the cream of the crop anymore. But if your game is super flawed but you want to be off campus and in the pros even if it means you’ll be second round and bounce around the G-League, we are a great place.
Looking at how that 2018 Villanova team and 2017 UNC team looked made me pretty envious. You see talent like that stick around multiple years and you see guys like Grayson Allen stay four years at Duke and several other examples and you find yourself longing for that type of consistency combined with a couple of good freshmen.
Pitino lost to a lower seed 3 out of his last 4 years at UK. He was a huge choker and should have won the title 93, 95 and 97. 1997 was a huge choke job as Bibby and Simon abused our guards and Arizona was a five seed. He never did adjust in that game.
As far as criticism of Cal, have at it. It changes nothing. You could write a 1,000 page thesis on what Cal needs to do better. It won’t make any difference. All of the top coaches have warts. And they all have forgotten more basketball than you will ever know. So I trust Cal’s coaching over a poster on Rafters.
Please. The fab five never won a title. And Bibby and Simon couldn’t beat Utah the next year. And don’t bring up Duke. Pitino only has to put a man on Grant Hill to win that game. You know, middle school coaching stuff. Pitino was stacked up upperclassmen and pros. And still choked away title after title and lost to lower seeds 3 out of his last 4 years. That’s a fact not an opinion.Pitino lost to guys like Stackhouse, Wallace, Bibby, Terry, Webber, Laettner, Hill, Rose, and Howard.
In recent years, Cal has lost to guys like Barry Brown Jr., Xavier Sneed, Horace Spencer, Austin Wiley, and Jared Harper.
I'm not sure this is as comparable as you're trying to argue or that it can be used to totally negate any critique of Calipari's offensive and recruiting system.
Cal himself has stated that every coach is capable of improvement.
4 titles last 60 years. LolWe have 4 titles the last 40 years. Are we pretending like we were winning titles regularly before Cal?
Over the past 62 seasons, we've won 5 titles (one every 12 years) and been to 13 Final Fours (one very 4-5 years). There's nothing different about now. We just had crazy high expectations with Calipari and instead, we've merely performed a little above par for Kentucky basketball.
Figures.Lots of dumbassery in this thread! I am missing Tubby and Billy Clyde too guys. :flush:
We have made the elite eight in 7 of the last 10 years. No other team has done that. No other team has come close.
Outside of Duke, few, if any, other teams has even made half as many in the same time span, and really, if you look at their tourney results outside their two title runs, they've barely made it out of the second round.
A lot of you all are absurd.
We have 4 titles the last 40 years. Are we pretending like we were winning titles regularly before Cal?
Please. The fab five never won a title. And Bibby and Simon couldn’t beat Utah the next year. And don’t bring up Duke. Pitino only has to put a man on Grant Hill to win that game. You know, middle school coaching stuff. Pitino was stacked up upperclassmen and pros. And still choked away title after title and lost to lower seeds 3 out of his last 4 years. That’s a fact not an opinion.
Point being it is as easy to criticize Pitino’s coaching, K’s coaching, Roy’s coaching etc as it is to criticize Cal’s.
Nothing you discuss solves anything. How do you not understand that? Cal doesn’t give a **** what you think and will coach as he sees fit. Your posts about what needs to change are completely irrelevant.I respect both of you guys, but neither of these posts really address what most are arguing.
Falling back on historical precedent doesn't address the problem: we're losing to teams that are injured and inferior, and we're doing it playing a style that is different than the one we've featured all season long. Should we negate all discussions of potential improvement due to UK presently maintaining some comparable historical positioning?
If we fall back on historical precedent as our deflection, it does little to actually solve the problems we're presently facing.
5 whole years. Man, you must have been suicidal from 78' until 84'. Or been in lock down from 84' until 93'. I don't even know how you survived from 98' until 11'.Elite 8s are nice and all....for Auburn, Purdue, etc...
Elite 8 seems to be our ceiling now. It’s certianly not changing next year with what’s coming so it will be at least a 5 year FF drought
Nothing you discuss solves anything. How do you not understand that? Cal doesn’t give a **** what you think and will coach as he sees fit. Your posts about what needs to change are completely irrelevant.
Now if you want to just post about it fine. But it solves and changes nothing.
You preferred the Sutton,Tubby and BCG days? What's acceptable to you?In Cals 10 years he increased my immune system. They dont hurt any more. He has lost to inferior teams now on Numerous occasions. Wva U conn twice Wisconsin K state and now Auburn. I am tired of elite 8 final 4 crap. Finish the deal or change your model. Cal has been a huge disappointment
And you are willing to criticize Cal and not Pitino. What’s the difference?You're obviously willing to critique Pitino, but not Calipari?
Why the difference? Seems biased and doesn't really help your point.
I respect both of you guys, but neither of these posts really address what most are arguing.
Falling back on historical precedent doesn't address the problem: we're losing to teams that are injured and inferior, and we're doing it playing a style that is different than the one we've featured all season long. Should we negate all discussions of potential improvement due to UK presently maintaining some comparable historical positioning?
If we fall back on historical precedent as our deflection, it does little to actually solve the problems we're presently facing.
4 titles last 60 years. Lol
My friend. I clearly said you can criticize Cal 24/7. But when you mentioned “solving” the issues you see, there will be no solving anything on this board. Nothing. Nada.I usually have understood you to be reasonable and respectful (a poster I typically agree with), but my point isn't that we can change anything Cal does. I'm not that imbecilic, and for you to suggest that is strange.
This is a message board. We're discussing the sport. It doesn't hurt anything in vying for a public position, even if that position "solves and changes nothing."
You've decided to lock down your own critique of Cal, which is fine, but please stop acting like some of us are absurd for suggesting that the system needs some slight improvements. It does. It's not working, and falling back on a deflection of "historical precedent" does nothing to address present realities.
And you are willing to criticize Cal and not Pitino. What’s the difference?
The difference I see is one is our current coach and one isn’t who scum of the earth. One has averaged 30 wins a year, has a title and four final fours who remains our coach. One left UK, coached at our rival and is a complete lying shithook.
These kinds of posts astound me. Cal has taken UK to EE 7 years of the 10 he has been here. That means one game from a FF and you post trash like this.In Cals 10 years he increased my immune system. They dont hurt any more. He has lost to inferior teams now on Numerous occasions. Wva U conn twice Wisconsin K state and now Auburn. I am tired of elite 8 final 4 crap. Finish the deal or change your model. Cal has been a huge disappointment
My friend. I clearly said you can criticize Cal 24/7. But when you mentioned “solving” the issues you see, there will be no solving anything on this board. Nothing. Nada.
Ok, I'm sick of stupid posts like this. You're just an imbecile. I don't care what happens. You're a disgrace.Honestly look back at his career in big games in his career. He blew a title game to Kansas while at Memphis. He nearly allowed Kansas to come back in 2012. Only if he has an Anthony Davis surrounded by MKG TJ and a couple of veterans If Izzo had had Cals talent he would have had 4 titles. Cal is a great recruiter but poor game coach
I can assure you I have issues with things Cal does during games. I also had many issues with things Pitino did as a coach. What I do know is what UK’s history has been the past 60 years. And Cal has clearly exceeded the vast majority of that time.I'm willing to critique both. I can offer critique of Pitino if you'd like me to.
You asked me a very specific question and I answered it accordingly.
There's a place called objectivity somewhere out there beyond the subjective emotions that dictate so much of our thinking. I'm trying to get to that place in these discussions. I can assure you I haven't arrived there yet.
My opinion of the current state of the program is UK has won 30 games two out of the last three years. Won two SEC tournament titles. Made it to the Elite 8 two out of three years. To argue it’s in the decline is simply a false narrative with zero basis in fact. Decline compared to when in the past 60 years?"Solving" was an inappropriate word, but I think delineating our present condition as a program is at the very least, acceptable for message board standards.
We have room for improvement. Falling back on the one trick pony of "historical precedent" or deflecting to another program's inadequacy doesn't help us heighten our level of discourse.
Using those elements is fine within a larger conversation, but they can't be the only counter to present critique. It obscures the fuller picture.
Everyone loses to teams that are inferior.
That's my point.
Go back and look at Dukes tournament record over the last decade and tell me how many times they've been upset.
Every year that they havent won the title.
Its the NCAA tournament. Rarely does the best team win.
Do you hear yourself? Auburn hasnt lost since February. They beat Kansas last week, then turned around and smashed UNC a few days ago; the same UNC team that everyone picked in their final four.
And then we lost to them. So what? So has everyone in their last 20+ games. They're a great team with great shooters.
I mean, look at this thread. Some of you all need to get a grip on reality. The odds of winning a title in today's game is slim to none. This isnt 40 years ago where a half dozen teams are good, those guys are legit ballers who shot the lights out against other dudes much taller than them. It happens.
Cal definitely has his flaws and things he needs to clean up but people are talking like we're some downtrodden program like IU. We're not, I think just need a few adjustments and definitely an assistant who can install a competent offense. We very easy could've won that game yesterday and a national title this year, I'm just saying let's not throw away the baby with the bathwater.I respect both of you guys, but neither of these posts really address what most are arguing.
Falling back on historical precedent doesn't address the problem: we're losing to teams that are injured and inferior, and we're doing it playing a style that is different than the one we've featured all season long. Should we negate all discussions of potential improvement due to UK presently maintaining some comparable historical positioning?
If we fall back on historical precedent as our deflection, it does little to actually solve the problems we're presently facing.
Everyone loses to teams that are inferior.
That's my point.
Go back and look at Dukes tournament record over the last decade and tell me how many times they've been upset.
Every year that they havent won the title.
Its the NCAA tournament. Rarely does the best team win.
Do you hear yourself? Auburn hasnt lost since February. They beat Kansas last week, then turned around and smashed UNC a few days ago; the same UNC team that everyone picked in their final four.
And then we lost to them. So what? So has everyone in their last 20+ games. They're a great team with great shooters.
I mean, look at this thread. Some of you all need to get a grip on reality. The odds of winning a title in today's game is slim to none. This isnt 40 years ago where a half dozen teams are good, those guys are legit ballers who shot the lights out against other dudes much taller than them. It happens.
Cal definitely has his flaws and things he needs to clean up but people are talking like we're some downtrodden program like IU. We're not, I think just need a few adjustments and definitely an assistant who can install a competent offense. We very easy could've won that game yesterday and a national title this year, I'm just saying let's not throw away the baby with the bathwater.
In Cals 10 years he increased my immune system. They dont hurt any more. He has lost to inferior teams now on Numerous occasions. Wva U conn twice Wisconsin K state and now Auburn. I am tired of elite 8 final 4 crap. Finish the deal or change your model. Cal has been a huge disappointment
You do realize that inferior team just trashed The Filth just 48 hrs before? A 1 seed. Don’t matter?
Resume the ridiculous crying and looking like a selfish child as you wish.
KSR Football
Where Kentucky sits in updated AP, Coaches Polls following loss at Mizzou
KSR Football
SEC Officials Made an Egregious Error in Kentucky vs. Missouri
KSR
Dethroned: Kentucky VB’s SEC title streak snapped, but chance for redemption is alive
KSR Football
Kentucky will host Louisville as an underdog at Kroger Field
KSR Football
KSR Today: Kentucky officially out of CFP race, but what's next?