I'm not smart enough to know for sure. But one thing I'll mention with Cal's recruiting that's bothered me is how he'll leave schollies unused (or give an extra to his son) that could've been offered to the type of kids we've been seeing lead team to titles over the last decade.
My observation in recent years is that what really makes a difference in the tournament is savvy guard play, but NOT generally from one and done type guards, but instead from older kids who were a bit lower ranked in HS. Look at the kids who've been Final Four MVPs over the last decade or so, they're nearly always guards (except for AD in 2012) and nearly always older kids who've played three or four years of college basketball (except for AD and Tyus Jones in 2015). But we do NOT recruit those kinds of guards, instead our best guards are always in and out the door in a year or two, and Cal won't offer the type of prospects who often develop into those kinds of guards.
Just look at the best guards in the country this year (Carsen Edwards, Ja Morant, Markus Howard, Cassius Winston, etc.). Is there a single one Cal even considered recruiting?
And just look at the starting guards in this year's Final Four (Winston, Matt McQuaid, Jared Harper, Bryce Brown, Morretti, Matt Mooney, Kyle Guy, Ty Jerome, etc.). I believe they're ALL either seniors or juniors who've been playing for several years, and they're ALL guys that Cal would never have considered recruiting (except maybe Kyle Guy, who was a McD AA).
I doubt we're gonna win more titles by processing through a whole new tandem of turnover-prone freshmen guards every year. So, instead of leaving spots unused, maybe Cal should take a chance on some lower rated prospects of the sort that've actually been winning titles in recent years.