The facts are in: IT CANNOT BE DONE

ubtrapper_rivals103836

All-Conference
Jan 14, 2014
1,519
1,696
0
I'm almost 38 and I agree completely. The last few Tubby years and BCG were terrible. That's putting it mildly.

Edit: Our problem this year was that we didn't possess a PG capable of winning the title. I thought (more so hoped) Hagans would finally figure it out over a six game stretch to get us there. It really all hinged on that IMO. At the end of the day, we didn't have a capable enough PG to win the title this year. Turnovers killed us as much as missed FTs.
That's it right there. We say it every year that in order to win a title, you have to have a really good PG. I know Teague wasn't elite but he could make shots, handle the ball, pass etc. But he also had AD and MKG. Lol

Hagans was good for about 10 games then reverted back and that did us in when we got to where it really mattered.
 

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,171
0
2012 UK and 2015 Duke ring any bells?

I stopped here instead of reading further.

2012 UK had upperclassman, returning sophomores, and freshman. It is not a team using majority freshman to win.

2015 Duke had upperclassman Quinn Cook and Jefferson. They relied heavily on upperclassman through the entire tournament and without Jefferson’s offensive rebounds they don’t win it.

You cannot take a team full of freshman and win a title. It’s not going to happen unless a crazy class comes through with AD and Zion going to the same program.

The way we recruit? Or anyone on earth? That ain’t happening.

Duke just formed a super team of one class and didn’t make the final four.

The truth is only a crazy, unheard of, irrational and bizarre class going to one program can win with all freshman leading the way.
 

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,171
0
This is definitely frustrating, but part of it.

Sad thing is there are fans bemoaning the possibility of a guy like Richards returning and starting for us next year.

So what do we want? Do we want guys to come back that need more time or not?

You can't have it both ways.

Its simple.

In college basketball you’re supposed to always be over recruiting players. If you’re not over recruiting you’re not trying. If Richards returns he should easily be recruited over. If not Richards will take what he wants.

Outside of a PC world that has permeated into sports, this is how it should look.
 

thebluestripes

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2014
2,145
2,621
0
It took a tough hard nosed experienced team to bring down maybe the best oad team to come along since the fab 5. You need a blend of talent and experience to do well in march. Had d lamb and t jones been freshmen in 2012, cal wouldn't have had a championship.
 

UKWildcats#8

All-American
Jun 25, 2011
30,327
9,338
0
I'll ask this again, what model works for Kentucky? The ***** model that won 3 titles in 50 years before Calipari. Someone needs to address this. I really want to hear this. Kentucky has sucked at winning national titles for 60 years now
 

BBNinSCar

All-Conference
Apr 23, 2013
1,880
3,544
81
If you buy into the upperclassmen model, you can expect to have a title contending team every 3-4 years.
Cal is getting us to the doorstep every season, we will kick the door in soon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CatfanMike47

NoDef

All-American
Sep 1, 2001
5,187
7,168
113
It's just a hard title to win. Two OAD led teams have won it in the last 9 years. A couple have made it to the finals and maybe the best team of the decade was a shot clock violation away from winning it. We were three really clean blocks away from winning yesterday and going to the final four with not even the top OAD players in the country. It has to do more with the NCAA basketball tournament being the hardest one in all of sports to win . It's called March Madness for a reason and that why the very best team every year only wins it about 1 out of every 4 tries.
 

BlueBloodKyFan73

All-Conference
Oct 29, 2010
3,954
4,977
113
You ALWAYS recruit the best and take the best that are willing to come. How the games play out is a luck of the draw.
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
And since then recruiting has become so watered down for uk that itbisnt getting the elite talent it takes. Duke had it this year and ratface couldn’t manage it. Since then though has a freshman laden team even made a ff?? I don’t think so and the last two years has been all experience in the final four.


Do you think Duke fans should be “sick” of K in the same fashion that you think UK fans should be “sick” of Cal?
 
  • Like
Reactions: CatfanMike47

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
It can’t be done except for those two times it has already been done.

Dain Bramage
 

CatfanMike47

All-American
Oct 9, 2017
4,861
5,222
0
Don't get me wrong guys. I have been just as fascinated, enthusiastic, and optimistic with this strategy as one can possibly be. But, it is time to be objective. It is too painful to continually watch successive UNNECESSARY failures. It is hard on us, but it is also hard on these kids. We must have some maturity. One graduate student in the starting line-up is not enough.
You’re an idiot
 

Bluegrassking

All-Conference
Jul 18, 2006
4,050
1,913
0
You’re arguing with me about a concept that needs two things in order to be successful. Freshmen by themselves will not win it all. You need a blend.

There are few all freshmen teams even here.

Small sample size, moot point, argument by hyperbole.
 

fisherscat

All-Conference
Feb 9, 2005
11,283
4,714
0
I wasn’t aware that they did it without Darius Miller, Terrence Jones, and Doron Lamb?
They didn’t. It’s the biggest misconception about UK b-ball under Cal. Look at the 2012 tourney games. Lamb, Miller, and Jones were beasts. Cal has to have a combination. Stud frosh and talented returnees. This year the frosh were not studs. Last year we didn’t have either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyWa11

cal=8

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2009
2,049
1,417
0
John Calipari is the best thing to happen to Ky Basketball period.. His record here is unparalleled.. His philosophy as a coach and recruiter have been more successful than any coach we've had in modern times. Those are facts.. When Coach retires or chooses a different path it will be a sad day for BBN.
 

UKat51

All-Conference
May 9, 2003
2,456
1,932
113
Or is it Darius Miller, Terrence Jones and Doron Lamb couldnt win one without outstanding freshmen to lead the way.....hmmmmmm

The point is...... a team has to have a balance of maturity, experience and talented underclass men. Our 2012 class had that mixture as did Duke’s 2015 class. No team has won a national title with only O&D players. Duke is a shining example of that this year. We have not had upperclassmen with the talent of Lamb, Jones and Miller since 2013.

I will be glad when O&D is over. I believe we will be better then. Check out this year’s final four. All teams dominated by uperclassmen
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyWa11

Bratkartoffeln

All-Conference
Jan 1, 2003
3,642
2,033
113
We have now had over a decade of experience with the "One and Done Strategy". And the results are in. You can either recruit kids to play one year and go to the NBA, OR you can win National Championships. You cannot do both. The Fab Five paved the way, and not enough people paid attention then; even THEY didn't win it all.

It is really simple....the NCAAT is TOO BIG a stage for inexperienced kids to make plays. Our guys shot FTs well all season, but suddenly in KC, can't find the hoop. Herro MISSED three wide-open 3's, any one of which would have won the game. Inexperience causes too much adrenaline flow in these kids under the lights. AND THEY ARE KIDS. Ironically, Duke was also not immune to this problem: it is a matter of physiology. If you can't shave, you are not going to perform well in the clutch on the big stage in crunch time. When you think about it, this should be a no-brainer.

So there it is. There really should be no more debate. If you want championships, you MUST have upper-classmen. Let's hope that Cal will pay attention, and encourage these KIDS to stick around. They may yet hoist a trophy......
Main problem the last two years especially is recruiting "one and doners" who really were not that good yet. We won in 2012 because our freshmen had a great older supporting cast. Same in 2015 when we should have won (I think pressure on our kids to be perfect was just too much of a burden). In both cases we had quality returnees. This year we were close but the level of talent just wasn't what we had hoped. SO, that should be good news for next year...I see us winning 30+ and competing again for a NC.
 

UKWildcats#8

All-American
Jun 25, 2011
30,327
9,338
0
The point is...... a team has to have a balance of maturity, experience and talented underclass men. Our 2012 class had that mixture as did Duke’s 2015 class. No team has won a national title with only O&D players. Duke is a shining example of that this year. We have not had upperclassmen with the talent of Lamb, Jones and Miller since 2013.

I will be glad when O&D is over. I believe we will be better then. Check out this year’s final four. All teams dominated by uperclassmen

If you look at Kentucky's history the last 60 years that's not true. I think it is something like three titles and 8 final fours in the 50 years before Calipari. Calipari has went four final four in a decade and he could have been to a couple more. Kentucky is average in one final for every 5 years the last 60 years. They are averaging one title every 15 years. If Calipari wins another one in the next 5 years he's doing really well
 

JohnDoe090

Redshirt
Jan 4, 2009
801
2
0
In a single elimination tournament the best team seldom wins. There have been a few exceptions (2012 for example). You can go back 20 years and the best team probably has only won it all 3 or 4 times.

Sorry, but this isn't true. Villanova was the best team last year, they won.

Last 20 years best teams to win:
2018 Villanova
2013 Louisville
2012 Kentucky
2009 North Carolina
2007 Florida
2005 North Carolina
2003 Syracuse
2001 Duke

And if we go back further even...
1999 UConn
1996 Kentucky
1995 UCLA
1994 Arkansas
1993 North Carolina
1992 Duke
1991 Duke
1990 UNLV

All of these teams were arguably the best in the country in each of these seasons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: walterwonderful

jbubb98

Senior
Mar 26, 2018
717
444
63
We have now had over a decade of experience with the "One and Done Strategy". And the results are in. You can either recruit kids to play one year and go to the NBA, OR you can win National Championships. You cannot do both. The Fab Five paved the way, and not enough people paid attention then; even THEY didn't win it all.

It is really simple....the NCAAT is TOO BIG a stage for inexperienced kids to make plays. Our guys shot FTs well all season, but suddenly in KC, can't find the hoop. Herro MISSED three wide-open 3's, any one of which would have won the game. Inexperience causes too much adrenaline flow in these kids under the lights. AND THEY ARE KIDS. Ironically, Duke was also not immune to this problem: it is a matter of physiology. If you can't shave, you are not going to perform well in the clutch on the big stage in crunch time. When you think about it, this should be a no-brainer.

So there it is. There really should be no more debate. If you want championships, you MUST have upper-classmen. Let's hope that Cal will pay attention, and encourage these KIDS to stick around. They may yet hoist a trophy......
We're going to have at least 5 return, maybe 6 and some pretty good freshmen coming in. We do need another big man though.
 

jboler

Senior
Feb 7, 2011
567
408
0
We have now had over a decade of experience with the "One and Done Strategy". And the results are in. You can either recruit kids to play one year and go to the NBA, OR you can win National Championships. You cannot do both. The Fab Five paved the way, and not enough people paid attention then; even THEY didn't win it all.

It is really simple....the NCAAT is TOO BIG a stage for inexperienced kids to make plays. Our guys shot FTs well all season, but suddenly in KC, can't find the hoop. Herro MISSED three wide-open 3's, any one of which would have won the game. Inexperience causes too much adrenaline flow in these kids under the lights. AND THEY ARE KIDS. Ironically, Duke was also not immune to this problem: it is a matter of physiology. If you can't shave, you are not going to perform well in the clutch on the big stage in crunch time. When you think about it, this should be a no-brainer.

So there it is. There really should be no more debate. If you want championships, you MUST have upper-classmen. Let's hope that Cal will pay attention, and encourage these KIDS to stick around. They may yet hoist a trophy......
Well since you’ve spoken on the matter, I’m sure that makes it so. Cal will have to take your advice...how many title teams have you coached?

Some of you people need therapy.
 

Cal-4-Three

All-Conference
Apr 2, 2011
1,591
1,844
0
The point is...... a team has to have a balance of maturity, experience and talented underclass men. Our 2012 class had that mixture as did Duke’s 2015 class. No team has won a national title with only O&D players. Duke is a shining example of that this year. We have not had upperclassmen with the talent of Lamb, Jones and Miller since 2013.

I will be glad when O&D is over. I believe we will be better then. Check out this year’s final four. All teams dominated by uperclassmen

You'll just ***** about something else when it's over. "Man I hate this stupid two and done system, we just don't have the same caliber of players we used to" I can see it coming.
 

NoDef

All-American
Sep 1, 2001
5,187
7,168
113
We started a senior and a sophomore. Our problems this year with the OAD was that we didn't get enough of the best ones. Our 2nd best player this year was a OAD that was ranked in the 30-40 range. Those kids are not supposed to be OAD but what do you do? Tell them not to overachieve? If SGA comes back and we win it all. He goes from a top 30-40 player to a lottery pick. I'm sure Cal didn't recruit him or Herro thinking they were OAD players.

That's the thing about guards though. There is just not that much skill difference in an NAIA guard and a guard at Ole Miss. Our guards get drafted because they are bigger. Other teams have just as skilled guards that play four years because they are 6'0 instead of 6'3. It then comes down to who is making shots on that day and the Auburn guards have played lights out for the last month..
 

Trinity45

All-American
Oct 26, 2005
3,428
5,354
113
We have now had over a decade of experience with the "One and Done Strategy". And the results are in. You can either recruit kids to play one year and go to the NBA, OR you can win National Championships. You cannot do both. The Fab Five paved the way, and not enough people paid attention then; even THEY didn't win it all.

It is really simple....the NCAAT is TOO BIG a stage for inexperienced kids to make plays. Our guys shot FTs well all season, but suddenly in KC, can't find the hoop. Herro MISSED three wide-open 3's, any one of which would have won the game. Inexperience causes too much adrenaline flow in these kids under the lights. AND THEY ARE KIDS. Ironically, Duke was also not immune to this problem: it is a matter of physiology. If you can't shave, you are not going to perform well in the clutch on the big stage in crunch time. When you think about it, this should be a no-brainer.

So there it is. There really should be no more debate. If you want championships, you MUST have upper-classmen. Let's hope that Cal will pay attention, and encourage these KIDS to stick around. They may yet hoist a trophy......

To a point I agree with you, you need a mix of vets to go with the OAD, 2012 had the versatile Miller, Dukes 2015 team had vets on the team that contributed as well. When your roster gets to the point where we are looking at sophomores as the vets I think you can win 25 to 30 games but the tournament format of lose and your done is very hard with almost no experience on the floor.
 

cat888

Senior
Jul 23, 2006
1,994
785
113
I'm confused. Was our best player a freshman? And did we not have a senior who played damn near every minute of our last game? Others have said it already, but it begs repeating: IT IS A ONE AND OUT TOURNAMENT. THE BEST TEAM RARELY WINS. Look at the final four. Are those the best four teams in the country?
CORRECT It would be hard to take Duke or North Carolina out of the four best teams an most believe Coach K to be one of the best Coaches.
 
Mar 8, 2006
3,309
942
0
I'm almost 38 and I agree completely. The last few Tubby years and BCG were terrible. That's putting it mildly.

Edit: Our problem this year was that we didn't possess a PG capable of winning the title. I thought (more so hoped) Hagans would finally figure it out over a six game stretch to get us there. It really all hinged on that IMO. At the end of the day, we didn't have a capable enough PG to win the title this year. Turnovers killed us as much as missed FTs.
And what still makes loss painful is even after all of that.. turnovers.. free throws .. bad outside shooting.. we were still up 2 points in last minute of game. Tough loss
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cowtown Cat
Mar 8, 2006
3,309
942
0
It's just a hard title to win. Two OAD led teams have won it in the last 9 years. A couple have made it to the finals and maybe the best team of the decade was a shot clock violation away from winning it. We were three really clean blocks away from winning yesterday and going to the final four with not even the top OAD players in the country. It has to do more with the NCAA basketball tournament being the hardest one in all of sports to win . It's called March Madness for a reason and that why the very best team every year only wins it about 1 out of every 4 tries.
This post sums it up even after all the other issues we had during game those three blocks were the plays of the game especially the last two in last minute without fouling.
 

jbubb98

Senior
Mar 26, 2018
717
444
63
We started a senior and a sophomore. Our problems this year with the OAD was that we didn't get enough of the best ones. Our 2nd best player this year was a OAD that was ranked in the 30-40 range. Those kids are not supposed to be OAD but what do you do? Tell them not to overachieve? If SGA comes back and we win it all. He goes from a top 30-40 player to a lottery pick. I'm sure Cal didn't recruit him or Herro thinking they were OAD players.

That's the thing about guards though. There is just not that much skill difference in an NAIA guard and a guard at Ole Miss. Our guards get drafted because they are bigger. Other teams have just as skilled guards that play four years because they are 6'0 instead of 6'3. It then comes down to who is making shots on that day and the Auburn guards have played lights out for the last month..
Not disagreeing with your post, some years it's an advantage to have tall guards and some years it isn't. Skill level and agility have something to do with it too I think. I guess that last statement of mine would be in the duh category.
 

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
Sorry, but this isn't true. Villanova was the best team last year, they won.

Last 20 years best teams to win:
2018 Villanova
2013 Louisville
2012 Kentucky
2009 North Carolina
2007 Florida
2005 North Carolina
2003 Syracuse
2001 Duke

And if we go back further even...
1999 UConn
1996 Kentucky
1995 UCLA
1994 Arkansas
1993 North Carolina
1992 Duke
1991 Duke
1990 UNLV

All of these teams were arguably the best in the country in each of these seasons.

So based on your numbers, the favorites have won 40% of the time over the last 20 years.

However, Syracuse was not the favorite in 2003. They were a 3 seed.

So down to 35%.

Also:

1991- UNLV was the team to beat and undefeated before losing to Duke in the semis.
1993- I would argue that IU (before Henderson went down) or Michigan (Fab Five) were the favorites.
1995- Arkansas was the defending champs with pretty much everyone back.
1999- Duke was the favorite, UConn upset them in the title game.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Recruiting 5-star C Cherif Millogo signs with Kentucky
  2. 02 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  3. 03 KSR Basketball KSR Show, 11/19: Matt is back in Lexington, live from 10 (a.m.) to noon (p.m.)
  4. 04 KSR KSR Today: Prepping for Indiana and Missouri, GTA VI is out, and end-of-season honors
  5. 05 KSR Football Kentucky vs. Missouri Availability Report: Starting WR Could Return