The facts are in: IT CANNOT BE DONE

jackcarlson

Senior
Jan 6, 2011
2,006
647
0
We have now had over a decade of experience with the "One and Done Strategy". And the results are in. You can either recruit kids to play one year and go to the NBA, OR you can win National Championships. You cannot do both. The Fab Five paved the way, and not enough people paid attention then; even THEY didn't win it all.

It is really simple....the NCAAT is TOO BIG a stage for inexperienced kids to make plays. Our guys shot FTs well all season, but suddenly in KC, can't find the hoop. Herro MISSED three wide-open 3's, any one of which would have won the game. Inexperience causes too much adrenaline flow in these kids under the lights. AND THEY ARE KIDS. Ironically, Duke was also not immune to this problem: it is a matter of physiology. If you can't shave, you are not going to perform well in the clutch on the big stage in crunch time. When you think about it, this should be a no-brainer.

So there it is. There really should be no more debate. If you want championships, you MUST have upper-classmen. Let's hope that Cal will pay attention, and encourage these KIDS to stick around. They may yet hoist a trophy......
 

Wildcats1st

Heisman
Sep 16, 2017
18,949
28,911
0
2012 UK and 2015 Duke ring any bells?

And since then recruiting has become so watered down for uk that itbisnt getting the elite talent it takes. Duke had it this year and ratface couldn’t manage it. Since then though has a freshman laden team even made a ff?? I don’t think so and the last two years has been all experience in the final four.
 

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
Need a balance of young talent and returning talent.

That's why getting Hagans, Montgomery, Richards, and Quickley to stay is as important as adding Maxey, Whitney, and Brooks.

If we have to rely on either our returnees to do it all or our newcomers to do it all, then we have no shot.

The combination of the two has a chance to win a title.

I really want McDaniels added to the mix, but I don't think he leaves the West Coast, though.
 

ZZBlueComet

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2009
46,208
2,152
113
I think most UK fans understand and accept when guys like KAT, Wall and AD leave but it’s the players who leave like Teague, Skal, Gabriel, Vanderbilt etc., who clearly aren’t ready that get to fans. Throw in all the players who transfer out and it’s not fun not making Final Fours and losing most of the team - and, I don’t give a damn what other schools are doing.
 

billCgmx

All-American
Apr 9, 2015
3,060
6,725
0
In a single elimination tournament the best team seldom wins. There have been a few exceptions (2012 for example). You can go back 20 years and the best team probably has only won it all 3 or 4 times.

Why is it so hard for some people to see this?
 

MegaBlue05

Heisman
Mar 8, 2014
11,275
23,098
66
Fine. Fire Cal. Get 3-4 year players. Get a couple 6-9 seeds to go with that occasional high seed. No complaining if this model doesn’t work. No complaining about project bigs or daydreaming about the 13th man becomming a star as a senior. No bitching about recruiting classes outside the top 10 or 20.

I’ve enjoyed the run, and outside of the Pitino years, this is the best weve had it in my 39 years on earth.
 
Nov 12, 2014
4,807
11,637
0
We have now had over a decade of experience with the "One and Done Strategy". And the results are in. You can either recruit kids to play one year and go to the NBA, OR you can win National Championships. You cannot do both. The Fab Five paved the way, and not enough people paid attention then; even THEY didn't win it all.

It is really simple....the NCAAT is TOO BIG a stage for inexperienced kids to make plays. Our guys shot FTs well all season, but suddenly in KC, can't find the hoop. Herro MISSED three wide-open 3's, any one of which would have won the game. Inexperience causes too much adrenaline flow in these kids under the lights. AND THEY ARE KIDS. Ironically, Duke was also not immune to this problem: it is a matter of physiology. If you can't shave, you are not going to perform well in the clutch on the big stage in crunch time. When you think about it, this should be a no-brainer.

So there it is. There really should be no more debate. If you want championships, you MUST have upper-classmen. Let's hope that Cal will pay attention, and encourage these KIDS to stick around. They may yet hoist a trophy......

 

antiduke_99

Junior
Apr 1, 2009
664
390
0
I'm confused. Was our best player a freshman? And did we not have a senior who played damn near every minute of our last game? Others have said it already, but it begs repeating: IT IS A ONE AND OUT TOURNAMENT. THE BEST TEAM RARELY WINS. Look at the final four. Are those the best four teams in the country?
 

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
I think most UK fans understand and accept when guys like KAT, Wall and AD leave but it’s the players who leave like Teague, Skal, Gabriel, Vanderbilt etc., who clearly aren’t ready that get to fans. Throw in all the players who transfer out and it’s not fun not making Final Fours and losing most of the team - and, I don’t give a damn what other schools are doing.

This is definitely frustrating, but part of it.

Sad thing is there are fans bemoaning the possibility of a guy like Richards returning and starting for us next year.

So what do we want? Do we want guys to come back that need more time or not?

You can't have it both ways.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CatfanMike47

jackcarlson

Senior
Jan 6, 2011
2,006
647
0
Don't get me wrong guys. I have been just as fascinated, enthusiastic, and optimistic with this strategy as one can possibly be. But, it is time to be objective. It is too painful to continually watch successive UNNECESSARY failures. It is hard on us, but it is also hard on these kids. We must have some maturity. One graduate student in the starting line-up is not enough.
 

Blueisbest

All-American
Mar 22, 2003
24,628
5,325
0
We should have high expectations. Low expectations only lead to settling for less. Settle for less long enough and you become Indiana.
I'm not saying that I don't have high expectations and want to win every year, It's okay to expect that but the ones that criticize Cal and/or the players need to realize that a championship or bust mentality is just not realistic. It never has been and it never will be. You are just setting yourself up for a lot of disappointment when we don't win it all.
 

rmattox

All-Conference
Nov 26, 2014
6,786
4,006
0
We have now had over a decade of experience with the "One and Done Strategy". And the results are in. You can either recruit kids to play one year and go to the NBA, OR you can win National Championships. You cannot do both. The Fab Five paved the way, and not enough people paid attention then; even THEY didn't win it all.

It is really simple....the NCAAT is TOO BIG a stage for inexperienced kids to make plays. Our guys shot FTs well all season, but suddenly in KC, can't find the hoop. Herro MISSED three wide-open 3's, any one of which would have won the game. Inexperience causes too much adrenaline flow in these kids under the lights. AND THEY ARE KIDS. Ironically, Duke was also not immune to this problem: it is a matter of physiology. If you can't shave, you are not going to perform well in the clutch on the big stage in crunch time. When you think about it, this should be a no-brainer.

So there it is. There really should be no more debate. If you want championships, you MUST have upper-classmen. Let's hope that Cal will pay attention, and encourage these KIDS to stick around. They may yet hoist a trophy......

Okay. Exactly how do you want Cal to adjust his recruiting? No longer recruit the top 25-50 high school players? Would you like him to recruit guys that dook, unc, etc...don't want?

Agree with the part about some kids needing to stick around, but that's not Cal's call. If he has a kid that can get first round, guaranteed money, it's his job to encourage him to go for it. It's the job of a university to prepare and equip kids for the professions of their choice. If their dream is to be pro players, it's the job of the university to help them get such jobs.
 

KYExtemper

All-Conference
Mar 6, 2013
4,471
4,618
0
I'm fine with bringing in highly touted freshmen (after all, someone is going to get them and I'd rather it be us) but it'd be nice if we had more guys stay. It just sucks when we have guys who come, are expected to be 2-3 year players, and they bounce after one year. I mean, the Harrison twins didn't do jack in the league. Dakari Johnson would've been a nice piece to have in 2016. And we could assemble a long list of guys we need to retain for experience purposes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyWa11

Graced 1

Junior
Sep 18, 2017
299
336
63
Spot on OP, and the proof is in the history books.
Experienced ,older teams with great guards usually win in march. Doron lamb won our only title under Cal when he knocked down shots.
Jimmy Dykes referenced this in one of our games this year and I didnt want to hear it, but I was concerned and it showed up yesterday in a team we beat by 30 a month ago
 

jackcarlson

Senior
Jan 6, 2011
2,006
647
0
Yes, Cal needs to adjust his recruiting speech a little bit. He NOW has enough credibility to not be questioned or second-guessed by NBA scouts. And the change is a simple one, "I am not going to encourage you to go to the NBA until you are ready to be in a starting lineup."

And he really shouldn't be encouraging them to go before then, anyway. Playing in the D-league ain't that glamorous....
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyWa11

Blueisbest

All-American
Mar 22, 2003
24,628
5,325
0
A lot of this angst will be moot in a couple of years if the one and done rule is abolished as expected. Many of the players we have been getting the last decade or so that have jumped to the NBA after one year will likely not be going to college after this change.

We will have to adjust our recruiting to try and get the best of the one's that decide they aren't NBA ready. This means that players that are the caliber of the 15-30 range will be the most sought after. These types of players will probably stay multiple seasons. Most or all of the Top 15 players won't even consider college.
 

ubtrapper_rivals103836

All-Conference
Jan 14, 2014
1,519
1,696
0
Maybe Cal should make a rule that if you come to Ky, you can't leave for the draft unless your in the top 10. That way any recruit from 11 on down has to come back or transfer! Lol That's it! I just solved the OAD problem!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cowtown Cat

Cowtown Cat

Heisman
Aug 23, 2015
24,412
55,796
100
Fine. Fire Cal. Get 3-4 year players. Get a couple 6-9 seeds to go with that occasional high seed. No complaining if this model doesn’t work. No complaining about project bigs or daydreaming about the 13th man becomming a star as a senior. No bitching about recruiting classes outside the top 10 or 20.

I’ve enjoyed the run, and outside of the Pitino years, this is the best weve had it in my 39 years on earth.
I'm almost 38 and I agree completely. The last few Tubby years and BCG were terrible. That's putting it mildly.

Edit: Our problem this year was that we didn't possess a PG capable of winning the title. I thought (more so hoped) Hagans would finally figure it out over a six game stretch to get us there. It really all hinged on that IMO. At the end of the day, we didn't have a capable enough PG to win the title this year. Turnovers killed us as much as missed FTs.
 

Graced 1

Junior
Sep 18, 2017
299
336
63
In my judgment the Title now belongs to UVA, they will beat Auburn comfortably and then Michigan St.
Those guards are experienced and make big shots.
We will see . Said on selection Sunday that MSU would be a tough out and Duke had the toughest bracket and that proved true
 
  • Like
Reactions: CatfanMike47

MegaBlue05

Heisman
Mar 8, 2014
11,275
23,098
66
I'm not saying that I don't have high expectations and want to win every year, It's okay to expect that but the ones that criticize Cal and/or the players need to realize that a championship or bust mentality is just not realistic. It never has been and it never will be. You are just setting yourself up for a lot of disappointment when we don't win it all.

This.

We had people talking Final Four and NC in 2006, 2007 and even early in 2009. Did these people not see the rosters I saw?

I expect to be a legit threat each year with a 1-4 seed. That’s attainable. WE GUNNA WIN IT ALL EVERY YEAR is not.
 

Cowtown Cat

Heisman
Aug 23, 2015
24,412
55,796
100
This.

We had people talking Final Four and NC in 2006, 2007 and even early in 2009. Did these people not see the rosters I saw?

I expect to be a legit threat each year with a 1-4 seed. That’s attainable. WE GUNNA WIN IT ALL EVERY YEAR is not.
Lol I hear ya. Reality was, the last pre Cal roster good enough was maybe 2005.
 

barryn2000

Senior
Dec 8, 2006
21,194
642
0
One and Done Strategy

I've asked several times what this strategy is. I'm pretty sure that prior to the NBA rule change in 2005, recruiting was exactly the same - try and recruit the best players you can. In fact, I checked and UK has had the #1 recruiting class many times over the decades. It seems to me that there isn't a strategy at all, that the NBA rules complicated keeping top talent for more than 1 year. This means the best recruiting schools simply end up with more kids that serve their 1 year NBA ban than others. The only way to avoid this would be to stop recruiting the best.

What is the One and Done "Strategy"?
 
  • Like
Reactions: burnacct41
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Recruiting 5-star C Cherif Millogo signs with Kentucky
  2. 02 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  3. 03 KSR Basketball KSR Show, 11/19: Matt is back in Lexington, live from 10 (a.m.) to noon (p.m.)
  4. 04 KSR KSR Today: Prepping for Indiana and Missouri, GTA VI is out, and end-of-season honors
  5. 05 KSR Football Kentucky vs. Missouri Availability Report: Starting WR Could Return