Two major points that never get translated when a 25 year old reporter tries to summarize TIF in a short article in the local fishwrap:
1. The Tax Increment Financing vehicle does bring in additional tax dollars to the local entity. Only a percentage of the increased taxes is reimbursed to the developer. Note I said PERCENTAGE and INCREASED taxes. Those new dollars don't exist unless you have a store selling something. So there is increased sales tax to the city. Not to mention, the TIF is paid out in a relatively short amount of time (usually 10 years or so), meaning that from that point on, the city gets ALL of their share of the sales tax dollars. Oh and by the way, the Ad Valorem tax goes up. Academy will (or would have) paid much more to the city and county in real estate taxes on that parcel than the owner of the vacant land does currently. So the city loses in several ways by not making a deal.
2. I'll restate what I said in talking about Costco in Ridgeland. Academy doesn't need to go to Starkville. They have literally hundreds of other small towns courting them, and most of those towns have better demographics. If local yokels want to have nice new things, sometimes public officials have to make the deal attractive. In other words, while I don't necessarily love the location they were going to in Starkville, Academy is a great store -- about the best of its kind that a town like StarkVegas can get -- so if it takes a small TIF to make the deal work financially, most Mayors, supervisors, or city councilmen who don't have some personal reason not to do it, usually jump at the opportunity. As I said, the sales tax dollars are NEW dollars, so overall retail is seen as a good thing for the city.