The development w/ Academy in Starkville is dead

Duke Humphrey

All-Conference
Oct 3, 2013
2,786
1,949
113
Struck down by LINK and city fathers.

The leadership of the City of Starkville and political environment is the biggest threat to the future of Mississippi State University.
 

11thEagleFan

All-Conference
Sep 6, 2015
3,022
2,032
113
I never understood why people got excited about an Academy opening in Starkville anyway. There's an Academy in the town where I live and honestly... It sucks. There are many other developments that Starkville could use more than an Academy sports store.
 

Duke Humphrey

All-Conference
Oct 3, 2013
2,786
1,949
113
It's not about Academy.... It's about the lack of partnership between city leaders, economic developers and private investors/developers.... Nobody can seem to get on the same page.
 

Duke Humphrey

All-Conference
Oct 3, 2013
2,786
1,949
113
Could not agree on the financing... And the leaders may have been right, but why wasn't this agreed upon before a public meeting? Why can't the powers that be get the crap done before hand like in most communities instead of it being played out to failure for all the public to see?
 

mcdawg22

Heisman
Sep 18, 2004
13,790
12,459
113
I like Academy. They have a great saltwater selection and lots of add ons for my kayak. I don't know what it's like in an inland non saltwater store.
 
Nov 12, 2007
26,211
10,364
113
Because evidently an overgrown vacant lot is a lot better for the city than a large business contributing to a boost in tax revenue. So who's brother or cousin on the board has a store that sells sporting goods or firearms?

Havent lived in Starkville in almost nine years, but I would give good odds that this is exactly what the issue is.

It is weird to imagine being in a town that thinks this way when I live in Austin. I give you is larger, but they bend over backward to bring in business and development. To say it has worked is an understatement.
 

ronpolk

All-American
May 6, 2009
9,459
5,496
113
Who owns the Sports Center on hwy 12?

Unless he has sold it, I'm pretty sure castleberry owns that shopping center that sports center is in. I can't imagine the people who own sports center were real happy that castleberry was bringing competition.
 

ronpolk

All-American
May 6, 2009
9,459
5,496
113
Because evidently an overgrown vacant lot is a lot better for the city than a large business contributing to a boost in tax revenue. So who's brother or cousin on the board has a store that sells sporting goods or firearms?

As much as I want to see vacant lots developed in Starkville, if this was dependent on public finance from the city then I agree with turning it down. I mean this is a $11 million development for an academy's. This is something the developer needs to finance on his own. There is no reason for the tax payers to be on the hook for this small of a job producer.
 

uptowndawg

All-Conference
Jul 15, 2010
2,272
1,142
113
Going to academy is one of my favorite

Weekday afternoon hobbies. I'll go spend 2 hours and a hundred bucks just to get out of the house. But I do hunt a dozen different species, fish both fresh and salt water and wear advanced comfort wranglers. So I guess I'm the target market.
 

11thEagleFan

All-Conference
Sep 6, 2015
3,022
2,032
113
Ah. I live in a landlocked state in the middle of the desert. Beautiful city, great weather, but literally hundreds of miles from any significant body of water. Maybe that's why I'm not impressed with our Academy. I've gotta get back to the Gulf Coast, I miss the water.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,571
3,179
113
I wonder if Starkville had to chip in to get Walmart in town when it was built several years ago. Walmart has closed down thousands of local businesses in many towns.

I can understand tax breaks for a while if needed to attract new businesses or manufacturers, but pretty much agree with you that public funds shouldn't be used to essentially close local businesses.
 

LandsurveyorDawg

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
315
0
0
I agree with you. This whole TIF stuff is a scam. I believe California has outlawed them. Developers should use their own money, since they are the ones that will reap the rewards.
 

was21

Senior
May 29, 2007
10,013
637
113
You could say that with pretty much certainty about the entire state of Mississippi. I live here by the way
 

dickiedawg

All-Conference
Feb 22, 2008
4,612
1,584
113
Yeah I like going to Academy a lot more than, for example, Dick's. They seem to carry more stuff in big man sizes as well as carrying some less expensive store brand stuff that is decent product. Just less pricey overall, or so it seems to me.
I was very excited to have them in Starkville.
 

Drewbowski

Redshirt
Sep 2, 2012
810
0
0
This is may be one of those things that are better for Starkville in the long term but presently we are left with a vacant, ugly lot.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,312
5,867
113
Because evidently an overgrown vacant lot is a lot better for the city than a large business contributing to a boost in tax revenue. So who's brother or cousin on the board has a store that sells sporting goods or firearms?

Based on earlier reported stories, they were looking at TIF, so Starkville wouldn't have gotten a boost in tax revenue. Any boost in tax revenue would have essentially gone to pay off debt to build the development. There may be situations where TIF is justified, but the only time I ever hear of it being used is with retail box stores, which I don't think ever qualifies as one of those situations.
 

Shamoan

Redshirt
Jun 27, 2013
12,466
0
0
starkville is run by a bunch of small minded imbeciles. i understand that the new leadership is trying to turn that around, but its baffling how backwards the old guard is...like embarrassingly backwards.
 

ShrubDog

Redshirt
Apr 13, 2008
5,307
3
38
As long as there is a Dollar General, Freds, Walmart, Walgreens and Sonic everyone has been covered.
 

Junction John

Redshirt
Oct 22, 2014
3,249
0
0
90% of people don't bc they only get info from the local paper.

I'm not so sure you totally understand how a TIF works.

Two major points that never get translated when a 25 year old reporter tries to summarize TIF in a short article in the local fishwrap:

1. The Tax Increment Financing vehicle does bring in additional tax dollars to the local entity. Only a percentage of the increased taxes is reimbursed to the developer. Note I said PERCENTAGE and INCREASED taxes. Those new dollars don't exist unless you have a store selling something. So there is increased sales tax to the city. Not to mention, the TIF is paid out in a relatively short amount of time (usually 10 years or so), meaning that from that point on, the city gets ALL of their share of the sales tax dollars. Oh and by the way, the Ad Valorem tax goes up. Academy will (or would have) paid much more to the city and county in real estate taxes on that parcel than the owner of the vacant land does currently. So the city loses in several ways by not making a deal.

2. I'll restate what I said in talking about Costco in Ridgeland. Academy doesn't need to go to Starkville. They have literally hundreds of other small towns courting them, and most of those towns have better demographics. If local yokels want to have nice new things, sometimes public officials have to make the deal attractive. In other words, while I don't necessarily love the location they were going to in Starkville, Academy is a great store -- about the best of its kind that a town like StarkVegas can get -- so if it takes a small TIF to make the deal work financially, most Mayors, supervisors, or city councilmen who don't have some personal reason not to do it, usually jump at the opportunity. As I said, the sales tax dollars are NEW dollars, so overall retail is seen as a good thing for the city.
 
Last edited:

ronpolk

All-American
May 6, 2009
9,459
5,496
113
Two major points that never get translated when a 25 year old reporter tries to summarize TIF in a short article in the local fishwrap:

1. The Tax Increment Financing vehicle does bring in additional tax dollars to the local entity. Only a percentage of the increased taxes is reimbursed to the developer. Note I said PERCENTAGE and INCREASED taxes. Those new dollars don't exist unless you have a store selling something. So there is increased sales tax to the city. Not to mention, the TIF is paid out in a relatively short amount of time (usually 10 years or so), meaning that from that point on, the city gets ALL of their share of the sales tax dollars. Oh and by the way, the Ad Valorem tax goes up. Academy will (or would have) paid much more to the city and county in real estate taxes on that parcel than the owner of the vacant land does currently. So the city loses in several ways by not making a deal.

2. I'll restate what I said in talking about Costco in Ridgeland. Academy doesn't need to go to Starkville. They have literally hundreds of other small towns courting them, and most of those towns have better demographics. If local yokels want to have nice new things, sometimes public officials have to make the deal attractive. In other words, while I don't necessarily love the location they were going to in Starkville, Academy is a great store -- about the best of its kind that a town like StarkVegas can get -- so if it takes a small TIF to make the deal work financially, most Mayors, supervisors, or city councilmen who don't have some personal reason not to do it, usually jump at the opportunity. As I said, the sales tax dollars are NEW dollars, so overall retail is seen as a good thing for the city.

So, what happens when a city or county issues a TIF bond and the development fails, which at this point does not produce the sales tax revenue increase that is expected? In that case you have the bond buyer (typically a bank) looking at the city or county for the payment and then the tax payers are on the hook for something that benefitted no one, except for the developer who probably added a nice "developer fee" onto the cost of the bond.

You want a good example of this? Read up on Madison county, galleria parkway and trustmark bank. Trustmark is currently getting paid by the county for a failed project that received TIF funding. Sucks for the taxpayers of Madison county.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,497
33,370
113
You want a good example of this? Read up on Madison county, galleria parkway and trustmark bank. Trustmark is currently getting paid by the county for a failed project that received TIF funding. Sucks for the taxpayers of Madison county.
That's just one of a long list of ways the former Board of Supervisors has screwed the taxpayers of Madison County.
 

ronpolk

All-American
May 6, 2009
9,459
5,496
113
That's just one of a long list of ways the former Board of Supervisors has screwed the taxpayers of Madison County.

Galleria parkway TIF's problems go beyond what I mentioned above. The leadership was so poor in Madison county that this TIF district included tax exempt property. Now explain to me how a tax exempt property is going to have an increased taxable basis at any point in the future? Just a very good example of why cities do not need to be involved in financing economic development. I can get behind a short term tax break, rather this be property or sales, but not sure fire public finance like TIF bonds.

I'll add this, I'm not opposed to TIF districts being created. At their heart they are really just a tax break.
 
Sep 25, 2009
57
0
6
wrong people

Unless he has sold it, I'm pretty sure castleberry owns that shopping center that sports center is in. I can't imagine the people who own sports center were real happy that castleberry was bringing competition.

Castleberry doesn't own the shopping center with Sports Center nor is he involved in Proposed Academy project. Project isn't officially dead, but City offered a different TIFF agreement from what developer asked for.
 

ronpolk

All-American
May 6, 2009
9,459
5,496
113
Castleberry doesn't own the shopping center with Sports Center nor is he involved in Proposed Academy project. Project isn't officially dead, but City offered a different TIFF agreement from what developer asked for.

You're right. Castleberry owns that cspire in front of that shopping center. I knew he had something in that area.
 

Junction John

Redshirt
Oct 22, 2014
3,249
0
0
So no city should ever offer incentives because one project failed?

So, what happens when a city or county issues a TIF bond and the development fails, which at this point does not produce the sales tax revenue increase that is expected? In that case you have the bond buyer (typically a bank) looking at the city or county for the payment and then the tax payers are on the hook for something that benefitted no one, except for the developer who probably added a nice "developer fee" onto the cost of the bond.

You want a good example of this? Read up on Madison county, galleria parkway and trustmark bank. Trustmark is currently getting paid by the county for a failed project that received TIF funding. Sucks for the taxpayers of Madison county.

I can point to dozens of TIFs that have been successful and good for the community for every one that was unsuccessful. Not to speak ill of the deceased, but since I knew him personally, I would've voted 'no' to giving the Galleria PID any public financing without property security too.

There are ways for TIFs and any incentives to be structured with clawbacks, etc., so that the city is not at risk. We're talking about a credit national tenant here in Academy. No tenants were signed up when Galleria was being discussed. It was just a hope and a prayer.
 

ronpolk

All-American
May 6, 2009
9,459
5,496
113
I can point to dozens of TIFs that have been successful and good for the community for every one that was unsuccessful. Not to speak ill of the deceased, but since I knew him personally, I would've voted 'no' to giving the Galleria PID any public financing without property security too.

There are ways for TIFs and any incentives to be structured with clawbacks, etc., so that the city is not at risk. We're talking about a credit national tenant here in Academy. No tenants were signed up when Galleria was being discussed. It was just a hope and a prayer.

Offering incentives an issuing a bond is totally different. Like I stated in a later post, I'm fine with a TIF district. Let a city create a TIF district and the developer move in and get traditional financing. My problem comes in with TIF bonds. I believe the government has a higher responsibility to maintaining good roads rather than giving a developer cheap financing. Again, my problem is not with the TIF district only when a bond is issued to provide financing.
 

xxxWalkTheDawg

Redshirt
Oct 21, 2005
4,262
0
25
It's not about Academy.... It's about the lack of partnership between city leaders, economic developers and private investors/developers.... Nobody can seem to get on the same page.

And that makes me shake my head at how you cannot have your stuff straight. They came to tupelo and had zero trouble building on prime property. You can drive past the place on a Wednesday at 11:00 in the morning and the lot is half full. It's packed on the weekend. its paying a hell of a lot more sales taxes than sage grass even if there was an agreement of some sort.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Mississippi State Soccer hosts Samford in NCAA Tournament on Friday
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Who carries the load?
  3. 03 Maroon and White Basketball Bulldogs prepare for mid-major test against Tulsa in Jackson
  4. 04 On3 Football Mississippi State RB Fluff Bothwell re-signs with Bulldogs for 2027
  5. 05 Maroon and White "There will be an opportunity for Brodie": Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby sets freshman up for Saturday runout