I looked back at Schianos recruiting classes and they were mostly middle of the pack Big Ten. The 2012 class woukd have been 3rd. We've fallen so much with Flood and now Ash. It's very concerning.
First off, we were only "middle of the pack" for our division for two years, in 2011-2012, which were Schiano/Hafley's best recruiting classes before he left for Tampa Bay. We've pretty much been at the bottom of the division since Schiano left.
Part of that is because our recruiting dropped a touch under Flood, part is because Indiana was no longer lagging way behind in recruiting, part is because the sanctions on PA St ended, and part was because of some coaching additions that are top recruiters (Meyer/Harbaugh/Franklin).
Our division started rising in the recruiting rankings around us, and we haven't kept pace. We were 6th in the division in 2010 when the average recruiting rank was 39.9 and there were no Top 10 teams.... we were also 6th last year when the average rank was 25.1 and there were 2 Top 5 and 4 Top 25 teams.
Looking at our division during Schiano's peak recruiting until now:
Schiano
2006 (Avg: 31.3... 0 Top 5, 1 Top 10, 3 Top 25... RU 6th)
2007 (Avg: 32.1... 0 Top 5, 0 Top 10, 3 Top 25...
RU 5th)
2008 (Avg: 37.9... 1 Top 5, 2 Top 10, 2 Top 25... RU 5th)
2009 (Avg:
25.0... 1 Top 5, 2 Top 10,
4 Top 25... RU 6th)
2010 (Avg: 39.9... 0 Top 5, 0 Top 10, 3 Top 25... RU 6th)
2011 (Avg: 33.1... 0 Top 5, 0 Top 10, 2 Top 25...
RU 4th)
2012 (Avg: 32.9... 1 Top 5, 2 Top 10, 3 Top 25...
RU 3rd)
Flood
2013 (Avg:
29.4...
2 Top 5, 2 Top 10, 2 Top 25... RU 7th)
2014 (Avg: 32.5... 1 Top 5, 1 Top 10, 3 Top 25... RU 7th)
2015 (Avg: 35.7... 0 Top 5, 1 Top 10, 3 Top 25... RU 6th)
2016 (Avg: 31.0...
2 Top 5, 2 Top 10,
4 Top 25... RU 7th)
Ash
2017 (Avg:
25.1...
2 Top 5, 2 Top 10,
4 Top 25... RU 6th)
2018 (Avg:
27.0...
2 Top 5, 2 Top 10, 3 Top 25... RU 7th)