Rate our recruiting class

mikefla

All-Conference
Nov 19, 2012
6,450
1,552
0
RU's 2018 class is currently rated #42 by Rivals.
These are the years when Rutgers had a more highly rated class: 2007 (#37), 2009 (#38), 2011 (#32), 2012 (#24)
The 2006 class was also rated #42.
These are the years when RU had a weaker class....as per Rivals rankings: 2017 (#43), 2016 (#78), 2015 (#53), 2014 (#57), 2013 (#45), 2010 (#64), 2008 (#46), 2005 (#68), 2004 (#52), 2003 (#45), 2002 (#46)
So, it looks like the 2018 class would rank in the top third of Rutgers recruiting classes since 2002....which is as far back as this site goes BTW.
Ash's two classes have been rated #42 and #43.....which isn't bad unless you thought he was gonna out-recruit the elite teams right away.
There's plenty of progress to be made in recruiting here, but his first two classes aren't too shabby.

Damn good work!

THANK YOU!!!!!
 

sct1111

All-American
Nov 30, 2014
6,171
8,516
113
It's 57, not 59.
Don't get hung up on rank. There is an infinitesimal difference in quality below about 30-35.

Teams are are above:
Northwestern (59)
Syracuse! (62) (future opponent)
BC! (66) (future opponent)--noting a trend that northeastern teams are low-ranked
Stanford (70)
Arkansas (79)

Teams we are in the same neighborhood with:
Illinois (50) have to hand it to Lovie. . .
Purdue (49)
Indiana (44)
Row The Gopher (42)
Wisconsin (39) - 1 four star-- they do more with less, maybe we will too. Do you think they are bitching that they are ranked below some teams?
Iowa (39)


Cry harder. Maryland is 29 pal.
I'm not your pal, buddy...

Recruiting services are no where near perfect but they get more and more accurate every year. Ash simply has to recruit better than this or he'll be gone a few years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Plum Street

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,333
113
I'm not your pal, buddy...

Recruiting services are no where near perfect but they get more and more accurate every year. Ash simply has to recruit better than this or he'll be gone a few years.
Thanks, buddy!
Who was disputing the recruiting services?
Totally agree on the last statement. This class better have quite a few diamonds in the rough, and he needs a top 25-30 class in 2019.
And Maryland is still not top 25, pal.:fistbump:
 
  • Like
Reactions: KnightsofChrome

sct1111

All-American
Nov 30, 2014
6,171
8,516
113
Thanks, buddy!
Who was disputing the recruiting services?
Totally agree on the last statement. This class better have quite a few diamonds in the rough, and he needs a top 25-30 class in 2019.
And Maryland is still not top 25, pal.:fistbump:
I'm not your buddy, guy..

I understand Maryland recruiting a little better than us but the gap shouldn't be this large. And if you average out their last two classes they have top 25 talent, friend. [thumb2]
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,333
113
I'm not your buddy, guy..

I understand Maryland recruiting a little better than us but the gap shouldn't be this large. And if you average out their last two classes they have top 25 talent, friend. [thumb2]
Cheer for Maryland, Amigo.
They did not get plumbed to the depth RU did with all of the nonsense with the former coach and the circus side show of an AD. They have Under Armor backing them up. Some of you people are funny. You expect the new coach to wave a magic wand and start bringing in 4 and 5 star recruits.
 

RUforlife

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2002
3,444
4,218
0
Bottom line, Ash has not recruited well enough to move the needle in the B1G East Division. What he has done is to stop the bleeding for now. If he coaches these kids up we now have the potential in the next 2-3 years to reach the Pinstripe Bowl. You are not competing against OSU, Penn State, and even the Michigan school with these recruiting classes, period, there is no debate, nothing to argue. On a very good year we might end up fourth within the division, that is the future under Ash based on his recruiting classes.

By the way, the real issue that needs to be addressed at some point is the absolute farce of having Penn State and Ohio State in the same division. Until that disgrace is finally addressed by the B1G everything else is white noise.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: koleszar

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,305
23,008
0
Damn good spin. Second to last class in the B1G and dead last in our division behind even Indiana . Ash is generating no buzz at all for this program. Even row the boat guy recruited three 4 star guys. Ash, zero

But remember we were told by people on his board “ash gets it” , “ash is a closer “.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUaMoose_rivals

RUDead

All-Conference
Sep 20, 2017
3,655
3,840
0
I don't think you can compare this to a flood class since half those guys flamed out for various reasons. If these two classes have a normal attrition rate it will be a huge improvement vs the flood classes. Its a solid class.

In the B!G this year its OSU, PSU and then everyone else. A couple guys either way and you are middle of the pack or the bottom. With a few wins, and what appears to be a better recruiting staff, i think RU makes that jump to top half in the conference in 2019.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sct1111

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,333
113
Have a question for all those clamoring that our classes are not on par with PSU, Michigan, tOSU and MSU--what concrete steps does Ash need to take to be a "better recruiter" to convince the top kids that coming to Rutgers is a better option than the aforementioned schools, along with all of the other schools that take the top recruits from New Jersey.

We have been down this road many times before. Would say the large majority of to recruits want to:
1. Leave NJ
2. Play for a storied program
3. Play for a CFP contender.

Once you realize that Ash (or nobody else) can fix those things, the crying game gets old.
 

koleszar

Heisman
Jan 1, 2010
38,522
61,110
113
Bottom line, Ash has not recruited well enough to move the needle in the B1G East Division. What he has done is to stop the bleeding for now. If he coaches these kids up we now have the potential in the next 2-3 years to reach the Pinstripe Bowl. You are not competing against OSU, Penn State, and even the Michigan school with these recruiting classes, period, there is no debate, nothing to argue. On a very good year we might end up fourth within the division, that is the future under Ash based on his recruiting classes.

By the way, the real issue that needs to be addressed at some point is the absolute farce of having Penn State and Ohio State in the same division. Until that disgrace is finally addressed by the B1G everything else is white noise.
Sorry to say I have to agree completely. Now I do concede he should have 4 to 5 yrs. to see what he can do after what he inherited. But the initial bump a new coach sees in recruiting is over, that's if it even happened. Ash has created no excitement around the program since he came in.

Actually he came in and culled any optimism. With his talk that the entire program must be reworked from scratch because basically it was crap before he got here. He preached that this would be a long arduous journey and while we'll work hard don't expect many wins. While this maybe true, he dampened expectations to the point where nobody gives a **** any longer.(not on here)

People outside of Rutgers aren't talking about Rutgers, there's no buzz around the program. If people aren't talking about it then you've already lost half the battle. Schiano got people to believe in the Chop and State of Rutgers by being a salesman. Even though we scoffed at him in the beginning, he kept constantly selling the program. Can you say the same for Ash with the Hunt and Fence the Garden?
 
Last edited:

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
I looked back at Schianos recruiting classes and they were mostly middle of the pack Big Ten. The 2012 class woukd have been 3rd. We've fallen so much with Flood and now Ash. It's very concerning.

First off, we were only "middle of the pack" for our division for two years, in 2011-2012, which were Schiano/Hafley's best recruiting classes before he left for Tampa Bay. We've pretty much been at the bottom of the division since Schiano left.

Part of that is because our recruiting dropped a touch under Flood, part is because Indiana was no longer lagging way behind in recruiting, part is because the sanctions on PA St ended, and part was because of some coaching additions that are top recruiters (Meyer/Harbaugh/Franklin).

Our division started rising in the recruiting rankings around us, and we haven't kept pace. We were 6th in the division in 2010 when the average recruiting rank was 39.9 and there were no Top 10 teams.... we were also 6th last year when the average rank was 25.1 and there were 2 Top 5 and 4 Top 25 teams.

Looking at our division during Schiano's peak recruiting until now:
Schiano
2006 (Avg: 31.3... 0 Top 5, 1 Top 10, 3 Top 25... RU 6th)
2007 (Avg: 32.1... 0 Top 5, 0 Top 10, 3 Top 25... RU 5th)
2008 (Avg: 37.9... 1 Top 5, 2 Top 10, 2 Top 25... RU 5th)
2009 (Avg: 25.0... 1 Top 5, 2 Top 10, 4 Top 25... RU 6th)
2010 (Avg: 39.9... 0 Top 5, 0 Top 10, 3 Top 25... RU 6th)
2011 (Avg: 33.1... 0 Top 5, 0 Top 10, 2 Top 25... RU 4th)
2012 (Avg: 32.9... 1 Top 5, 2 Top 10, 3 Top 25... RU 3rd)

Flood
2013 (Avg: 29.4... 2 Top 5, 2 Top 10, 2 Top 25... RU 7th)
2014 (Avg: 32.5... 1 Top 5, 1 Top 10, 3 Top 25... RU 7th)
2015 (Avg: 35.7... 0 Top 5, 1 Top 10, 3 Top 25... RU 6th)
2016 (Avg: 31.0... 2 Top 5, 2 Top 10, 4 Top 25... RU 7th)

Ash
2017 (Avg: 25.1... 2 Top 5, 2 Top 10, 4 Top 25... RU 6th)
2018 (Avg: 27.0... 2 Top 5, 2 Top 10, 3 Top 25... RU 7th)
 

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,305
23,008
0
Have a question for all those clamoring that our classes are not on par with PSU, Michigan, tOSU and MSU--what concrete steps does Ash need to take to be a "better recruiter" to convince the top kids that coming to Rutgers is a better option than the aforementioned schools, along with all of the other schools that take the top recruits from New Jersey.

We have been down this road many times before. Would say the large majority of to recruits want to:
1. Leave NJ
2. Play for a storied program
3. Play for a CFP contender.

Once you realize that Ash (or nobody else) can fix those things, the crying game gets old.

I am not interesting in figuring out the steps ash needs to take. That’s not my job . This guy gets paid good coin to figure it out. If he stinks at it (he seems to, but I am willing to give him 5 years barring total collapse on or off the field ) - he should be fired and Hobbs needs to hire someone that can.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUaMoose_rivals

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,333
113
I am not interesting in figuring out the steps ash needs to take. That’s not my job . This guy gets paid good coin to figure it out. If he stinks at it (he seems to, but I am willing to give him 5 years barring total collapse on or off the field ) - he should be fired and Hobbs needs to hire someone that can.


It needs to be slow build. I think your statement about 5 years is right.
Short of hiring a coach of the caliber of Chris Petersen, Scott Frost, James Franklin, etc for $4-5 million per year, nobody is coming into Rutgers and hitting it out of the park in recruiting on day 1. Even then, RU is still not a storied program or a CFP contender, which is the type of team many kids want to play for.
We need to follow the Wisconsin/Northwestern model and hope our 3-stars play like high level 3 stars or 4 stars. It's all we have right now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rutger80

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,305
23,008
0


It needs to be slow build. I think your statement about 5 years is right.
Short of hiring a coach of the caliber of Chris Petersen, Scott Frost, James Franklin, etc for $4-5 million per year, nobody is coming into Rutgers and hitting it out of the park in recruiting on day 1. Even then, RU is still not a storied program or a CFP contender, which is the type of team many kids want to play for.
We need to follow the Wisconsin/Northwestern model and hope our 3-stars play like high level 3 stars or 4 stars. It's all we have right now.


Yes, and unfortunately I don’t think we are getting a big name anytime soon. So we give ash 5 years unless he’s an apparent train wreck in the next season or two. The biggest mistakes this program had over the years was hanging onto losers like Shea and flood when they should have been fired after 1 or 2 seasons. If we go 2-10 this season then we need to cut our losses .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

rufeelinit

All-Conference
May 16, 2010
12,647
4,351
0
I think everyone understands that if Ash does not have a much better recruiting class next year it is possible he will never see the fruits of any good classes beyond that point. While more kids play as freshman, there are growing pains and likely more lumps. He needs to get kids in here now and take those lumps so that in years 4 and 5 the record is .500 or better. Couldn't agree more about his inability to create any buzz or juice with the program. And you wonder why season ticket sales continue to decline? As much as we criticized DM and ZK as coaches I think last years class was the strongest thus far and they were some of the best recruiters under Ash.
 

RU2055

All-Conference
Sep 9, 2009
3,582
1,693
0
Oh for goodness freaking sake. Take out Ohio State and I can guarantee you recruiting rankings DO NOT CORRELATE to the B1G Standings. THEY DO NOT. GO CHECK IT. We've gone over this a billion times.

Stars only matter if you want to get to Ohio State's level (or Clemson, Florida State, Alabama, etc).

To get to Wisconsin, Nebraska, Iowa, Michigan State's level, you don't need stars. What you need are players that fit the systems.

Do you really think if we recruited based on stars, we wouldn't have a higher stars ranking? We could if we wanted to. We could have gotten Clement instead of Pacheco. Leary instead of Chatman. We could have gotten one of the MANY 3 star DE from Florida who wanted to come here instead of this no name no star kid from Sweden.

Besides, how much more evidence do you need that Ash can identify talent, stars be damned?

And again, I repeat, our two lowest rated classes, 2010 and 2005 produced the most RU contributors and NFL talent - this isn't opinion, it is FACT. So, stars don't even correlate to results on the field for Rutgers. So, why the hell are you so hung up on stars???

You people hung up on stars really have no clue. No clue at all. It is unbelievable how clueless some of you guys truly are.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,333
113
I think everyone understands that if Ash does not have a much better recruiting class next year it is possible he will never see the fruits of any good classes beyond that point. While more kids play as freshman, there are growing pains and likely more lumps. He needs to get kids in here now and take those lumps so that in years 4 and 5 the record is .500 or better. Couldn't agree more about his inability to create any buzz or juice with the program. And you wonder why season ticket sales continue to decline? As much as we criticized DM and ZK as coaches I think last years class was the strongest thus far and they were some of the best recruiters under Ash.
And maybe (hopefully) that will change with the addition or Campanile.
DM was a good recruiter, but the better recruiting may have been more due to the first year or two buzz that some say did not exist.
 

bitnez

All-American
Jan 18, 2006
6,791
7,834
113
You people hung up on stars really have no clue. No clue at all. It is unbelievable how clueless some of you guys truly are.

This sounds great except for the fact that we’re a league doormat and finishing with lower star classes than our competitors. Sure, it can improve but it hasn’t yet.
 

kcg88

Heisman
Aug 11, 2017
10,862
17,230
0
Oh for goodness freaking sake. Take out Ohio State and I can guarantee you recruiting rankings DO NOT CORRELATE to the B1G Standings. THEY DO NOT. GO CHECK IT. We've gone over this a billion times.

Stars only matter if you want to get to Ohio State's level (or Clemson, Florida State, Alabama, etc).

To get to Wisconsin, Nebraska, Iowa, Michigan State's level, you don't need stars. What you need are players that fit the systems.

Do you really think if we recruited based on stars, we wouldn't have a higher stars ranking? We could if we wanted to. We could have gotten Clement instead of Pacheco. Leary instead of Chatman. We could have gotten one of the MANY 3 star DE from Florida who wanted to come here instead of this no name no star kid from Sweden.

Besides, how much more evidence do you need that Ash can identify talent, stars be damned?

And again, I repeat, our two lowest rated classes, 2010 and 2005 produced the most RU contributors and NFL talent - this isn't opinion, it is FACT. So, stars don't even correlate to results on the field for Rutgers. So, why the hell are you so hung up on stars???

You people hung up on stars really have no clue. No clue at all. It is unbelievable how clueless some of you guys truly are.

This is completely inaccurate. Nobody thinks the rankings are perfect. But perfection isn't the standard we should be using.

If you get higher-rated recruits, you're much more likely to win. End of story.

https://www.footballstudyhall.com/2...-matters-why-the-sites-get-the-rankings-right

https://www.foxsports.com/college-f...-gary-derrick-brown-demetris-robertson-020116

https://www.sbnation.com/college-fo...6/national-signing-day-rankings-ncaa-football
 

RU2055

All-Conference
Sep 9, 2009
3,582
1,693
0
This is completely inaccurate. Nobody thinks the rankings are perfect. But perfection isn't the standard we should be using.

If you get higher-rated recruits, you're much more likely to win. End of story.

https://www.footballstudyhall.com/2...-matters-why-the-sites-get-the-rankings-right

https://www.foxsports.com/college-f...-gary-derrick-brown-demetris-robertson-020116

https://www.sbnation.com/college-fo...6/national-signing-day-rankings-ncaa-football


Totally missed the point, but not surprising.
 

madchuck

Heisman
Oct 22, 2016
21,856
46,631
62
Oh for goodness freaking sake. Take out Ohio State and I can guarantee you recruiting rankings DO NOT CORRELATE to the B1G Standings. THEY DO NOT. GO CHECK IT. We've gone over this a billion times.

Stars only matter if you want to get to Ohio State's level (or Clemson, Florida State, Alabama, etc).

To get to Wisconsin, Nebraska, Iowa, Michigan State's level, you don't need stars. What you need are players that fit the systems.

Do you really think if we recruited based on stars, we wouldn't have a higher stars ranking? We could if we wanted to. We could have gotten Clement instead of Pacheco. Leary instead of Chatman. We could have gotten one of the MANY 3 star DE from Florida who wanted to come here instead of this no name no star kid from Sweden.

Besides, how much more evidence do you need that Ash can identify talent, stars be damned?

And again, I repeat, our two lowest rated classes, 2010 and 2005 produced the most RU contributors and NFL talent - this isn't opinion, it is FACT. So, stars don't even correlate to results on the field for Rutgers. So, why the hell are you so hung up on stars???

You people hung up on stars really have no clue. No clue at all. It is unbelievable how clueless some of you guys truly are.

You’re delusional.
 

superfan01

All-American
May 29, 2003
8,837
8,086
78
@RU2055

See your point but it’s hard to run a good system when your lines are getting blown up from the snap because there too slow or small.

We can’t have recruiting classes at the bottom of the big ten and expect to compete. Whether you look at stars or other P5 offers we rank near the bottom on every recruiting site.

I’m disappointed in Ash. He struck out big time in NJ. Clearly the Nunzio hire was too correct and fix this disaster.

For whatever reasons Ash isn’t connecting with NJ kids. He has created no buzz in this state.
 

kcg88

Heisman
Aug 11, 2017
10,862
17,230
0
Here's how recruiting looked for the 2014-2017 classes. I just averaged every school's ranking, so Ohio State being ranked 3rd, 7th, 4th, and 2nd averages out to #4, tops in the Big Ten:

1. Ohio State
2. Michigan
3. Penn State
4. Michigan State
5. Nebraska
6. Wisconsin
7. Maryland
8. Northwestern
9. Iowa
10. Indiana
11. Rutgers
12. Minnesota
13. Illinois
14. Purdue

And here's the Big Ten ranked by S&P+ for the 2017 season, the most objective rating system I'm aware of:

1. Ohio State (no difference)
2. Penn State (+1)
3. Wisconsin (+3)
4. Michigan State (no difference)
5. Michigan (-3)
6. Purdue (+8)
7. Northwestern (+1)
8. Iowa (+1)
9. Indiana (+1)
10. Minnesota (+2)
11. Nebraska (-6)
12. Rutgers (-1)
13. Maryland (-6)
14. Illinois (-1)

That's not no correlation. It's a pretty decent positive correlation:


The big differences are easy to explain: Mike Riley is a terrible coach (Nebraska), Jeff Brohm is a really good coach (Purdue), and Maryland was playing their 4th string QB. Even with Michigan it's easy to see why they underperformed according to this (because they had a lot of guys go pro early after last season).

This is one conference in one year. If you increased the sample and did this for every year, in every conference, the noise would even out. Take that for data.
 
Last edited:

RU2055

All-Conference
Sep 9, 2009
3,582
1,693
0
@RU2055

See your point but it’s hard to run a good system when your lines are getting blown up from the snap because there too slow or small.

We can’t have recruiting classes at the bottom of the big ten and expect to compete. Whether you look at stars or other P5 offers we rank near the bottom on every recruiting site.

I’m disappointed in Ash. He struck out big time in NJ. Clearly the Nunzio hire was too correct and fix this disaster.

For whatever reasons Ash isn’t connecting with NJ kids. He has created no buzz in this state.

Nobody is disputing that recruiting NJ needs to improve. But it is not a "disaster" and it is not as bad as some here are making out to be. If you go down the list, people will be surprised at how many of those kids this staff truly wanted. Dorian Hardy went to ECU for goodness sake. You can't "lose" recruits you didn't want. I still remember all the angst with BC's NJ commits when in reality, we weren't really interested in many of those guys. I know, I know, hard to believe because of stars. But it's true, whether fans choose to believe it or not.

I will repeat, to get to the ultimate goal, which is to one day compete for the national championship, we most certainly need to be recruiting better. BUT if the first step is to 1) get to a bowl game and then 2) compete the same way schools like Wisky or Iowa does, the coaches ability to identify talent and develop talent is ultimately more important than some Rivals ranking. Whether people want to believe it or not, as far as I could tell, our trajectory is still going up. THAT has not changed. When it does, I will be the first to yell about it, I guarantee it. Just like I did with Flood.
 
  • Like
Reactions: superfan01

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,333
113
Here's how recruiting looked for the 2014-2017 classes. I just averaged every school's ranking, so Ohio State being ranked 3rd, 7th, 4th, and 2nd averages out to #4, tops in the Big Ten:

1. Ohio State
2. Michigan
3. Penn State
4. Michigan State
5. Nebraska
6. Wisconsin
7. Maryland
8. Northwestern
9. Iowa
10. Indiana
11. Rutgers
12. Minnesota
13. Illinois
14. Purdue

And here's the Big Ten ranked by S&P+, the most objective rating system I'm aware of:

1. Ohio State (no difference)
2. Penn State (+1)
3. Wisconsin (+3)
4. Michigan State (no difference)
5. Michigan (-3)
6. Purdue (+8)
7. Northwestern (+1)
8. Iowa (+1)
9. Indiana (+1)
10. Minnesota (+2)
11. Nebraska (-6)
12. Rutgers (-1)
13. Maryland (-6)
14. Illinois (-1)

That's not no correlation. It's a pretty decent positive correlation:


The big differences are easy to explain: Mike Riley is a terrible coach (Nebraska), Jeff Brohm is a really good coach (Purdue), and Maryland was playing their 4th string QB. Even with Michigan it's easy to see why they underperformed according to this (because they had a lot of guys go pro early after last season).

This is one conference in one year. If you increased the sample and did this for every year, in every conference, the noise would even out. Take that for data.
Very nice analysis.

So, Rutgers performed according to the recruiting ranking, despite not having a serviceable QB and a bunch of freshman WRs.
This is the year where Ash needs to show that his recruits, his development and his coaching is showing some positive results. The blaming the previous guy excuse is not going to "hunt" after this year. It's all on Ash and his assistants.
Either Ash is going to show at least incremental improvement on the field, which should lead to at least incremental recruiting improvements in the next 2 years, or he will likely not be hear more than 2 more years.
 

kcg88

Heisman
Aug 11, 2017
10,862
17,230
0
Very nice analysis.

So, Rutgers performed according to the recruiting ranking, despite not having a serviceable QB and a bunch of freshman WRs.
This is the year where Ash needs to show that his recruits, his development and his coaching is showing some positive results. The blaming the previous guy excuse is not going to "hunt" after this year. It's all on Ash and his assistants.
Either Ash is going to show at least incremental improvement on the field, which should lead to at least incremental recruiting improvements in the next 2 years, or he will likely not be hear more than 2 more years.

Yup. The biggest thing that Jeff Brohm had going for him last year was not just one but TWO decent quarterbacks on the roster. Obviously his scheme helped a ton too.

With Ash... yes, now is the time. The development of our skill guys (Lewis, Blackshear, Melton, the Hayeks, Wormley, etc) is going to be the key. If we don't see the development in 2018 from those guys then I'm not sure why we'd be optimistic about seeing it in 2019 from Chatman, Sitkowski, Pacheco, etc.
 

MV9000

All-Conference
Jan 6, 2016
2,951
4,064
46
Think we did okay. 6 max. Look at who were competing against. If we remain at the bottom of this grouping year after year it doesnt matter.
 

RU85inFla

Heisman
Aug 4, 2003
15,577
10,567
73
Very nice analysis.

So, Rutgers performed according to the recruiting ranking, despite not having a serviceable QB and a bunch of freshman WRs.
This is the year where Ash needs to show that his recruits, his development and his coaching is showing some positive results. The blaming the previous guy excuse is not going to "hunt" after this year. It's all on Ash and his assistants.
Either Ash is going to show at least incremental improvement on the field, which should lead to at least incremental recruiting improvements in the next 2 years, or he will likely not be hear more than 2 more years.
I think you missed the point of the analysis. The analysis shows that performance is tied directly recruiting ranking. What makes you think that Ash and his coaching ability is going to somehow outperform expectations. Since he was not able to make lemonade out of the lemons he was left with by Flood, why do you expect him to do it now? What has Ash shown that the other coaches have not that leads us to believe he can break the data trend?
 

RU2055

All-Conference
Sep 9, 2009
3,582
1,693
0
Here's how recruiting looked for the 2014-2017 classes. I just averaged every school's ranking, so Ohio State being ranked 3rd, 7th, 4th, and 2nd averages out to #4, tops in the Big Ten:

1. Ohio State
2. Michigan
3. Penn State
4. Michigan State
5. Nebraska
6. Wisconsin
7. Maryland
8. Northwestern
9. Iowa
10. Indiana
11. Rutgers
12. Minnesota
13. Illinois
14. Purdue

And here's the Big Ten ranked by S&P+ for the 2017 season, the most objective rating system I'm aware of:

1. Ohio State (no difference)
2. Penn State (+1)
3. Wisconsin (+3)
4. Michigan State (no difference)
5. Michigan (-3)
6. Purdue (+8)
7. Northwestern (+1)
8. Iowa (+1)
9. Indiana (+1)
10. Minnesota (+2)
11. Nebraska (-6)
12. Rutgers (-1)
13. Maryland (-6)
14. Illinois (-1)

That's not no correlation. It's a pretty decent positive correlation:


The big differences are easy to explain: Mike Riley is a terrible coach (Nebraska), Jeff Brohm is a really good coach (Purdue), and Maryland was playing their 4th string QB. Even with Michigan it's easy to see why they underperformed according to this (because they had a lot of guys go pro early after last season).

This is one conference in one year. If you increased the sample and did this for every year, in every conference, the noise would even out. Take that for data.

AP Rankings (rankings that are actually based on wins and losses):

Average B1G recruiting ranking from 3 previous years in Paren ( )


2017 (average recruiting ranking from 2016-2014)

1. OSU (1)

2. WIS (6)

3. PSU (3)

4. MSU (4)

5. NW (11)


2016 (average recruiting ranking from 2015-2013):

1. OSU (1)

2. PSU (4)

3. WIS (7)

4. MICH (5)

5. IOWA (10)


2015 (average recruiting ranking from 2014-2012):

1. OSU (1)

2. MSU (3)

3. IOWA (8)

4. MICH (2)

5. WISC (9)


2014 (average recruiting ranking from 2013-2011):

1. OSU (1)

2. MICH (2)

3. WIS (9)

4. NEB (3)

5. MINN (11)


Tell Minny, Wisky, Iowa and Northwestern that they are never supposed to compete in the B1G. They should fire their coaches every year for such poor recruiting rankings.
 
Last edited:

bitnez

All-American
Jan 18, 2006
6,791
7,834
113
As many as Flood did in his 4 years.
0 for 40 was Flood on the Top 10 NJ Recruits for 4 years.
This is why the Program is where it is now.

We know Flood was terrible. Is it supposed to make us feel better that going into year 3 Ash hasn’t done any better with these kids?
 
  • Like
Reactions: soundcrib

lilphilw

Senior
Nov 24, 2010
1,411
459
0
Ash definitely has to do better to be able to compete but the good news is last years recruiting class will be more of an impact this year. I think we'll see better results with a favorable schedule in 2018 and a couple more wins. Also we already have a top 10 NJ talent in Zamar Wise so hopefully that gives us a bit of an advantage this early. Gotta see an upset to get some excitement in NJ and give recruits a reason to come here
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Staff Predictions for Rutgers Football versus Penn State
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report How to watch Rutgers / Penn State; Pregame Info, Spread, More: Gameday Central
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod