Rate our recruiting class

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
24,481
13,091
113
The only one that matters is how we stack up against our competition: BIG East. On that basis this class rating is 1.
I don't see us getting better than our competition so how could rate this class any higher.
Nothing against the kids. They are going to work hard but we are not getting past Tier3 status with this recruiting class.

Bottom line Ash needs to recruit NJ much, much better. To be even mildly competitive in the B1G East, we need to get more than the occasional 1 of the Top 10 NJ Recruits. This Class is better than the disaster known as Flood but they need to be even better . Better than the best Big East classes under Schiano. Get classes that rank 20-30 consistently and we will be Bowling again.
 

Perricone7

All-Conference
Jan 26, 2015
1,509
2,137
113
I give it a 4/10. 0 of the top 10 in NJ is not cutting it. 5-6 recruits have solid offer sheets, but there’s not much else there. With that said, this is not flood level bad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUaMoose_rivals

yesrutgers01

Heisman
Nov 9, 2008
122,967
38,873
113
So hard to rate it based on ratings, sorry. Our best performing class ever rated 68 if the poster earlier on is correct.
But, in going with the OP, I give it a 6. It could end up a 7 if we get a DT and bring in that Sr transfer RB.
What I do like, the past 2 classes have football players and speed. We also filled needs we had not too long ago. If, one of the QBs develop into a 20+ TD and single digit Int type of guy for 2-3 years, it jumps to an 8.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Loyal-Son

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,986
8,959
113
This is like the yearly exercise in silliness that takes place after the NFL draft every year, where "experts" assign grades to teams before any of the players they've drafted have played a professional game. We aren't going to know anything about these players until they get on the field against B1G opposition. It would be nice if one of these QBs turns into a 25-30 TD guy, but that requires coaching, development, and adequate blocking, all of which have been in short supply here in the last 2 years.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

rufeelinit

All-Conference
May 16, 2010
12,647
4,351
0
A five would be about as generous as I can be at this point. Until Ash improves in NJ which should be a relative source of strength for recruiting or establishes firm base in a place like Florida, MD/VA, Ohio or PA, he is going to struggle to bring in talent comparative to our competition, which unfortunately is setting a very high bar. I don't expect us to out recruit Michigan, Ohio State or even Penn State at this point but we need to do better against the others in our division and conference.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rurichdog

seels2662

Heisman
Aug 16, 2005
25,018
18,028
113
Just an FYI, Illinois just got a 4 star player and now has a better class than us. There is a very likely scenario that we will have the worst rated recruiting class in the B1G.
 

RuBird

Heisman
Jun 28, 2001
19,471
25,435
113
Just an FYI, Illinois just got a 4 star player and now has a better class than us. There is a very likely scenario that we will have the worst rated recruiting class in the B1G.
How many years do we go through this. Wait until the final signing day. Even after that no one knows for sure which class “won” the recruiting game for at least 2 or 3 years.

Artur dropped from a 4 to 3 (rivals only) which brought down our ranking. Right now he is somewhere in between the best or worst QB recruit we have ever had. Point being no “expert” knows for sure. Must give it time.
 

rufeelinit

All-Conference
May 16, 2010
12,647
4,351
0
Just an FYI, Illinois just got a 4 star player and now has a better class than us. There is a very likely scenario that we will have the worst rated recruiting class in the B1G.

I only care about stars to the extent that they are highly correlated to an impressive commitable offer list. We have too many kids that we are relying on the coaching staff being smarter in their evaluations rather than winning recruiting battles against other P-5 and more importantly other B1G schools. We have should have a separate discussion that evaluates the recruiting prowess of our existing staff. None of them standout in any particular manner to me.
 

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
How many years do we go through this. Wait until the final signing day. Even after that no one knows for sure which class “won” the recruiting game for at least 2 or 3 years.

Artur dropped from a 4 to 3 (rivals only) which brought down our ranking. Right now he is somewhere in between the best or worst QB recruit we have ever had. Point being no “expert” knows for sure. Must give it time.

It's not about any specific individual player - it's a numbers game. Stars are definitely an inexact science.

A portion of 3* guys are going to go on to become rockstars, and a portion will wash out. Same for 5* players and walk-ons. However, a larger portion of 5* guys are going to succeed than will walk-ons... so, a team that consistently pulls in Top 20 classes will have a much higher "hit rate" across their 85 scholarships than a team that consistently pulls in classes ranked in the low 40s.

The more players you sign that are highly-regarded out of HS, the more likely you are to get a core group of rockstars. It's possible that a class of 2-3* players will end up with more productive/successful college careers than a class of 4-5* players.... but I wouldn't put money on it. As Hugh Keough said: “The race is not always to the swift, nor the battle to the strong; but that is the way to bet.”
 

SoCalNYC

Junior
Jan 20, 2018
320
204
0
The recruiting classes are finalized now.

The B1G has ramped up. Schools like Nebraska have done well with new coaches.

Tough league
 

RU2055

All-Conference
Sep 9, 2009
3,582
1,693
0
Not to hijack, but can I ask you guys something, what do you base your ratings on? Rivals? Offers?

While you dwell on that, just remember that our 2 lowest "rated" classes, 2005 and 2010 from the Greg Schiano years produced the most contributors and NFL talent.
 

JCKnight

Senior
Aug 27, 2017
938
489
0
Not to hijack, but can I ask you guys something, what do you base your ratings on? Rivals? Offers?

While you dwell on that, just remember that our 2 lowest "rated" classes, 2005 and 2010 from the Greg Schiano years produced the most contributors and NFL talent.
Everyone rates the class in their own way which is the beauty of the discussion...I choose to rate it against the teams we are in direct competition with annually which is primarily the teams in the B1G East...by that measure I think this class overall is a 3 out of 10...I don't see any true impact players like last year with Micah and Melton were thought to be...I also fear that our OLine and DLine recruiting have really fallen off the last few classes with the exception of Micah and we have many projects that are hoping become starters, I just don't see any guys that will play in the next year or two on either line in this class...we also don't have a true LB unless Lacewell moves to defense and he isn't a true LB...the positives are we needed two QBs and got some real potential with Artur and Jalen and I think Pacheco could be a nice offensive weapon, but all goes for naught if we don't have a an at least average Oline...
IMO 2019 is Ash's year to bring in some impact players that he has developed relationships with the since they were high school freshsman...this (2019) is a strong year for NJ high school seniors and we need to get some of the better guys like Alfano, we must close the gap to some degree with the other teams in our division
 
  • Like
Reactions: superfan01

78CollegeAve

All-Conference
Jul 1, 2001
6,651
2,155
113
RU is a B1G East program with a $2 mill head coach. Flood or no Flood, the class is a 4. Making no dent in the talent deficit against half of the annual schedule.

Now, if McNulty, Brown and Camp are all 9 or 10 for player develoment, all is well going into the hump year on a 5-year rebuild.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

RuBird

Heisman
Jun 28, 2001
19,471
25,435
113
Until these players at least have their senior prom there is no reason to rate the class. They are Scarlet men who Ash bELieves in. Good enough for me
 

Perricone7

All-Conference
Jan 26, 2015
1,509
2,137
113
59th ranked class based on rivals score and average stars. That's brutal.

With that said, show me a 2018 offense with a pulse and a top 40 2019 class and I will be happy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUDead

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,216
17,017
113
I won't rate the players, they are Scarlet Knights and deserve out support and benefit of doubt talent wise.

But I'll rate the RU HC and his staff as under-performing when it comes to recruiting the top HS talent that the so called recruiting experts claim as 4/5 star.
Wins have a lot to do with the programs 4/5 star recruits commit to and last year's 4-8 RU FB team doesn't look good in that category, but it was better than the 2-10 record they had the year before.

Ash deserved a mulligan for his first year's record.
Grading him on a curve for RU's 4-8 record in 2017 might be appropriate.
So all in all, I rate Ash and his staff with a 5 out of a possible 10 rating as recruiters.
Based on the recruits Ash and staff brought in (class of 2018) despite going 6-18 since Ash took control of the Football program
 

FELONIOUSMONK

All-American
Apr 1, 2012
11,909
5,090
0
It doesn't matter .If we don't have a QB who can throw wr's who can run a route and a D line that can rsh the passer then all these 3's and a few 4"s will face the same 3 or 4 years of frustration that our previous classes have. It is what it is.
 

kapyoche

All-Conference
Sep 11, 2010
5,151
1,509
0
2 since it will get us the two wins in the BIG.

We are losing ground every year. OSU will have the #1 class and we will be lucky to break the top 75.
We are in the wrong conference.
 

masice520

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2015
2,293
3,670
113
5. Not good enough, but there’s a little progress there. Extremely concerned with the front 7 moving forward.
 

sct1111

All-American
Nov 30, 2014
6,171
8,516
113
Not impressed with Ash's recruiting. This class is Flood-like. Last year's class was a good class. I scratch my head when Maryland puts together top 25 classes and we land outside the top 50. What is going on? Why don't kids want to come here?
 

RCBeta79

All-Conference
Jun 7, 2013
1,058
1,046
0
The most important rating for me is:

Did we fill the player gaps on offense and defense that will help us get to 6 wins or more in the 2018 season.
 

rufeelinit

All-Conference
May 16, 2010
12,647
4,351
0
Not good enough at all. My prior grade of 5 was very generous. Not sure how anyone can realistically be expecting much better results this fall unless last years freshman class really comes on strong. Let’s hope Ash recent additions to the staff are an acknowledgment that he needs to step it up immediately.
 
  • Like
Reactions: superfan01

sct1111

All-American
Nov 30, 2014
6,171
8,516
113
I looked back at Schianos recruiting classes and they were mostly middle of the pack Big Ten. The 2012 class woukd have been 3rd. We've fallen so much with Flood and now Ash. It's very concerning.
 
  • Like
Reactions: superfan01

RUwoz

All-Conference
Jul 20, 2014
3,266
1,982
0
Until these players at least have their senior prom there is no reason to rate the class. They are Scarlet men who Ash bELieves in. Good enough for me
Yeah but proven coaches in our division don’t believe in them (see offer sheets) and I’ll defer to them over Ash
 

CrazyfoRU

Sophomore
Feb 23, 2017
326
186
0
I am am pretty happy with the top 10 or so recruits in the class and having 2 QBs that we can be excited to see this spring/summer. But it falls off after that. We also got hurt because I don't think we get any points from the rating services for Dixon and Hilliman since they were transfers even though RU includes them as part of the 2018 class.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,333
113
59th ranked class based on rivals score and average stars. That's brutal.

With that said, show me a 2018 offense with a pulse and a top 40 2019 class and I will be happy.
It's 57, not 59.
Don't get hung up on rank. There is an infinitesimal difference in quality below about 30-35.

Teams are are above:
Northwestern (59)
Syracuse! (62) (future opponent)
BC! (66) (future opponent)--noting a trend that northeastern teams are low-ranked
Stanford (70)
Arkansas (79)

Teams we are in the same neighborhood with:
Illinois (50) have to hand it to Lovie. . .
Purdue (49)
Indiana (44)
Row The Gopher (42)
Wisconsin (39) - 1 four star-- they do more with less, maybe we will too. Do you think they are bitching that they are ranked below some teams?
Iowa (39)
Not impressed with Ash's recruiting. This class is Flood-like. Last year's class was a good class. I scratch my head when Maryland puts together top 25 classes and we land outside the top 50. What is going on? Why don't kids want to come here?

Cry harder. Maryland is 29 pal.
 

huskersalways

All-Conference
Dec 21, 2001
72,848
4,276
78
It's 57, not 59.
Don't get hung up on rank. There is an infinitesimal difference in quality below about 30-35.

Teams are are above:
Northwestern (59)
Syracuse! (62) (future opponent)
BC! (66) (future opponent)--noting a trend that northeastern teams are low-ranked
Stanford (70)
Arkansas (79)

Teams we are in the same neighborhood with:
Illinois (50) have to hand it to Lovie. . .
Purdue (49)
Indiana (44)
Row The Gopher (42)
Wisconsin (39) - 1 four star-- they do more with less, maybe we will too. Do you think they are bitching that they are ranked below some teams?
Iowa (39)


Cry harder. Maryland is 29 pal.

Stanford has 14 recruits, Northwestern has 18, and Arky has 16 so their ranking is a little off. If they had the 20 players to be considered a full class then they would be ahead of RU. That's definitely something that can make the rankings screwy with them using 20 as "full class".
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,333
113
Stanford has 14 recruits, Northwestern has 18, and Arky has 16 so their ranking is a little off. If they had the 20 players to be considered a full class then they would be ahead of RU. That's definitely something that can make the rankings screwy with them using 20 as "full class".
Hey look, a Nebraska fan sounding like a Rutgers fan.
Hey man, I was rolling . . . [roll]
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,333
113
Haha, I do agree with the rest of what you said. [thumb2]
We can only hope the Wisconsin and/or Northwestern approach works for us. Otherwise, we are doomed to eternal failure against the top 4 teams in our division.

Who is in the lead to be the starting Huskers QB?
Will Tanner Lee get on an NFL roster?
 

huskersalways

All-Conference
Dec 21, 2001
72,848
4,276
78
We can only hope the Wisconsin and/or Northwestern approach works for us. Otherwise, we are doomed to eternal failure against the top 4 teams in our division.

Who is in the lead to be the starting Huskers QB?
Will Tanner Lee get on an NFL roster?

Somebody on the NU board went through Wisconsin's roster over the last 5 years or so. They have more higher rated kids than you would think. Nothing like the OSU's of the world but enough. Northwestern has seemed to slowly get more guys that others are after as well in the last 3-4 years. Both Wisconsin and Northwestern admission standards hurt them a little, especially Northwestern.

I think it is going to be a wide open deal for QB. O'Brien has a little experience and a cannon but is the least mobile although he looks like Michael Vick compared to Lee.
Gebbia is more athletic and has a very good arm but is pretty skinny. At least he was the last time I saw any pictures but that was when he signed last year. He redshirted. He fits Frost's system better than O'Brien but isn't a true dual threat like Frost wants.
Martinez is the QB Frost signed. He is a dual threat guy but will be a true freshmen and is coming off shoulder surgery.
All 3 were 4*s not that that means a lot. Ha

Frost did say today that he expects his QB to be the toughest guy on the team. Be ready to hit and be hit. He joked then that he ran out of bounds once when playing for NU and Osborne made him run all the stadium stairs for doing that.

As for Lee. If a team needs a QB to help their DB's practice returning interceptions he will be a first round pick....
He will probably make a roster because he is the prototypical size the NFL likes and he does have a live arm. He just struggles with seperating the color of his teams jersey from the other teams.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Staff Predictions for Rutgers Football versus Penn State
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report How to watch Rutgers / Penn State; Pregame Info, Spread, More: Gameday Central
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod