Praise from Rantoul for Fitz

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
28,591
3,740
113

NUChicago

Junior
Aug 23, 2001
3,811
392
83
More garbage. Can we ever get a read from those parts where winning at NU is not a “minor miracle” or that NU fans basically suck. Look in the mirror, pal.
I know Illinois people who feel they are on par with Michigan.....seriously. Keep beating them like a drum, they can't fathom our success.
 

Hungry Jack

All-American
Nov 17, 2008
39,065
6,238
67
More garbage. Can we ever get a read from those parts where winning at NU is not a “minor miracle” or that NU fans basically suck. Look in the mirror, pal.
Well, he did call Fitzgerald the most underrated coach in the B1G. Perceptions of NU from the Dark Ages persist like a cold sore, but they are changing.
 

phatcat_rivals223240

All-Conference
Nov 5, 2001
19,041
1,172
113
They have a LOT in common with Michigan. Give them credit where credit is due.

  1. Annoying fans
  2. Can't beat dOSU
  3. Can't win the division
  4. Lose the last game of the year
  5. Most of their program success was when people wore leather helmets or no helmets
 

Gocatsgo2003

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2006
47,283
3,685
78
More garbage. Can we ever get a read from those parts where winning at NU is not a “minor miracle” or that NU fans basically suck. Look in the mirror, pal.

Because it's really ******* hard to win at Northwestern. Pat Fitzgerald is just much better at the job than pretty much anyone else before him.
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
28,591
3,740
113
Well, he did call Fitzgerald the most underrated coach in the B1G. Perceptions of NU from the Dark Ages persist like a cold sore, but they are changing.
Changing? Pretty much always get the back handed compliments like this one. I don’t think that will change until we consistently get to the Big Ten championship game and win a few and we actually beat Michigan and OSU instead of playing them close.

Look at the pre-season polls for next year. Most have Nebby and Iowa ranked ahead of us. Why? It’s perception. Whether us NU fans like it or not, every fan base in the West think they can and should beat NU next year. Do they have the same opinion about Michigan?
 

Gocatsgo2003

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2006
47,283
3,685
78
Changing? Pretty much always get the back handed compliments like this one. I don’t think that will change until we consistently get to the Big Ten championship game and win a few and we actually beat Michigan and OSU instead of playing them close.

Look at the pre-season polls for next year. Most have Nebby and Iowa ranked ahead of us. Why? It’s perception. Whether us NU fans like it or not, every fan base in the West think they can and should beat NU next year. Do they have the same opinion about Michigan?

Preseason polls mean exactly nothing.
 

EvanstonCat

Senior
May 29, 2001
50,793
787
73

Hungry Jack

All-American
Nov 17, 2008
39,065
6,238
67
Changing? Pretty much always get the back handed compliments like this one. I don’t think that will change until we consistently get to the Big Ten championship game and win a few and we actually beat Michigan and OSU instead of playing them close.

Look at the pre-season polls for next year. Most have Nebby and Iowa ranked ahead of us. Why? It’s perception. Whether us NU fans like it or not, every fan base in the West think they can and should beat NU next year. Do they have the same opinion about Michigan?
Agreed. At this point, the only thing missing from the resume is winning the "big" game. The obvious one is winning the B1G, but even beating OSU or Michigan (regularly) would go a ways toward changing this view.

Re polling, the perception is that those programs have more "talent" than NU and thus should be ranked higher. I don't necessarily disagree, but execution matters more, and this where our staff and players excel. The lack of mistakes (penalties, fumbles) by our teams is remarkable. Generally, this is how we win---via attrition. It is a very good formula for a team that generally lacks elite playmakers at "skill" positions.
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
28,591
3,740
113
Preseason polls mean exactly nothing.
I think you are a born contrarian.

The response was regarding whether the perception of NU football is changing. Is there still a stigma around the dark ages?

Preseason polls at least partially are driven by perception of the program. I am sure Nebby uses their top 20 preseason rating to reinforce to prospective recruits that Frost is a savior and we won’t suck like we did last year. The narrative around NU is twisted to be “they are a fluke, a one year wonder”, they will be passed up, look at the projections for 2019 Mr. Hot shot football recruit. Poo poo them all you want, but being ranked in the pre-season is good publicity.
 

seavue617

Sophomore
May 21, 2014
994
112
41
If you look at it realistically, every fan base in the Big 10 thinks they will beat "NWU" every year. Well, maybe not Rutgers. Wait, are they still in the Big 10?
 

Fiadhaich

Redshirt
Mar 26, 2006
5,566
28
0
Yes, exactly my point on perception.

A different perspective. Winning at NU is hard. Difficult. There are many challenges that most all other schools don’t face. IMO, Fitz is underrated, and not just by general public and news media. By posters on this board, too.
 

Gocatsgo2003

All-Conference
Mar 30, 2006
47,283
3,685
78
I think you are a born contrarian.

The response was regarding whether the perception of NU football is changing. Is there still a stigma around the dark ages?

Preseason polls at least partially are driven by perception of the program. I am sure Nebby uses their top 20 preseason rating to reinforce to prospective recruits that Frost is a savior and we won’t suck like we did last year. The narrative around NU is twisted to be “they are a fluke, a one year wonder”, they will be passed up, look at the projections for 2019 Mr. Hot shot football recruit. Poo poo them all you want, but being ranked in the pre-season is good publicity.

It’s really not a big deal from a recruiting perspective. At all.
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
28,591
3,740
113
A
A different perspective. Winning at NU is hard. Difficult. There are many challenges that most all other schools don’t face. IMO, Fitz is underrated, and not just by general public and news media. By posters on this board, too.
Agree with this. I take umbrage with the constant use of terms such as minor miracle etc. Fitz has had such success and winning is no longer a miracle. This is through his hard work and many others. I just find it insulting to not recognize the changes made throughout the entire athletic department during the last two decades.
 

Deeringfish

All-Conference
Jun 23, 2008
21,542
1,578
63
I think you are a born contrarian.

The response was regarding whether the perception of NU football is changing. Is there still a stigma around the dark ages?

Preseason polls at least partially are driven by perception of the program. I am sure Nebby uses their top 20 preseason rating to reinforce to prospective recruits that Frost is a savior and we won’t suck like we did last year. The narrative around NU is twisted to be “they are a fluke, a one year wonder”, they will be passed up, look at the projections for 2019 Mr. Hot shot football recruit. Poo poo them all you want, but being ranked in the pre-season is good publicity.

I think the preseason polls are driven more by Money than perception. Sports writers and coaches who are paying attention know that NU has moved to the cusp of the top third of the B1G. Telling the world that doesn't tickle enough eyeballs or sell enough sweatshirts because the fan base is small.
 

NU Houston

Senior
Apr 12, 2010
6,456
406
83
Well, he did call Fitzgerald the most underrated coach in the B1G. Perceptions of NU from the Dark Ages persist like a cold sore, but they are changing.
The Dark Ages ended nearly 25 years ago. Most people under the age of 40 have no recollection of that terrible time. At some point, we can't keep using it to explain the lack of respect for NU football.

I'm elated that NU went 8-1 in conference play last year and won the West. I don't care what fans of other programs think.
 

DaCat

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
25,805
2,246
113
The Dark Ages ended nearly 25 years ago. Most people under the age of 40 have no recollection of that terrible time. At some point, we can't keep using it to explain the lack of respect for NU football.

I'm elated that NU went 8-1 in conference play last year and won the West. I don't care what fans of other programs think.

Absolutely right! We are already in the top 4 of the B1G over the past several seasons, and have played #3 Wisconsin pretty even in the decade.
 

GOUNUII

Junior
Jan 4, 2004
6,418
238
63
It's really ****ing hard to put forth this level of success at NU.

Hard? Yes. But now easier than ever before. With Fitz going forward I would argue that there are only 5 teams in the BIG where it’s easier to win a lot. OSU, Michigan, PSU, Wisconsin and Nebraska. And the latter 2 don’t have insurmountable leads over NU. Talk in terms of playing for a BIG championship and the number shrinks to 2 or 3.

GOUNUII
 

phatcat_rivals223240

All-Conference
Nov 5, 2001
19,041
1,172
113
The Dark Ages ended nearly 25 years ago. Most people under the age of 40 have no recollection of that terrible time. At some point, we can't keep using it to explain the lack of respect for NU football.

I'm elated that NU went 8-1 in conference play last year and won the West. I don't care what fans of other programs think.
There is still some of it, a lot of it, by media that kids largely ignore.

Adding to it is being like +1 all year in point differential. Easy to say we got lucky, like when we had 3 straight OT wins

Plus, teams that are "defense first" unless they suffocate opponents, just dont get a lot of notice.

Finally, no superstars, no flash, just do your job. Not sexy.

Just win, baby
 

EvanstonCat

Senior
May 29, 2001
50,793
787
73
I guess you think it is a minor miracle.

When the Conquistadors landed, the natives thought their firearms and steel swords were minor miracles. It's all a matter of perspective.

Those of us who remember winning 3 B1G titles in 6 years don't think it's as impossible as others who weren't around in those days. And those who insist on speaking from an experience which was during a period of a relative lack of success compared to the time when we were winning the B1G, perhaps should consider that their views aren't really worth much when it comes to talking about what is required to get to a level where you are winning championships. How would they know? They do have perhaps a good perspective on what's not good enough and maybe even what not to do. And on evaluating how hard it is, is it a surprise that someone who has never been a part of achieving a B1G title would think it's so hard? My kids thought riding a bike was impossible, until they did it.
 

Catreporter

Senior
Sep 4, 2007
5,016
527
113
Are we really arguing that it's not harder to win at Northwestern (in either football or basketball) than other schools in the Big Ten? Seriously?
 

SciCat_rivals

Sophomore
Mar 7, 2005
1,848
185
0
When the Conquistadors landed, the natives thought their firearms and steel swords were minor miracles. It's all a matter of perspective.

Those of us who remember winning 3 B1G titles in 6 years don't think it's as impossible as others who weren't around in those days. And those who insist on speaking from an experience which was during a period of a relative lack of success compared to the time when we were winning the B1G, perhaps should consider that their views aren't really worth much when it comes to talking about what is required to get to a level where you are winning championships. How would they know? They do have perhaps a good perspective on what's not good enough and maybe even what not to do. And on evaluating how hard it is, is it a surprise that someone who has never been a part of achieving a B1G title would think it's so hard? My kids thought riding a bike was impossible, until they did it.

Last time I checked, hard, harder, and impossible all had different meanings. Anyone who argues that it is not harder to win at NU than at other schools is smoking tainted weed.
 
Wildcat Report

Latest

  1. 01 Wildcat Report Ten Questions: 9. Will a better offense translate to more wins for the Cats?
  2. 02 Wildcat Report Notebook: Chiles formally named QB1, OL still in flux, team names six captains
  3. 03 On3 Big Ten to pass rule that prohibits players to return to college football from NFL
  4. 04 Rivals 4-star SG Jeremiah Profit down to 6 schools
  5. 05 Wildcat Report Ten Questions: 8. Will the Cats take better care of the football?