OT: Pedestrian bridge collapses at FIU.

DJ Spanky

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
51,277
63,377
113
FIU touted the bridge to be a first of its kind, tweeting that it swung into place on Saturday.

According to an FIU press release, the 174-foot, 950-ton bridge was just installed "in a few hours" using "accelerated bridge construction" methods, which the university said "reduces potential risks to workers, commuters, and pedestrians and minimizes traffic interruptions."

Accelerated bridge construction techniques = cutting corners
 
  • Like
Reactions: cicero grimes
Sep 27, 2006
20,274
23,340
0
Bridge was just dedicated on Saturday. Not open yet for pedestrian traffic. Fatalities & injuries are construction workers & multiple cars trapped under the bridge.
 

DJ Spanky

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
51,277
63,377
113
Multiple deaths, 8 people in the hospital so far. Still trying to get people out.

Bridge was supposed to open in early 2019.
 
Sep 27, 2006
20,274
23,340
0
Per a TV news report & the Miami News Times:

"2 of the biggest firms that built the FIU bridge that collapsed today have recently been accused of unsafe practicea. In one of those cases another bridge collapsed & fell onto workers."

The bridge was made elsewhere & transported to FIU. Dedication was last weekend & grand opening scheduled for this upcoming weekend. They have been doing stress tests all week including today. It was the stress test that caused the collapse
 
Last edited:

Ataylor1989x

All-Conference
Dec 11, 2015
2,209
2,355
0
The bridge was made elsewhere & transported to FIU. Dedication was last weekend & grand opening scheduled for this upcoming weekend. They have been doing stress tests all week including today. It was the stress test that caused the collapse

Of course, bridges need stress tests, but doing them when the road underneath is being driven on? Is this really about not wanting to pay people overtime to work late night?
 

RutHut_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2017
4,483
4,903
0
Of course, bridges need stress tests, but doing them when the road underneath is being driven on? Is this really about not wanting to pay people overtime to work late night?
I find it strange that stress tests would be needed for a new prefab structure, particularly without the side spans in. The design is rather unusual with a center truss and a top (I assume) ornamental piece. The bottom slab which would support peds is rather slender. Railings were not yet installed. It might have been a construction load that was not anticipated in design which caused the failure. Just speculating and feel for all involved. FIU is considered a leader in ABC techniques and has government work to educate on the various methods.
 

RUSK97

All-American
Dec 28, 2007
10,460
6,551
0
I find it strange that stress tests would be needed for a new prefab structure, particularly without the side spans in. The design is rather unusual with a center truss and a top (I assume) ornamental piece. The bottom slab which would support peds is rather slender. Railings were not yet installed. It might have been a construction load that was not anticipated in design which caused the failure. Just speculating and feel for all involved. FIU is considered a leader in ABC techniques and has government work to educate on the various methods.
Prefabbed in China of recycled cardboard seems like.
 

ashokan

Heisman
May 3, 2011
25,325
19,690
0
From what I've picked up, the bridge was several months short of completion. According to artist renderings, the bridge was getting towers and would be cable stayed. Maybe folks thought it could be built without more preliminary support, or maybe bad materials? I recall when Boston "Big Dig" tunnel roofs collapses because epoxies were used wrong



 

RutHut_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2017
4,483
4,903
0
From what I've picked up, the bridge was several months short of completion. According to artist renderings, the bridge was getting towers and would be cable stayed. Maybe folks thought it could be built without more preliminary support, or maybe bad materials? I recall when Boston "Big Dig" tunnel roofs collapses because epoxies were used wrong



Thanks. The design makes more sense now and more typical.
 

krup

Heisman
Feb 5, 2003
70,133
10,066
0
Per a TV news report & the Miami News Times:

"2 of the biggest firms that built the FIU bridge that collapsed today have recently been accused of unsafe practicea. In one of those cases another bridge collapsed & fell onto workers."

The bridge was made elsewhere & transported to FIU. Dedication was last weekend & grand opening scheduled for this upcoming weekend. They have been doing stress tests all week including today. It was the stress test that caused the collapse
I happened to watch another show on Chernobyl last week and that story was similar in that they were performing tests on the reactor at the same time certain safety features were disabled.

What possesses people to perform tests designed to check if a system will break down, without any thought seemingly given to the consequences if it does break down? Stress tests while cars are stopping under the bridge at the intersection????
 
  • Like
Reactions: cicero grimes

RutHut_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2017
4,483
4,903
0
From some of the photos, there seems to be evidence that the top of the center of the span crushed under its own weight or weight plus construction load. Concrete is strong in compression but that top member looked small to support a span of that length, particularly with voids for lighting, which can be seen in the installation video.
 

krup

Heisman
Feb 5, 2003
70,133
10,066
0
From some of the photos, there seems to be evidence that the top of the center of the span crushed under its own weight or weight plus construction load. Concrete is strong in compression but that top member looked small to support a span of that length, particularly with voids for lighting, which can be seen in the installation video.
Unfortunately, the press release from Saturday seemed to take particular pride in that construction of this type of bridge was going to "minimize disruption to traffic".

It is hindsight now, but it seems obvious that when you are building a bridge over a road with the amount of volume this road has losing a lane each way so you can have extra temporary supports until construction is complete might be the way to go.
 

RutHut_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2017
4,483
4,903
0
For all construction of this magnitude , calculations are required that the partial construction could stand on it's own. Also the concrete would be tested to verify strength. Factors of safety are required (although smaller factors for temporary conditions). Somewhere there was either a major screwup or loads were added to the bridge that were not intended to be added.. Either the calcs were blown or something was changed at a latter date and not rechecked.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cicero grimes

Armor and Sword

All-Conference
Oct 18, 2007
4,505
1,320
0
Not a fan of pedestrian bridges given that they take more time and effort for the pedestrian to use it than to use the at-grade signalized crosswalk to cross the street.Also factor in the time and effort to go upstairs/ramp then downstairs/ramp on the other end. Or wait for the elevators. Pedestrian are like water, they follow the path of least resistance (and the straightest line possible from Point A to Point B).

Unless that bridge was connecting the parking deck on one side (it doesn't appear to) and a building on another (there's the bridge tower and a canal behind it and homes behind it, so no), chances are that peds would choose to use the crosswalk rather than the bridge. Either FIU, Miami-Dade or FDOT (or all three) were thinking more about accommodating vehicular traffic through the intersection by eliminating the conflict with the pedestrians. SW 8th St, where the bridge crosses, is 6 lanes.

I visited FIU once and may have been where that deck is in the picture.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SteveVA2

krup

Heisman
Feb 5, 2003
70,133
10,066
0
For all construction of this magnitude , calculations are required that the partial construction could stand on it's own. Also the concrete would be tested to verify strength. Factors of safety are required (although smaller factors for temporary conditions). Somewhere there was either a major screwup or loads were added to the bridge that were not intended to be added.. Either the calcs were blown or something was changed at a latter date and not rechecked.
I have read a little more since I posted and while some people said there were stress tests going on, evidently some witnesses say a crane broke a cable and dropped something on the bridge then it collapsed.

That could mean there were unintentional “added loads” like you mentioned.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RutHut_rivals

JonathanAlan

Heisman
Jan 14, 2002
6,705
10,816
113
Per a TV news report & the Miami News Times:

"2 of the biggest firms that built the FIU bridge that collapsed today have recently been accused of unsafe practicea. In one of those cases another bridge collapsed & fell onto workers."

The bridge was made elsewhere & transported to FIU. Dedication was last weekend & grand opening scheduled for this upcoming weekend. They have been doing stress tests all week including today. It was the stress test that caused the collapse
Why would they be doing a stress test while cars are traveling underneath?
 
  • Like
Reactions: cicero grimes

RUseaweed

Senior
Dec 8, 2007
3,518
490
83
Not a fan of pedestrian bridges given that they take more time and effort for the pedestrian to use it than to use the at-grade signalized crosswalk to cross the street.Also factor in the time and effort to go upstairs/ramp then downstairs/ramp on the other end. Or wait for the elevators. Pedestrian are like water, they follow the path of least resistance (and the straightest line possible from Point A to Point B).
A student was killed a year ago crossing that busy road, which is why they invested in this bridge. Look to Vegas for a great example of how much safer traversing The Strip is on foot now vice when all foot traffic was at grade. Traffic flows more smoothly and pedestrians are away from vehicular traffic for nearly a mile. Sure pedestrians will generally prefer the path of least resistance, so you make the other paths untenable. In Vegas they do that through fencing that prevents people from walking across traffic.
 

RutHut_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2017
4,483
4,903
0
A student was killed a year ago crossing that busy road, which is why they invested in this bridge. Look to Vegas for a great example of how much safer traversing The Strip is on foot now vice when all foot traffic was at grade. Traffic flows more smoothly and pedestrians are away from vehicular traffic for nearly a mile. Sure pedestrians will generally prefer the path of least resistance, so you make the other paths untenable. In Vegas they do that through fencing that prevents people from walking across traffic.
True. Accusations that the bridge was being put in to improve traffic are ridiculous.

Wonder how they were going to install the second span over the waterway?
 

DJ Spanky

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
51,277
63,377
113
I see where there's actual video of the collapse - I would expect them to dissect that frame by frame to help diagnose the root cause of the failure.

There is gonna be a LOT of finger pointing on this one!
The newspaper, citing Occupational Safety Health Administration records, also said MCM has been slapped with fines totaling more than $50,000 during the past five years for 11 safety violations, which included complaints about cement dust and unsafe trenches at construction sites.
CEMENT DUST!!! That's the culprit right there!

Looks, I know these companies cut corners, but pointing back to BS like that is completely counterproductive.

This is something more to the point:
The Virginia Department of Labor cited Figg for four violations in 2012 after a 90-ton slab of concrete fell from a bridge it was building near Norfolk, according to the Miami Herald.

Figg was hit with a $28,000 fine and the Department of Labor said the company modified a girder without properly inspecting it or getting written consent from its manufacturer, The Virginian-Pilot reported.
Again, though, this type of situation has to be put in context of that overall construction project.

Ultimately part of this is gonna come back against FIU as they were in favor of this hurry-up construction technique.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RutHut_rivals

RUschool

Heisman
Jan 23, 2004
49,960
14,044
78
Why do you need a 950 ton bridge for a walkway? A metal walkway that allowed 20 people to cross at the same time as opposed to the 950 ton bridge that accommodate 5,000 people crossing at the same time. The current cost is over 19 million as opposed to maybe 5 million.
 

krup

Heisman
Feb 5, 2003
70,133
10,066
0
Why do you need a 950 ton bridge for a walkway? A metal walkway that allowed 20 people to cross at the same time as opposed to the 950 ton bridge that accommodate 5,000 people crossing at the same time. The current cost is over 19 million as opposed to maybe 5 million.
If you look at the video showing how it was going to look when it completed, it seems it was not designed as a way to just get you from point A to point B. It is much wider than you would think for a walkway, had places to sit down, etc. It was almost like they were trying to add some "open" space to an otherwise congested area.
 

CERU00

All-Conference
Feb 10, 2005
3,626
1,677
0
If you look at the video showing how it was going to look when it completed, it seems it was not designed as a way to just get you from point A to point B. It is much wider than you would think for a walkway, had places to sit down, etc. It was almost like they were trying to add some "open" space to an otherwise congested area.
Who would want to hang out and relax sitting on a bridge over a highway? Did it offer views of something scenic? Seems bizarre.
 

krup

Heisman
Feb 5, 2003
70,133
10,066
0
Who would want to hang out and relax sitting on a bridge over a highway? Did it offer views of something scenic? Seems bizarre.
Here's a still pulled from the architect's video of what the finished product would look like.

 

Armor and Sword

All-Conference
Oct 18, 2007
4,505
1,320
0
Who would want to hang out and relax sitting on a bridge over a highway? Did it offer views of something scenic? Seems bizarre.

This bridge may be an example of a design concept called Context Sensitive Solutions, where among other goals you make a transportation or building project more aesthetically pleasing, environmentally friendly and create multiple uses other than the primary function of the structure. By incorporating the table, benches, ceiling fans into the structure they are creating more than a pedestrian bridge. The project designers, with the OK (and maybe encouragement) of FIU and the other project stakeholders probably wanted to build a ped bridge that becomes a multi-functional place and provides as much incentive as possible for pedestrians to use the bridge instead of the at-grade crosswalk. Now that I've seen the demo video, it's more than a ped bridge and strives to be a campus hangout.

The more I see of this bridge, the more I think it would've worked to keep peds off the crosswalk.

https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/planning/css/
 

RutHut_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2017
4,483
4,903
0
I see where there's actual video of the collapse - I would expect them to dissect that frame by frame to help diagnose the root cause of the failure.

There is gonna be a LOT of finger pointing on this one!

CEMENT DUST!!! That's the culprit right there!

Looks, I know these companies cut corners, but pointing back to BS like that is completely counterproductive.

This is something more to the point:

Again, though, this type of situation has to be put in context of that overall construction project.

Ultimately part of this is gonna come back against FIU as they were in favor of this hurry-up construction technique.
If there is a video of the collapse, I would like to see it. I think there's a good chance that it would be the property of either FIU or Figg for marketing reasons to have a time lapse video of the build.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report How to watch Rutgers / Penn State; Pregame Info, Spread, More: Gameday Central
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod
  5. 05 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics