First of all Hall85 stated the score he made, a 40. It is irrelevant if number 12 is a par 3, a par 4 or a par 5. You shoot a 40 your score is a 40. As far as posting, which Hall85 never mentioned, it does make a difference whether it is a par 3, par 4 or a par 5, what his personal handicap is and what the index of the hole is.
Cali talks quite often of his club and the beautiful courses he plays. I was just offering a friendly piece of advise from a long time golfer. Learn the rules or people will lose interest in playing with you. The guy played college lacrosse, I am quite sure he appreciates the role rules play in sport and competition.