OT - Lebron calls himself the GOAT?

TheDude1

Heisman
Apr 15, 2010
8,726
11,199
0
I see a lot of people say that, but honestly I don't think this is right. I've never heard a single person ever mention the decision anywhere but places like this message board. There is only one thing that makes me think Lebron is not the goat. He shrinks in big moments and that's what the discussions I've ever had about him with other live humans always centered around.

I've always said he has the most ability/talent of anyone I've ever seen pick up a basketball. He has the body of a power forward and the skills of a point guard. He never gets hurt, can make every pass, shoots it pretty well, can get to the rim and score at will. However that's where it changes. Why doesn't he do that? Why is looking to pass in the big moments? When he can get to the rim at will, well how many times have you seen him choke clutch free throws? A lot. He is scared of the biggest moments. I've watched him for 15 years not want the ball at the end. That is why he isn't the goat.

Oh, sorry, I was saying that The Decision was a reason people don't LIKE him, not why people don't think he is the GOAT. Agreed on all you said.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ABlockalypseBrow

TheDude1

Heisman
Apr 15, 2010
8,726
11,199
0
Oh, shut up. I was trying to figure out if the red X was just on my end, or not.

I thought you said you don't post here anymore because of all the crazy UK fans...?

;)
 

JimboBBN

Heisman
Jan 26, 2016
15,536
31,605
113
Oh, shut up. I was trying to figure out if the red X was just on my end, or not.

I thought you said you don't post here anymore because of all the crazy UK fans...?

;)
I was literally laughing as I was going through this thread. You and borden both in here, what are the odds. Both with a higher post count than me lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheDude1

TheDude1

Heisman
Apr 15, 2010
8,726
11,199
0
I was literally laughing as I was going through this thread. You and borden both in here, what are the odds. Both with a higher post count than me lol

Hah! I saw that too... Borden without his avatar is weird. I'd put mine on, but figure a Coach K/Shane Battier avatar might be pushing things too far...
 

king of cali

All-Conference
Nov 24, 2005
6,955
3,877
0
I see a lot of people say that, but honestly I don't think this is right. I've never heard a single person ever mention the decision anywhere but places like this message board. There is only one thing that makes me think Lebron is not the goat. He shrinks in big moments and that's what the discussions I've ever had about him with other live humans always centered around.

I've always said he has the most ability/talent of anyone I've ever seen pick up a basketball. He has the body of a power forward and the skills of a point guard. He never gets hurt, can make every pass, shoots it pretty well, can get to the rim and score at will. However that's where it changes. Why doesn't he do that? Why is looking to pass in the big moments? When he can get to the rim at will, well how many times have you seen him choke clutch free throws? A lot. He is scared of the biggest moments. I've watched him for 15 years not want the ball at the end. That is why he isn't the goat.

Did you miss last years playoffs when he hit game winner after game winner?
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood

keefsopeng

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2005
5,015
2,068
0
Did you miss last years playoffs when he hit game winner after game winner?
did you miss the finals where he got swept? did you especially miss game one of the finals where he had 51 points and dominated the entire game until the last 2-3 minutes of the game he wanted no part of shooting the ball? where he passed in every spot? i don't care how many game winners he's taken in the regular season or the first round playoff series or anything but the finals. That's what it takes to be considered the greatest to ever to do it.
 

king of cali

All-Conference
Nov 24, 2005
6,955
3,877
0
did you miss the finals where he got swept? did you especially miss game one of the finals where he had 51 points and dominated the entire game until the last 2-3 minutes of the game he wanted no part of shooting the ball? where he passed in every spot? i don't care how many game winners he's taken in the regular season or the first round playoff series or anything but the finals. That's what it takes to be considered the greatest to ever to do it.

What you’re saying literally doesn’t match what the play by play says lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood

mustnotsleepnow

All-Conference
May 18, 2011
1,923
1,328
57
did you miss the finals where he got swept? did you especially miss game one of the finals where he had 51 points and dominated the entire game until the last 2-3 minutes of the game he wanted no part of shooting the ball? where he passed in every spot? i don't care how many game winners he's taken in the regular season or the first round playoff series or anything but the finals. That's what it takes to be considered the greatest to ever to do it.

Didn't Jordan get swept BEFORE even making the finals? I think twice?
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood

JASUN74

All-American
May 22, 2008
3,973
5,955
73
No, I think Magic was. No one out there could play every position and not lose effectiveness like he could. Jordan could play 3 positions well, Magic could play all 5 well.

Magic was Magical for sure and he would definitely be in my top five. Maybe three, behind Jordan and Bill Russell! Wilt would also be in my top five! I’ll not get into a big list or anything. Haha. Anyway, you’re definitely welcome to believe in your opinion, but for me, it can only be Jordan at the top until someone comes along to take it from him.

Just because he didn’t line up at center, doesn’t mean anything to me! We’re not picking the best Positions, we’re picking the Greatest Player of All Time. Im glad you mentioned Magic though. Lol. Man I have soo many memories of Bird / Magic games. Wow. They were some of my favorite Playoffs of all time as far as competition. Love magic!

Still, when asked my answer can only be Jordan! He was simply incredible, when his team needed to win, he made it happen, his desire, heart and competitive nature, made him one of the all time greats alone. But when he wanted to win, no one could do anything about it. Since you picked Magic I assume you’re 40 plus, so you seen how physical the NBA WAS THEN!!
He got absolutely killed almost every game and still won anytime he wanted. Lol. It’s amazing how today’s game is so good, but you sure can’t play like they did. It truly was a contact sport back then, and he still dominated. Anyway, I respect Magic and loved his game soo much. One of my favorite players of all time for sure. But MJ was, and still is the best to ever pick up a basketball to me.

To me the only people who really believe that LeBron is the greatest, are people under 30 years old. Some of them, Maybe in their 30s, but they didn’t get to see every Jordan game like most of us did. LeBron is definitely top Ten now and working his way closer to the top five. He’s got the time to get there, but we’ll have to see one it turns out. If he can win 3 more and be the man in all the series then he can move on up.
 

UKCatsFan10

Junior
May 17, 2010
1,681
303
0
Did you see MJ play? How about Wilt?

Saw MJ, not Wilt. MJ was my hero growing up, and to this day I still like him much more as a player than I do Lebron. His style was more appealing and he was certainly more fun. However, despite my fandom I still think Lebron is the better player. I can build a long argument as to why I believe that but I'll spare you. I'd venture to guess that neither of us can sway the others opinion.
 

king of cali

All-Conference
Nov 24, 2005
6,955
3,877
0
Yeah....as a rookie. By the Celtics. A Celtics team so felt was the best of all-time. BTW, Jordan dropped 63 on'em, though..

And LeBron lost to a Golden State team that many feel is among the best of all time. And he dropped 51 on ‘em. What exactly is the difference?

You think a team with MJ and not much else would be beating Golden State?
 

tjay11

Sophomore
Aug 10, 2018
192
180
0
To me the only people who really believe that LeBron is the greatest, are people under 30 years old. Some of them, Maybe in their 30s, but they didn’t get to see every Jordan game like most of us did. LeBron is definitely top Ten now and working his way closer to the top five. He’s got the time to get there, but we’ll have to see one it turns out. If he can win 3 more and be the man in all the series then he can move on up.
HAHAHAHA top ten now? buddy, hes at worst, second best.

while we are here... anyone that says anyone in any sport is the GOAT that played before 1970 is just not that smart. bill russell would be a rotation player in 2019.
 

UKCatsFan10

Junior
May 17, 2010
1,681
303
0
HAHAHAHA top ten now? buddy, hes at worst, second best.

while we are here... anyone that says anyone in any sport is the GOAT that played before 1970 is just not that smart. bill russell would be a rotation player in 2019.

We overvalue the past. Not just in sports but in all things. It's human nature.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tjay11

ib4ky_rivals111873

All-Conference
Dec 18, 2005
1,323
2,302
113
 
  • Like
Reactions: tjay11

wildcatdonf

Hall of Famer
Sep 26, 2003
78,022
128,835
0
Yes he's won a few titles...but lost even more.

3-8 in championships doesn't make you the GOAT... sorry your not the NBA's Tom Brady... it makes you John Elway and the Broncos'.

One of the unique and best players to play sure, but you're not the GOAT.

It's got to be MJ? 6 for 6 (..and I'm a long time Knicks fan) ... and even that's arguable with other all-time greats from the past like Russell, Wilt, Kareem, Bird, Magic. I have him behind all of these players, likely more i'm leaving out.

Heck if Golden State keeps the band together another 4-5 years...He may get passed up by Durrant and Co in the present. Forget all time.
Modesty is not his thing.
 

JASUN74

All-American
May 22, 2008
3,973
5,955
73
HAHAHAHA top ten now? buddy, hes at worst, second best.

while we are here... anyone that says anyone in any sport is the GOAT that played before 1970 is just not that smart. bill russell would be a rotation player in 2019.
I didn’t say Bill Russell was the greatest! I said he was second! Jordan is the greatest basketball player to ever live, and if I’m not mistaken, me being stupid and all, I believe he played in the 80s/90s!

. LeBron still dreams of Jordan hitting his game winner against Utah, and the many other Finals MVP performances! I didn’t say LeBron sucks!! He’s a great player, but there have been many great players! Do you think someone saying a player, being in the top ten Ever! OF ALL TIME!! In the NBA is an insult to that player? Pretty big time praise if you ask me!!

Just because you grew up with him being your hero, doesn’t make him the best Ever. LeBron isn’t second as far as I’m concerned, and Magic puts him out of third place. I could make a case for four to ten range I guess, but he’s got more to do, and time to move up. You’re acting like you’re his agent or something bro !

Ohh!, You talking about The Bill Russell that has so many Championships Rings, he has to wear one on his toe? That Bill Russell? Probably a pretty good player I’d say!! You don’t have to agree with me, but, there’s no need to call out my intelligence over giving an opinion, it’s your world and all, just not a very nice thing to do.

I’ve experienced both Jordan and LeBron from the beginning of their careers and it’s not even a discussion really! As far as Bill Russell is concerned, you may want to check into his career and do some research before calling the second greatest player to ever live, a roll player. In a lot of people’s minds he’s the greatest with Jordan second. Hard to convince LeBron people that basketball was played before he got to the league. It’s all good though. You have a good evening buddy.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,940
63,126
113
Disagree with this.



Definitely agree with this.

Hard to say which areas Lebron was correct on. He's off-base with his NFL-players-are-slaves bit. He's incorrect thinking Adam Silver wouldn't start to take the same measures as Goodell if faced with anywhere near the backlash from fans or political stunts from the players. The NBA has been pretty quiet with a lot of this.

Then he goes on to make an off-color comment about Jews. Not political, but terribly stupid, and confirming his self-importance.

And feuding with Trump. Certainly face-palm worthy why the president needs to address him, but Lebron should also be above this. He not only felt entitled enough to get involved in something that was between Trump and GSW, but he kept going, and to top it all off, just pulled a very Trump-ian move about his accomplishments.

Lebron is in a bubble. Heck, he's in a bubble, that's in a bubble.
 
Mar 10, 2003
5,927
11,325
93
It's almost entirely about an athlete who is vocal and visible involving issues outside of sports. Some folks just want athletes to be one dimensional, and get angry when they aren't just a basketball-playing caricature but instead act like most people, having thoughts and ideas and influence outside of their job. The rest is anger about The Decision show (which James has said was the worst moment of his career) because they think that it was self-centered.
It’s not for me. I disagree with a lot of Lebrons views but I honestly think he’s genuine and a great guy. He’s done great things for his community and at least tries to put his time into things he cares about.

My question is if LeBron played in the West instead of a weak East his whole career would this even be a thread right now? How many Finals appearances would there even be?
 

TheDude1

Heisman
Apr 15, 2010
8,726
11,199
0
It’s not for me. I disagree with a lot of Lebrons views but I honestly think he’s genuine and a great guy. He’s done great things for his community and at least tries to put his time into things he cares about.

My question is if LeBron played in the West instead of a weak East his whole career would this even be a thread right now? How many Finals appearances would there even be?

I just meant that was why some people hate him, not why people don’t think he is the GOAT. I think the argument for not-GOAT is more about basketball.
 

mustnotsleepnow

All-Conference
May 18, 2011
1,923
1,328
57
Yeah....as a rookie. By the Celtics. A Celtics team so felt was the best of all-time. BTW, Jordan dropped 63 on'em, though..

Oh...he was a rookie for two years? Also, snagged this from the net: "3 times he lost the series in the first round. And a total of 15 games from 84 to 98 in the first rounds. In case you are wondering, He lost the series twice in the conference finals and twice in the conference semi finals."

Point being...I don't punish Lebron for losing in the Finals while looking past Jordan not making it there.
 

tjay11

Sophomore
Aug 10, 2018
192
180
0
I didn’t say Bill Russell was the greatest! I said he was second! Jordan is the greatest basketball player to ever live, and if I’m not mistaken, me being stupid and all, I believe he played in the 80s/90s!

. LeBron still dreams of Jordan hitting his game winner against Utah, and the many other Finals MVP performances! I didn’t say LeBron sucks!! He’s a great player, but there have been many great players! Do you think someone saying a player, being in the top ten Ever! OF ALL TIME!! In the NBA is an insult to that player? Pretty big time praise if you ask me!!

Just because you grew up with him being your hero, doesn’t make him the best Ever. LeBron isn’t second as far as I’m concerned, and Magic puts him out of third place. I could make a case for four to ten range I guess, but he’s got more to do, and time to move up. You’re acting like you’re his agent or something bro !

Ohh!, You talking about The Bill Russell that has so many Championships Rings, he has to wear one on his toe? That Bill Russell? Probably a pretty good player I’d say!! You don’t have to agree with me, but, there’s no need to call out my intelligence over giving an opinion, it’s your world and all, just not a very nice thing to do.

I’ve experienced both Jordan and LeBron from the beginning of their careers and it’s not even a discussion really! As far as Bill Russell is concerned, you may want to check into his career and do some research before calling the second greatest player to ever live, a roll player. In a lot of people’s minds he’s the greatest with Jordan second. Hard to convince LeBron people that basketball was played before he got to the league. It’s all good though. You have a good evening buddy.
bill russell would come off the bench in 2019 lmao
 

IUfanBorden

Heisman
Dec 11, 2011
53,775
52,300
0
Oh...he was a rookie for two years? Also, snagged this from the net: "3 times he lost the series in the first round. And a total of 15 games from 84 to 98 in the first rounds. In case you are wondering, He lost the series twice in the conference finals and twice in the conference semi finals."

Point being...I don't punish Lebron for losing in the Finals while looking past Jordan not making it there.
Lost...sure. You said swept. Or the question was swept. I was only aware of them being swept his rookie year. Lots of greats lost series...A few never even reached the finals....A few never won a title. I highly doubt anyone will ever go their entire career, w/o losing a series, being swept, etc, etc....SO its a moot argument. BUT....for those who do reach the Finals, they'll be judged on how they did. Thats just how it is. Jordan got their 6 times...Won it 6 times...Never had a Finals series go past 6 games....MVP of the Finals 6 times. LeBron has been there 8 times...Won 3. 3 Finals MVP's. Rather you want to include that in the discussion, is on you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ABlockalypseBrow

JASUN74

All-American
May 22, 2008
3,973
5,955
73
bill russell would come off the bench in 2019 lmao
Haha. Good stuff. You know, I watched a game last night, where they called a flagrant foul, but back in Bills day it wasn’t even a foul.
Different times for sure and I’m not sure some of these guys today could’ve survived it. You must consider if Bill Russell played today, that he’d have all the advantages as all the other players from today’s game has too, as far as training!! Lmao.

I’m really not interested in this enough to go back and forth with you about it, because I’m sure you think you’re right and you’re welcome to think so. It’s hard for people to believe their dads were better than them. Haha. Have a good one my brother. Lol. I’m just joking about a little bit with you bud. But you really should at the very least, go back and watch Russell. I think you’d change your mind pretty quick. Bench player! Lmao. That was pretty good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ABlockalypseBrow
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Kentucky vs. Missouri Availability Report: Starting WR Could Return
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Jerone Morton nears Kentucky debut, Trent Noah officially week-to-week
  3. 03 KSR Football Will Stein Show Recap: Who's Improved the Most for Kentucky?
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Kam Williams is showing rust, but Mark Pope is confident he'll 'get his vibe back'
  5. 05 KSR Football Will Stein knows Missouri is better than its recent losses suggest