OT - Lebron calls himself the GOAT?

justin_uk_5

All-American
May 26, 2007
3,901
7,356
85
Peyton? If you really think Peyton is better then Brady your hatred is getting the best of you. I really dont care about either, but Brady was running circles around Manning in the beginning of the rivalry, till the end. Aren't they the same age?
Lol look at the colts defenses compared to Brady’s! Good lord not even a comparison. Patriots have a huge advantage being in New England. Playing the jets dolphins and bills twice a year gets them home field advantage the majority of the time and only a select few teams are used to those cold conditions. It’s more than a normal home field advantage
 

Louis_Skunt

All-American
Oct 4, 2013
6,336
7,071
66
Lol look at the colts defenses compared to Brady’s! Good lord not even a comparison. Patriots have a huge advantage being in New England. Playing the jets dolphins and bills twice a year gets them home field advantage the majority of the time and only a select few teams are used to those cold conditions. It’s more than a normal home field advantage
This reminds me of the conversation with UL fans about playing in the SEC vs ACC. The cool part is, Kentucky, just like the Patriots, have a post season where they have to play the best......and they've done really well.
 

Louis_Skunt

All-American
Oct 4, 2013
6,336
7,071
66
Because I think Peytn is better, means I hate Brady? Why? I just happen to think Brady was in a better system, surrounded by better players, with more options. PLus he had a defense to go with his offense. PM rarely, if ever did. Put Peyton on the Pats, and he probably has more titles than what Brady has now. Don't let your hate for Tennessee get in the way....:D
Hate to say it, but youre in the minority believing Peyton is better than Brady. Way minority. Your Indiana eyes only see what they want. I like Peyton, he's an SEC guy, but he's not even on Bradys level.
 

keefsopeng

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2005
5,015
2,068
0
Lol look at the colts defenses compared to Brady’s! Good lord not even a comparison. Patriots have a huge advantage being in New England. Playing the jets dolphins and bills twice a year gets them home field advantage the majority of the time and only a select few teams are used to those cold conditions. It’s more than a normal home field advantage
Tom Brady played with Randy Moss for 1 year healthy then he blew up his knee. In that year he broke every record that ever existed and went undefeated and lost the super bowl on some fluky helmet catch. The NFC South, aka the Jaguars, Titans, and Texans were every bit as pitiful as the NFC east and honestly probably more pitiful. If Tom Brady would of played with Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, and Edgerrin James for 8-10 years like Manning did my lord. You can say Brady is weird or acts like a robot or whatever but you can't say he isn't the goat. And trust me a die hard 49ers fan it pains me to say it isn't Joe anymore.
 

IUfanBorden

Heisman
Dec 11, 2011
53,775
52,300
0
Hate to say it, but youre in the minority believing Peyton is better than Brady. Way minority. Your Indiana eyes only see what they want. I like Peyton, he's an SEC guy, but he's not even on Bradys level.
What about my Denver eyes? It has noting to do with where he played. Its just an opinion. I think MJ is the GOAT. Is that because he played in Chicago, which is close to Indiana? I know I'm in the minority. And Im good with that. I also said Peyton or Montana. TBH, I'd take either over Brady. Its just a preference. IMO, Brady, though extremely good, benefited a ton from playing in Belichick's system. It was the perfect storm. Brady was fortunate to be a Patriot. And to play for such a astrong orginazation. NOt to mention, a great coach who ultilized his skills, and builkt around him. Not to mention, understanding you also needed to play defense.
I like Brady. A ton. Great QB. I just prefer Manning and or Montana.
 

IUfanBorden

Heisman
Dec 11, 2011
53,775
52,300
0
This reminds me of the conversation with UL fans about playing in the SEC vs ACC. The cool part is, Kentucky, just like the Patriots, have a post season where they have to play the best......and they've done really well.
Yeah, but unlike UK, they got to play a ton of games at home. And that was due to playing in a terrible division. When you are playing two games to go to a SB, and both are at home---Your chances are good. When the Colts were finally able to get the Pats at home,in the playoffs.....they won. Going on towin the SB. Home field is huge.

BTW, From 2000-09, Indy had the most wins and best winning percentage in the NFL. Just didn't have a defense.
 

IUfanBorden

Heisman
Dec 11, 2011
53,775
52,300
0
Tom Brady played with Randy Moss for 1 year healthy then he blew up his knee. In that year he broke every record that ever existed and went undefeated and lost the super bowl on some fluky helmet catch. The NFC South, aka the Jaguars, Titans, and Texans were every bit as pitiful as the NFC east and honestly probably more pitiful. If Tom Brady would of played with Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, and Edgerrin James for 8-10 years like Manning did my lord. You can say Brady is weird or acts like a robot or whatever but you can't say he isn't the goat. And trust me a die hard 49ers fan it pains me to say it isn't Joe anymore.
Offensive weapons wasn't the issue' though lets not act as if Brady didn't have those. It was the defense. Peyton nver had a defense that could stop a HS team. The year they won the SB, that defense was great in the playoffs. But the reg season, it was ****. The AFC East has been a **** hole of a conference for as long as Brady has been a a partiot. Home field advantage was parlayed thorugh that. And that is a huge advantage.
 

Alayyahfuqyaself

Redshirt
Sep 14, 2018
7
0
0
Lol look at the colts defenses compared to Brady’s! Good lord not even a comparison. Patriots have a huge advantage being in New England. Playing the jets dolphins and bills twice a year gets them home field advantage the majority of the time and only a select few teams are used to those cold conditions. It’s more than a normal home field advantage
The Pats competition in the division is a result of being in said division with the Pats.
 

Alayyahfuqyaself

Redshirt
Sep 14, 2018
7
0
0
Tom Brady played with Randy Moss for 1 year healthy then he blew up his knee. In that year he broke every record that ever existed and went undefeated and lost the super bowl on some fluky helmet catch. The NFC South, aka the Jaguars, Titans, and Texans were every bit as pitiful as the NFC east and honestly probably more pitiful. If Tom Brady would of played with Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, and Edgerrin James for 8-10 years like Manning did my lord. You can say Brady is weird or acts like a robot or whatever but you can't say he isn't the goat. And trust me a die hard 49ers fan it pains me to say it isn't Joe anymore.
THIS^^^^^
 

TheDude1

Heisman
Apr 15, 2010
8,726
11,199
0
Founded a school that will cost taxpayers 8 million a year. Not quite the badge of honor you and others portray it as.

Right now it costs 8 million *over the next five years.*. Eventually that will increase because gradually they are adding grade levels until it will be a k-8 school, but the trick is that the school is a public school, NOT a fancy private school that only celebrities go to, or a charter school that takes public money and then largely doesn’t have to answer to taxpayers. Public schools are paid for via taxpayers. That’s the way it works. Every other public school is exactly the same. LeBron's Foundation not only gave millions to help with construction, but it will continue to give millions towards school operation, including for things that schools for underprivileged kids often need and which research has shown has value far beyond the dollar amount put in but can not afford, like food and clothing pantries for families, family counselors, and more. They paid for the renovations of the building. And they have offered a college scholarship for every graduate. That’s incredibly generous.

I don’t think it is possible to spin this into anything other than a great thing to do for his community. Yes, public schools cost money to run. No, LeBron James isn’t paying for every cent of the school to run for perpetuity. But it is certainly not the action of someone who is me me me, which is how it came up, and I don’t know if I can think of any other athlete who has done something similar for their hometown.
 

KyFaninNC

Heisman
Mar 14, 2005
195,719
24,518
0
I absolutely detes Lebrons ... misguided ? Political views. We have fundamentally different views on things but I believe , as a basketball player , he is absolutely in the discussion of GOAT. Is he for sure? It’s up for debate but his name absolutely belongs with MJ and Kobe (imo)
As usual, you are wrong.

Signed,
Wilt, Reed,Bird,Jabbar,MJ,Havelchek,and dozens of others.
 

mustnotsleepnow

All-Conference
May 18, 2011
1,923
1,328
57
Right now it costs 8 million *over the next five years.*. Eventually that will increase because gradually they are adding grade levels until it will be a k-8 school, but the trick is that the school is a public school, NOT a fancy private school that only celebrities go to, or a charter school that takes public money and then largely doesn’t have to answer to taxpayers. Public schools are paid for via taxpayers. That’s the way it works. Every other public school is exactly the same. LeBron's Foundation not only gave millions to help with construction, but it will continue to give millions towards school operation, including for things that schools for underprivileged kids often need and which research has shown has value far beyond the dollar amount put in but can not afford, like food and clothing pantries for families, family counselors, and more. They paid for the renovations of the building. And they have offered a college scholarship for every graduate. That’s incredibly generous.

I don’t think it is possible to spin this into anything other than a great thing to do for his community. Yes, public schools cost money to run. No, LeBron James isn’t paying for every cent of the school to run for perpetuity. But it is certainly not the action of someone who is me me me, which is how it came up, and I don’t know if I can think of any other athlete who has done something similar for their hometown.

A lot of people are telling on themselves.
 

TheDude1

Heisman
Apr 15, 2010
8,726
11,199
0
BTW, I keep looking at that Lebron quote, and I know that everyone is taking it to mean that he thinks he is the best ever... but the actual quote is...

"That one right there made me the greatest player of all time ... that's what I felt."

FELT is past tense. Not present tense. He didn't say "That one made me the greatest player... that's what I feel." He also didn't just leave it as "That one right there made me the greatest player of all time," which would have been clear.

I can't help but wonder if that "that's what I felt" maybe indicates it was more a reflection of his reaction at that moment, and not necessarily his current, more clear headed take? Especially given the context, as he went on to discuss his reaction just after winning that game.

I suppose he would/will clarify, if that is the case. The media has certainly blown quotes out of proportion/taken quotes out of context before, and plenty of people can say something that is taken one way but mean something totally different.

Anyway... worth a thought.
 

SemperFiCat

Heisman
Mar 2, 2009
14,566
30,005
0
LBJ is the most talented basketball player, probably ever, but that doesn't make him the GOAT.

Honestly, I've never understood why so many people have so much hate for LBJ. He's never had any off court issues, he's a great husband and father, gives away tons of money every year, funds an entire school, etc...
 

TheDude1

Heisman
Apr 15, 2010
8,726
11,199
0
LBJ is the most talented basketball player, probably ever, but that doesn't make him the GOAT.

Honestly, I've never understood why so many people have so much hate for LBJ. He's never had any off court issues, he's a great husband and father, gives away tons of money every year, funds an entire school, etc...

It's almost entirely about an athlete who is vocal and visible involving issues outside of sports. Some folks just want athletes to be one dimensional, and get angry when they aren't just a basketball-playing caricature but instead act like most people, having thoughts and ideas and influence outside of their job. The rest is anger about The Decision show (which James has said was the worst moment of his career) because they think that it was self-centered.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,940
63,126
113
Used to be a big fan of Lebron. Loved how 29 fanbases all the sudden hated him because he didn't pick their team for The Decision. KNicks fans in particular, my goodness. They were all aboard the Lebron-Train. Next morning it was like he pillaged their towns and raped the women.

But recently he's annoyed me. Didn't love that he jumped ship, again. But I also understand the choice, too. But then he's become extremely mouthy, political (usually wrong here), and now telling people he's the greatest? His team is the 8th seed right now and what James Harden has been doing is probably going to get him back-to-back MVPs.

The door is just about closed on the "Lebron MVP" argument, and I'm starting to think he's closer to 3rd or 4th than he is to #1.
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
I’d be thinking I was the GOAT if I were him too... probably wouldn’t say it though.

It doesn’t really matter in the end... just another thing for hoops fans to argue over.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: TheDude1

warrior-cat

Hall of Famer
Oct 22, 2004
192,383
158,195
113
For anyone that saw Michael Jordan play, they know who the Greatest of all time is! Someone may come along someday but they haven’t yet, LeBron is working on top five, but getting to top five, and then taking the top spot is two different things.

MJ was the best to ever play the game of Basketball! Having watched them all, (excluding 70s and lower ), it’s not even a discussion! Especially between him and LeBron James! Lol. Kinda funny he even thinks that!
No, I think Magic was. No one out there could play every position and not lose effectiveness like he could. Jordan could play 3 positions well, Magic could play all 5 well.
 
Last edited:

ManitouDan_anon

Heisman
Dec 7, 2006
20,073
32,434
0
wish everyone would stop with the " he funded a school " stuff . Giving a small portion of your money away doesnt cleanse you from other forms of stupidity and arrogance . Whats his net worth and what amount did he give to the school ?
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
wish everyone would stop with the " he funded a school " stuff . Giving a small portion of your money away doesnt cleanse you from other forms of stupidity and arrogance . Whats his net worth and what amount did he give to the school ?

As much as he could and the school still remain a public school. Probably funded a lot behind the scenes to make it happen as well.

There’s a lot of wealthy people who don’t do things like this.
 

TheDude1

Heisman
Apr 15, 2010
8,726
11,199
0
wish everyone would stop with the " he funded a school " stuff . Giving a small portion of your money away doesnt cleanse you from other forms of stupidity and arrogance . Whats his net worth and what amount did he give to the school ?

Again... how do you bash an athlete for giving millions to a public school, and agreeing to send every graduate to college? He is literally the only athlete in history, AFAIK, to have done that. What, him going on TV for an hour to announce where he was going to play basketball, a decision that the world was literally waiting for and that people burned their possessions over, somehow makes him a terrible person, while giving millions to kids from his hometown... that doesn't make up for an hour long tv show?

People get so desperate to tear people down that they start to get a bit warped.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood

tjay11

Sophomore
Aug 10, 2018
192
180
0
Yes he's won a few titles...but lost even more.

3-8 in championships doesn't make you the GOAT... sorry your not the NBA's Tom Brady... it makes you John Elway and the Broncos'.

One of the unique and best players to play sure, but you're not the GOAT.

It's got to be MJ? 6 for 6 (..and I'm a long time Knicks fan) ... and even that's arguable with other all-time greats from the past like Russell, Wilt, Kareem, Bird, Magic. I have him behind all of these players, likely more i'm leaving out.

Heck if Golden State keeps the band together another 4-5 years...He may get passed up by Durrant and Co in the present. Forget all time.
your opinion is trash.
lol at lebron behind dudes that played in the 60's, larry freaking bird, and magic.

lebron is the best basketball player ever. foh with the 3 titles ish. do you think robert horry is better? lol
 

TheDude1

Heisman
Apr 15, 2010
8,726
11,199
0
your opinion is trash.
lol at lebron behind dudes that played in the 60's, larry freaking bird, and magic.

lebron is the best basketball player ever. foh with the 3 titles ish. do you think robert horry is better? lol

While I can't agree with how you phrased it, or that Lebron is the best player ever, I do think that Lebron, with his current body and training, would have been impossible for a guy like Larry Bird or John Havlicek to deal with. It is VERY hard to compare modern athletes with the guys from the past.

Hm. Now I'm feeling a bit racist, because I mentioned two white guys.
 

ManitouDan_anon

Heisman
Dec 7, 2006
20,073
32,434
0
Again... how do you bash an athlete for giving millions to a public school, and agreeing to send every graduate to college? He is literally the only athlete in history, AFAIK, to have done that. What, him going on TV for an hour to announce where he was going to play basketball, a decision that the world was literally waiting for and that people burned their possessions over, somehow makes him a terrible person, while giving millions to kids from his hometown... that doesn't make up for an hour long tv show?

People get so desperate to tear people down that they start to get a bit warped.

Facts on his amount donated are rather hard to drum up .. Forbes reported 2 million . His net worth is 440 million. Forbes also estimated ( guessed ??) the school was funded about 25% by Lebron and 75 % by the taxpayers in Akron . The whole " I'm taking my talents to Florida " thing wasnt a blip on my radar screen . I dont care enough about him to get worked up , Its just my opinion he doesnt rise to top 3-5 in GOAT status . And I could bore you with a dozen quips he's made that I dont personally agree with . I just dont like him. Too arrogant for my taste . Hes not a terrible person, not worth worshiping either.
 

CELTICAT

Heisman
May 21, 2002
19,501
19,711
113
I kind of expect Lebron to play into his mid-40s, seriously. Like he may literally play ten more seasons after this one, absent a devastating injury (which he's never had).

With that in mind, he will easily capture the career scoring record. He'll probably be very high on career rebounds, assists and steals when he's done, may even be #1 in one or more of those categories as well. Playoff career records? Shoot, he'll own every single one when he's done.

He'll have a boatload of All Star game appearances more to go, and will be All NBA first team for the foreseeable future, and then will slide into 2nd and then 3rd team. Will probably have a few years as a very effective rotation player, if he's up for it. I'm seriously guessing he'll play in 25 NBA seasons if he wants to.

I say all of that to lay the foundation that when LeBron is done, nearly all of the objective measures we use will point to him as the best or greatest. Nobody will have his seasons played, games won, points scored, all star appearances, etc etc, go on down the line. It'll be LeBron #1 across the board.

And yet, for those who remember when NBA basketball was not a glorified YMCA pickup game, there won't be anything even close to consensus on his GOATship when he's done. If my life depended on it, I'm not picking LeBron.

I don't hate Lebron, but I've thought for a long time he was comfortable with his greatness. He only recently said he's the GOAT, but he's probably thought that since he was in junior high school. He gets hungry sometimes, like in 2011 after losing to the Mavs, or 2015 after losing to the Cavs. But those are the exceptions. Bob Costas called Michael Jordan the "overachieving superstar", meaning that MJ had all of the physical and mental gifts to be great, and yet his drive and determination still enabled him to achieve a level of greatness that shouldn't have been possible. Lebron is the underachieving superstar who will have an uncanny resume when all is said and done.
 

keefsopeng

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2005
5,015
2,068
0
It's almost entirely about an athlete who is vocal and visible involving issues outside of sports. Some folks just want athletes to be one dimensional, and get angry when they aren't just a basketball-playing caricature but instead act like most people, having thoughts and ideas and influence outside of their job. The rest is anger about The Decision show (which James has said was the worst moment of his career) because they think that it was self-centered.

I see a lot of people say that, but honestly I don't think this is right. I've never heard a single person ever mention the decision anywhere but places like this message board. There is only one thing that makes me think Lebron is not the goat. He shrinks in big moments and that's what the discussions I've ever had about him with other live humans always centered around.

I've always said he has the most ability/talent of anyone I've ever seen pick up a basketball. He has the body of a power forward and the skills of a point guard. He never gets hurt, can make every pass, shoots it pretty well, can get to the rim and score at will. However that's where it changes. Why doesn't he do that? Why is looking to pass in the big moments? When he can get to the rim at will, well how many times have you seen him choke clutch free throws? A lot. He is scared of the biggest moments. I've watched him for 15 years not want the ball at the end. That is why he isn't the goat.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CELTICAT
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Kentucky vs. Missouri Availability Report: Starting WR Could Return
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Jerone Morton nears Kentucky debut, Trent Noah officially week-to-week
  3. 03 KSR Football Will Stein Show Recap: Who's Improved the Most for Kentucky?
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Kam Williams is showing rust, but Mark Pope is confident he'll 'get his vibe back'
  5. 05 KSR Football Will Stein knows Missouri is better than its recent losses suggest