Nepotism….

Anon1751457816

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
1,108
1,996
113
Again, Ben's general lack of awareness around this whole dynamic is really surprising to me, especially with his sharp he seems otherwise. Somewhere deep down he has to know PM should be playing a lower level D1 or d2 ball - which is still a impressive level to compete at - and that he would not be on a big ten roster otherwise. And I don't like this about the Iowa fanbase, but they'll let the boos cascade. It's not fair to the fans, to players who should be taking that spot, and most of all to PM
 
  • Like
Reactions: QChawks

Anon1751457816

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
1,108
1,996
113
Again, Ben's general lack of awareness around this whole dynamic is really surprising to me, especially with his sharp he seems otherwise. Somewhere deep down he has to know PM should be playing a lower level D1 or d2 ball - which is still a impressive level to compete at - and that he would not be on a big ten roster otherwise. And I don't like this about the Iowa fanbase, but they'll let the boos cascade. It's not fair to the fans, to players who should be taking that spot, and most of all to PM
 

BringBackBradBanks

All-Conference
Jul 19, 2022
967
2,150
93
Again, Ben's general lack of awareness around this whole dynamic is really surprising to me, especially with his sharp he seems otherwise. Somewhere deep down he has to know PM should be playing a lower level D1 or d2 ball - which is still a impressive level to compete at - and that he would not be on a big ten roster otherwise. And I don't like this about the Iowa fanbase, but they'll let the boos cascade. It's not fair to the fans, to players who should be taking that spot, and most of all to PM
And all this plus minus talk is just gaslighting. We went on a run in the first half because Creighton missed threes and Jirok and Koch went to work. Not because of Peyton.
 

BringBackBradBanks

All-Conference
Jul 19, 2022
967
2,150
93
I don't understand as a B1G ten basketball coachs son, why you'd want to play for your dad unless you knew you were going to be the best player on the team or a benchwarmer. It just leaves you up for nonstop critique. Jack had it right.
I don’t get it either. Especially when they say you either want your son to be the best player on the team or the worst, therefore you know exactly where they stand. But at Iowa as multiple coaches in the past have shown, you can be the worst player on the team and still play a ton. And Peyton is not the worst on the team but he should not be getting serious minutes for a Big Ten basketball team, period.
 

ChicagoHawk2020

All-Conference
Nov 6, 2017
1,320
3,986
112
I don’t get it either. Especially when they say you either want your son to be the best player on the team or the worst, therefore you know exactly where they stand. But at Iowa as multiple coaches in the past have shown, you can be the worst player on the team and still play a ton. And Peyton is not the worst on the team but he should not be getting serious minutes for a Big Ten basketball team, period.
When the announcers were talking about Peyton and they said Ben told them that Peyton had the "best efficiency on the team" in practice pretty much confirmed to me that he has a weak spot.
 

BLHawkeye

Junior
Jan 3, 2023
95
202
33
When the announcers were talking about Peyton and they said Ben told them that Peyton had the "best efficiency on the team" in practice pretty much confirmed to me that he has a weak spot.
That is a very political approach for Ben. Control the narrative through the media. We all have our blind spots, and Ben is showing his. Peyton is a 4 minute per half player at most....
 

Rifler

All-American
Jan 26, 2011
6,640
7,496
113
Shocked The Wind GIF


Not this schit again....
 
Mar 28, 2008
536
989
93
Oh I don't know. I'm sure someone with an ounce of basketball intelligence might bring up things like, Creighton having small quick guards that were getting wide open shots against Iowa's taller exterior players, or that Sage was zero for 5 from the field in the game. Just spitballing it, but I'm pretty sure that if you truly watched the game you will see that McCollum was probably the 4th best player on the court yesterday and Sage for this game was like the 8th or 9th best player when it came to production and defense.
Just my thoughts.
I want Sage in there on the last play of the game taking that shot before PM 100 times out of 100.
Just my thoughts.
 

Palmerhawk

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,601
5,124
113
Katrell Harmon of Creighton , true frosh, was recruited heavily by Ben and we were bridesmaid on, contributed yesterday. We needed that guy, but maybe Ben sits him like coon and harris.

Our guard rotation is short one starter quality guy so Peyton has to play.
Good college teams have great backcourts.
We are loaded with wing guys that are not true guards.
Roster composition is an issue this year.
 

BringBackBradBanks

All-Conference
Jul 19, 2022
967
2,150
93
in this department would it be fair to say that ben is an upgrade from lickliter but a step down from fran?
Connor and Patrick were at least recruits that would have been at Big Ten schools without their dad. Now they wouldn’t have played there based on what happened at Iowa but they at least deserved to be there. Can’t say the same for Peyton.
 

Hawkeye Tech

Junior
Iowa Swarm member
Mar 28, 2014
107
287
63
Katrell Harmon of Creighton , true frosh, was recruited heavily by Ben and we were bridesmaid on, contributed yesterday. We needed that guy, but maybe Ben sits him like coon and harris.

Our guard rotation is short one starter quality guy so Peyton has to play
.
Good college teams have great backcourts.
We are loaded with wing guys that are not true guards.
Roster composition is an issue this year.
The entire 2nd half? I don't think so.
 

Max Rebo

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2022
885
2,436
93
I will say that when Ben McCollum was originally hired, and a few weeks later Peyton signed -- and was awarded a scholarship -- I was surprised and a little skeptical. The issues with apparent nepotism in both the MBB and football programs have been well-documented, and it seemed like a mistake to give anything close to the appearance of going there again. But I didn’t say anything, because it was the era of good feelings, and everything else Ben was doing was right on the money.

So I get why fans are upset now. There’s a lot of scar tissue there, and that frustration is understandable.

At the same time, I know from years of experience that when a team loses a game or two that fans think they should have won, they are going to look for a scapegoat. And the old “coach played his own kid too much” always makes for some pretty juicy low-hanging fruit.

I think Peyton is an OK player. Not as bad as many are saying, but certainly not great either. Some folks have pointed to his +/- stats, which apparently were among the highest on the team Sunday. On the flip side, I was looking at Evan Miya’s site, and Peyton is listed last on the team in terms of his "Bayesian Performance Rating" (whatever that is). So we can find stats to back up whatever we want.

But here’s a point of context that I think matters: Ben McCollum wants his guys to play a certain way, and to prepare a certain way. It’s about the culture he wants to build in the program. Ben has absolutely no problem benching a guy who isn’t approaching the game the right way, no matter how talented he is. And he’s shown he’s just as willing to run off guys who don’t buy in. If you’re not all-in on his system and his standards, he’ll move on from you and find someone who is. Talent doesn’t buy anyone a pass in his program.

With that in mind, I would venture a guess that Peyton is practicing and playing the way the head coach has instructed, and that’s being rewarded with playing time, even if some of the other guys are more talented.

That said, as good as we all felt last March, I don’t think you can win on culture alone. At the end of the day, we’ve got to get more talent. That, more than anything else, is the biggest reason we’re 2-2. It’s not about who is getting minutes at the end of the bench or in the rotation. It’s about the overall talent level of the roster, and that’s something that gets fixed over time through recruiting and development.

So my plea to everyone is this: Let’s be civil, and let’s see how the season plays out. Venting about the program is fine, but beating up on one player doesn’t change anything. There’s a lot of season left, and Ben has earned some patience.
 
Last edited:
Nov 29, 2021
318
892
92
Call me surprised that Ben would even risk having his own son on the team let along playing him significant minutes. Seems like it simply wouldn't be worth the vitriol. Let his son go find a team and learn to play independently. This won't end well
I was a little concerned last year when I read PM was on scholarship. I never looked into it, but if he didn’t receive any other D1 offers I don’t understand how as a coach and dad Ben can feel it’s fair to give him a scholarship when there’s other walk ons on the team.
 

QChawks

Heisman
Dec 17, 2022
13,295
27,557
113
I was a little concerned last year when I read PM was on scholarship. I never looked into it, but if he didn’t receive any other D1 offers I don’t understand how as a coach and dad Ben can feel it’s fair to give him a scholarship when there’s other walk ons on the team.
I can't find a true offer sheet on PM anywhere online

nothing
 
  • Like
Reactions: CarterHall

Rambler Hawk

All-Conference
Oct 10, 2001
3,104
4,144
113
I will say that when Ben McCollum was originally hired, and a few weeks later Peyton signed -- and was awarded a scholarship -- I was surprised and a little skeptical. The issues with apparent nepotism in both the MBB and football programs have been well-documented, and it seemed like a mistake to give anything close to the appearance of going there again. But I didn’t say anything, because it was the era of good feelings, and everything else Ben was doing was right on the money.

So I get why fans are upset now. There’s a lot of scar tissue there, and that frustration is understandable.

At the same time, I know from years of experience that when a team loses a game or two that fans think they should have won, they are going to look for a scapegoat. And the old “coach played his own kid too much” always makes for some pretty juicy low-hanging fruit.

I think Peyton is an OK player. Not as bad as many are saying, but certainly not great either. Some folks have pointed to his +/- stats, which apparently were among the highest on the team Sunday. On the flip side, I was looking at Evan Miya’s site, and Peyton is listed last on the team in terms of his "Bayesian Performance Rating" (whatever that is). So we can find stats to back up whatever we want.

But here’s a point of context that I think matters: Ben McCollum wants his guys to play a certain way, and to prepare a certain way. It’s about the culture he wants to build in the program. Ben has absolutely no problem benching a guy who isn’t approaching the game the right way, no matter how talented he is. And he’s shown he’s just as willing to run off guys who don’t buy in. If you’re not all-in on his system and his standards, he’ll move on from you and find someone who is. Talent doesn’t buy anyone a pass in his program.

With that in mind, I would venture a guess that Peyton is practicing and playing the way the head coach has instructed, and that’s being rewarded with playing time, even if some of the other guys are more talented.

That said, as good as we all felt last March, I don’t think you can win on culture alone. At the end of the day, we’ve got to get more talent. That, more than anything else, is the biggest reason we’re 2-2. It’s not about who is getting minutes at the end of the bench or in the rotation. It’s about the overall talent level of the roster, and that’s something that gets fixed over time through recruiting and development.

So my plea to everyone is this: Let’s be civil, and let’s see how the season plays out. Venting about the program is fine, but beating up on one player doesn’t change anything. There’s a lot of season left, and Ben has earned some patience.
Great post...👍
 

ComradeKirk

All-Conference
Jan 12, 2026
533
1,467
93
...

At the same time, I know from years of experience that when a team loses a game or two that fans think they should have won, they are going to look for a scapegoat. And the old “coach played his own kid too much” always makes for some pretty juicy low-hanging fruit.

...
Agree with most of this, especially singling out one player, because it's not his fault. But the 'nepo baby' card is quick and easy to play since it's could be a cosmic gumbo of potential red flags like system rigidity, talent ID, roster composition, or man management. We're all working with partial details, at best, so it's easier to judge the output rather than distill the inputs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Max Rebo

BringBackBradBanks

All-Conference
Jul 19, 2022
967
2,150
93
+19 with McCollum in the game, by far the best number. Next person was +12.
Jirok and Koch got hot and Creighton missed threes in the first half. Little Mac dribbled the ball off his foot and fouled chasing the ball during that stretch. His biggest contribution in the first half, where a lot of that plus minus number came from.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ken58

The Big Z

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2023
2,331
4,509
113
Katrell Harmon of Creighton , true frosh, was recruited heavily by Ben and we were bridesmaid on, contributed yesterday. We needed that guy, but maybe Ben sits him like coon and harris.

Our guard rotation is short one starter quality guy so Peyton has to play.
Good college teams have great backcourts.
We are loaded with wing guys that are not true guards.
Roster composition is an issue this year.
A wing also has the ability to play 2 guard. What would you consider Howard? Coon clearly has the ability to play the 2. And at 6-5 he's a way better athlete than little Mac. Sage will get it together. He was to good down the stretch last year to not. But if not Coon needs to be the next guy in not little Mac.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hawkeyemark18

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,032
8,582
113
I will say that when Ben McCollum was originally hired, and a few weeks later Peyton signed -- and was awarded a scholarship -- I was surprised and a little skeptical. The issues with apparent nepotism in both the MBB and football programs have been well-documented, and it seemed like a mistake to give anything close to the appearance of going there again. But I didn’t say anything, because it was the era of good feelings, and everything else Ben was doing was right on the money.

So I get why fans are upset now. There’s a lot of scar tissue there, and that frustration is understandable.

At the same time, I know from years of experience that when a team loses a game or two that fans think they should have won, they are going to look for a scapegoat. And the old “coach played his own kid too much” always makes for some pretty juicy low-hanging fruit.

I think Peyton is an OK player. Not as bad as many are saying, but certainly not great either. Some folks have pointed to his +/- stats, which apparently were among the highest on the team Sunday. On the flip side, I was looking at Evan Miya’s site, and Peyton is listed last on the team in terms of his "Bayesian Performance Rating" (whatever that is). So we can find stats to back up whatever we want.

But here’s a point of context that I think matters: Ben McCollum wants his guys to play a certain way, and to prepare a certain way. It’s about the culture he wants to build in the program. Ben has absolutely no problem benching a guy who isn’t approaching the game the right way, no matter how talented he is. And he’s shown he’s just as willing to run off guys who don’t buy in. If you’re not all-in on his system and his standards, he’ll move on from you and find someone who is. Talent doesn’t buy anyone a pass in his program.

With that in mind, I would venture a guess that Peyton is practicing and playing the way the head coach has instructed, and that’s being rewarded with playing time, even if some of the other guys are more talented.

That said, as good as we all felt last March, I don’t think you can win on culture alone. At the end of the day, we’ve got to get more talent. That, more than anything else, is the biggest reason we’re 2-2. It’s not about who is getting minutes at the end of the bench or in the rotation. It’s about the overall talent level of the roster, and that’s something that gets fixed over time through recruiting and development.

So my plea to everyone is this: Let’s be civil, and let’s see how the season plays out. Venting about the program is fine, but beating up on one player doesn’t change anything. There’s a lot of season left, and Ben has earned some patience.
I will say that when Ben McCollum was originally hired, and a few weeks later Peyton signed -- and was awarded a scholarship -- I was surprised and a little skeptical. The issues with apparent nepotism in both the MBB and football programs have been well-documented, and it seemed like a mistake to give anything close to the appearance of going there again. But I didn’t say anything, because it was the era of good feelings, and everything else Ben was doing was right on the money.

So I get why fans are upset now. There’s a lot of scar tissue there, and that frustration is understandable.

At the same time, I know from years of experience that when a team loses a game or two that fans think they should have won, they are going to look for a scapegoat. And the old “coach played his own kid too much” always makes for some pretty juicy low-hanging fruit.

I think Peyton is an OK player. Not as bad as many are saying, but certainly not great either. Some folks have pointed to his +/- stats, which apparently were among the highest on the team Sunday. On the flip side, I was looking at Evan Miya’s site, and Peyton is listed last on the team in terms of his "Bayesian Performance Rating" (whatever that is). So we can find stats to back up whatever we want.

But here’s a point of context that I think matters: Ben McCollum wants his guys to play a certain way, and to prepare a certain way. It’s about the culture he wants to build in the program. Ben has absolutely no problem benching a guy who isn’t approaching the game the right way, no matter how talented he is. And he’s shown he’s just as willing to run off guys who don’t buy in. If you’re not all-in on his system and his standards, he’ll move on from you and find someone who is. Talent doesn’t buy anyone a pass in his program.

With that in mind, I would venture a guess that Peyton is practicing and playing the way the head coach has instructed, and that’s being rewarded with playing time, even if some of the other guys are more talented.

That said, as good as we all felt last March, I don’t think you can win on culture alone. At the end of the day, we’ve got to get more talent. That, more than anything else, is the biggest reason we’re 2-2. It’s not about who is getting minutes at the end of the bench or in the rotation. It’s about the overall talent level of the roster, and that’s something that gets fixed over time through recruiting and development.

So my plea to everyone is this: Let’s be civil, and let’s see how the season plays out. Venting about the program is fine, but beating up on one player doesn’t change anything. There’s a lot of season left, and Ben has earned some patience.
To be fair Kirks issue were never with his sons playing at Iowa. If he hadn't promoted Brian to OC there never was an issue, regardless of how much people want to say that now. As for Ben, I knew this is what the board would look like after yesterdays game. Pretty short leash after taking us to the first elite 8 in 50 years, in his first year. I guess this is truly what have you done for me lately??
 
  • Like
Reactions: Max Rebo

ChicagoHawk2020

All-Conference
Nov 6, 2017
1,320
3,986
112
To be fair Kirks issue were never with his sons playing at Iowa. If he hadn't promoted Brian to OC there never was an issue, regardless of how much people want to say that now. As for Ben, I knew this is what the board would look like after yesterdays game. Pretty short leash after taking us to the first elite 8 in 50 years, in his first year. I guess this is truly what have you done for me lately??
There was the whole Brian apartment issue while he was playing to be fair
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,032
8,582
113
There was the whole Brian apartment issue while he was playing to be fair
Which was available to any other player as well. SO, should Brian have been treated like any other player, or should he have been singled out. I mean that is what many here ***** about right. The coaches kid should be the same as everyone else, right? And frankly you REALLY have to be carrying the torch forward on that one to bring that up a couple of decades later. I suppose you'll be complaining about Pmac getting to many minutes in games around the year 2050?
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
5,032
8,582
113
Why not? Especially when he was getting more minutes than 2 future 1st round NBA draft picks...
Dude seriously. My point was, (and is) why must we continue to rehash stuff that's from 2 decades ago. Poster brings up Brian and the appt deal. So I say Pmac playing time more then 25 years later, (will still be complaining about in 2050). I mean do you guys REALLY have to carry that stuff around decades later? I mean, do what you must, but shite, maybe get over it at some point.....
 

Roncuba65

All-Conference
Aug 15, 2022
1,304
2,178
113
Dude seriously. My point was, (and is) why must we continue to rehash stuff that's from 2 decades ago. Poster brings up Brian and the appt deal. So I say Pmac playing time more then 25 years later, (will still be complaining about in 2050). I mean do you guys REALLY have to carry that stuff around decades later? I mean, do what you must, but shite, maybe get over it at some point.....
Fair. It happened though... and I really never cared about the uproar about Brian, lots of parents quit supporting their children at 18. I am not saying the Ferentz did, but it was a loophole that he took advantage of...
 

7and5baby

Junior
Sep 22, 2018
133
218
43
This is literally the ONE thing Ben could do to QUICKLY turn an entire fan base against him. Yes, this could get ugly fast. Get ready for more of the usual empty seats and fan apathy Ben. Nice job!👎
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Hawkeyes land top 2028 kicker Dima Petrov
  2. 02 On3 Football College Football Rankings: AP Poll Top 25 after Week 11 released
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Football The Chuck Long Podcast
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Inside the rankings on Iowa's 2027 recruiting class
  5. 05 On3 Basketball Women's College Basketball Rankings: AP Poll Top 25 released after Week 2