I will say that when Ben McCollum was originally hired, and a few weeks later Peyton signed -- and was awarded a scholarship -- I was surprised and a little skeptical. The issues with apparent nepotism in both the MBB and football programs have been well-documented, and it seemed like a mistake to give anything close to the appearance of going there again. But I didn’t say anything, because it was the era of good feelings, and everything else Ben was doing was right on the money.
So I get why fans are upset now. There’s a lot of scar tissue there, and that frustration is understandable.
At the same time, I know from years of experience that when a team loses a game or two that fans think they should have won, they are going to look for a scapegoat. And the old “coach played his own kid too much” always makes for some pretty juicy low-hanging fruit.
I think Peyton is an OK player. Not as bad as many are saying, but certainly not great either. Some folks have pointed to his +/- stats, which apparently were among the highest on the team Sunday. On the flip side, I was looking at Evan Miya’s site, and Peyton is listed last on the team in terms of his "Bayesian Performance Rating" (whatever that is). So we can find stats to back up whatever we want.
But here’s a point of context that I think matters: Ben McCollum wants his guys to play a certain way, and to prepare a certain way. It’s about the culture he wants to build in the program. Ben has absolutely no problem benching a guy who isn’t approaching the game the right way, no matter how talented he is. And he’s shown he’s just as willing to run off guys who don’t buy in. If you’re not all-in on his system and his standards, he’ll move on from you and find someone who is. Talent doesn’t buy anyone a pass in his program.
With that in mind, I would venture a guess that Peyton is practicing and playing the way the head coach has instructed, and that’s being rewarded with playing time, even if some of the other guys are more talented.
That said, as good as we all felt last March, I don’t think you can win on culture alone. At the end of the day, we’ve got to get more talent. That, more than anything else, is the biggest reason we’re 2-2. It’s not about who is getting minutes at the end of the bench or in the rotation. It’s about the overall talent level of the roster, and that’s something that gets fixed over time through recruiting and development.
So my plea to everyone is this: Let’s be civil, and let’s see how the season plays out. Venting about the program is fine, but beating up on one player doesn’t change anything. There’s a lot of season left, and Ben has earned some patience.