Toggle sidebar

Nathan Phillips - Stolen Valor

W

WVUBRU

Freshman
Aug 7, 2001
24,731
62
0
Getting an appointment to a military academy in the early 80's (as I don't know if things have changed or not), it was a ton of red tape. Probably not surprising. Prior to your senator recommending the appointment, you had to go through what is like a pre qualification. Part of that was a medical examination. I don't think it is the same as when one enlist or not. But I went to my pediatrician as a junior in high school and he of course knew of my condition. He plainly told me and my mother he would not sign it and advised if he did, I would most likely fail the real one. I was niave and had no clue my issue would keep me from a military career. I was disappointed like never before and we decided as a family not to try any longer for the appointment. I wrote Sen Randolph a letter taking myself out of consideration and thanked him.

I later applied to WVU with no other thought of going anywhere else.
 
W

wvu2007

Senior
Jan 2, 2013
21,220
458
0
Nathan Phillips lied about his military service. Shame, Shame Shame on that no good for nothing liberal.
 
T

TarHeelEer

Freshman
Dec 15, 2002
89,338
59
48
Mntneer said:
It sounds like, from what I read elsewhere, that this guy is doing what a number of other people that joined the military in the early 70's, and that is to not draw the distinction between a Vietnam ERA Vet and a Vietnam Vet.
Click to expand...

No, he didn't skirt the edges.

https://m.cnn.com/en/article/h_1dc42c3dec10ec0d383aa008f55e4bf1

"I’m the one whose all that anger and all that wanting to have the freedom to just rip me apart, that was scary. And I’m a Vietnam veteran and I know that mentality of “There’s enough of us. We can do this."
 
bornaneer

bornaneer

All-Conference
Jan 23, 2014
31,051
1,786
113
WVUBRU said:
Getting an appointment to a military academy in the early 80's (as I don't know if things have changed or not), it was a ton of red tape. Probably not surprising. Prior to your senator recommending the appointment, you had to go through what is like a pre qualification. Part of that was a medical examination. I don't think it is the same as when one enlist or not. But I went to my pediatrician as a junior in high school and he of course knew of my condition. He plainly told me and my mother he would not sign it and advised if he did, I would most likely fail the real one. I was niave and had no clue my issue would keep me from a military career. I was disappointed like never before and we decided as a family not to try any longer for the appointment. I wrote Sen Randolph a letter taking myself out of consideration and thanked him.

I later applied to WVU with no other thought of going anywhere else.
Click to expand...
Sorry you were never able to fulfill your desire to serve your country. West Point will only take the cream of the crop, I know because my nephew went to West Point. I also know that I did not have to take a physical when I was taking AF ROTC at WVU. I also am aware that the list of physical issues that will keep someone from serving is almost endless if they want to avoid service. I also know,as Dog laid it out, that if someone really wants to get into the military.....they can circumvent the physical if necessary. Do you have problem with everyone that avoided service OR only President Donald Trump? That's the real issue......correct?
 
W

WVUBRU

Freshman
Aug 7, 2001
24,731
62
0
bornaneer said:
Sorry you were never able to fulfill your desire to serve your country. West Point will only take the cream of the crop, I know because my nephew went to West Point. I also know that I did not have to take a physical when I was taking AF ROTC at WVU. I also am aware that the list of physical issues that will keep someone from serving is almost endless if they want to avoid service. I also know,as Dog laid it out, that if someone really wants to get into the military.....they can circumvent the physical if necessary. Do you have problem with everyone that avoided service OR only President Donald Trump? That's the real issue......correct?
Click to expand...
I thought I made it clear in a post I have nothing to say about what Trump did. I have never posted an opinion on the subject other than the post saying I resent being compared to him as I was trying to get in and he was attempting to stay out. I didn't criticize his actions but our situations are not comparable.

My problem was the attempt of redefining the well known phrase of "draft dodger".
 
W

WVUBRU

Freshman
Aug 7, 2001
24,731
62
0
On the larger subject of individuals attempting to get out of serving through the draft during the Vietnam war, everyone has their own story. I try not to judge others with these type of things. I am not always successful though.

My opinion on attempting to do whatever to not serve in Vietnam is the same regardless who it is, including Trump. I respect and honor all that did serve and I try to do that in a positive manner. If those individuals that did serve have a problem with those that "dodged" it, I can certainly understand it.
 
Airport

Airport

All-American
Dec 12, 2001
86,914
7,692
113
WVUBRU said:
Getting an appointment to a military academy in the early 80's (as I don't know if things have changed or not), it was a ton of red tape. Probably not surprising. Prior to your senator recommending the appointment, you had to go through what is like a pre qualification. Part of that was a medical examination. I don't think it is the same as when one enlist or not. But I went to my pediatrician as a junior in high school and he of course knew of my condition. He plainly told me and my mother he would not sign it and advised if he did, I would most likely fail the real one. I was niave and had no clue my issue would keep me from a military career. I was disappointed like never before and we decided as a family not to try any longer for the appointment. I wrote Sen Randolph a letter taking myself out of consideration and thanked him.

I later applied to WVU with no other thought of going anywhere else.
Click to expand...
Color blind?
 
E

eerdoc

Redshirt
May 29, 2001
24,014
26
48
TarHeelEer said:
He appears to be a ‘first class’ liar. He, apparenty, claimed th boys were chanting ‘build the wall, build the wall, build the wall... while he was in their faces, beating his drum and chanting. Folks who have viewed the entire incident find no evidence that this was the case. The kid whywas closest to him apparently remained silent throughout. No where on the sound track was the chant he reported ever heard. More fake news readily swallowed, repeated and acted upon by the fake media, most Dems, unfortunately some idiotic Republicans, far too many Catholic “leaders”, some school officials where the kids attended...Too bad so many are so willing to pass judgement on thykids and even issue totally inappropriate threats and condemnations before gathering and analyzing the FACTS of the case. The safety another aspects of their future has been severly compromised by the premature and inappropriate threats and other dialog that has been so prevalent. Sad and so very disgusting!
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom