Name KF's replacement ...

Clonewithasigh

Heisman
Jun 18, 2001
97,126
39,140
113
Iowa State's offense was not that much better either. That tipped pass completion was actually tipped twice! LAF.

Iowa State had 238 yards of total offense.
Which was still more than Iowa. The moral of the story is that the ISU staff determined the Clones could beat the Hawks playing the same game as KF plays. If KF would build some versatility into his game plans and recruit to that strategy, the hawks would be much more dangerous. He refuses to think outside the box so this is what you get.
 

Hawksfor3

All-American
Dec 5, 2016
5,204
6,081
113
I'll go with this guy. Enthusiasm, vocal, good eyes to check the on field action, and urging players on. Chews gum also.

gum GIF
 

Rod_Ironwood

Redshirt
Aug 4, 2025
3
2
3
Hear me out...If Kirk only lasts 1-2 more years based on results, age, etc., but the offense does continue to improve (especially the passing game), do we consider Lester as a strong candidate to become head coach. He's a past head coach at W. Michigan (wasn't spectacular, but had a winning record), he's pretty well liked by the players and knows Iowa Football culture. As much as some fans want to "burn it to the ground" and start over, a lot of Kirk's philosophy has lead to Iowa being a respected, successful football program over the past two decades. Lester can definetly update some things (offense) as he see's fit, but build on the foundation Kirk has laid. Keep Phil Parker if he wants to stay or turn the defense over to Seth Wallace. Slide Warren Ruggerio into OC. Some things change, but a lot of things that have made this program successful stay the same.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anon1751543574

paednoch23

Senior
Oct 23, 2009
387
917
93
…..do we consider Lester as a strong candidate to become head coach. He's a past head coach at W. Michigan (wasn't spectacular, but had a winning record), he's pretty well liked by the players and knows Iowa Football culture.
Good Lord.
 

Amahawk

Senior
May 1, 2002
3,355
627
113
I do not see a need for a lifer. An outstanding up and comer that sticks aroud for 4 or 5 years would be nice. Then find another one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bierhalter
Oct 30, 2023
201
399
63
Tim Polasek is the only guy I want. Iowa OL coach for 4 seasons and current NDSU head coach for those unfamiliar.


My dark horse pick is Drew Tate, although he needs to keep doing well as a Offensive Assistant in the CFL and get an OC/HC job in the CFL/NCAA.
 

hahkize

Senior
Feb 7, 2007
315
482
63
When Hayden joined the Big 10 it was known as the Big 2 and little 8 for a reason. Nice that you count ISU as a power 5 school. In the 20 years Hayden played ISU these are the non-power 5 schools they lost to UNI twice, Drake, Pacific all FCS schools. Wyoming 3 times, Western Mich., and 5 others. Hayden's last 10 years ISU won 29 games.

The first 15 years Hayden played Northwestern they won 29 games or less than 2 wins per year never winning more than 4.

If you want to compare strength of schedule here is some info. Ferentz 3 top 10 schedules Fry 0, Ferentz 4 top 15 schedules Fry 2. Ferentz 6 top 20 schedules Fry 6. Hayden 0 top 10 schedules and 2 top 15.

Played real opponents Ferentz sure did check Iowa’s schedule in 2017 when it was ranked #3 in the country. The non- conference was 8-5 Wyoming, 8-5 ISU, 9-5 North Texas then we played these ranked teams #5 OSU, #7 Wisconsin, #8 PSU, #15 MSU, and #17 NW. 1999 and 2000 were also top 10 schedules. Fry no top 10 schedules.

Fry came to Iowa at the end of Earle Bruce's time at ISU when the Clowns won 8 games each of Bruces' last 3 years and were rated. As you know, they had just renewed the series in '77. There was a lot of political pressure to play the games, as well as contests w/ UNI / Drake to keep $$$ in the state of Iowa. Fry was going to play ISU whether he wanted to or not.


The '99 and 2000 schedules were made several years in advance, before KF was even asked to interview, so KF didn't make those schedules.

KF's 1999 team had Neb and Northern Ill.; 2000 team - K-State West. Mich and Neb; (These were set years in advance so Hayden did have some Top 10 schedules. : )
'01 - Kent St and Miami OH; '02 Akron, Miami OH, Utah St and KF surely had control over Non-con schedules by then.

Ranked opponents for KF are usually Big10 opponents as you noted. He has no control over our Big10 schedule or what any conference teams are ranked.


Fry's SOS in 20 years @ Iowa is 3.88. Over his last 10 years it was 3.84. Link: Sports-Reference - Hayden Fry Record

Fry was 6-7-1 in bowl games. 3 Rose Bowls = 3 Big10 Champs. !st Rose Bowl in his 3rd year, 2nd Rose in yr #7, and the 3rd Rose in year #12 which was w/in his Last 10 years
Fry also had 7 of his LAST 10 teams ranked in top 25 and 6 in top 18, 2 in top 10


Ferentz' SOS in 27 years so far is 3.02. His last 10 complete years is 3.68
KF's 10-11 in bowls w/ 1 Rose Bowl (B1G Champs) and 2 Orange Bowls


Since you brought up Coach Fry, look at the non-con games under both coaches: Grayhair is correct and you're a little disengenuous.

Both played ISU each year possible: Fry vs ISU: 16-4. Ferentz vs ISU: 13-10

(**Note- Didn't count bowl games or Iowa State. Non-P5 teams in Red)

Fry played 23 P4 non-conference opponents in 20 years (NOT counting ISU and Bowl game opponents)


Oklahoma-1

Nebraska-4

Arizona-5

UCLA-1

Penn St-2

North Carolina St-1

Colorado-2

K-State-2

Tennessee-1

Oregon-2

Miami (FL)-2


Northern Illinois-4

UTEP-1

Central Mich-2

Tulsa-4

Cincy-1

New Mexico St-1

Hawaii-3

UNI-2

Drake-1


---------------------
Ferentz has played 13 P4 non-conference games in 27 years (Again, I left out ISU b/c both coaches played every available season)


Nebraska-2

K-State-1

Arizona St-2

Syracue-2

Pitt-4

Arizona-2


Northern Illinois-6

Miami (OH)-5

Western Mich-3

Kent St-3

Ball St-3

North Texas-2

Akron-1

Utah St-1

Buffalo-1

Colorado St-1

Montana-1

Maine-1

UFlorida International-1

Arkansas St-1

Eastern Illinois-1

Nevada-1

Wyoming-1

Tenn Tech-1

Louisiana Monroe-1

Central Mich-1

Missouri St-1

Illinois St-1

UNI-5

No Dakota St-1

Middle Tenn St-1

So Dakota St-1
 

hahkize

Senior
Feb 7, 2007
315
482
63
The next coach needs to have:

- Had successful Head coaching experience, showing the ability to produce significant growth in area(s) of need the 1st year at prior job,
- Proven ability to recruit,
- Worked under successful name coaches, and
- Playing / coaching experience on offense, preferably QB or WR/TE on a highly competitive level
 
  • Like
Reactions: Amahawk

3-D_chess

Senior
Jul 18, 2025
862
947
93
Fry came to Iowa at the end of Earle Bruce's time at ISU when the Clowns won 8 games each of Bruces' last 3 years and were rated. As you know, they had just renewed the series in '77. There was a lot of political pressure to play the games, as well as contests w/ UNI / Drake to keep $$$ in the state of Iowa. Fry was going to play ISU whether he wanted to or not.


The '99 and 2000 schedules were made several years in advance, before KF was even asked to interview, so KF didn't make those schedules.

KF's 1999 team had Neb and Northern Ill.; 2000 team - K-State West. Mich and Neb; (These were set years in advance so Hayden did have some Top 10 schedules. : )
'01 - Kent St and Miami OH; '02 Akron, Miami OH, Utah St and KF surely had control over Non-con schedules by then.

Ranked opponents for KF are usually Big10 opponents as you noted. He has no control over our Big10 schedule or what any conference teams are ranked.


Fry's SOS in 20 years @ Iowa is 3.88. Over his last 10 years it was 3.84. Link: Sports-Reference - Hayden Fry Record
Fry was 6-7-1 in bowl games. 3 Rose Bowls = 3 Big10 Champs. !st Rose Bowl in his 3rd year, 2nd Rose in yr #7, and the 3rd Rose in year #12 which was w/in his Last 10 years
Fry also had 7 of his LAST 10 teams ranked in top 25 and 6 in top 18, 2 in top 10


Ferentz' SOS in 27 years so far is 3.02. His last 10 complete years is 3.68
KF's 10-11 in bowls w/ 1 Rose Bowl (B1G Champs) and 2 Orange Bowls


Since you brought up Coach Fry, look at the non-con games under both coaches: Grayhair is correct and you're a little disengenuous.

Both played ISU each year possible: Fry vs ISU: 16-4. Ferentz vs ISU: 13-10

(**Note- Didn't count bowl games or Iowa State. Non-P5 teams in Red)

Fry played 23 P4 non-conference opponents in 20 years (NOT counting ISU and Bowl game opponents)


Oklahoma-1

Nebraska-4

Arizona-5

UCLA-1

Penn St-2

North Carolina St-1

Colorado-2

K-State-2

Tennessee-1

Oregon-2

Miami (FL)-2


Northern Illinois-4

UTEP-1

Central Mich-2

Tulsa-4

Cincy-1

New Mexico St-1

Hawaii-3

UNI-2

Drake-1


---------------------
Ferentz has played 13 P4 non-conference games in 27 years (Again, I left out ISU b/c both coaches played every available season)


Nebraska-2

K-State-1

Arizona St-2

Syracue-2

Pitt-4

Arizona-2


Northern Illinois-6

Miami (OH)-5

Western Mich-3

Kent St-3

Ball St-3

North Texas-2

Akron-1

Utah St-1

Buffalo-1

Colorado St-1

Montana-1

Maine-1

UFlorida International-1

Arkansas St-1

Eastern Illinois-1

Nevada-1

Wyoming-1

Tenn Tech-1

Louisiana Monroe-1

Central Mich-1

Missouri St-1

Illinois St-1

UNI-5

No Dakota St-1

Middle Tenn St-1

So Dakota St-1
The last time I witnessed a beat-down this complete was when I was behind the bleachers and Joe confused me with Orangeman.
















(Of course I won, who do you think beat his brains out of his skull right before the debate!)
 

Grayhair1981

All-Conference
Sep 3, 2006
576
1,080
93
Fry came to Iowa at the end of Earle Bruce's time at ISU when the Clowns won 8 games each of Bruces' last 3 years and were rated. As you know, they had just renewed the series in '77. There was a lot of political pressure to play the games, as well as contests w/ UNI / Drake to keep $$$ in the state of Iowa. Fry was going to play ISU whether he wanted to or not.


The '99 and 2000 schedules were made several years in advance, before KF was even asked to interview, so KF didn't make those schedules.

KF's 1999 team had Neb and Northern Ill.; 2000 team - K-State West. Mich and Neb; (These were set years in advance so Hayden did have some Top 10 schedules. : )
'01 - Kent St and Miami OH; '02 Akron, Miami OH, Utah St and KF surely had control over Non-con schedules by then.

Ranked opponents for KF are usually Big10 opponents as you noted. He has no control over our Big10 schedule or what any conference teams are ranked.


Fry's SOS in 20 years @ Iowa is 3.88. Over his last 10 years it was 3.84. Link: Sports-Reference - Hayden Fry Record
Fry was 6-7-1 in bowl games. 3 Rose Bowls = 3 Big10 Champs. !st Rose Bowl in his 3rd year, 2nd Rose in yr #7, and the 3rd Rose in year #12 which was w/in his Last 10 years
Fry also had 7 of his LAST 10 teams ranked in top 25 and 6 in top 18, 2 in top 10


Ferentz' SOS in 27 years so far is 3.02. His last 10 complete years is 3.68
KF's 10-11 in bowls w/ 1 Rose Bowl (B1G Champs) and 2 Orange Bowls


Since you brought up Coach Fry, look at the non-con games under both coaches: Grayhair is correct and you're a little disengenuous.

Both played ISU each year possible: Fry vs ISU: 16-4. Ferentz vs ISU: 13-10

(**Note- Didn't count bowl games or Iowa State. Non-P5 teams in Red)

Fry played 23 P4 non-conference opponents in 20 years (NOT counting ISU and Bowl game opponents)


Oklahoma-1

Nebraska-4

Arizona-5

UCLA-1

Penn St-2

North Carolina St-1

Colorado-2

K-State-2

Tennessee-1

Oregon-2

Miami (FL)-2


Northern Illinois-4

UTEP-1

Central Mich-2

Tulsa-4

Cincy-1

New Mexico St-1

Hawaii-3

UNI-2

Drake-1


---------------------
Ferentz has played 13 P4 non-conference games in 27 years (Again, I left out ISU b/c both coaches played every available season)


Nebraska-2

K-State-1

Arizona St-2

Syracue-2

Pitt-4

Arizona-2


Northern Illinois-6

Miami (OH)-5

Western Mich-3

Kent St-3

Ball St-3

North Texas-2

Akron-1

Utah St-1

Buffalo-1

Colorado St-1

Montana-1

Maine-1

UFlorida International-1

Arkansas St-1

Eastern Illinois-1

Nevada-1

Wyoming-1

Tenn Tech-1

Louisiana Monroe-1

Central Mich-1

Missouri St-1

Illinois St-1

UNI-5

No Dakota St-1

Middle Tenn St-1

So Dakota St-1
Speaking of the B1G West:
Iowa conference winning % in KF's first 15 yeas before the West: .533 averaged 4.27 wins; 3.73 losses
Ten years of the West: .677. 5.8 wins; 2.9 losses.

It was fair to point out how bad NW was for much of Fry's tenure. Ditto ISU post Duncan.
He didn't point out how bad the majority of the West teams were during those ten years.
 

Nvhwk

Sophomore
Mar 20, 2025
108
170
43
It is kind of a split of hiring someone on staff and the comfort zone it would bring. But at the same time hiring someone not on staff could bring the excitement of unpredictability for the fans and also being unpredictable for the opposing teams.
 

BunchofAholes

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2025
2,071
3,958
113
When Hayden joined the Big 10 it was known as the Big 2 and little 8 for a reason. Nice that you count ISU as a power 5 school. In the 20 years Hayden played ISU these are the non-power 5 schools they lost to UNI twice, Drake, Pacific all FCS schools. Wyoming 3 times, Western Mich., and 5 others. Hayden's last 10 years ISU won 29 games.
ISU has lost 4 games to FCS schools in the most recent 20 years as well.

What you're also overlooking, if you're comparing overall records is the extra cupcake KFz got every year since the 12 game schedule began in 2006. That's 19 freebies at home against weak opponents.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: SCHawkeye2

Kirbs

Senior
Jan 8, 2023
143
419
63
I’m old. Give me something no one else does at this point. If Iowa is not going to get elite WRs or passing QBs, let’s run the wishbone/flexbone. We can be the service academy of the b10.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SCHawkeye2

OnlyTheObscure

All-Conference
Jul 3, 2025
2,533
3,684
113
I wonder if a school like Iowa could build a winner by overpaying all the top Offensive Lineman to come to Iowa. Run the heck out of the ball.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Amahawk

Pharcyded

All-American
Sep 7, 2021
2,352
5,365
113
Tim Polasek is the only guy I want. Iowa OL coach for 4 seasons and current NDSU head coach for those unfamiliar.


My dark horse pick is Drew Tate, although he needs to keep doing well as a Offensive Assistant in the CFL and get an OC/HC job in the CFL/NCAA.
Hell no. That guy is a tool redneck.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Bierhalter

Pharcyded

All-American
Sep 7, 2021
2,352
5,365
113
For what reason?
He's excelled at whatever position Kirk has put him at. He's probably the top ST coach in the country and if he's not, he's in the top 3. I believe he identifies talent extremely well and plays the correct players. Many of Kirk's best players were coached by Levar. He's innovative but I believe is held back (hunch) with his innovation by Kirk. We saw all the ST plays he came up with the year Iowa stomped OSU, for example. I also think he's at a good age where he's experienced but still hungry. Last but not least, he loves Iowa and the Iowa FB program.
 

JmM52990

Junior
Jan 3, 2017
240
342
63
Idk how no one on hear has mentioned Will Stein the OC at Oregon. Chances are he won’t be at Oregon in 1-2 years and be a head coach somewhere. He’s developed 2 Heisman finalists already in the last two seasons and looks like another one is in the making this year. He’s also a great recruiter. You want someone who can convince recruits the offense will be different than I think he would be a good choice.
 

paednoch23

Senior
Oct 23, 2009
387
917
93
He's excelled at whatever position Kirk has put him at. He's probably the top ST coach in the country and if he's not, he's in the top 3. I believe he identifies talent extremely well and plays the correct players. Many of Kirk's best players were coached by Levar. He's innovative but I believe is held back (hunch) with his innovation by Kirk. We saw all the ST plays he came up with the year Iowa stomped OSU, for example. I also think he's at a good age where he's experienced but still hungry. Last but not least, he loves Iowa and the Iowa FB program.
Dude Iowa needs a re set not a hire from the same regime. Think bigger. Iowa is a big time job. A big time name needs to be the next coach.....with zero KF residue
 

HawkinAZ

Sophomore
Aug 23, 2008
59
100
33
ISU has also lost 4 games to FCS schools in the most recent 20 years.

What you're also overlooking, if you're comparing overall records is the extra cupcake KFz got every year since the 12 game schedule began in 2006. That's 19 freebies at home against weak opponents.
Why waste time proving someone wrong that does not bother checking schedules? But I will. Show me how you got to 19 freebees at home?

Every year Iowa plays ISU with home and away alternating. 2006 Iowa also played at 4-8 Syracuse, 2007 2-10 Syracuse at Home, 2008 at 9-4 Pitt, 2009 8-5 Arizona, 2010 at 7-6 Arizona, 2011 6-7 Pitt, 2012 & 2013 non power 5, 2014 at 6-7 Pitt, 2015 8-5 Pitt. 2016 and beyond the Big 10 went to a nine game schedule.
 

BunchofAholes

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2025
2,071
3,958
113
Why waste time proving someone wrong that does not bother checking schedules? But I will. Show me how you got to 19 freebees at home?

Every year Iowa plays ISU with home and away alternating. 2006 Iowa also played at 4-8 Syracuse, 2007 2-10 Syracuse at Home, 2008 at 9-4 Pitt, 2009 8-5 Arizona, 2010 at 7-6 Arizona, 2011 6-7 Pitt, 2012 & 2013 non power 5, 2014 at 6-7 Pitt, 2015 8-5 Pitt. 2016 and beyond the Big 10 went to a nine game schedule.
Yes, I just sloppily threw out 19 as that was the number of seasons with 12 games. My bad. A closer look at the schedules yields this.

In 20 seasons Hayden played 18 NonP5 teams (3 FCS). That's an average of .9 per year. In 6 seasons the schedule was all P5 teams

In 26 seasons (leaving out the incomplete 2020) Kirk played 49 non P5 teams (including 14 FCS teams) for an average of 1.88/year.

So Kirk played more than twice as many non P5 teams as Hayden. (1.88/yr vs .9/yr) That extra non P5 game helps the win total a bit, especially the FCS opponents. Curiously enough if you scale that difference to 20 years to match Hayden's tenure it's...wait for it... 18 more Non P5 games, not 19. Sorry, I was off by 1.

HAYDEN Non P5 18 (3FCS*) .9/season

79-none

80-none

81-none

82-none

83-none

84-@Hawaii

85-Drake* Northern Ill

86 Northern ILL, UTEP

87 -none

88 @Hawaii

89Tulsa

90-Cincinnati

91-Hawaii

92 Northern ILL

93-Tulsa

94-central MI

95-UNI* New Mexico St

96-Tulsa

97-UNI* Tulsa

98-Central MI

KIRK 49 Non P5 (14FCS*) 1.88/season

99- Northern Ill

00- Western MI

01-Kent ST, Miami OH

02-Akron, Miami OH, Utah St

03-Miami OH, Buffalo

04-Kent st

05-Ball St, UNI*

06-Montana *

07-North Ill

0-8Maine*, Fla Intl

09-UNI*,Ark ST

10-Eastern ILL* Ball ST

11-Tenn Tech, LA Monroe

12-Northern ILL, UNI*

13-Northern Ill, Mizzou St*, Western MI

14-UNI*, Ball St

15-Ill ST*, N Texas

16-Miami OH, NDSU*L

17-Wyoming, NTexas

18-Northern ILL, UNI*

19-Miami OH, Middle Tenn

20-CANCELLED UNI* Northern Ill

21-Kent ST, Colorado st

22-SDSU* Nevada

23-Utah ST, Western MI

24-Ill ST* Troy

25-Marshall, Albany*
 
Last edited:

hawkdave007

Senior
Dec 10, 2003
394
801
93
If KF decides to retire at the end of this season, here are my current top two:

1) Alex Golesh (unless USF flames out)
2) Matt Entz

Golesh is a Big Ten guy and he would "get it" when it comes to the Iowa v. Iowa State rivalry, and it would be fun to see a former Campbell guy beat him on the field.

To me Entz is sorta like Klieman, but younger. I think he's a developer and he'd be good at Iowa.

You probably want to give Nate Scheelhaase and LeVar Woods an interview, but we don't know what we're getting in terms of head coaching material with either of them. I was big on Nate Scheelhaase for a while, but I'm not sure whether he even wants to be a head coach, or even return to college.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LaQuintaHawk

hawkeyemark18

Senior
Aug 16, 2019
256
448
63
If KF decides to retire at the end of this season, here are my current top two:

1) Alex Golesh (unless USF flames out)
2) Matt Entz

Golesh is a Big Ten guy and he would "get it" when it comes to the Iowa v. Iowa State rivalry, and it would be fun to see a former Campbell guy beat him on the field.

To me Entz is sorta like Klieman, but younger. I think he's a developer and he'd be good at Iowa.

You probably want to give Nate Scheelhaase and LeVar Woods an interview, but we don't know what we're getting in terms of head coaching material with either of them. I was big on Nate Scheelhaase for a while, but I'm not sure whether he even wants to be a head coach, or even return to college.
Great to see some names thrown out which allowed me to do some research. Entz looks interesting with his success at North Dakota State. Waterloo native so like Ben in basketball would come in with a passion. LeVar seems the most likely choice on the current staff but I think Beth has to look hard outside the program too. We definitely need to get younger on the coaching side just like we did in basketball.
 

Max Rebo

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2022
570
1,451
93
If KF decides to retire at the end of this season, here are my current top two:

1) Alex Golesh (unless USF flames out)
2) Matt Entz

Golesh is a Big Ten guy and he would "get it" when it comes to the Iowa v. Iowa State rivalry, and it would be fun to see a former Campbell guy beat him on the field.

To me Entz is sorta like Klieman, but younger. I think he's a developer and he'd be good at Iowa.

You probably want to give Nate Scheelhaase and LeVar Woods an interview, but we don't know what we're getting in terms of head coaching material with either of them. I was big on Nate Scheelhaase for a while, but I'm not sure whether he even wants to be a head coach, or even return to college.
I like the Entz suggestion. He seems a lot like Kirk, but a bit less “Fer.”