Mega conferences or more smaller conferences?

Which CFB structure do you prefer?

  • Lets just delete all sports now and become like those futuristic movies where sports dont exist

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    11
  • This poll will close: .

GoHawks2009

Freshman
Feb 18, 2010
15,939
91
48
I think we can all agree that nobody but the media sickos wants these super conferences, and the NFL-lite 20-32 team mega conference. They stand to gain the most from it because they get to only focus on the big matchups they want to see. In their perfect world, we'd have USC-Ohio State, Texas-Oregon, and Alabama-Michigan EVERY week. They'd rather it be like the NFL, except they also forget they (yes, the media) complain about the same problem with the NFL because they don't get Chiefs-Ravens and Chiefs-Packers on Sunday Night and Chiefs-Cowboys on Fox at Noon every single week, and are occasionally forced to watch Chiefs-Jaguars and Chiefs-Falcons and Cardinals-Texans on a Thursday night.

But here we are with a "Power 4" in the loosest of terms because if the B10 and the SEC had their way, it would be an exclusive showdown between those two conferences for CFB supremacy every year (and you can argue all you want about how "well that's how it's been for years, and therefore we should throw out all of CFB history just because all the best moron high school kids want to only go to those schools to keep them at the top of the CFB hierarchy, and of course so they can go to the NFL and what not..........but only after they've made millions and millions of dollars just playing football (or in some cases not even doing that). We're not even talking about the ones that actually f***ing win championships and awards for being recognized as the best at what they do"............................................ why yes, you will certainly try to make that argument and stand on the table believing that with every dying bone in your body). 🙃

So what do we do about it? Why we complain, of course, on social media until nothing changes, because that is how Americans "solve" their problems, right? 😀

And the best part is, reading that will immediately trigger some people into dismissing what I'm saying because this truth hits too close to home for them, and they'd never willingly admit that to some stranger online. 😁 (But it's okay, your secret is safe with me...............)

But let's get to the point of this thread. Are we really gonna sit here and just let college football devolve and consolidate into an untenable structure with just the "best of the best" moneymaking programs playing each other for profit? Or would you rather CFB go back to smaller, more regionally-based conferences? This would mean MORE conferences (aka new conferences or previously-defunct conferences being reborn), but also more opportunities for everyone. This seems like the right thing to do, but the funny thing is, we can't make this happen, you see, because, you see, the people allegedly in charge of college football, along with the TV networks like ESPN and Fox would never allow this simply because it in their minds "wouldn't make them as much money"......you see.

So which is it gonna be?

Complain about the way things are while nothing changes or continues to change for the worse...............or push back at every turn against ways to do what we all know IS THE RIGHT THING TO DO with college athletics, simply because you can't wrap your heads around how it would work, or be allowed to work?

Take your pick. 😃
 

paednoch23

Senior
Oct 23, 2009
417
957
93
I think we can all agree that nobody but the media sickos wants these super conferences, and the NFL-lite 20-32 team mega conference. They stand to gain the most from it because they get to only focus on the big matchups they want to see. In their perfect world, we'd have USC-Ohio State, Texas-Oregon, and Alabama-Michigan EVERY week. They'd rather it be like the NFL, except they also forget they (yes, the media) complain about the same problem with the NFL because they don't get Chiefs-Ravens and Chiefs-Packers on Sunday Night and Chiefs-Cowboys on Fox at Noon every single week, and are occasionally forced to watch Chiefs-Jaguars and Chiefs-Falcons and Cardinals-Texans on a Thursday night.
But here we are with a "Power 4" in the loosest of terms because if the B10 and the SEC had their way, it would be an exclusive showdown between those two conferences for CFB supremacy every year (and you can argue all you want about how "well that's how it's been for years, and therefore we should throw out all of CFB history just because all the best moron high school kids want to only go to those schools to keep them at the top of the CFB hierarchy, and of course so they can go to the NFL and what not..........but only after they've made millions and millions of dollars just playing football (or in some cases not even doing that). We're not even talking about the ones that actually f***ing win championships and awards for being recognized as the best at what they do"............................................ why yes, you will certainly try to make that argument and stand on the table believing that with every dying bone in your body). 🙃

So what do we do about it? Why we complain, of course, on social media until nothing changes, because that is how Americans "solve" their problems, right? 😀

And the best part is, reading that will immediately trigger some people into dismissing what I'm saying because this truth hits too close to home for them, and they'd never willingly admit that to some stranger online. 😁 (But it's okay, your secret is safe with me...............)

But let's get to the point of this thread. Are we really gonna sit here and just let college football devolve and consolidate into an untenable structure with just the "best of the best" moneymaking programs playing each other for profit? Or would you rather CFB go back to smaller, more regionally-based conferences? This would mean MORE conferences (aka new conferences or previously-defunct conferences being reborn), but also more opportunities for everyone. This seems like the right thing to do, but the funny thing is, we can't make this happen, you see, because, you see, the people allegedly in charge of college football, along with the TV networks like ESPN and Fox would never allow this simply because it in their minds "wouldn't make them as much money"......you see.

So which is it gonna be?

Complain about the way things are while nothing changes or continues to change for the worse...............or push back at every turn against ways to do what we all know IS THE RIGHT THING TO DO with college athletics, simply because you can't wrap your heads around how it would work, or be allowed to work?

Take your pick. 😃
I don’t see the coming changes as a tragedy. I see them as a correction.

The state of Iowa was never really big enough for two major college football programs. Iowa has always been the flagship, and if the Hawkeyes had been the only major program all along, we’d probably look a lot more like Nebraska: one fan base, one television audience, one statewide identity.

Meanwhile, a lot of energy over the years was spent maintaining the illusion that Iowa had two nationally relevant brands. One school never seemed comfortable with what it was and spent decades chasing an identity it never quite possessed.

The super league won’t create a new reality. It’ll simply acknowledge the one that was always there.

Markets are ruthless. Pretenders can survive for a while. They rarely survive forever.
 

GoHawks2009

Freshman
Feb 18, 2010
15,939
91
48
I don’t see the coming changes as a tragedy. I see them as a correction.

The state of Iowa was never really big enough for two major college football programs. Iowa has always been the flagship, and if the Hawkeyes had been the only major program all along, we’d probably look a lot more like Nebraska: one fan base, one television audience, one statewide identity.

Meanwhile, a lot of energy over the years was spent maintaining the illusion that Iowa had two nationally relevant brands. One school never seemed comfortable with what it was and spent decades chasing an identity it never quite possessed.

The super league won’t create a new reality. It’ll simply acknowledge the one that was always there.

Markets are ruthless. Pretenders can survive for a while. They rarely survive forever.
Ya know, my favorite part about your line of thinking is that you always think you're right, and are very comfortable and smug in the belief of those ideals..................until you're eventually betrayed by the very principles you believe in. ;)

Of course, you're probably one of those people who will say publicly that you won't be bothered (okay maybe for just a little bit initially) if the system you're defending, and hoping casts Iowa State into college sports purgatory, turns on Iowa and they get left behind as well. You seem very much like an "Ehhh, oh well, it happens. I'll move on and find something else." kind of guy. And that kind of thinking is exactly what's wrong with and needs to get out of college athletics.

I know that's not what you want to hear and I know you'll disagree with it because it goes against your belief structure.......................and that's just too gotdam bad. 😃
 

Palmerhawk

All-Conference
Jul 3, 2025
1,900
3,794
113
Let's get rid of the Internet as well.
While we are at it let's get rid of computers.
And BTN and SEC Network.

Should be rather easy to go back to 1990..just spin the globe backwards.
Sorry,genie is out of the bottle.
 

paednoch23

Senior
Oct 23, 2009
417
957
93
Ya know, my favorite part about your line of thinking is that you always think you're right, and are very comfortable and smug in the belief of those ideals..................until you're eventually betrayed by the very principles you believe in. ;)

Of course, you're probably one of those people who will say publicly that you won't be bothered (okay maybe for just a little bit initially) if the system you're defending, and hoping casts Iowa State into college sports purgatory, turns on Iowa and they get left behind as well. You seem very much like an "Ehhh, oh well, it happens. I'll move on and find something else." kind of guy. And that kind of thinking is exactly what's wrong with and needs to get out of college athletics.

I know that's not what you want to hear and I know you'll disagree with it because it goes against your belief structure.......................and that's just too gotdam bad. 😃
I put up a little thing about Iowa State and, by some miracle of modern civilization, it summoned a four-paragraph report on the defects of my character.
A man who commits himself to the sacred office of Guy Who Takes Message Boards Too Seriously ought to get a ribbon or a commemorative plate.

The interesting part is how fast your boiler started rattling. Most Hawkeye fans spend their energy worrying about the Hawkeyes. You, however, saw an Iowa State post and reacted as though the smoke alarm had gone off. For a fellow flying a Hawkeye banner, you seem awfully interested in the neighbors. Funny thing, that.

And then came the manifesto. Nothing announces “I’m perfectly calm” quite like composing an essay about another man’s fandom.

Human beings are marvelous creatures.

Truly captivating.
 

Istvan Teleky

Redshirt
Nov 3, 2022
23
49
13
I think it will eventually be a hybrid of both.

2 super conferences (B1G and SEC) with their own games and playoffs. NFL style

And then the "smaller FBS conferences" who will be free to have their playoff system as well. Maybe more like the current FBS style.

Bowl games will not go away. Most will be assimilated into the playoff games.

Honestly, I have no issue with Iowa playing more B1G games or cross over games with the SEC than playing Albany, UNI, Northern Illinois. etc.

Either way it is money driven and changes are coming.
 

paednoch23

Senior
Oct 23, 2009
417
957
93
I think it will eventually be a hybrid of both.

2 super conferences (B1G and SEC) with their own games and playoffs. NFL style

And then the "smaller FBS conferences" who will be free to have their playoff system as well. Maybe more like the current FBS style.

Bowl games will not go away. Most will be assimilated into the playoff games.

Honestly, I have no issue with Iowa playing more B1G games or cross over games with the SEC than playing Albany, UNI, Northern Illinois. etc.

Either way it is money driven and changes are coming.
This is the way.
 
Feb 25, 2008
31,209
29,461
113
Let's get rid of the Internet as well.
While we are at it let's get rid of computers.
And BTN and SEC Network.

Should be rather easy to go back to 1990..just spin the globe backwards.
Sorry,genie is out of the bottle.
 
Feb 25, 2008
31,209
29,461
113
I put up a little thing about Iowa State and, by some miracle of modern civilization, it summoned a four-paragraph report on the defects of my character.
A man who commits himself to the sacred office of Guy Who Takes Message Boards Too Seriously ought to get a ribbon or a commemorative plate.

The interesting part is how fast your boiler started rattling. Most Hawkeye fans spend their energy worrying about the Hawkeyes. You, however, saw an Iowa State post and reacted as though the smoke alarm had gone off. For a fellow flying a Hawkeye banner, you seem awfully interested in the neighbors. Funny thing, that.

And then came the manifesto. Nothing announces “I’m perfectly calm” quite like composing an essay about another man’s fandom.

Human beings are marvelous creatures.

Truly captivating.
Too bad he was right about you, though.

It's okay to be hurt by the fact that you'll never live to see Iowa State off of Iowa's schedule. 😉
 

paednoch23

Senior
Oct 23, 2009
417
957
93
Too bad he was right about you, though.

It's okay to be hurt by the fact that you'll never live to see Iowa State off of Iowa's schedule. 😉
People once thought Sears would be around forever. Strange creatures, we are.

I’ve already lived to see ISU off the schedule.

I started going to Iowa games in 1975. Iowa State wasn’t on the schedule. Both schools somehow managed to carry on.

Times change. They seem to be doing so again.

Don’t become an old man shaking his fist at history. History has a poor record of listening
 
Last edited: