Dude. You are wrong. Period. The only thing in the model now is what happened this year. There is ZERO EFFECT of preseason assumptions. They do not enter into the calculations whatsoever. The only data entered is what happened this year. There is no such thing as "they played in game 12 and they were assumed to be so strong at that point factoring in preseason data." We beat a team in week 12 and that team's strength is 100% based on what that team did this year.
Yes, and what that team did this year is determine an adjusted efficiency, which is adjusted according to the quality of the opponent. The derived adjusted efficiency is based on preseason assumptions. So even though at January 22 or whatever, his preseason assumptions are completely removed, the efficiency of the team.at that point is tied to the preseason rankings. As he says in his blog, the preseason assumptions are a factor in the main equation. And in january he starts diminishing the said factor, until the factor is completely removed. That removes the factor, as he says. From that respect, it is completely removed. The problem is the adjusted efficiency of that team at that moment in time is still based on the preseason assumption. What he is talking about in his blog is removing the preseason factor in the equation. That makes the rankings more volatile as he suggests. Do you know why he still included the preseason rank when showing the table?? Because you have to start with the teams ranked somewhere in order to calculate the strength of the opponent, and thus adjust the efficiency. If you didnt do that, the equation would be really unstable in trying to factor in the strength of the opponent, or wildly incorrect if you didnt. In order to factor in the strength of the opponent, there has to be a starting point. That starting point influences your adjusted efficiency, which then influences your strength as an opponent moving forward. And even though with more data, there is convergence, it still has influence.
As to why KenPom is the best, because for the most part, his preseason assumptions and the way he derives them are pretty good, and in the ballpark for most teams. My argument was never that it was crap, or that it doesnt work or any of that. My sole argument is that preseason assumptions do still affect the rankings to some degree even after that little 5 game factor is taken completely out of the equation.