Looking at KenPom, the Big10

Jan 3, 2003
145,534
15,709
0
Exactly. Other than Auburn, which played an atrociously weak schedule, the SEC absolutely **** the bed during nonconference, Kentucky included.

That may build a lie into the metrics, if the SEC’s losses and the B10’s wins were all flukes, but what’s more likely to be the falsehood - the net outcome of hundreds of games or a single fan’s eye test?

once you get to conference play, I would not expect much if any change in your average league measurement/rank, because as stated above Conf play is zero-sum for the Conf.
So it all comes down to non-conf games.
 

DerekMcPwn

Heisman
Sep 13, 2016
5,937
19,655
0
I'm sorry but when Michigan State is the top kenpom B10 team and Michigan is the 3rd, both of whom are rated way better than UK, something is broken. I dont care about the math. Michigan isnt good. We already beat Michigan State. At one point, Michigan went 4-8, two of those losses to teams we beat. Explain it any way you'd like, Kenpom is terribly flawed and far more than usual this year.

That last part is definitively false. As @The_Answer1313 pointed out, KenPom’s predictiveness has been right on the money this year.

I will admit that Purdue is probably a little skewed metrically because they’ve managed to absolutely annihilate several good teams. But that has to be accounted for. Over thousands of possessions, they’ve done some good stuff. They just have really high variance.
 
Jan 3, 2003
145,534
15,709
0
I'm starting to think the main issue people have with these metrics is the inability to predict everything correctly.

If it can't be 100%, why are we bothering lol

it is not possible to predict everything correctly. No 2 teams considered for an at-large birth would have the same winner if they played 100 times. So it is about probabilities.
Back to Purdue being 2 spots ahead of UK. What that is predicting (roughly) is that if they played 100 games Purdue would win 49-52 times (and UK 48-51 times).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big_Blue79
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
it is not possible to predict everything correctly. No 2 teams considered for an at-large birth would have the same winner if they played 100 times. So it is about probabilities.
Back to Purdue being 2 spots ahead of UK. What that is predicting (roughly) is that if they played 100 games Purdue would win 49-52 times (and UK 48-51 times).

Definitely. But I feel like some might be looking for that.

Like if a team overrates or underrates Team X immediately it's called into question all accuracy in said system.

All these things do is try to estimate the true talent level of teams. There are way too many variables to consider to get 100% there, but you do your best to get the majority of the way there.

And then there's also luck.......which no one wants to talk about but plays a huge role in all of this.

Especially in college basketball where you are playing a one and done tournament. In the last four games UVA, went into OT twice, won another game by 4 and another game by a single point. It's not hard to envision a senario where they don't win the title last year.


But just because something can't get 100% of the way, also doesn't mean it's complete trash either.
 
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
In regards to Purdue yeah the line would be close and if they played 100 times it would be near even.

Which is another point to note.

I don't know if it's Purdue or not but I garantee that people will look at records and massively underrate a team from the Big Ten and overrate a team with a good record from a weaker power conference.

We understand this with mid majors. We are well aware that Gonzaga and SD State can have nice records because of the conference they play in. It's repeatedly said well if these teams played in a power conference they'd still be very good teams but they would have more losses.

But that doesn't seem to extend between power conferences. There's a difference this season between the SEC and Big Ten. In Kenpom the average Big Ten team is at 17.49. In the SEC.......10.93. That's a massive gap that I just don't think many take into account.

If we were in the Big Ten I don't think it's a stretch to think we would have 7-10 losses and be grouped with the same teams that our ranking says we are grouped with.
 

kitttysmeow

Freshman
Mar 29, 2007
147
68
0
Just wait until tourney. Big 12 and big 10 well start dropping like flies. Always does. Sec proves all their computer systems wrong. Fact is sec plays uk therefore its a huge game for them, so they get into tourney and knows how to play these big games. Why we see sec still hanging around in elite 8s and final 4s
 
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
Just wait until tourney. Big 12 and big 10 well start dropping like flies. Always does. Sec proves all their computer systems wrong. Fact is sec plays uk therefore its a huge game for them, so they get into tourney and knows how to play these big games. Why we see sec still hanging around in elite 8s and final 4s

But does that really prove anything.

The big ten is going to get a ton of teams in the tournament. Currently 10 of them are projected to be in. But 7 of them are projected 6 seed or worse. Those teams aren't going to go far in the tournament because they will be playing teams they are underdogs to.

So their record will most likely look poor.

That doesn't necessarily prove the conference is tho. The mere fact they get 10 in would be proof that it wasn't.
 

revcort

Heisman
Feb 20, 2003
32,522
30,904
113
Yet.......it's entirely possible should those teams meet on a neutral court, that the line is close to even or we are slight favorites.....but not by much.
Ha! I'm not asking what the line would be. These skewed numbers are flawed. Those same numbers said this UK team would lose at Tennessee and at LSU. But my question is what do YOU think? Do you think Purdue would beat us on a neutral court?The same Purdue that lost by 17 on their home floor to Illinois- the same Purdue team that has lost 4 straight and is STILL rated ahead of UK, winners of 6 straight and 10 of 11?? If so, I got nothing else to say to you about it. You've left the farm.
 
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
Ha! I'm not asking what the line would be. These skewed numbers are flawed. Those same numbers said this UK team would lose at Tennessee and at LSU. But my question is what do YOU think? Do you think Purdue would beat us on a neutral court?The same Purdue that lost by 17 on their home floor to Illinois- the same Purdue team that has lost 4 straight and is STILL rated ahead of UK, winners of 6 straight and 10 of 11?? If so, I got nothing else to say to you about it. You've left the farm.

The point being is Vegas is usually pretty accurate.
If the line was close, it's entirely possible that the two teams are equal.

You keep saying they are skewed, yet we fail to outperform the numbers on a game by game basis. Or we perform just about as expected. That's why the numbers are low to begin with.

And the numbers didn't say UK WOULD lose at Tenn and at LSU. Just that we were slight underdogs in the games. That's all. If anything, taken as a whole, it was predicted we'd win 1 of the 2. If both games were 50/50.........the system would say we only had a 25% of losing both, 25% of winning both and 50% chance of going 1-1.

And yes of course Purdue can beat us on a neutral court. Do I think they'd win the majority of the time? No I don't believe so. Do I think it's about 55/45 tho and a lot closer than you seem to think it is.............of course. And so would Vegas. Or anyone that realizes Purdue plays in a tougher conference and was always going to have more losses.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big_Blue79

DerekMcPwn

Heisman
Sep 13, 2016
5,937
19,655
0
Ha! I'm not asking what the line would be. These skewed numbers are flawed. Those same numbers said this UK team would lose at Tennessee and at LSU. But my question is what do YOU think? Do you think Purdue would beat us on a neutral court?The same Purdue that lost by 17 on their home floor to Illinois- the same Purdue team that has lost 4 straight and is STILL rated ahead of UK, winners of 6 straight and 10 of 11?? If so, I got nothing else to say to you about it. You've left the farm.

Again, I don’t think you’re interpreting the model correctly. What the model says is that on a neutral court Purdue has something like a 51% to win, and that over a thousand Kentucky-Purdue games, most would be decided by a couple points either way.

Having witnessed an entire season of one-possession wins over teams inferior to Purdue, do you really find that prediction shocking?
 

BigBlueFanGA

Heisman
Jun 14, 2005
26,435
23,456
0
Like all computer models, kenpom is full of assumptions. I simply dont agree with you guys. I think the B10 is pretty average as a whole without tremendous separation top to bottom. That results in unexpected wins and losses. How is the first ranking of the year determined?
 
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
Like all computer models, kenpom is full of assumptions. I simply dont agree with you guys. I think the B10 is pretty average as a whole without tremendous separation top to bottom. That results in unexpected wins and losses. How is the first ranking of the year determined?

What happened was the Big Ten at the beginning of the year played so well vs other conferences.

It be really good to have some non conference games later on in the season to see if this changed but unfortunately we just don't. The number of non conference games after Feb 1st has fallen off a cliff. They used to have those bracket buster games I believe years ago but now we get next to nothing.

So basically the system is just going by what it knows.

I mean when two conference teams play.........one is gonna have to lose. It's a net zero. Any increase a team will get from a game, the opposition will get the same decrease. The average will stay the same for the most part.

Is it possible the conference got worse as the season went on? Maybe. But I just don't see anything to suggest that would be the case and I think it's hard to prove. Anyone saying the Big Ten got worse and the SEC improved cannot provide any reasonable logic as to why they think that way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DerekMcPwn

BigBlueFanGA

Heisman
Jun 14, 2005
26,435
23,456
0
What happened was the Big Ten at the beginning of the year played so well vs other conferences.

It be really good to have some non conference games later on in the season to see if this changed but unfortunately we just don't. The number of non conference games after Feb 1st has fallen off a cliff. They used to have those bracket buster games I believe years ago but now we get next to nothing.

So basically the system is just going by what it knows.

I mean when two conference teams play.........one is gonna have to lose. It's a net zero. Any increase a team will get from a game, the opposition will get the same decrease. The average will stay the same for the most part.

Is it possible the conference got worse as the season went on? Maybe. But I just don't see anything to suggest that would be the case and I think it's hard to prove. Anyone saying the Big Ten got worse and the SEC improved cannot provide any reasonable logic as to why they think that way.
Yes, but how is the very first ranking of the year determined?
 
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
Yes, but how is the very first ranking of the year determined?

I don’t know all the details but previous year data and then factoring in incoming freshman.

as the season is played the previous season is weighed less and less until it completely goes away in late Jan I believe.
 
Mar 13, 2004
14,745
12,925
0
What disqualified them from winning the championship? There is no such thing in his system.

There's a trend that every champion is in the top 20 in Ken Pom offense and defense. Smashcat (edit: sorry put YOUR username here initially) can't comprehend that the model doesn't turn off and lock before the tournament, so teams that keep winning through the tournament see their efficiency numbers improve. He seems to think that Ken put his thumb on the scale to boost Duke's numbers. For... reasons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big_Blue79

BigBlueFanGA

Heisman
Jun 14, 2005
26,435
23,456
0
I don’t know all the details but previous year data and then factoring in incoming freshman.

as the season is played the previous season is weighed less and less until it completely goes away in late Jan I believe.
Assumptions for the most part and works from there. Are his probabilities assuming neutral courts or home/away? I dont know.
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
Assumptions for the most part and works from there. Are his probabilities assuming neutral courts or home/away? I dont know.

Yes assumptions to start the year but they play zero factor in his current rankings.

If you’re comparing his net efficiency for teams it’s based on neutral court vs average D1 team per 100 possessions.
 
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
Assumptions for the most part and works from there. Are his probabilities assuming neutral courts or home/away? I dont know.

They home/away are factored in the predictions. It's the standard 3 point bump if at home.

Yeah just about with anything, you know very little at the beginning of the year and as the season plays itself out, it becomes more and more accurate.

Tho he has this in the model diagnostics I find interesting. He breaks down the MAE by month

Nov = 9.32
Dec = 9.10
Jan = 9.00
Feb = 8.34

So it gets better as the year goes on but it's pretty accurate even in Nov.
 

BigBlueFanGA

Heisman
Jun 14, 2005
26,435
23,456
0
Yes assumptions to start the year but they play zero factor in his current rankings.

If you’re comparing his net efficiency for teams it’s based on neutral court vs average D1 team per 100 possessions.
Thanks. There is no way on Gods green earth Purdue would win close to 50% against us on a neutral court. They would be hard pressed to win 25%. The same could be said about at least a third of the teams above us, Gonzaga in particular.
 

Big_Blue79

All-Conference
Apr 2, 2004
52,487
2,147
0
Lost faith in KenPom in 2015 when Duke didn’t qualify to win a championship per his system but their numbers suddenly got better as they advanced in the NCAAs to make them a KemPom qualifier.

Yes, their "numbers suddenly got better" as they continued to beat good (read: NCAA Tournament) teams. Also, wut?

Anybody that thinks that Purdue is better than UK is living in a dream world. We have beaten MSU (9 losses) and Uavel BOTH of whom are in the top 9 in KenPom. Ridiculous. Again, the fatal flaw in these rankings is they don't take into consideration improvement. We're way better than the fluky loss to Evansville and some of the other early season losses.
Latest Oddshark odds:
These are before last night's win against UF
UK 20-1
MSU 20-1
Purdue 75-1
Michigan 50-1
Iowa/ILL 75-1
Penn State 40-1

The teams listed below UK at higher odds are ALL ranked ahead of us in KenPom. So, clearly Vegas is rating us ahead of many teams vs. the KenPom system. I guess we'll find out who's right soon enough.

Books bring in money from sharps and the general public. UK is a public team (i.e. draws dumb public money at a high rate), which means that UK always has better (or worse, if you're betting on them) odds than they would in a world where they were not a public team. Also something like KenPom factors in performance, not ceiling. UK has a much higher ceiling than those teams (I suppose), but that doesn't mean they have the better median outcome.

Also, most models take into account improvement, such as KenPom: The inputs into the pythagorean equation are the team’s adjusted offensive and defensive efficiencies. Any time you see something “adjusted” on this site, it refers to how a team would perform against average competition at a neutral site. For instance, a team’s offensive efficiency (points scored per 100 possessions) is adjusted for the strength of the opposing defenses played. I compute an adjusted offensive efficiency for each game by multiplying the team’s raw offensive efficiency by the national average efficiency and dividing by the opponent’s adjusted defensive efficiency. The adjusted game efficiencies are then averaged (with more weighting to recent games) to produce the final adjusted offensive efficiency. https://kenpom.com/blog/ratings-explanation/.

That said, all these models (and the garbage RPI before it) tend to get stick with deep conferences with lots of good (and few bad) teams, leading to clusters of teams with meh records and good model scores. The MVC (RPI days) was notorious for this, as was the Big 12 circa five years ago. This year it's the B1G. But it's not based on bias or preseason ratings or unwarranted assumptions or not factoring in improvement or any of the other BS spouted in this thread by people who just don't understand how these systems work.
 

revcort

Heisman
Feb 20, 2003
32,522
30,904
113
Looking at Purdue's record, I think I see the flaw in KenPom. Purdue is rated so highly based on winning by large margins in several of their games. KenPom loves those large margins. Kentucky hasn't won games by large margins, which is one reason the Cats are rated so poorly considering their record. So, Purdue "must be better based on the numbers." Apparently, blow-out losses don't hurt you in KenPom, though, because Purdue has multiple games they've lost by 10+ points. (They have 7 such losses) How many 10+ point losses does UK have? ZERO.

Kenpom places great value on these large margins but doesn't place as much value on the most important number of all, which is a win of any margin. That's what this Kentucky team has done- they just win. They don't care if it's by 1 point or 10. That's something Purdue hasn't done so well... FOURTEEN TIMES.

Trust me on this, Purdue isn't a better team than UK, and it's not close. They are a case study on inconsistency. Isn't consistency what matters? What are the chances UK could win 6 games in a row by 2-10 points? High. What are the chances Purdue could? Zero. They haven't done it all season. They haven't won more than 3 games in a row all season. Look at how Purdue and UK are rated by Sagarin, a system that values winning more than margin... UK #6 and Purdue #32. That's about right.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: FltDoc
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
Kenpom definitely factors in blowout losses.......they hurt as much as blowout wins help. It's all about efficiency numbers. It's basically scoring margin just on a possession level instead of total score to even the playing field between teams that play at a slow pace vs teams that play at a faster pace.

What's keeping Purdue where they are at is essentially the SOS and the fact they play in the Big Ten.

This isn't a flaw tho. In pretty much any sport, scoring margin is a better indicator of future success than actual W/L record. So it's not a flaw but rather what the systems deems important because years and years of testing that's what has been important.

I will admit Purdue is a strange case. They have blown out some very good teams and they have gotten blown out by some teams.

I know people want to put a value on wins and that's great. We are going to get a good seed because of that. And it shouldn't take away from what UK has done this season.

But if you are constantly playing close games against teams that might not even make the tournament, what do you think is going to happen when we do face tournament teams?

It's not a UK thing. If ANY team was playing close games time and time again, I wouldn't feel confident in them winning 6 in a row in the tournament. I'm not sure how anyone could. If u keep playing in close games, one missed shot, one bad bounce, a bad call..........and you're out.
 

revcort

Heisman
Feb 20, 2003
32,522
30,904
113
Kenpom definitely factors in blowout losses.......they hurt as much as blowout wins help. It's all about efficiency numbers. It's basically scoring margin just on a possession level instead of total score to even the playing field between teams that play at a slow pace vs teams that play at a faster pace.

What's keeping Purdue where they are at is essentially the SOS and the fact they play in the Big Ten.

This isn't a flaw tho. In pretty much any sport, scoring margin is a better indicator of future success than actual W/L record. So it's not a flaw but rather what the systems deems important because years and years of testing that's what has been important.

I will admit Purdue is a strange case. They have blown out some very good teams and they have gotten blown out by some teams.

I know people want to put a value on wins and that's great. We are going to get a good seed because of that. And it shouldn't take away from what UK has done this season.

But if you are constantly playing close games against teams that might not even make the tournament, what do you think is going to happen when we do face tournament teams?

It's not a UK thing. If ANY team was playing close games time and time again, I wouldn't feel confident in them winning 6 in a row in the tournament. I'm not sure how anyone could. If u keep playing in close games, one missed shot, one bad bounce, a bad call..........and you're out.
UK has a much better shot at winning 6 in a row than Purdue. Kentucky has won 6 in a row twice, including their current streak which includes 3 difficult true road wins.

I still say the Big Ten is an overrated conference. Now, if you're talking about raw number of good teams, they're the best. But if you're talking about teams that could make a Final Four or have a shot to win it all? I don't see even one.
 
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
UK has a much better shot at winning 6 in a row than Purdue. Kentucky has won 6 in a row twice, including their current streak which includes 3 difficult true road wins.

I still say the Big Ten is an overrated conference. Now, if you're talking about raw number of good teams, they're the best. But if you're talking about teams that could make a Final Four or have a shot to win it all? I don't see even one.

In the end I don't think it'll matter. I don't think Purdue even makes the tournament. They are current in the first four out category on Bracket Matrix so if they do make it, it'll be close.

Yeah but what makes a conference? I agree with you. I mean maybe Maryland can make a final four. But as a whole, you're facing a good team almost every single night. So even tho they might not have that final four caliber group of teams, you are going to rack up quite a bit of losses facing all those good teams.

As far as UK's position in Kenpom. The line came out for the Texas A&M game. UK is favored by 7. A quick look at Kenpom predicts a UK win 67-60......once again matching the Vegas line of 7. I see this on a consistent basis which makes me think that where UK is at is probably accurate. As such there's quite a bit of games where we would be underdogs in.

But you know we are always a tough out in the tournament and usually playing our best basketball. So it is what it is at this point. I just sit there hope for a good seed which I think we'll get, an easy road and let's see what we can do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big_Blue79

Nooneputsbabyinacorner

All-Conference
Aug 19, 2013
2,849
1,008
0
Looks like some kind of super conference this season. All 12 of their teams are in the top 36 of KenPom. This is the genesis of Pomeroy's issues. What they really are is a bunch of mediocre teams, with not a single dominant team among them, beating up on each other all season. One of the biggest evidences of this is the fact that Purdue is 14-14 and 2 spots ahead of #27 Kentucky at #25. How in the world can that be? That is an embarrassment to KenPom in my opinion. There is no question that the Big10 metrics are all screwed up this year.

They have destroyed all the top teams they've played out of conference.
 
May 27, 2007
32,244
25,613
113
FWIW if people really want to know why we are where we are in Kenpom it's this

Offensive stats
Eff FG% = 136th
Turnover % = 112th
Rebounding = 86th
Free Throw Rate = 10th

Defensive Stats
Eff FG% = 14th
Turnover % = 283rd
Rebounding % = 204th
Free Throw Rate = 167th

Outside of getting to the line on offense and our opponents Eff FG% on defense, there's not much we do well on either side of the ball. And while basketball is down as a whole this year, our ranks in these categories are way down from previous Cal teams. On offense, we usually rebound way better. We haven't this season. And we haven't shot the ball well enough to compensate for that.

On defense while our fg% is awesome.......not turning teams over and not rebounding well we are giving teams so many additional shots.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big_Blue79
Mar 10, 2003
5,927
11,325
93
So what I’m getting from all this is to have a great Ken Pom Ranking for Teams in your conference is to have the perfect storm of returning veteran teams who will peak out early in non-conference games, and then have them beat up on each other?

I would be interested to compare the non conference opponents experience levels despite rankings when they played. To me the Big 10 played great early in the season but haven’t improved as the season progressed.
 
A

anon_ddojbbh8q7xrt

Guest
Are you serious bro. Big Ten has at least 6 second round teams. Do you even follow college basketball?

Maryland
PSU
MSU
Iowa
OSU
Michigan

At the very least.
 
A

anon_013cn8yrfncx2

Guest
I said it in another thread that I believe the BIG10 is full of mostly middle of the pack teams. I just don't see a legit title contender in the bunch and won't be surprised to see most of them out of the NCAA Tournament in the first weekend.

Don’t know about this but do you remember when Wayne Duke was the selection chair and The Big10 got 7 teams in amongst a lot of pushback.

It was the year where Purdue was a 1 seed and came within a shot at the buzzer that missed of becoming the first 1 seed to lose to a 16 seed. The other B10 teams all lost their first game and Purdue went on to lose their next game.

No relation to this year but they have a history.
 

fatguy87

All-American
Oct 8, 2004
13,764
9,093
0
But if you are constantly playing close games against teams that might not even make the tournament, what do you think is going to happen when we do face tournament teams?

It's not a UK thing. If ANY team was playing close games time and time again, I wouldn't feel confident in them winning 6 in a row in the tournament. I'm not sure how anyone could. If u keep playing in close games, one missed shot, one bad bounce, a bad call..........and you're out.

Regarding close games, just take a look at a couple of our recent tussles at Rupp. There were definitely some calls down the stretch against Ole Miss and Florida that could have been missed by the referee. The referee could've missed that call in the Florida game where the defender reached in and knocked it off Nick's foot. It would have been Florida's ball with a chance to tie or take the lead. We also had a 50/50 call that went our way late against Ole Miss. If a ref makes a mistake and doesn't make those calls, there's a chance that we are 0-2 in our last 2 games at Rupp. Being unable to blow teams out, even the bad ones, puts us in a position to lose for reasons out of our control
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big_Blue79

Nooneputsbabyinacorner

All-Conference
Aug 19, 2013
2,849
1,008
0
B1G has 14 teams and Northwestern and Nebraska can't possibly be anywhere near the top 36. They might be the 2 worst power 5 teams in the country.

They'll get in a minimum (and deservedly so) of 8 of their 14 teams. The Big12 will get no more than 5. The ACC should get 3, but will probably get 6. The SEC should get 2, but maybe get 4. The PAC shouldn't get any, but will probably get 4.
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
Don’t know about this but do you remember when Wayne Duke was the selection chair and The Big10 got 7 teams in amongst a lot of pushback.

It was the year where Purdue was a 1 seed and came within a shot at the buzzer that missed of becoming the first 1 seed to lose to a 16 seed. The other B10 teams all lost their first game and Purdue went on to lose their next game.

No relation to this year but they have a history.

i think you’re talking about 96 but the Big Ten only got five teams in that year and Iowa made the second round before losing as well.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Kentucky vs. Missouri Availability Report: Starting WR Could Return
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Jerone Morton nears Kentucky debut, Trent Noah officially week-to-week
  3. 03 KSR Football Will Stein Show Recap: Who's Improved the Most for Kentucky?
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Kam Williams is showing rust, but Mark Pope is confident he'll 'get his vibe back'
  5. 05 KSR Football Will Stein knows Missouri is better than its recent losses suggest