Laviano to start

JPhoboken

Senior
Mar 15, 2005
11,963
585
0
ru-baby said: ↑
* Asked whether he is considering playing both QBs, Flood reiterated Laviano is his starter and he doesn't want anyone looking over their shoulder at that position.///////:

when did he say this? he just said post game Saturday that he was never in this situation before and (appeared to suggest) was completely open to doing something a bit different..at least come off this hard stance. Did he really flip back to that stance last 24 hours and what could he have seen in the film to caused such a flip-flop

At a minimum, I'd want Laviano to look over his shoulder which might help his off field decision making.

Regardless. Good Luck to us. We have options. I think Flood will be much more likely to pull the trigger this year and not lose games to rigid stance on matters....(hope so)

Flood already reversed course again today, saying he won't pull him for a mistake, doesn't want him looking over his shoulder.

In my mind, this decision was made probably over a week ago. Flood said he would decide at halftime what to do. Well, there was no reason to take Rettig out, based on his good performance and what he had said, but he planned all along to give Laviano the 2nd half.

Caroo let the cat out of the bag when he was talking to Laviano before halftime and he knew he was starting the 2nd half.

I don't think most of us arguing for Retting are adamant about it based on performance. We are not there every day. Again, I know we will all support whoever is in there, but.

1. Rettig played great in the first half and didn't have caroo to rely on.
2. Rettig followed team rules and was not suspended.

I hope we get a chance to see both play meaningful minutes this year.
 

RUbacker

Heisman
Dec 5, 2014
16,232
23,249
108
You are hanging your anlaysis on Dodd's MVP performance in Italy? What about his performance against ND in the bowl game? Three picks and three missed TD passes.
There are still people holding on to some little back up from the past. You will always these posters who just always root for the back up. They are annoying. Coaches see these guys every day and this poster thinks he has a the better answers. Lol
 

NickKnight 1

All-Conference
Mar 22, 2003
8,778
2,052
0
* Asked whether he is considering playing both QBs, Flood reiterated Laviano is his starter and he doesn't want anyone looking over their shoulder at that position.///////:

Just saw above. Appearance of fairness again voided. Shame. At the very least seeing what we have you play two and give them chances.

Nothing more to say on this, other than thought the favorite days were done w nova completinh his days. Guess its how flood operates.

What could happen if he is looking over his shoulder,is maybe he would stay
in and look at film, instead of running over to a bar, with false ID. Yes for either
one looking over the shoulder is good, for the competition, better than being
confident that the coach says its me no matter what. " look at me I screwed up
and I'm still the starter."
 
Nov 29, 2011
384
377
0
Flood already reversed course again today, saying he won't pull him for a mistake, doesn't want him looking over his shoulder.
.
Flood on his decision: ""And I don't want any player in our program looking over their shoulder worried that they would be pulled out of a game because they made a mistake... Ultimately I've got to look at the body of work and make a decision based on what gives our team the best opportunity to be 1-0, just like we do at every position."

We heard almost the same exact words over and over again regarding Nova. One thing for sure, Flood is stubborn. I'm not expecting Rettig to see the field.
 

RUTrack94

All-American
Nov 15, 2008
11,549
5,319
113
Flood already reversed course again today, saying he won't pull him for a mistake, doesn't want him looking over his shoulder.

In my mind, this decision was made probably over a week ago. Flood said he would decide at halftime what to do. Well, there was no reason to take Rettig out, based on his good performance and what he had said, but he planned all along to give Laviano the 2nd half.

Caroo let the cat out of the bag when he was talking to Laviano before halftime and he knew he was starting the 2nd half.

I don't think most of us arguing for Retting are adamant about it based on performance. We are not there every day. Again, I know we will all support whoever is in there, but.

1. Rettig played great in the first half and didn't have caroo to rely on.
2. Rettig followed team rules and was not suspended.

I hope we get a chance to see both play meaningful minutes this year.
True ... But then you need to bench Caroo, too.
 

RUsSKii

Senior
Nov 10, 2009
28,780
755
0
I have no preference between Rettig and Laviano and will support whomever starts at QB. However, it's absurd to me that posters are using a curfew violation and caught using a fake ID as a reason to justify benching the QB that the coaches feel gives us the greatest chance to win games.

For the record, I'll reiterate that the 21-year-old U.S. drinking age law is laughable and outright flouted for a large number of reasons. Oh, and many college students obtain fake IDs so they can enter more fun bars and lounge establishments, not to get "fu**ked up at the club" which can be done at any campus house or frat party. Even mentioning that phrase tells me you're way out of touch with the lives of twenty-something year olds.

Now you may carry on with your football-related arguments,.
 

RUScrew85

Heisman
Nov 7, 2003
30,054
16,939
0
I would have preferred Rettig based on Laviano's play last year. But we don't know enough about either as starters to determine if the right choice is being made. That said if HCKF says they'll both play then who actually takes the first snap is irrelevant.

This thread really supports the notion that the most popular player on a football team is the back-up QB.

It's a long season and as long as HCKF has an open mind we'll be fine.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,185
90,330
113
I have no preference between Rettig and Laviano and will support whomever starts at QB. However, it's absurd to me that posters are using a curfew violation and caught using a fake ID as a reason to justify benching the QB that the coaches feel gives us the greatest chance to win games.

For the record, I'll reiterate that the 21-year-old U.S. drinking age law is laughable and outright flouted for a large number of reasons. Oh, and many college students obtain fake IDs so they can enter more fun bars and lounge establishments, not to get "fu**ked up at the club" which can be done at any campus house or frat party. Even mentioning that phrase tells me you're way out of touch with the lives of twenty-something year olds.

Now you may carry on with your football-related arguments,.

Also, maybe Laviano wanted to get into a club that had a HIGHER CEILING. :flush:
 

scarletrat

All-Conference
Aug 28, 2003
10,990
1,048
0
This is so typical Flood. This is why I never wanted him as HC. Now it gives greater credibility that Rettig never truly a fair shot, in camp or against NSU.

I would have been fine playing both against WSU as they appear to have slightly different strengths. Many schools successfully do this--Wisconsin did last year.

That said, based on what I've seen as a fan, I'm leaning with Rettig because I do think he has more upside and importantly, our offense features throwing the ball deep. Going back to Teel, and since continuing to play the pro style, thought Rettig fit the offense better.

I hope Flood's stubbornness on QBs doesn't cost us games.

There are no excuses against WSU.
 

bitnez

All-American
Jan 18, 2006
6,791
7,834
113
I'm disappointed but not surprised. I think we see Rettig starting before the end of the season.
 

RUsojo

Heisman
Dec 17, 2010
30,228
29,693
113
I wish I was utterly surprised by the negative tone in this thread after both quarterbacks had positive performances.

Both should play each week and who starts each week is almost irrelevant. After a few more games and a bigger sample size the right decision can be made.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BLewis1968

IL Lusciato

Heisman
Oct 31, 2011
10,680
13,292
0
Now they are posting criminal statutes on here. Again, my point is 100% correct. People are busy trying to tear down Laviano b/c he is playing very and has earned the spot. They would rather laviano be kicked off the team or worse just to get Rettig to start, even though Rettig prob does not give us the best chance to win football games.

Its really sick stuff.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ruready07
Nov 29, 2011
384
377
0
That said if HCKF says they'll both play then who actually takes the first snap is irrelevant.
Flood said today: "I don't want any player in our program looking over their shoulder worried that they would be pulled out of a game because they made a mistake. Right now Chris is the starting quarterback." I don't read those words and think both will be playing.
 

Rutgers1976

Senior
Dec 30, 2005
3,438
769
0
I wasn't surprised in the least to see Laviano in the 2nd half vs. Norfolk. I thought Rettig had plenty of poise for his first start. Laviano had the advantage of Carroo and the worn down Norfolk defense. He ran the uptempo offense with almost all running plays.

Rettig was laughing with others on the sideline during the 3rd quarter so I can't see how anybody under say he was pissed.

What if e Wazzu game is handled as the reverse with a plan to play Rettig in the 2nd half--another way to keep TTFP guessing a little.

Nobody can say for sure if the decision was Laviano all along or anything about what the thought process of the coaching staff has been or will be. And to judge the decision in advance is just plain silly. Win and it's the right decision, Los and it was wrong. Make the correct prediction and "I told you so".
 

Calazzus

Freshman
Apr 25, 2012
87
88
18
You honestly believe that?
Come off the ledge and root for Laviano to have a great half and that hopefully Flood gives Rettig a lot of snaps too.

Let's remember, if the Norfolk LB didn't pull a James Townsend the first half score could have been different.
Let's not forget if that DB was D 1A size and talented, that TD to Caroo may have been an INT or broken up.
 

NBKnight

Heisman
Jul 8, 2008
24,757
15,666
61
This is so typical Flood. This is why I never wanted him as HC. Now it gives greater credibility that Rettig never truly a fair shot, in camp or against NSU.

I would have been fine playing both against WSU as they appear to have slightly different strengths. Many schools successfully do this--Wisconsin did last year.

That said, based on what I've seen as a fan, I'm leaning with Rettig because I do think he has more upside and importantly, our offense features throwing the ball deep. Going back to Teel, and since continuing to play the pro style, thought Rettig fit the offense better.

I hope Flood's stubbornness on QBs doesn't cost us games.

There are no excuses against WSU.

Wisconsin is a different situation and it was not very successful.

Stave completely lost it in camp and McEvoy played poorly early leading to losses to LSU, where they had a nice lead, and NW. Once Stave got his confidence back they played much better.

Beyond that, Stave and McEvoy were much different types of QB, which is not the case here. McEvoy is no longer at QB this year.
 
Dec 17, 2008
45,214
16,775
0
I didn't realize Flood changed positions. It doesn't sound like Rettig is going to get time unless there's garbage time. No plans to use 2 qbs Saturday.

It sounds like it's settled and in that respect I prefer it even if it's not the guy I preferred. I'm not a big fan of shuffling 2 qbs so the quicker it's settled the better. Hopefully, it's the right choice. Again undoubtedly there are going to be rough patches and I'm with Flood on letting the chosen guy work through them. Maybe not as much rope as Nova had at times but definitely some. First 1-2 INT thrown and I can see the pitchforks come out. There has to be some leeway how much though is subjective.
 
  • Like
Reactions: winRU
Dec 17, 2008
45,214
16,775
0
I figured that but even long leash is subjective. I mean Nova had a leash that went around the block a couple times. Is it going to be like that, not as much.... hard to know and it's subjective.
 

ClassOf02v.2

Heisman
Sep 30, 2010
14,020
15,693
103
Now they are posting criminal statutes on here. Again, my point is 100% correct. People are busy trying to tear down Laviano b/c he is playing very and has earned the spot. They would rather laviano be kicked off the team or worse just to get Rettig to start, even though Rettig prob does not give us the best chance to win football games.

Its really sick stuff.

I think you've lost some credibility with this post. Saying that people here would rather see CL kicked off the team is absurd. You initially seemed pretty reasonable with your argument for supporting Laviano, but you've just gotten as bad (if not worse) than the Rettig supporters you're criticizing.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,410
113
can someone inform me as to why this decision is causing so much angst. I really do not see the issue here. The board isn't at practice or privy to exactly how each guy has commend yet there are those that insist that Rettig is the better choice or has the better ceiling based on nothing but opinion

don't make this out to be more controversial than it is just because your guy didn't get picked
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,185
90,330
113
can someone inform me as to why this decision is causing so much angst. I really do not see the issue here. The board isn't at practice or privy to exactly how each guy has commend yet there are those that insist that Rettig is the better choice or has the better ceiling based on nothing but opinion

don't make this out to be more controversial than it is just because your guy didn't get picked
Thank you. A voice of reason.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

rutgers4life11

All-Conference
Jan 22, 2014
2,951
2,450
66
There are still people holding on to some little back up from the past. You will always these posters who just always root for the back up. They are annoying. Coaches see these guys every day and this poster thinks he has a the better answers. Lol

Oh, of course.. the fans are delusional! The coach is always right! Sorry to burst your bubble, but we may be the only team in power 5 history that has had a QB throw for 5 or more interceptions TWICE, and still inexplicably keep him in the game.

I doubt any other D1 coach would do the same thing.

Look, there is one insanely simple reason why this backup issue is a big deal for fans. We can all acknowledge Gary Nova was an incredible practice QB, he lit up mediocre teams marvelously, and had all the on-paper ability you could ever ask for in a QB... but when it came to game-time situations against good defenses... he crumbled. Time and time again. It was so apparent that opposing linebackers would joke about it after games, saying that they studied his film, and knew exactly how to target him to make mistakes.

Somehow Flood could not look beyond this glaring flaw. He just saw the perfect recruit. The perfect practice QB. And stubbornly would not explore ANY other possibilities. This is why so many of us are worried right now. In last year's case, thankfully the Fridge understood Nova's limitations and that's why the gameplan altered so much, and focused more on check downs, establishing the run, using kroft as a blocker, and keeping him comfortable. But it still didn't work against elite defenses! I mean you guys remember those massive blowouts right? Or how if we threw one less interception to PSU, we would have beat them, right?

The reality of the QB position is some kids are just gamers. They're wired for it. And most importantly, some may not seem the greatest on paper/practice, but have a way of bringing it against top competition. Drew Brees being the poster child for it.

As fans pushing for a backup all those years... our point was that we NEVER got to see anyone else. No one got a legitimate chance. And that's fine if you have an unbelievable QB up there, who brings it against the best... but was it worth committing to a QB that would falter against a solid defense?

In the case of Dodd, you can go ahead and knock him for a couple bad games (none of which were anything like the horror shows Nova put us through), but the guy went to a league of professional players that still pulls in former NFL and elite college players and absolutely destroyed it. To the point that he was put on the Italian Madden cover. Now, obviously who knows if he'd ever have been able to do it here, but the one takeaway is that this kid had some intangibles working for him. And there were plenty of times where he showed it here at RU. As for the Notre Dame game... we'll never know if it would have been a different outcome if he was given a full season to play, build chemistry and master the offense. Instead, the guy was kind of just thrown in there out of desperation at the end of the season.

As for this decision, I think some of us are just worried Flood is walking down another close-minded path. The simple pragmatic solution would have been to do a 2 qb system until one separates from the other, since it's so close - but he didn't. Thankfully, both look sharp... and like some people have already mentioned - as long as the entire offensive staff is in unison (fridge and mcdaniels) then sure. But I can't imagine everyone was in unison when Nova threw 6 ints, and Flood stubbornly kept him in there. Let's just hope Flood has learned from those mistakes, and of course wish both QBs best of luck.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JQRU91 and G- RUnit

RU4Real

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
50,955
30,734
0
I'll say this - if anybody comes on this board after next week's game and gloats about booing Laviano because he's not "their guy", I will personally set them on fire.

And you can ask people - I've done that before.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Proud NJ Sports Fan

JPhoboken

Senior
Mar 15, 2005
11,963
585
0
can someone inform me as to why this decision is causing so much angst. I really do not see the issue here. The board isn't at practice or privy to exactly how each guy has commend yet there are those that insist that Rettig is the better choice or has the better ceiling based on nothing but opinion

don't make this out to be more controversial than it is just because your guy didn't get picked

Angst? Kicked off the team? What is all this craziness. THis is a Football board. We are discussing the biggest decision the coach can make. FOr the most part, people are expressing their views calmy and reasonably. Nothing we say really matters. Who care if there is a controversy on a message board? Please explain to me why it cant be discussed?

Geez, all off season, people complained we shouldn't be discussing OTs. Now we can't discuss Picking a starting QB? Bac, this is in no way directed just at you, but this is the most we have talked about football since last year, so controversial or not, as long as people are being reasonable, lets have at it. The board should be fun going back and forth this time of year!!!!
 

bitnez

All-American
Jan 18, 2006
6,791
7,834
113
can someone inform me as to why this decision is causing so much angst. I really do not see the issue here. The board isn't at practice or privy to exactly how each guy has commend yet there are those that insist that Rettig is the better choice or has the better ceiling based on nothing but opinion

don't make this out to be more controversial than it is just because your guy didn't get picked

Because we're a fan board and everyone has an opinion. If people would just let everyone voice their opinion it wouldn't be an issue. Instead, there are folks who feel the need to constantly remind those who have voiced an opinion in favor of Rettig that (a) they aren't at practice, (b) didn't coach and/or (c) have no idea what they are talking about because of (a) and/or (b).
 
  • Like
Reactions: winRU
Feb 5, 2003
11,004
9,426
113
You will always these posters who just always root for the back up. They are annoying.
By all reports, the competition was very close. If Rettig had been chosen as the starter, would you be as critical of anyone thinking Laviano looked better than Rettig on Saturday?

Both played well. I liked what Rettig did more overall but am not at all the practices. I hope whoever is playing for Rutgers helps us win, and I hope the guys on the sideline are ready to kick butt if/when their time comes.
 

MS-RU

Heisman
Aug 9, 2013
9,530
14,225
67
Laviano might not be a short leash from Flood but a large portion the fanbase will be screaming for a change after the 1st turnover. It's going to get really annoying if he struggles at any point.
 

RUScrew85

Heisman
Nov 7, 2003
30,054
16,939
0
Flood said today: "I don't want any player in our program looking over their shoulder worried that they would be pulled out of a game because they made a mistake. Right now Chris is the starting quarterback." I don't read those words and think both will be playing.

An earlier post implied both would play. I agree it looks like ridin the pine for Rettig.
 

IL Lusciato

Heisman
Oct 31, 2011
10,680
13,292
0
I think you've lost some credibility with this post. Saying that people here would rather see CL kicked off the team is absurd. You initially seemed pretty reasonable with your argument for supporting Laviano, but you've just gotten as bad (if not worse) than the Rettig supporters you're criticizing.

I don't think it is absurd at all. These people have gone from tearing down the kids TD pass, to now quoting criminal statutues regarding fake IDs on this board. and resorting to saying that his rule violation should be a reason to sit him. I honestly do not doubt they would stop at anything to get what they want. Laviano cannot do anything right apparently.
 

IL Lusciato

Heisman
Oct 31, 2011
10,680
13,292
0
Because we're a fan board and everyone has an opinion. If people would just let everyone voice their opinion it wouldn't be an issue. Instead, there are folks who feel the need to constantly remind those who have voiced an opinion in favor of Rettig that (a) they aren't at practice, (b) didn't coach and/or (c) have no idea what they are talking about because of (a) and/or (b).

It is not b/c people are "voicing opinions" it is b/c people are straight up saying Flood is biased and has a problem since he picked the QB is is "clearly" the lesser talent and destined to fail eventually.

When people make those types of statements, and make them as if they are undisputed fact, as they have on this board all day today - That is when they should be reminded they are not at practice every day and dont coach.
 

ScarletNYC

All-Conference
Jul 31, 2008
10,497
1,538
113
It is not b/c people are "voicing opinions" it is b/c people are straight up saying Flood is biased and has a problem since he picked the QB is is "clearly" the lesser talent and destined to fail eventually.

When people make those types of statements, and make them as if they are undisputed fact, as they have on this board all day today - That is when they should be reminded they are not at practice every day and dont coach.
You say this as if Flood has never displayed bias when it came to QBs. Is it going to take 8 more mentions of the Dodd/Nova scenario?
 

fatknightfatty

Redshirt
Sep 7, 2015
12
13
0
10 year lurker, season ticket holder, but first time poster. A friend recently visited the CFHOF and sent me this picture. Thought it was relevant to this forum (and thread) for so many reasons.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Maryland Eastern Shore Press Conference