Laviano to start

May 11, 2010
72,487
56,953
0
And Rettig will get time too, he should since he earned it IMO.

I really think the locker room leans towards Laviano.

As a fan, I 100% root for every player that's on the field for Rutgers.

I'd like to see each QB get somewhat equal snaps and lead us to victory.
 

koleszar

Heisman
Jan 1, 2010
38,502
61,085
113
I have to believe this was always the plan. Flood can spin it all he wants but if Laviano doesn't get suspended I believe he would have started Norfolk as well. I think the decision was made a while ago. I think Flood fells more comfortable with Laviano's knowledge of the playbook. I do hope however, that with a legit second option he will not do what he did with Nova. I believe he had no choice in that situation. If he does I will be pissed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MidwestKnights

KJRU

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2001
3,098
1,149
113
All things being equal, the guy that didn't break the rules should get the nod. Nothing against Laviano and he might do well but this is one of the reasons why Flood can't control this team. The message is do what you want, without consequences...unless of course, the university forces me to impose consequences, no wonder the players love him.
 

Raritan83

All-Conference
Sep 6, 2011
1,688
1,468
0
I personally disagree after this weekend but will support whoever is out there. To me if it was a tie give it to the one who didn't break the rules. Plus with our WR core give it to the one with arm strength to allow leonte, Andre and janarion stretch the field.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KJ_RU

miklosru

Sophomore
Nov 16, 2006
147
121
0
Bad decision! Flood is attached to Laviano just like he used to be attached to Nova. Retting could have made the difference. The season is over with this decision.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU_27

rufeelinit

All-Conference
May 16, 2010
12,647
4,351
0
He'd better have a reasonable explanation for Rettig to keep him onboard and ready to go. Sounded like some at the stadium thought Rettig needed some one on one time with McDaniels on the sidelines when he realized he was not starting in the second half. I would have thought he would have been told before the came on the field.
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,838
50,365
98
All things being equal, the guy that didn't break the rules should get the nod. Nothing against Laviano and he might do well but this is one of the reasons why Flood can't control this team. The message is do what you want, without consequences...unless of course, the university forces me to impose consequences, no wonder the players love him.
Wasn't the suspension the consequence? Should he not play Caroo either? Your post is idiotic on all levels.
 
May 11, 2010
72,487
56,953
0
Bad decision! Flood is attached to Laviano just like he used to be attached to Nova. Retting could have made the difference. The season is over with this decision.

You honestly believe that?
Come off the ledge and root for Laviano to have a great half and that hopefully Flood gives Rettig a lot of snaps too.

Let's remember, if the Norfolk LB didn't pull a James Townsend the first half score could have been different.
 

MS-RU

Heisman
Aug 9, 2013
9,530
14,225
67
I will yield to Flood's decision as he obviously knows best and I respect all of his decisions, but if Laviano begins to struggle or implodes one game people will be second guessing him and calling for Rettig immediately. Even if Flood claims the QB won't be a short lease, he will start feeling the heat VERY quickly especially because people are already split and saw that Rettig can play as well. It will be 100x worse than the normal "grass is always greener" with the backup QB.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ScarletNYC

GSGS

Heisman
Aug 2, 2001
29,450
23,891
113
Bad decision! Flood is attached to Laviano just like he used to be attached to Nova. Retting could have made the difference. The season is over with this decision.

I don't see the comparison with Nova, as Nova was by far the best QB on the RU roster during his time here. That said, I thought that Rettig would be the better choice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: satnom

BuggsyRU

All-American
Mar 22, 2007
7,057
5,668
0
Bad decision! Flood is attached to Laviano just like he used to be attached to Nova. Retting could have made the difference. The season is over with this decision.

I am a Rettig fan, but saying the season is over with this decision is stupid on so many levels.

1.) Laviano could perform very well, in which case the season is not over.
2.) Laviano could perform subpar, and Flood, who has already said he is not going to just stick with one QB no matter how much he is struggling, could insert Rettig early on.
3.) Laviano could face injury, which would put Rettig back in.

To say the season is over NOW i just silly.
 

jay_hq

All-Conference
Apr 24, 2010
6,817
3,401
0
I dont understand why we are all assuming:

1) It was Floods choice.
- Ben McDaniels, the Fridge, and Flood all made a decision together.

2) Laviano is Flood's guy.
- Uhhh. Flood recruited both Laviano and Rettig.

3) Flood just wanted Laviano all along.
- If this was the case then Laviano would have been named starter after the first week of summer practice. That was the plan. He could have named him the starter after week 2. Or week 3. Or week 4. Except he didn't.

4) This is a final decision set in stone.
- Uhh, no. It's not. Flood himself said both will play.

5) Laviano stares down Carroo and doesn't distribute the ball.
- Well if thats the case Ben McDaniels will have him pulled for Rettig. The competition will be never ending.
 

Ru2bnj

Sophomore
Apr 21, 2006
10,060
179
0
I'm fine with it, watching the game ...very difficult to tell who may be better. As others have mentioned, I think the decision is based more on who runs the offense better and Laviano has been around longer and probably has more support among team members. It doesn't really matter that much. If Laviano struggles a lot, i'm sure they will look to Rettig pretty quickly. The difference in years past is that Nova was clearly the best option the last few years....much different situation now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: winRU
Sep 29, 2005
14,051
16,131
0
Of course blitz didn't like it. Never anything positive. Laviano's punishment was not starting 1st game. So you are suggesting he be punished a second time. From my point of view, I don't know who should start as I don't see practices. Norfolk game by itself is not enough to gauge.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Proud NJ Sports Fan

KJRU

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2001
3,098
1,149
113
He'd better have a reasonable explanation for Rettig to keep him onboard and ready to go. Sounded like some at the stadium thought Rettig needed some one on one time with McDaniels on the sidelines when he realized he was not starting in the second half. I would have thought he would have been told before the came on the field.
Flood said after halftime that he needed to talk to the coaches to decide who was going to start the second half...IMO, he knew he was going to start Laviano but he wanted to portray this as a staff decision rather than his own. If Lav does well, great call by Flood. If he fails, it was a staff decision.

Personally, I hope exceeds beyond our wildest dreams but if you think this was a true competition, you're kidding yourself.
 
Sep 2, 2013
2,078
769
0
Ive got no problem with this whatsoever, as long as Rettig doesn't get the Chas Dodd treatment. ANYTHING to beat the Cougs. Rettig is too good to get locked in a cellar. If CL falters, you know you gotta make the switch. I know the whole 2 qbs = 0 qbs equation, but Flood put himself in this position by not making a decision in the spring. He is going to have to deal with this controversy for the rest of the season. Makes no difference to me as long as either guy kicks ***.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,185
90,330
113
Before fans get carried away with hyperbole, keep in mind that there is a LOT more that goes into the decision besides what you saw on the field Saturday, which was an important, but not all-determining component. This is not a terminal decision. It's the starter for game 2.

And please, let's not get carried away with what we think we saw from the stands with McDaniels and Rettig. So, nobody could ready numbers, but now we are reading lips, facial expression and minds from the stands?

Reminds me a Felix Unger in the plane--"I much fear serious trouble in the fuselage Frederick."
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,732
151,568
113
Bold move by Flood. Laviano better perform very well or the hook should come fast.

Hope we don't lose Rettig over this.
 

KJRU

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2001
3,098
1,149
113
Of course blitz didn't like it. Never anything positive. Laviano's punishment was not starting 1st game. So you are suggesting he be punished a second time. From my point of view, I don't know who should start as I don't see practices. Norfolk game by itself is not enough to gauge.
Imo, the punishment didn't fit the crime. To say he sat out the first half so he has already been punished is correct...but for a guy that is competing for the starting QB job to get a fake ID, break curfew, and go to a club obviously to get f××ked up. I'd say the punishment should've been more. Believe it or not I feel the same way about Caroo, he is a captain...he is the guy that is supposed to keep knuckleheads like Laviano under control.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sol Iustitiae

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,185
90,330
113
Imo, the punishment didn't fit the crime. To say he sat out the first half so he has already been punished is correct...but for a guy that is competing for the starting QB job to get a fake ID, break curfew, and go to a club obviously to get f××ked up. I'd say the punishment should've been more. Believe it or not I feel the same way about Caroo, he is a captain...he is the guy that is supposed to keep knuckleheads like Laviano under control.

You should choose your words more carefully. I know a lot of people who go to clubs that don't drink. Maybe he just wanted to hang out in the club. How can you say what you said if you were not there?
 

Pils86

All-Conference
Sep 21, 2008
1,840
1,412
113
I am OK with this as long as qb's are pulled if they are performing poorly. I was rooting for the best to win but wanted Lov because he committed to RU out of high school and is more of a local product. I thought the offense clicked with Lov and I don't remember any mistakes by him, and he showed wheels last year. Rettig looked real good but did need the TO's and I thought he held the ball long and the luxury of time we be decreased with better teams. I would definitely give the 2nd teamer, (even if it changes) one series per game to keep him fresh and keep up morale.

The Townsend reference above is classless.
 

NickKnight 1

All-Conference
Mar 22, 2003
8,778
2,052
0
So, Flood goes with the more experienced guy, so next year he goes with the
more experianced guy and their next year after that. Problem for Rettig he
is in the same year as Laviano and may not get a chance. Looks like another
Savage senerio. I think Rettig should get a chance, and not have to wait till Laviano blows it.
 

RU848789

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
65,459
44,500
113
Bad decision! Flood is attached to Laviano just like he used to be attached to Nova. Retting could have made the difference. The season is over with this decision.
I can't believe so many of you are responding to this troll with 8 posts (and yes, I know I'm responding, but only to point out the troll). NCAAballz anyone?
 

koleszar

Heisman
Jan 1, 2010
38,502
61,085
113
I dont understand why we are all assuming:

- If this was the case then Laviano would have been named starter after the first week of summer practice. That was the plan. He could have named him the starter after week 2. Or week 3. Or week 4. Except he didn't..
I should have clarified "that was the plan all along" time frame. I think the decision was made after the final scrimmage as both quaterbacks were pretty equal. Flood felt more comfortable with Laviano's grasp of the playbook and this decision is more risk adverse. I believe the suspension delayed this decision. You don't want to name him the starter than declare he's suspended, it put's things in a bad light. I don't believe there was anything Rettig could do in that first half to change their minds. Unless Laviano totally imploded in the second half.
 
May 11, 2010
72,487
56,953
0
Thinking out of the box, is it possible that Rettig has a hand/finger injury making that tackle on the fumble return?

Another thought, imagine you were Mr or Mrs Laviano while reading this thread?
 
  • Like
Reactions: IL Lusciato

JPhoboken

Senior
Mar 15, 2005
11,963
585
0
Bad decision! Flood is attached to Laviano just like he used to be attached to Nova. Retting could have made the difference. The season is over with this decision.
Don't know if season's over, that's way premature. But I do agree about being attached at the hip.
 

RUTBAY

Senior
Dec 14, 2006
2,616
472
0
Some people here make it seem as if this was Flood's decision in a vacuum and with no input from the other coaches. Although I think Rettig has more upside and I wanted him to start it was pretty clear that the playbook was opened in the second half when Laviano went into the game. It was McDaniels calling the plays not Flood. It was McDaniels increasing the tempo at the start of the second half. Based on what I saw yesterday it seems as if the OC feels more comfortable with Laviano. So much speculation going on here impugning the character and intent of Flood. How about this for speculation, did it ever occur to people here that the night those guys were caught missing curfew it was because Laviano was told he had won the position and that it was a celebratory night out with Carroo's full endorsement because he wanted Laviano throwing him the ball this year?

Personally I hope we never have a reason to pull Laviano the rest of the season. At the beginning of each year the QB competition should be open. It may well be that Rettig, after a year taking reps on something other than the scout team catches up and surpasses Laviano. If Rettig ever starts over Laviano I hope it is because the staff feels that the chances of winning go up even more than what they are seeing with Laviano rather than because Laviano has failed to perform well. Based on what I saw with Russo on TV I'm going to tell you right now, the kid is legit. Every ball right where he wanted it to be and a good long ball too. It may well be that neither Laviano nor Rettig see the field next year and if it happens that way I hope it is because Russo takes the position rather than the incumbent failing. Anyone hoping for Laviano to fail so that Flood looks bad is not a fan, and although everyone here will say they don't want that, the history of some of the contributors on this board says otherwise.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Maryland Eastern Shore Press Conference