Isiah Thomas traded for Kyrie

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
Man that's stupid. They made big strides picking up Hayward and Irving, but they can potentially get so much better still....and they will have to if they want to compete with GSW.


Agreed. Stevens has done pretty incredible so far .having Boston in the conference finals last year ? Very nice. He's also still superrrrr young and already making his mark.

After the next 3-4 years (if Lebron stays with Cle) OR if Lebron goes elsewhere (Western Conf) after next year Boston will be top of the food chain in the east. Couple that with SIX first round draft pics in the next few years ?? Not to mention possibly being able to do another trade etc ... Boston is back on the up and up (idk if / when?the Lakers get there )

All that being said is why I absolutely don't think Stevens would come back to college (it was downright comical seeing MANY IU fans honestly think he was considering IU lol ok ) .
I don't even think he'd come back for Duke or UK seeing as how it seems as if he's gonna make a very positive mark in the NBA
 

Catzman

Heisman
Apr 29, 2002
17,530
14,705
113
Am I missing something? Did Cleveland just rob Boston and Boston is cool with it? Someone who knows more about the NBA, please explain what I'm missing. Cleveland to me looks like they just got the better end of the deal by a mile. One player, who's a literally a loser (only wins with LBJ) for all of that?

I have to admit though, I'm glad to see LeBron getting support in Cleveland. After his first run, I was curious how serious they'd take surrounding him with good players and future draft picks. If they can really get a top 3 pick and land a Bagley/Ayton to go along with Crowder and IT, LeBron will be a very happy man for many more seasons.
 

DSmith21

Heisman
Mar 27, 2012
8,297
13,024
0
Am I missing something? Did Cleveland just rob Boston and Boston is cool with it? Someone who knows more about the NBA, please explain what I'm missing. Cleveland to me looks like they just got the better end of the deal by a mile. One player, who's a literally a loser (only wins with LBJ) for all of that?

I have to admit though, I'm glad to see LeBron getting support in Cleveland. After his first run, I was curious how serious they'd take surrounding him with good players and future draft picks. If they can really get a top 3 pick and land a Bagley/Ayton to go along with Crowder and IT, LeBron will be a very happy man for many more seasons.

This article is a pretty good breakdown of the trade. It's an +A for the Cavs and a B grade for the Celtics.

"...Irving is a great scorer who is also young with a better contract status than Thomas moving forward....
the deal is far from a failure for Boston. Irving is an upgrade over Thomas, his deal runs through next season, and his age is better aligned with Boston’s core. The Celtics also did well to hold on to Jayson Tatum and Jaylen Brown, two promising forwards who can be valuable contributors—and who also leave the door open for future trades.

It’s a good trade for the Celtics, but not necessarily a great one. It pushes them slightly closer to a Finals berth, which is an interesting push considering the team seemed intent on waiting out LeBron a few months ago. But with James’s future in the East in question, Boston is looking at a potentially wide-open conference in the near future with a talented young core that still has some flexibility for more moves."


https://www.si.com/nba/2017/08/22/kyrie-irving-isaiah-thomas-cavaliers-celtics-trade-grades-analysis
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
That reasoning is ridiculous. Cavs are a C at best, and frankly we won't know how this pans out for them until LBJ makes his next "decision". CLE had to downgrade and collect assets because their management is garbage, Kyrie demanded a trade, and in hopes to cover their *** if Lebron decides to leave. This was making the best out of a bad situation, which is what that article points on right off top, so no, you cannot just ignore all that. An A+ deal would be if Cleveland managed to add a blue chipper to their super core so they could compete with GSW and remain the King of the pathetic east. Not only did they bow out of the championship talk and regress, they gave more power to BOS who will now attempt to overthrow CLE to become the East's only hope against the West.

So yea, good for the losers who managed to get something out of nothing after caving to Kyrie's orders. Good luck rebuilding. This trade is all about Danny Ainge and the chess moves he made to pull off something like this. And he ain't even close to finished.
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
I hated Danny Ainge for a long time, and he was absolutely gifted the Big 3 by a former Celtic, but he's earned this one. Unreal what he, and Stevens, accomplished with that rag tag bunch of players while acquiring 2309732948 picks and setting himself up for this offseason...and they're still in prime position to build on that.
 

UKUGA

Heisman
Jan 26, 2007
18,505
26,810
0
They will because a number 1 pick for cousins is better than him leaving and getting nothing

I agree. But, we will see how the season goes.

Pelicans should be good enough to avoid this chatter and actually make the play-offs and put up a fight.

Davis and Cousins are really, really good. It's akin to having Sampson and Olajuwon, if handled correctly.
 

weatherbird

All-American
Aug 1, 2006
5,929
9,558
113
While Cleveland's front office has been a joke, they got the better end of this deal. not that Boston got hosed, but Cleveland did better. Irving hasn't even made the playoffs without LBJ, but he also didn't have the talent around him that he will have in Boston. Irving is a ball dominate guard who plays little defense and is a little self-absorbed. He likely would be better outside of the LBJ shadow, so this is likely a good deal for Boston. However, with LBJ on the team, there won't be much drop off in switching Irving for Thomas, plus Cleveland picks up some extra pieces, and a likely top 3 pick which they will either use in a trade to make a run now, or hold onto to potentially snag Bagley/Porter/Ayton. LBJ won't be in Cleveland a lot longer, regardless of what happens next offseason, as he only has a few years left in the tank anyway. The draft pick, if not used in a trade, jumpstarts their rebuilding efforts with a top pick in one of the most talent rich drafts at the top in some time. The IT contract also allows them to totally shed salaries next year should LBJ leave. They have an opportunity to make cap space, snag Bagley, and then turn around and get Barrett the year after due to not being any good whatsoever. Then having shed all those salaries, could draw in a superstar free agent the year after, and reduce the rebuild to 3-4 years.

As for the Boston homer in this thread, @Mashburned this is no where near the great trade deal you are making it out to be for Boston. Irving is really good, and will likely be better than IT for Boston, he isn't the difference maker, and it's possible that Boston just gave Cleveland Bagley along with the other pieces to a conference rival. Now Boston is a couple of years away anyway, as they wait on Tatum and Brown to develop, and hope that they can hold onto Irving during that time. But if they can do that, they would have a really good core, but not sure it will be enough to win a championship. It generally takes one megastar, with two superstars, and some really good role players to win one, and I'm not sure who the mega star would be. In 2-3 years we can look back at this trade and determine who really got the better end of the deal, but for right now, at least on the surface, Cleveland got the better end of the deal.
 

UKUGA

Heisman
Jan 26, 2007
18,505
26,810
0
While Cleveland's front office has been a joke, they got the better end of this deal. not that Boston got hosed, but Cleveland did better. Irving hasn't even made the playoffs without LBJ, but he also didn't have the talent around him that he will have in Boston. Irving is a ball dominate guard who plays little defense and is a little self-absorbed. He likely would be better outside of the LBJ shadow, so this is likely a good deal for Boston. However, with LBJ on the team, there won't be much drop off in switching Irving for Thomas, plus Cleveland picks up some extra pieces, and a likely top 3 pick which they will either use in a trade to make a run now, or hold onto to potentially snag Bagley/Porter/Ayton. LBJ won't be in Cleveland a lot longer, regardless of what happens next offseason, as he only has a few years left in the tank anyway. The draft pick, if not used in a trade, jumpstarts their rebuilding efforts with a top pick in one of the most talent rich drafts at the top in some time. The IT contract also allows them to totally shed salaries next year should LBJ leave. They have an opportunity to make cap space, snag Bagley, and then turn around and get Barrett the year after due to not being any good whatsoever. Then having shed all those salaries, could draw in a superstar free agent the year after, and reduce the rebuild to 3-4 years.

As for the Boston homer in this thread, @Mashburned this is no where near the great trade deal you are making it out to be for Boston. Irving is really good, and will likely be better than IT for Boston, he isn't the difference maker, and it's possible that Boston just gave Cleveland Bagley along with the other pieces to a conference rival. Now Boston is a couple of years away anyway, as they wait on Tatum and Brown to develop, and hope that they can hold onto Irving during that time. But if they can do that, they would have a really good core, but not sure it will be enough to win a championship. It generally takes one megastar, with two superstars, and some really good role players to win one, and I'm not sure who the mega star would be. In 2-3 years we can look back at this trade and determine who really got the better end of the deal, but for right now, at least on the surface, Cleveland got the better end of the deal.

I didn't read every word, but that's a pretty good take.

Funny thing: I've heard it said before that the best way to evaluate a trade is to ask: "Who got the best player?"

On the surface, Boston acquired the best player. Accordingly, they are okay with this deal, I'm pretty sure of that.

But, there is a rational argument for Thomas being better than Irving. That's step one.

Next, you can't simply look at best player in this deal. You can't. The NBA is designed now to force teams to look much deeper than that. Given salary caps, tax penalties, trade restrictions, draft picks, etc., there is more to building a team than simply acquiring the largest conglomeration of talent.

To that point, both teams actually did a nice job. Boston goes out and acquires a legitimate all-start and former #1 over-all pick, moving past a team of well-coached, over-achievers, to a team that now has 2-3 actual NBA stars, with additional young talent/future stars.

Cleveland "threaded the needle" (to steal a phrase from another article) by adding talent, increasing salary flexibility, and adding future talent in the form of a draft pick.

In 2018, either of these teams has a chance to be better than the prior year, or a little worse, depending on how it all comes together for both teams.

What's neat about this deal, is the conference rivalry serves as a motivation for both teams, and both sets of traded players to perform.

Seriously, this is a great, great deal for the league and the eastern conference, just a few months after one of the most moribund play-off seasons we have witnessed in recent memory.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big_Blue79

DSmith21

Heisman
Mar 27, 2012
8,297
13,024
0
It generally takes one megastar, with two superstars, and some really good role players to win one, and I'm not sure who the mega star would be. In 2-3 years we can look back at this trade and determine who really got the better end of the deal, but for right now, at least on the surface, Cleveland got the better end of the deal.

Generally agree with what you say about the Celtics. You did leave out Gordon Hayward (another All-Star) as part of the core. Along with Irving, they have two young (25 & 27) perennial All-Stars plus two guys that are expected to be studs in Brown & Tatum (20 & 19). Then top that off with 6 first round draft picks over the next three drafts and you could have a monster in the making. Boston will be very good now but their best is still about two years away.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
Yup. They got an all NBA player, a decent wing forward with a favorable contract, and what has a very good chance of being a top 5 pick. Damn nice coup for a player that publicly asked to be traded.

I'm just waiting for ITs hip results in Sept that may lead to his career essentially being over. I think the only reason Boston made the trade is they knew.
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
If he fails the physical, does the deal fall thru?

I have no idea what the physical actually entails but this is from right before the trade happened.

http://boston.cbslocal.com/2017/08/21/celtics-isaiah-thomas-hip-injury-brad-stevens-update/

I'm also not sure how much time Cleveland has to evaluate him before the trade is final. Based on everything Boston gave up i'm pretty sure his health was discussed and Cleveland knew the risk going in.

ETA: if the Celtics were trying to hide it or anything I doubt they're Coach would be discussing it on a podcast as the trade talks were happening.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MWes11

king of cali

All-Conference
Nov 24, 2005
6,955
3,877
0
As I understand it, all players have to be able to pass a physical. If any of the players don't pass then the trade is voided. But maybe Boston and Cleveland already have something worked out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GoCatsForever2k15

GoCatsForever2k15

All-Conference
Jun 7, 2015
3,082
1,895
0
Penalties for what? Cleveland is allowed to do a medical exam on him.

Again, I'm not privy to NBA rules and regulations, but I can't imagine Boston is allowed to intentionally trade a player it knows has a career ending injury without disclosing that fact. I would think Boston would be punished for something like that.
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
Again, I'm not privy to NBA rules and regulations, but I can't imagine Boston is allowed to intentionally trade a player it knows has a career ending injury without disclosing that fact. I would think Boston would be punished for something like that.

lmao
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
Irving is really good, and will likely be better than IT for Boston,

That's all that matters. Boston is one step closer to challenging GSW.

CLE is one step away, and likely heading back to the dumpster.

They had Love-Irving-LBJ. It's looking like they will have none shortly. BOS had no superstars, they now have Hayward and Kyrie, plus they have room to add LBJ if he wanted to go there, they can get Boogie, etc...they have all the juice to be the super team of the east.

I have no idea what y'all are talking about. This league now more than ever takes super teams. We just saw that with CLE. They had the super team. It fell apart because CLE sucks as a franchise. Now BOS is looking to move up and overtake CLE...which they will have to prove, but they certainly have the momentum moving forward.

I just can't understand how blowing up a super team, losing your #2, likely losing your #1, and publically trashing your #3 is "good". Then adding IT and a first round pick acting like that sets you up for the future. They will likely make the playoffs lmao. GREAT WORK!
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
Again, I'm not privy to NBA rules and regulations, but I can't imagine Boston is allowed to intentionally trade a player it knows has a career ending injury without disclosing that fact. I would think Boston would be punished for something like that.

As I said above Stevens was on a podcast a couple days before the trade happening and said IT was questionable and would need to be reevaluated in Sept. I don't think they were hiding much. To me it makes the deal make a lot more sense.
 

GoCatsForever2k15

All-Conference
Jun 7, 2015
3,082
1,895
0
That's all that matters. Boston is one step closer to challenging GSW.

CLE is one step away, and likely heading back to the dumpster.

They had Love-Irving-LBJ. It's looking like they will have none shortly. BOS had no superstars, they now have Hayward and Kyrie, plus they have room to add LBJ if he wanted to go there, they can get Boogie, etc...they have all the juice to be the super team of the east.

I have no idea what y'all are talking about. This league now more than ever takes super teams. We just saw that with CLE. They had the super team. It fell apart because CLE sucks as a franchise. Now BOS is looking to move up and overtake CLE...which they will have to prove, but they certainly have the momentum moving forward.

I just can't understand how blowing up a super team, losing your #2, likely losing your #1, and publically trashing your #3 is "good". Then adding IT and a first round pick acting like that sets you up for the future. They will likely make the playoffs lmao. GREAT WORK!

They didn't "blow up" a super team. They traded a great, disgruntled point guard for another really, really good all-NBA point guard who's maybe a slight down grade, plus a solid wing player, plus a pretty valuable pick (that they can package and use to trade for another player who's ready to compete now or keep and use to start building for the future).

What does "publically calling out your #3" and "likely losing your #1" have anything to do with the trade itself? No ones saying Cleveland is a well-run franchise, but as far as this individual trade goes, you have to intentionally try to be dense to not see that they got the better end of the deal
 

GoCatsForever2k15

All-Conference
Jun 7, 2015
3,082
1,895
0
As I said above Stevens was on a podcast a couple days before the trade happening and said IT was questionable and would need to be reevaluated in Sept. I don't think they were hiding much. To me it makes the deal make a lot more sense.

Think you're latching on too much to the punishment thing. Assuming Boston knows that he has a career ending injury right now, which was your original premise, one of two things will happen:

1) physical will catch it and the trade will be undone.

2) physical won't catch it, it'll manifest later, and Cleveland will file some type of claim/petition against Boston for not disclosing, which could (and should) result in Boston getting punished.
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
Generally agree with what you say about the Celtics. You did leave out Gordon Hayward (another All-Star) as part of the core. Along with Irving, they have two young (25 & 27) perennial All-Stars plus two guys that are expected to be studs in Brown & Tatum (20 & 19). Then top that off with 6 first round draft picks over the next three drafts and you could have a monster in the making. Boston will be very good now but their best is still about two years away.


I agree with this. Which is also why I don't think there's a chance in hellll Stevens comes back to coach UK (or college in general)
 

king of cali

All-Conference
Nov 24, 2005
6,955
3,877
0
Dude, Boston is not "one step closer" to challenging Golden State. That's just silly talk. It can be argued that they fell another half step behind Cleveland.

They didn't add 2 superstars. They added 2 very good players. One an all offense no defense player, and the other a good offense and a little player. They lost there 2 best perimeter defenders, both 3 and D guys. They lost their best big off the bench, and he was also a plus 3 point shooter. They're depending on Brown and Tatum to take huge leaps forwards. They were already a poor rebounding team and got even worse in that department. Put the Boston bias aside and tell us how that is "one step closer" to challenging Golden State.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
Think you're latching on too much to the punishment thing. Assuming Boston knows that he has a career ending injury right now, which was your original premise, one of two things will happen:

1) physical will catch it and the trade will be undone.

2) physical won't catch it, it'll manifest later, and Cleveland will file some type of claim/petition against Boston for not disclosing, which could (and should) result in Boston getting punished.

What about the possibility that Cleveland already knows as well?
 

GoCatsForever2k15

All-Conference
Jun 7, 2015
3,082
1,895
0
What about the possibility that Cleveland already knows as well?

...Cleveland already knows that a player they just traded for's career is finished? I think that's pretty unlikely, but I'd completely guess and say they're waiting to see and confirm via the physical, at which point they'd either undo the trade or waive the physical results and keep him because they couldn't get anything better at this point than a cheap crowder and a top pick.
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
What does "publically calling out your #3" and "likely losing your #1" have anything to do with the trade itself?

Everything, because this trade for both teams is about 2-3 years from now. Will Kyrie stay? idk, id say doubtful for now, but that depends on what other moves boston makes. I don't see him being a "brad stevens system guy", but same thing was said about 6th man gunner IT. CLE has more questions. Do they keep lebron and somehow rebuild to beat GSW again? Idk if they have pieces to do that, but anybody could be willing to come play with LBJ. We'll see. But as of now, BOS absolutely has that momentum and a more favorable outlook after this trade. CLE is dumping, BOS is building. That's really all we know.

Has nothing to do with next year. Neither of these teams are competing outside of the lowly East. And, I don't believe any East team conquering Lebron this year, or even next year....unless Boston adds more, which they can, and I would expect them to. CLE could as well, but looks more difficult to do at this point. BOS set up better to compete vs West in the near future.
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
...Cleveland already knows that a player they just traded for's career is finished? I think that's pretty unlikely, but I'd completely guess and say they're waiting to see and confirm via the physical, at which point they'd either undo the trade or waive the physical results and keep him because they couldn't get anything better at this point than a cheap crowder and a top pick.

I'd go with the latter.
 

GoCatsForever2k15

All-Conference
Jun 7, 2015
3,082
1,895
0
Everything, because this trade for both teams is about 2-3 years from now. Will Kyrie stay? idk, id say doubtful for now, but that depends on what other moves boston makes. I don't see him being a "brad stevens system guy", but same thing was said about 6th man gunner IT. CLE has more questions. Do they keep lebron and somehow rebuild to beat GSW again? Idk if they have pieces to do that, but anybody could be willing to come play with LBJ. We'll see. But as of now, BOS absolutely has that momentum and a more favorable outlook after this trade. CLE is dumping, BOS is building. That's really all we know.

Has nothing to do with next year. Neither of these teams are competing outside of the lowly East. And, I don't believe any East team conquering Lebron this year, or even next year....unless Boston adds more, which they can, and I would expect them to. CLE could as well, but looks more difficult to do at this point. BOS set up better to compete vs West in the near future.

:alien:
 

DSmith21

Heisman
Mar 27, 2012
8,297
13,024
0
Will Kyrie stay? idk, id say doubtful for now, but that depends on what other moves boston makes. I don't see him being a "brad stevens system guy", but same thing was said about 6th man gunner IT.

Both Boston and Irving say that a contract extension is likely. Of course, they could trade him if he isn't a fit.

"Adrian Wojnarowski of ESPN reported Irving is "thrilled" to join the Celtics, and the team will have a "great chance" to re-sign him."


http://bleacherreport.com/articles/...ed-to-be-with-celtics-boston-plans-to-re-sign
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
I guess they probably wouldn't have made this move if they thought it wouldnt' be a long term relationship. So now they just need the next big piece. Can they get Paul George like they originally wanted? I assume LBJ will not take his talents to BOS...Boogie is a name that always pops up, but I can't ever seen Ainge doing that...unless Stevens and Boogie had a great understanding.
 
Jan 29, 2003
18,120
12,185
0
I think Crowder in particular, and maybe Thomas, too, are about to suffer the fate of Colin Kaepernick.

No, not that fate. Kaepernick looked like a fantastic quarterback early on. Ron Jaworski famously said he could be the best ever, or among them. All of that was under Jim Harbaugh. Once Harbaugh left the 49ers, CK got very ordinary very quickly.

So, I think Brad Stevens is a genius. Really. I think in terms of sheer X and O, of strategy, he is so far ahead of every other coach on the planet, college or pro, that whomever is in second place is just a spec on the horizon. I think he is obviously capable of making his players look much better than they really are. And I think a year from now the typical comment about Crowder - and maybe IT too - will be something like "man, I thought he was better than that - what happened to that guy?".....
 

MWes11

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
12,025
10,106
0
I think Crowder in particular, and maybe Thomas, too, are about to suffer the fate of Colin Kaepernick.

No, not that fate. Kaepernick looked like a fantastic quarterback early on. Ron Jaworski famously said he could be the best ever, or among them. All of that was under Jim Harbaugh. Once Harbaugh left the 49ers, CK got very ordinary very quickly.

So, I think Brad Stevens is a genius. Really. I think in terms of sheer X and O, of strategy, he is so far ahead of every other coach on the planet, college or pro, that whomever is in second place is just a spec on the horizon. I think he is obviously capable of making his players look much better than they really are. And I think a year from now the typical comment about Crowder - and maybe IT too - will be something like "man, I thought he was better than that - what happened to that guy?".....

 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Duke fans want to get rid of Jon Scheyer after getting blasted by Illinois
  2. 02 KSR Basketball A 69-year-old record held by Kentucky legend Grady Wallace was broken last night
  3. 03 KSR Basketball Indiana takes down John Calipari, Arkansas ahead of showdown with Kentucky in Indy
  4. 04 KSR KSR Show, 11/18: Ask Anything Wednesday, live from 10-noon
  5. 05 KSR Basketball Heshimu Evans arrested on domestic violence charge in Lexington