Isiah Thomas traded for Kyrie

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
They had leverage. They had him under contract for 3 years.

IT is FA at the end of next season. That's a big part of the reason why Boston had to pay up in this deal.

It's not just about player v. player.

The Cavs probably had legitimate offers from a dozen teams for Kyrie. The fact that they traded him - in August - to the team they just faced off against in the ECF tells you a whole lot about how Cleveland viewed Boston's trade package.

LBJ/Gilbert gave that up when they agreed to trade him....which is stupid, but if LBJ and him can't deal, then that's that. And they had no legit offers.
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
That's per 20 teams that were interested in him. Nobody could offer what Boston could. Largely because Boston has done such a great job building assets in order to complete a trade like this. And they still have a #1, right?
 

StubbornPenny

All-American
Nov 2, 2009
10,562
9,892
0
The more I look at this trade, the more I see Cleveland getting an absolute steal.

Irving/Thomas

I see a lot of hate on Thomas here. Tell me ONE thing the Cavs lose by replacing Kyrie with Thomas.

Defense? No, both players have a 112 Defensive rating (points given up per 100 possessions). Thomas' +/- is actually higher than Irving (both are net negatives on a defense). Nether is good at all, but Thomas is slightly better. What difference does being 5'8'' make if Irving plays defense like he's 5'8'' anyway?

Shooting? Eh. Irving has a moderate advantage on shooting threes, percentage wise (though he did manage to shoot a poor 32% just two years ago). Thomas is respectable and should see more open looks with LeBron. Here's an odd one though: Thomas' true shooting % is 62.5% while Irving is at 58%. Why? Thomas does not shoot many midrange jumpers, Irving does. Thomas hits a higher percentage of the ones he does shoot. Irving nullifies his advantage by taking worse shots. Thomas also shoots over double the amount of free throws Irving does, and hits a crazy high percentage (90%). Irving also shoots 90%, he just takes 350 less free throws. Conclusioj: Every time you see Irving take a long jumper, that's when Thomas would be driving. I'd rather have the driving.

Other stuff? Thomas' PER has been better for three straight years. Thomas does more overall - hell, he even out rebounds Irving. The raw assist numbers are close, but Thomas assists on a much higher percentage rate when he's on the floor. Again, all of this is really an indictment on Irving because he at least has some size. They shouldn't be this close.

Honestly, any way you cut it, the two players are not very different save for 7 inches of height... and if you aren't defending, who cares about your height?

1st round pick
Can't believe Cleveland got this. Lets say this year goes really well: trade the pick midseason for a star on a dead end team (Cousins perhaps, if he makes it clear he won't resign with New Orleans). Maybe the Knicks would be dumb enough to let go of Porzingas. Maybe OKC is in the tank and George is available. Maybe you can trade it with your albatross contracts.

Let's say the year goes badly and LeBron is gone. You have a top 3 pick to work with in your rebuild. So many options for a team that had very few just a couple weeks ago.

Crowder and the other dude

Good value getting Crowder, he's the 3 and D guy Cleveland needed. The other guy is a prospect, but he is 7 feet tall and if he can block a shot or two, he'll be useful to some degree.

All in all, I'm not really sure why Boston did this deal now. They were going to get to the Eastern Conf Finals regardless. They may have been able to get more for it. Even weirder that the two condtenders in the East swapped players. Each side must be REALLY convinced that they got the right guy.
 

UKUGA

Heisman
Jan 26, 2007
18,505
26,810
0
That's per 20 teams that were interested in him. Nobody could offer what Boston could. Largely because Boston has done such a great job building assets in order to complete a trade like this. And they still have a #1, right?

So, if it wasn't as good as Boston's offer, then it wasn't a "legitimate" offer?

Got it. Thanks.
 

UKUGA

Heisman
Jan 26, 2007
18,505
26,810
0
The more I look at this trade, the more I see Cleveland getting an absolute steal.

Irving/Thomas

I see a lot of hate on Thomas here. Tell me ONE thing the Cavs lose by replacing Kyrie with Thomas.

Defense? No, both players have a 112 Defensive rating (points given up per 100 possessions). Thomas' +/- is actually higher than Irving (both are net negatives on a defense). Nether is good at all, but Thomas is slightly better. What difference does being 5'8'' make if Irving plays defense like he's 5'8'' anyway?

Shooting? Eh. Irving has a moderate advantage on shooting threes, percentage wise (though he did manage to shoot a poor 32% just two years ago). Thomas is respectable and should see more open looks with LeBron. Here's an odd one though: Thomas' true shooting % is 62.5% while Irving is at 58%. Why? Thomas does not shoot many midrange jumpers, Irving does. Thomas hits a higher percentage of the ones he does shoot. Irving nullifies his advantage by taking worse shots. Thomas also shoots over double the amount of free throws Irving does, and hits a crazy high percentage (90%). Irving also shoots 90%, he just takes 350 less free throws. Conclusioj: Every time you see Irving take a long jumper, that's when Thomas would be driving. I'd rather have the driving.

Other stuff? Thomas' PER has been better for three straight years. Thomas does more overall - hell, he even out rebounds Irving. The raw assist numbers are close, but Thomas assists on a much higher percentage rate when he's on the floor. Again, all of this is really an indictment on Irving because he at least has some size. They shouldn't be this close.

Honestly, any way you cut it, the two players are not very different save for 7 inches of height... and if you aren't defending, who cares about your height?

1st round pick
Can't believe Cleveland got this. Lets say this year goes really well: trade the pick midseason for a star on a dead end team (Cousins perhaps, if he makes it clear he won't resign with New Orleans). Maybe the Knicks would be dumb enough to let go of Porzingas. Maybe OKC is in the tank and George is available. Maybe you can trade it with your albatross contracts.

Let's say the year goes badly and LeBron is gone. You have a top 3 pick to work with in your rebuild. So many options for a team that had very few just a couple weeks ago.

Crowder and the other dude

Good value getting Crowder, he's the 3 and D guy Cleveland needed. The other guy is a prospect, but he is 7 feet tall and if he can block a shot or two, he'll be useful to some degree.

All in all, I'm not really sure why Boston did this deal now. They were going to get to the Eastern Conf Finals regardless. They may have been able to get more for it. Even weirder that the two condtenders in the East swapped players. Each side must be REALLY convinced that they got the right guy.

Good post.

I think Boston did the deal now because of the uncertainty surrounding Thomas' contract and his injury history.

At the end of the day, they feel much more comfortable with Irving going forward than they did Thomas.

I'm a little surprised about the #1, too.

But, Tatum hasn't played a minute yet. And they may really expect great things.

Plus, they still have the Lakers #1 pick to play with next year.
 

UKUGA

Heisman
Jan 26, 2007
18,505
26,810
0
So, is Boston's offer good?

Yes. It's better than good. It's so good that Cleveland was willing to trade its all-star PG to a conference rival.

Accordingly, there could have been other offers that weren't as good, that would still have been "legitimate".
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
lmao

I think Boston did the deal now because of the uncertainty surrounding Thomas' contract and his injury history.

So, you believe this trade, in Danny's eyes, centered around Isiah Thomas' circumstance and not the fact that a blue chip superstar PG just became available for trade ASAP?
 

MWes11

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
12,025
10,106
0
Good post.

I think Boston did the deal now because of the uncertainty surrounding Thomas' contract and his injury history.

At the end of the day, they feel much more comfortable with Irving going forward than they did Thomas.

I'm a little surprised about the #1, too.

But, Tatum hasn't played a minute yet. And they may really expect great things.

Plus, they still have the Lakers #1 pick to play with next year.
True. But let's not forget that Irving is injury prone at well. He has never played more than 75 games/year. And I get that some of those are due to rest, but he is averaging 63 games/year. Coincidentally, IT is also averaging 63 games/year. The past two year, IT has played 76 and 82 games. Irving has played 53 and 72 games. Irving is 3 years younger, too.
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
Thanks. I never go there. Don't want to give them publicity.

Yeah man, fo sho, I never in a MILLION years would have thought you frequented the scout UL forum. I can tell from your posts n what not you're a true blue Cats fan and wouldn't be saddled down with that ridiculousness !
 
  • Like
Reactions: WildcatDJ

UKUGA

Heisman
Jan 26, 2007
18,505
26,810
0
lmao



So, you believe this trade, in Danny's eyes, centered around Isiah Thomas' circumstance and not the fact that a blue chip superstar PG just became available for trade ASAP?


No. I don't think it centered Isaiah's circumstance. I do think it was a factor.

I think Isaiah's circumstance is part of what drove up the price for Irving.
 

UKUGA

Heisman
Jan 26, 2007
18,505
26,810
0
True. But let's not forget that Irving is injury prone at well. He has never played more than 75 games/year. And I get that some of those are due to rest, but he is averaging 63 games/year. Coincidentally, IT is also averaging 63 games/year. The past two year, IT has played 76 and 82 games. Irving has played 53 and 72 games. Irving is 3 years younger, too.

I think the concern with ITs injury history is the way he broke down at the end of the play-offs last year, essentially rendering the Celtics uncompetitive in their last few games.

Plus, he's small and throws his body around. Not a good recipe for long-term durability.
 

StubbornPenny

All-American
Nov 2, 2009
10,562
9,892
0
Good post.

I think Boston did the deal now because of the uncertainty surrounding Thomas' contract and his injury history.

At the end of the day, they feel much more comfortable with Irving going forward than they did Thomas.

I'm a little surprised about the #1, too.

But, Tatum hasn't played a minute yet. And they may really expect great things.

Plus, they still have the Lakers #1 pick to play with next year.

Forgot about the Lakers. There's a lot of odd qualifiers that go with that one, so I guess that's why it didn't get traded. Why does the league enjoy giving Boston draft picks? The Lakers are idiots.. essentially two draft picks to take Lonzo Ball. I don't even care if he's good, that's two lottery picks for one guy.

I'm surprised Cleveland was able to get so much having been put in a "trade me" situation. I must be one of the few who think KI is very overrated.
 

UKUGA

Heisman
Jan 26, 2007
18,505
26,810
0
Forgot about the Lakers. There's a lot of odd qualifiers that go with that one, so I guess that's why it didn't get traded. Why does the league enjoy giving Boston draft picks? The Lakers are idiots.. essentially two draft picks to take Lonzo Ball. I don't even care if he's good, that's two lottery picks for one guy.

Ummm.

Not sure what you are talking about.

Lakers traded nothing for Lonzo Ball. They used their own pick based upon their poor performance from 2017 + lottery luck.


I think you may be referring to Philly trading picks to draft Fultz #1 over-all.

But hey, being wrong gave you a chance to bash Lonzo Ball and/or the Lakers, which is perhaps what you really wanted to do, whether you were accurate or not.
 

bluedog79

All-American
Mar 4, 2008
6,015
5,290
0
I wouldn't give you a sack of dog turds for I. Thomas. He sucks badly at defense and Ulis would kick his freaking *** ALL DAY long on a basketball court. That's a fact. A Huskie will NEVER outdo a WILDCAT mfers!
never.

I wish Ulis was the guy going to play with Lebron. Instead he gets Huskies and Blue devils.....inferior players.

Hell Id even say.. Bledsoe > Thomas. Thomas scoring 28 a game says more about the league than it does about Thomas.
That's my two cents...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: mashburned

StubbornPenny

All-American
Nov 2, 2009
10,562
9,892
0
Ummm.

Not sure what you are talking about.

Lakers traded nothing for Lonzo Ball. They used their own pick based upon their poor performance from 2017 + lottery luck.


I think you may be referring to Philly trading picks to draft Fultz #1 over-all.

But hey, being wrong gave you a chance to bash Lonzo Ball and/or the Lakers, which is perhaps what you really wanted to do, whether you were accurate or not.

Eh just not remembering how that whole draft deal went down. It happens in my ripe old age of 36. Either way, the rest of the league just loves giving draft picks to Boston.

And Lakers front office really sucks.
 

StubbornPenny

All-American
Nov 2, 2009
10,562
9,892
0
I wouldn't give you a sack of dog turds for I. Thomas. He sucks badly at defense and Ulis would kick his freaking *** ALL DAY long on a basketball court. That's a fact. A Huskie will NEVER outdo a WILDCAT mfers!
never.

I wish Ulis was the guy going to play with Lebron. Instead he gets Huskies and Blue devils.....inferior players.

Hell Id even say.. Bledsoe > Thomas. Thomas scoring 28 a game says more about the league than it does about Thomas.
That's my two cents...

Bledsoe is quite underrated. Had a PER better than Paul George last year, and teams went after him hard. For Bledsoe, it all comes down to who thinks he can stay on the floor.
 

*Fox2Monk*

Heisman
Jun 10, 2009
49,275
91,081
113
True. Maybe Boston won't be able to mess with CLE till LBJ ages a few more years, Idk. But Brad Stevens almost got it done with a bunch of role players. Now he's got legit pieces. Not far away from competing in the West.

IT is on the best contract in the league. in the future yes but in the now no.

CLE had it all, had the super team, but now they're at the mercy of lebron who (for some damn reason I can't understand) was/is hellbent on tearing it apart and starting over. So they're having to cut their losses and do the best that they can.

If LBJ didn't like Kyrie, how in the world is he gonna like IT? I guess because IT will just do whatever he's told bc he doesn't have the pedigree to run a team, but he's a fiery lil guy who's getting paid wayyyyy too much. Will be interesting. Back to the mo williams/larry hughes days but LBJ is older with a bit more help...and the league is officiated totally differently now allowing guys like IT to prosper.
 

*Fox2Monk*

Heisman
Jun 10, 2009
49,275
91,081
113
Kyrie brought CLE and LBJ championship in miraculous fashion against the damn Warriors.

Lebron in no way contributed to that win. His block was nothing in that game. His defense on that one play is greater than the sum of Kyries entire life of D.
 

*Fox2Monk*

Heisman
Jun 10, 2009
49,275
91,081
113
Just gonna throw this out there. It seems those that hate in IT either don't watch the NBA, argue that rules enable him to score or that they prefer wildcat players to whoever they are pitted against. You can't suck, be an all-star, and average 29 a game. It doesn't happen. LINSANITY was a fluke. IT has demonstrated his scoring based on stats for years so he is not a fluke.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
Nobody said he sucks. Just pointing out why it took IT, 2 more players, and a 1st rd pick to get him. Funny how quick things quickly went sour in Cleveland. Why couldn't they have added a free agent to help get them over GS again? They just blew it up for Isiah Thomas. That's weird.
 
Aug 9, 2017
169
218
0
Nobody said he sucks. Just pointing out why it took IT, 2 more players, and a 1st rd pick to get him. Funny how quick things quickly went sour in Cleveland. Why couldn't they have added a free agent to help get them over GS again? They just blew it up for Isiah Thomas. That's weird.


Because they already know James is gone. Starting the rebuild a year ahead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
Its t nets unprotected pick which will end up being very high lottery and best chance at number one. Important because the top of that draft is strong too.


Ya, I realized that later last night. It very well looks like the nets are going to be awful thus getting a top 3 ish pick... which is another reason (imo ) the Cavs were the winners in this trade deal .
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
IT finished 5th in the MVP race last year and was the most clutch player in the league last season. Alot of people in this thread hailing the greatness of Kyrie are some of the same people who have in the past said he was inefficient and overrated , he's leaving Lebron and he's great?
http://official.nba.com/2016-17-nba-annual-award-voting-results/


I think (possibly ) the bias towards Lebron is ... clouding/ impairing people's judgment on the matter lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: MWes11 and UKUGA

HenryMuto

Heisman
Mar 31, 2012
20,705
14,002
113
That seems way too high for Irving. The only thing I can think is that he's got 3 years on his contract. I have no idea what Isaiah has left. Maybe that was a factor?

Kyrie has basically only 2 years left on his deal he is likely to opt out after 2 years (3rd year player option).

Thomas has 1 year left on his deal and wants a max deal and coming off injury so that is why Boston dealt him.

I am a Cleveland fan and Kyrie was one of my favorite players to watch but he burned the bridge here and wasn't coming back so the Cavs got the most they could. I think the Cavs did great to get what they did considering the situation.

Still see Cavs not beating GS but who the hell is ?

Need Curry or Durant to go down to have any shot.
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
Kyrie has basically only 2 years left on his deal he is likely to opt out after 2 years (3rd year player option).

Thomas has 1 year left on his deal and wants a max deal and coming off injury so that is why Boston dealt him.

I am a Cleveland fan and Kyrie was one of my favorite players to watch but he burned the bridge here and wasn't coming back so the Cavs got the most they could. I think the Cavs did great to get what they did considering the situation.

Still see Cavs not beating GS but who the hell is ?

Need Curry or Durant to go down to have any shot.

Are there any "rumors" etc as to why Kyrie wasn't happy ? What happened ? It was always presumed that the drama was between Love and Lebron
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
Cavs have been shopping him for a while, which is nothing new or surprising. The rumor is Kyrie found out through a third party, and didn't like the fact Lebron didn't let him know, so he sulked about it, then eventually demanded a trade...

Which I find a little hard to believe, unless Kyrie is just very naive. I mean Lebron publically wanted Love gone, and that franchise is a joke. Maybe Kyrie thought he was gonna stay forever. Doubtful.

The more logical and realistic rumor is Kyrie simply wanted to be the PG of a team, to have the ball and run the offense. Understandable. Plus the fact Lebron is not loyal and Kyrie probabaly knew he wasn't gonna stay in bum *** Cleveland and keep a dynasty going.
 

*Fox2Monk*

Heisman
Jun 10, 2009
49,275
91,081
113
Ya, I realized that later last night. It very well looks like the nets are going to be awful thus getting a top 3 ish pick... which is another reason (imo ) the Cavs were the winners in this trade deal .

No doubt with the situation they were put in to have a chance this year and a trade chip to add additional pieces or a total rebuild after lebron is crazy good.
 

DSmith21

Heisman
Mar 27, 2012
8,297
13,024
0
That's per 20 teams that were interested in him. Nobody could offer what Boston could. Largely because Boston has done such a great job building assets in order to complete a trade like this. And they still have a #1, right?

Even after the Irving trade, Boston is going to have 6 first round draft picks in the next three drafts. They are building for the future. Irving being 3 years younger and a better player than Thomas fits that building plan.

Cleveland got a great deal but both Thomas and Crowder only have one year left on their contracts. So after this year, Cleveland could be left with only that first round pick plus Antic.

https://www.boston.com/sports/boston-celtics/2017/06/20/celtics-future-draft-picks-list
 
Mar 23, 2012
23,493
6,068
0
If you just look at the pieces involved in the deal and nothing else, I still think they gave up too much, mainly because of the draft pick. But you can't just look at the deal in a vacuum and ignoring the effects it has on other aspects.

If they don't trade Thomas and try to keep him next summer, he gets a max deal and the Celtics are stuck with the roster they have and are likely having to pay the luxury tax. They also would likely lose Marcus Smart because they just wouldn't be able to afford to pay him after the Thomas max contract. The only way they would have a chance of adding another key player is with trades or the Brooklyn draft pick, which does likely net them a pretty good player but draft picks are always an unknown quantity that are more likely to not be who we thought they were going to be.

But to trade Thomas and get anything remotely close to the same talent level, they were very likely either going to have to trade him for a stud on a rookie contract (and that's not happening) or trade him for an established All-Star making more and then have to add more players to the deal to get the salaries to match since the Celtics are either right at the cap or over it. It's one of the rare cases where you wish a player was actually making MORE money. Sure, an All-Star on a team friendly contract is a possibility, but how many of those exist? It's a pretty small # and those players are obviously going to be extremely difficult to trade for.

Either way, they were 1) going to sign him to a max contract and destroy their financial flexibility, 2) lose him for nothing in free agency, or 3) trade him and lose some talent along with him.

Trading him was by far the best option though, especially with the concerns about his hip. Getting an All-Star like Kyrie on a somewhat team friendly contract (makes under $20M a year which is a bargain for an All-Star) gives them more flexibility in free agency going forward. Now Marcus Smart, if they decide to retain him, is affordable next summer. And given how much Brad Stevens likes him, hard to imagine them not retaining him. This also opens up more playing time for Brown and Tatum, two wings with a much higher ceiling than Crowder. It also opens the way for Semi Ojeleye to potentially carve out a role, and he is a similar type player to Crowder and he is a better player coming into the league than Crowder was when he came into the league.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball A 69-year-old record held by Kentucky legend Grady Wallace was broken last night
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Indiana takes down John Calipari, Arkansas ahead of showdown with Kentucky in Indy
  3. 03 KSR KSR Show, 11/18: Ask Anything Wednesday, live from 10-noon
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Heshimu Evans arrested on domestic violence charge in Lexington
  5. 05 KSR KSR Today: Mark Pope previews Indiana, Will Stein previews Missouri