Isiah Thomas traded for Kyrie

UKUGA

Heisman
Jan 26, 2007
18,505
26,810
0
It's a good trade for the league. Adds some drama to the Eastern Conference, which was certainly lacking it last spring.
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
Yep. With Brooklyn pretty much guaranteed to stink next season, this puts the Cavs in the mix for Bagley, Porter and whomever else.

Strange that Boston didn't wanna give up that pick for Paul George, but they did for Irving.

They believe they can keep Irving. George would have been a one year rental.
 

king of cali

All-Conference
Nov 24, 2005
6,955
3,877
0
They believe they can keep Irving. George would have been a one year rental.

They also could have gotten Butler for it. To be so against including that pick with the other deals, but use it for a taller version of the player you traded away is not something you see everyday.
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
They also could have gotten Butler for it. To be so against including that pick with the other deals, but use it for a taller version of the player you traded away is not something you see everyday.

Taller, younger, and healthier (as of right now). And IT has already mentioned "back up the Brinks truck" after next season.

Not sure about what was on the table for Butler deal. I believe the trades were more centered around picks in this past draft.

It's a gamble for the Celtics for sure but maybe they know more about ITs injury than we do.
 

MWes11

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
12,025
10,106
0
Also saw this floating around our there... Cavs could trade the Nets pick they just got (High 1st rounder), as well as Shumpert and Frye to New Orleans for Boogie. Also a strong possibility that Wade joins the Cavs. Then you have...

I. Thomas
Wade
LeBron
Love
Boogie

Rose
Crowder
T. Thompson
JR Smith
Korver
 
  • Like
Reactions: LineSkiCat14

UKUGA

Heisman
Jan 26, 2007
18,505
26,810
0
It's a neat trade.

From the Celtics perspective, they "sold high" on IT. Trading a guy coming off a surprising career year, one year before he becomes a FA and demands max money. He already is developing a nice injury history, which makes him a long-term question mark.

Acquiring Irving nets them a more established star, who importantly, has won a title. Irving remains under contract for a few more years, which allows the Celtics to move forward with the peace of mind that he will be in a Celtics uniform at a price they know in the near term.

However, by trading Crowder, they give up a piece that was both useful to them, and will be useful playing alongside Lebron (and still with IT).

Also, the Nets pick is a nice piece. The Nets might win a few more games this year, but it's still a potential #1 pick that both teams now wait anxiously to see what happens with it.

The Celtics kept waiting, and this is what they got. Not so sure it was worth the fuss, especially since they did cave on the Nets pick.

Of course, they still have the Lakers pick next year, and that may end up being a nice asset, as well.

For the Cavs, they do a nice job of sticking with "win now" and getting pieces to help in a potential rebuild.

They can do whatever they want with that Nets pick at this point, so it will be fun to see what happens.

Just as some have noted that Stevens gets the max out of his players, it can be argued that playing with Lebron elevates a player's performance as well.

This could make for a really fun play-off series next year, and elevates the level of drama in Cleveland, now that Irving is gone, but still nearby.
 

wentzel25

Senior
Feb 13, 2006
3,896
560
0
Also saw this floating around our there... Cavs could trade the Nets pick they just got (High 1st rounder), as well as Shumpert and Frye to New Orleans for Boogie. Also a strong possibility that Wade joins the Cavs. Then you have...

I. Thomas
Wade
LeBron
Love
Boogie

Rose
Crowder
T. Thompson
JR Smith
Korver
0% chance Pelicans do that deal. No way, no how.
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
0% chance Pelicans do that deal. No way, no how.


Yeah that would be awesome for the cavs but I don't see the pelicans giving away arguably the top center in the league (at least top 3) for a high first round pick and a couple of "decent" players.
 

MWes11

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
12,025
10,106
0
0% chance Pelicans do that deal. No way, no how.
Wait till the deadline gets here and the pelicans are on the verge of being out of the playoff picture in the West, then we will circle back around on this. Nets almost certainly will have a top 3 pick so they can get one of Bagley, Ayton, Porter Jr. with that pic, plus dump Boogie's $ on Cleveland.
 

CELTICAT

Heisman
May 21, 2002
19,499
19,706
113
No bias from you at all I'm sure :joy:

What did kyrie do before Lebron blessed him with his presence??

What did Lebron do before Wade? Sometimes younger guys figure out the keys to success by learning from other winners. Kyrie was spectacular two finals ago and hit the game 7 game winner.

And yeah, of course I'm biased. It's sports, not math homework. I also don't see any Celtics fans down in the mouth over the trade. Everyone is acting like its highway robbery for the Cavs, but guess what, Irving is better than Rose and IT.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cgutta

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
Boston goes down to CHI because of IT last year if Rondo didn't get hurt. IT is the most overrated player in the league. Can't defend anybody, can be shutdown by a good defender... and let's say for some reason the league goes away from protecting guards and lets perimeter d check offensive players again, IT is back to being an off the bench 3pt specialist nobody.

I hate Kyrie, but he's taking CP3's spot on the PG totem pole. Plus Hayward. Man the Celtics improved a ton. They are no longer the scrappy underdog fan favorites. They are legit. We'll see if their chemistry takes a hit, but I don't see any reason why it would.
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
Kyrie was spectacular two finals ago and hit the game 7 game winner.

This was hailed by some as "the passing of the torch"...lmao like Lebron would entertain that. Nope. GTFO Kyrie.

I actually think Lebron stays in CLE, and it won't be as fun as he tries to rebuild again with this scrubby IT/Crowder bunch. He's still gotta get Love out and somehow attract 3 new superstars. Sure as heck wont' be able to flip IT again for something close to Kyrie, and they'll have to pay IT lmao.

Lebron/Kyrie put CLE in a bad spot where they had no leverage and had to deal Kyrie for pennies.

Danny Ainge looking brilliant.
 

MWes11

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
12,025
10,106
0
Boston goes down to CHI because of IT last year if Rondo didn't get hurt. IT is the most overrated player in the league. Can't defend anybody, can be shutdown by a good defender... and let's say for some reason the league goes away from protecting guards and lets perimeter d check offensive players again, IT is back to being an off the bench 3pt specialist nobody.

I hate Kyrie, but he's taking CP3's spot on the PG totem pole. Plus Hayward. Man the Celtics improved a ton. They are no longer the scrappy underdog fan favorites. They are legit. We'll see if their chemistry takes a hit, but I don't see any reason why it would.
While I do think IT is a little overrated, particularly on the defensive end, the things he can do on the court at his size are tremendous. I would consider John Wall a pretty good defensive point guard, yet he couldn't check IT at all in their series last year on the defensive end. IT averaged 29 ppg last year. He carried the Celtics the whole way through the playoffs while playing on a bad hip and dealing with a family death. There won't be much of a drop off at all as far as offensive output. Let's not forget that IT also lead the league in 4th quarter scoring throughout the regular season. The East is still the Cavs to lose as long as LeBron is on their roster. With Wade possibly joining him, it might give him incentive to stay in CLE. We will see.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaudylo

SuporChin

All-Conference
Mar 2, 2011
1,148
1,149
0
Also saw this floating around our there... Cavs could trade the Nets pick they just got (High 1st rounder), as well as Shumpert and Frye to New Orleans for Boogie. Also a strong possibility that Wade joins the Cavs. Then you have...

I. Thomas
Wade
LeBron
Love
Boogie

Rose
Crowder
T. Thompson
JR Smith
Korver
That team would be crazy to watch, but I'm not sure how they would beat Golden State. They have too much fire power to counteract.
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
True. Maybe Boston won't be able to mess with CLE till LBJ ages a few more years, Idk. But Brad Stevens almost got it done with a bunch of role players. Now he's got legit pieces. Not far away from competing in the West.

CLE had it all, had the super team, but now they're at the mercy of lebron who (for some damn reason I can't understand) was/is hellbent on tearing it apart and starting over. So they're having to cut their losses and do the best that they can.

If LBJ didn't like Kyrie, how in the world is he gonna like IT? I guess because IT will just do whatever he's told bc he doesn't have the pedigree to run a team, but he's a fiery lil guy who's getting paid wayyyyy too much. Will be interesting. Back to the mo williams/larry hughes days but LBJ is older with a bit more help...and the league is officiated totally differently now allowing guys like IT to prosper.
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
True. Maybe Boston won't be able to mess with CLE till LBJ ages a few more years, Idk. But Brad Stevens almost got it done with a bunch of role players. Now he's got legit pieces. Not far away from competing in the West.

CLE had it all, had the super team, but now they're at the mercy of lebron who (for some damn reason I can't understand) was/is hellbent on tearing it apart and starting over. So they're having to cut their losses and do the best that they can.

If LBJ didn't like Kyrie, how in the world is he gonna like IT? I guess because IT will just do whatever he's told bc he doesn't have the pedigree to run a team, but he's a fiery lil guy who's getting paid wayyyyy too much. Will be interesting. Back to the mo williams/larry hughes days but LBJ is older with a bit more help...and the league is officiated totally differently now allowing guys like IT to prosper.

How is IT overpaid? He most likely will be next year, that's part of the problem, but right now most would say he's underpaid considerably in relation to the overall NBA salary market.
 

MWes11

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
12,025
10,106
0
True. Maybe Boston won't be able to mess with CLE till LBJ ages a few more years, Idk. But Brad Stevens almost got it done with a bunch of role players. Now he's got legit pieces. Not far away from competing in the West.

CLE had it all, had the super team, but now they're at the mercy of lebron who (for some damn reason I can't understand) was/is hellbent on tearing it apart and starting over. So they're having to cut their losses and do the best that they can.

If LBJ didn't like Kyrie, how in the world is he gonna like IT? I guess because IT will just do whatever he's told bc he doesn't have the pedigree to run a team, but he's a fiery lil guy who's getting paid wayyyyy too much. Will be interesting. Back to the mo williams/larry hughes days but LBJ is older with a bit more help...and the league is officiated totally differently now allowing guys like IT to prosper.
So you think the Celtics got the better end of this deal? I see it the exact opposite way. The drop off at PG will not be that significant from Kyrie to IT, plus throw in a lockdown wing defender and capable 3 point shooter in Crowder. But here is the kicker, the Cavs will get a top 3, potentially #1, overall pick that they will have at their disposal come trade deadline time. Whether they want to hold on to the pick, or use it in a package deal for another borderline star, is up to them. Plus, don't be surprised if Wade jumps on board. Yeah, he is older now, but he is still a very capable SG in the NBA with plenty of finals experience. The team this year isn't even close to the mo williams/larry hughes team.

The Celtics are just hoping that LeBron leaves after this year, then they will run the East. That has to be their mindset, but if LeBron stays, the Cavs will still be the kings of the East.
 

fatguy87

All-American
Oct 8, 2004
13,764
9,093
0
With the Lebron window quickly closing, this was a must deal for the Cavs. It's easy to argue that Cavs got better at 2 of the their 5 starting positions with this deal. IT had a better season than Kyrie and Crowder, who has an very favorable contract, is >>>>>> than the JR/Shump/Richardson trio of ineptitude. The first round pick is icing on the cake.
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
Wait till the deadline gets here and the pelicans are on the verge of being out of the playoff picture in the West, then we will circle back around on this. Nets almost certainly will have a top 3 pick so they can get one of Bagley, Ayton, Porter Jr. with that pic, plus dump Boogie's $ on Cleveland.

Honest question
Are any of the top 3 potential draft pics better than cousins in your opinion ? Especially a duo of cousins and Davis ? Cousins is still young , established ... has been killing it in the league .., still in his prime. He Has several more years of being a top 1-4 big man in the league
 

Shaudylo

Heisman
Apr 2, 2011
11,555
26,020
112
Boston goes down to CHI because of IT last year if Rondo didn't get hurt. IT is the most overrated player in the league. Can't defend anybody, can be shutdown by a good defender... and let's say for some reason the league goes away from protecting guards and lets perimeter d check offensive players again, IT is back to being an off the bench 3pt specialist nobody.

I hate Kyrie, but he's taking CP3's spot on the PG totem pole. Plus Hayward. Man the Celtics improved a ton. They are no longer the scrappy underdog fan favorites. They are legit. We'll see if their chemistry takes a hit, but I don't see any reason why it would.
I'd consider Wall a great defender . Why did Thomas not get shutdown that series ?
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
So you think the Celtics got the better end of this deal? I see it the exact opposite way. The drop off at PG will not be that significant from Kyrie to IT, plus throw in a lockdown wing defender and capable 3 point shooter in Crowder. But here is the kicker, the Cavs will get a top 3, potentially #1, overall pick that they will have at their disposal come trade deadline time. Whether they want to hold on to the pick, or use it in a package deal for another borderline star, is up to them. Plus, don't be surprised if Wade jumps on board. Yeah, he is older now, but he is still a very capable SG in the NBA with plenty of finals experience. The team this year isn't even close to the mo williams/larry hughes team.

The Celtics are just hoping that LeBron leaves after this year, then they will run the East. That has to be their mindset, but if LeBron stays, the Cavs will still be the kings of the East.

You are seriously arguing IT is equal to Kyrie....which is why BOS gave up a role player and #1 pick to get a franchise PG who has yet to reach his prime.

And I've seen these arguments from the "stat guys". They are totally ridiculous. Read one guy equating IT to ALLEN IVERSON. All because of stats.

Who were Boston's scorers last year? How about Cleveland? Compare and contrast those teams for me. Style of play? Etc etc.

CLE got a peaked out glorified role player who they will now shell out max money to keep. A 4'6" max money "PG"...plus role player and pick. Because they suck and had no choice. Who is coming off hip surgery. Did he have surgery? Idk. Hip issues. And he plays in an era where you can't even touch the ballhandler.

But LBJ will run the east unless he runs off Love and continues to blow up this thing he helped create. He's trying his best.
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
Idk, probably has more to do with the fact that Washington as a team is abysmal, and Wall is far from a great defender. He's average to good. They don't play team defense or team offense, and it's largely because there is no on court chemistry between Wall and Beal - who both aren't the most heady players to begin with. Wall is ahead of Beal in the IQ department, but he's still mainly an instinctual physical force of nature who makes his team better by pressing the defense. Wizards are tough to watch. They have some nice talent, but no damn clue on the floor. It bothers me.

And I'm still not over the fact that John Wall lost to fn Truck Bryant in embarrassing fashion. The hardest game I've ever watched. Physically he's as good as anybody, but until he "gets it" you can't argue he's a better PG than guys like...and this pains so much...CP3 or Kyrie. Just a different "brand" of player. But I'm still drafting Wall before them and just not pairing him up with an idiot like Bradley Beal. Wall would also do a lot more damage in an old school officiated NBA league.
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
I am silly and very dumb. Dude really is trying to compare Kyrie and IT...based on nothing but stats. That's beyond dumb.
 

GoCatsForever2k15

All-Conference
Jun 7, 2015
3,082
1,895
0
I am silly and very dumb. Dude really is trying to compare Kyrie and IT...based on nothing but stats. That's beyond dumb.

You're using a single trade as evidence that kyrie torches IT. How is that any better than stats? You realize more goes into any given trade than just a straight up comparison of player talent, right?


You're dumb because you think kyrie is on another world than IT. That's wrong.
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
Another level, absolutely. Just starting naming the top tier PG's in the league. Plus the fact Kyrie is what? 25.

Again, that's why it cost BOS potential #1 pick + roles. And CLE had no leverage because they had to get rid of Kyrie.
 

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
If I had bias it would be against that dukie mfer who is a baby, isn't interested in D and reminds me way too much of my favorite most hated "nut tapping" PG whiny boy CP3.

Kyrie is 6'3" pure PG who can handle the ball better than anybody, and score with anybody. That's tough. Potentially, likely, he is going to end up better than CP3. I think he might could have too much "millenial" in him tho...idk if he's the competitor CP3 is.

IT is a circus act. Tough kid. Would not really exist if the league didn't change rules.
 

MWes11

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
12,025
10,106
0
I am silly and very dumb. Dude really is trying to compare Kyrie and IT...based on nothing but stats. That's beyond dumb.
Do I think Kyrie is a little better, yeah. But to think the gap is astronomical like you are implying is just plain stupid. Flip IT and Kyrie last year and the Eastern Conference finals is no different. And isn't the new thing PER? IT 26.5 KI 23. The gap is not as wide as you would like to think.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood

mashburned

Heisman
Mar 10, 2009
40,283
49,516
0
It's enough to warrant a #1 pick + player. That's about right.

Kyrie played with LBJ, btw. IT played with...Al Horford? Avery Bradley...

You can't compare stats. You can compare teams. IT was every bit as valuable, actually way more valuable to his team than Kyrie was to CLE. You can absolutley swap Kyrie and give LBJ IT, they wont' miss a whole lot, especially considering Kyrie was not interested in playing for LBJ and it showed. But Boston just added a legit top 5 PG to go along with Gordon Hayward and their upcoming youngsters. They did lose a lot of D, tho.

So Boston got a lot better...on paper, remains to be seen...than CLE who lost 1 of their "big 3", and will likely lose the last 2 pieces of their Big 3 soon.

This is only good for CLE because they have no choice, no leverage, no hope. Now they have a serviceable PG, role player plus a pick if/when the rest of their team falls apart. Then they can pay IT max money and rebuild around him :joy: because they are CLE.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CELTICAT

king of cali

All-Conference
Nov 24, 2005
6,955
3,877
0
Kyrie is 6'3" pure PG who can handle the ball better than anybody, and score with anybody. That's tough. Potentially, likely, he is going to end up better than CP3.

What??? To be better than CP3 wouldn't he have to impact the game the way CP3 does? Other than score, Irving doesn't impact the game at all. CP3 makes others better, something that Irving has never shown he can do, and he is one of the top defensive PGs in the league. Irving doesn't even reside in that same stratosphere.
 

MWes11

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
12,025
10,106
0
If I had bias it would be against that dukie mfer who is a baby, isn't interested in D and reminds me way too much of my favorite most hated "nut tapping" PG whiny boy CP3.

Kyrie is 6'3" pure PG who can handle the ball better than anybody, and score with anybody. That's tough. Potentially, likely, he is going to end up better than CP3. I think he might could have too much "millenial" in him tho...idk if he's the competitor CP3 is.

IT is a circus act. Tough kid. Would not really exist if the league didn't change rules.
The fact that you just called Kyrie a "pure" PG tells me all I need to know about your arguments. His handle is unreal and he can score the basketball, but to act like he makes his teammates better is absurd. My God, he has cracked the top 14 one time in assists since he has been in the NBA, and in the 20's more often than not. How the hell is IT a circus act? He lead a bunch of nobodies, minus an aging Al Horford, to the Eastern conference finals. Your hatred and disdain for IT is spewing out. Did he hurt you?
 

UKUGA

Heisman
Jan 26, 2007
18,505
26,810
0
Another level, absolutely. Just starting naming the top tier PG's in the league. Plus the fact Kyrie is what? 25.

Again, that's why it cost BOS potential #1 pick + roles. And CLE had no leverage because they had to get rid of Kyrie.

They had leverage. They had him under contract for 3 years.

IT is FA at the end of next season. That's a big part of the reason why Boston had to pay up in this deal.

It's not just about player v. player.

The Cavs probably had legitimate offers from a dozen teams for Kyrie. The fact that they traded him - in August - to the team they just faced off against in the ECF tells you a whole lot about how Cleveland viewed Boston's trade package.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WildMoon

Cowtown Cat

Heisman
Aug 23, 2015
24,412
55,795
100
Idk, probably has more to do with the fact that Washington as a team is abysmal, and Wall is far from a great defender. He's average to good. They don't play team defense or team offense, and it's largely because there is no on court chemistry between Wall and Beal - who both aren't the most heady players to begin with. Wall is ahead of Beal in the IQ department, but he's still mainly an instinctual physical force of nature who makes his team better by pressing the defense. Wizards are tough to watch. They have some nice talent, but no damn clue on the floor. It bothers me.

And I'm still not over the fact that John Wall lost to fn Truck Bryant in embarrassing fashion. The hardest game I've ever watched. Physically he's as good as anybody, but until he "gets it" you can't argue he's a better PG than guys like...and this pains so much...CP3 or Kyrie. Just a different "brand" of player. But I'm still drafting Wall before them and just not pairing him up with an idiot like Bradley Beal. Wall would also do a lot more damage in an old school officiated NBA league.
You sure you watched it? Truck Bryant didn't even play in that game. o_O

[laughing]
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Kentucky cranks up energy, leans into competition at practice after consecutive losses
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Zoom Action: What's going right/wrong for Kentucky + previewing Indiana
  3. 03 KSR Football Recruiting 4-Star Kentucky Commit Makes Surprise Visit to Louisville
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Jerone Morton nears Kentucky debut, Trent Noah officially week-to-week
  5. 05 KSR Volleyball Brooklyn DeLeye is SEC Player of the Year, Tuozzo Tabbed Libero of the Year