Toggle sidebar

Harbaugh v. Franklin

N

NebChicago

Sophomore
Oct 14, 2009
3,565
141
0
You know what's weird, is that people seem to be sure Harbaugh is a dead man walking after his crap start.
But I don't think anyone thinks James Franklin will get axed? Despite a worse start (W/Ls-wise)

Franklin has been at PSU for 7 years, and has a 67% win record
Harbaugh has been at UM for 6, and has a 69% win record.
Franklin has won the B10, and has a 3-6 bowl record.
Harbaugh has not, and has a 1-5 bowl record.
Franklin is not annoying.
Harbaugh IS Annoying with a capital "A".

Wonder if ADs are just going to assume 2020 is a huge asterisk, and not fire like crazy. Although tell that to Will Muschamp.
 
L

leodisflowers

Senior
Feb 25, 2011
14,801
808
0
NebChicago said:
You know what's weird, is that people seem to be sure Harbaugh is a dead man walking after his crap start.
But I don't think anyone thinks James Franklin will get axed? Despite a worse start (W/Ls-wise)

Franklin has been at PSU for 7 years, and has a 67% win record
Harbaugh has been at UM for 6, and has a 69% win record.
Franklin has won the B10, and has a 3-6 bowl record.
Harbaugh has not, and has a 1-5 bowl record.
Franklin is not annoying.
Harbaugh IS Annoying with a capital "A".

Wonder if ADs are just going to assume 2020 is a huge asterisk, and not fire like crazy. Although tell that to Will Muschamp.
Click to expand...

I'm not sure what is going on with Harbaugh, but if they are thinking of replacing Franklin they are idiots. He's done decent at PSU and this is a weird year. Especially in this day and age if you at least have the chance to contend you better stay put with your coach. No reason to even consider canning Franklin in my eyes.
 
R

RedCap_rivals330392

Heisman
Sep 29, 2001
75,439
12,977
0
One of the differences is that Michigan fans expect more than most other B1G teams with the possible exception of Ohio State.
 
Headcard

Headcard

Heisman
Feb 2, 2005
192,508
20,877
113
I think fans of Michigan and PSU will complain about their coaches, but neither is getting fired. Harbaugh may decide to go back to the NFL, but that is another story.
 
T

Trojanhorse13

Freshman
Oct 19, 2017
237
59
0
Harbaugh needs to beat Ohio State at some point. It wouldn't surprise me to see him take another job and resign rather than be fired.
 
T

TheBeav815

All-American
Feb 19, 2007
18,955
5,101
0
Michigan is in the same spot we are but with way more talent. Blue blood program, nobody can really explain why they aren't better. I'm absolutely shocked by how bad they are.

My suspicion is that Jim only knows WCO and pro-style play and he's a square peg in a round hole trying to recruit and execute spread offense. He needed to do his thing and get that Stanford offense going. Big sets, lots of run game, PA off that.

And stop me if you've heard this one before, but his fan base with lofty expectations didn't have the patience to wait for him to get players at RB and QB who could excel at that. They wanted the OC fired, change the system, up the tempo, points points points.
 
CornHub

CornHub

Heisman
Apr 12, 2017
24,090
29,828
113
TheBeav815 said:
My suspicion is that Jim only knows WCO and pro-style play and he's a square peg in a round hole trying to recruit and execute spread offense. He needed to do his thing and get that Stanford offense going. Big sets, lots of run game, PA off that.
Click to expand...
He tried this in his first few years at Michigan. It failed horribly because it's just too outdated. You're never going to beat OSU that way.
 
M

Mack In Motion

All-Conference
Jun 20, 2001
5,998
3,531
113
headcard said:
I think fans of Michigan and PSU will complain about their coaches, but neither is getting fired. Harbaugh may decide to go back to the NFL, but that is another story.
Click to expand...
This.

Don't like Harbaugh but he has been unable to stack up against Ohio State. Just like everyone else.
 
A

Antwill

All-Conference
Dec 18, 2004
4,450
1,085
113
I said Harbaugh would be gone in 5 years. Looks like he's right on schedule.
 
S

steinek11

All-Conference
Apr 18, 2004
13,517
1,253
113
headcard said:
I think fans of Michigan and PSU will complain about their coaches, but neither is getting fired. Harbaugh may decide to go back to the NFL, but that is another story.
Click to expand...
Does the NFL even want him? He's got a reputation for wearing people out. This Michigan performance has damaged his stock a lot
 
H

huskerhooligansdotcom

Senior
Mar 4, 2009
1,214
701
0
Harbaugh and Michigan DID beat Ohio State that one year... but the refs gave Ohio State a first down on 4th down when they were clearly short. I think his tenure would look a lot different if he had that one win against Ohio State. I wouldn't fire him.... he's done pretty well. I doubt they want to go back to the RichRod or Brady Hoke days.
 
S

schuele

All-American
Apr 17, 2005
21,124
5,734
0
While I would be happy if Penn State never won another game, this is really the first season Franklin has fallen short of expectations. Different story for Harbaugh.
 
otismotis08

otismotis08

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2012
12,613
2,740
113
PSU was nearly dead. Franklin put them back on the map quickly. This is a strange year, especially for him. PSU will give him a mulligan or two.

As long as the recruiting stays strong at UM, they will keep Jimmy. Unless Jimmy wants to leave on his own accord.
 
R

RedMyMind

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2017
12,390
1,506
0
huskerhooligansdotcom said:
It was a simpler time...
Click to expand...
oh those days...
 
R

RedMyMind

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2017
12,390
1,506
0
otismotis08 said:
PSU was nearly dead. Franklin put them back on the map quickly. This is a strange year, especially for him. PSU will give him a mulligan or two.

As long as the recruiting stays strong at UM, they will keep Jimmy. Unless Jimmy wants to leave on his own accord.
Click to expand...
Didn't O'Brien raise them from the dead?
 
H

hedonistimpulse

Junior
Jul 29, 2018
791
224
0
The 0-fer versus dynasty level Ohio State is a blow for Harbaugh, but he's also only 3-3 versus Michigan State during a span Michigan State finished or will finish unranked 4 of 6 seasons.

If you fire every coach because he can't beat a rival early in his career you're firing guys like TO, but Harbaugh's not winning most of the games Michigan wants to win and now they're losing ugly. The only thing that may save him is 2020 being 2020 and the UM administration giving him a mulligan because they're probably losing three more games this season if they play their full schedule + championship week and will finish with a worse record than Penn State by at least a couple games.
 
R

RedCap_rivals330392

Heisman
Sep 29, 2001
75,439
12,977
0
TheBeav815 said:
Michigan is in the same spot we are but with way more talent. Blue blood program, nobody can really explain why they aren't better. I'm absolutely shocked by how bad they are.

My suspicion is that Jim only knows WCO and pro-style play and he's a square peg in a round hole trying to recruit and execute spread offense. He needed to do his thing and get that Stanford offense going. Big sets, lots of run game, PA off that.

And stop me if you've heard this one before, but his fan base with lofty expectations didn't have the patience to wait for him to get players at RB and QB who could excel at that. They wanted the OC fired, change the system, up the tempo, points points points.
Click to expand...
I think Harbaugh has too quirky of a personality to motivate today's kids. Watching their game against Wisconsin I just didn't get the impression the Michigan kids were playing with any passion.

My best guess is that Harbaugh is going to escape to a head coaching job in the NFL after this season is over and that's how the Michigan "crisis" ends.
 
N

NebChicago

Sophomore
Oct 14, 2009
3,565
141
0
I wonder if the normal hair trigger firings we usually see will be neutered because these athletic departments will be so cash strapped with the lack of 2020 revenue, that they won't be able to stomach the massive buyouts?
 
R

RedCap_rivals330392

Heisman
Sep 29, 2001
75,439
12,977
0
NebChicago said:
I wonder if the normal hair trigger firings we usually see will be neutered because these athletic departments will be so cash strapped with the lack of 2020 revenue, that they won't be able to stomach the massive buyouts?
Click to expand...
They won't stop but I think they'll be fewer and more subdued this year then the past few years.
 
R

RedMyMind

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2017
12,390
1,506
0
huskerhooligansdotcom said:
When we got the new iMACs in my middle school computer lab, it felt like we were going into NASA's mission control room.
Click to expand...
I remember back in 1999/2000 when we would go to computer labs and try out all those space age search engines. There were 20 or so we were to try out. Now there are 2 or 3 used nowadays.
 
S

ssmill777

Junior
Nov 10, 2004
6,621
332
0
leodisflowers said:
I'm not sure what is going on with Harbaugh, but if they are thinking of replacing Franklin they are idiots. He's done decent at PSU and this is a weird year. Especially in this day and age if you at least have the chance to contend you better stay put with your coach. No reason to even consider canning Franklin in my eyes.
Click to expand...
Plus something like $35 million buyout
 
J

JohnRossEwing

All-American
Jul 4, 2013
11,899
5,284
0
Jim is annoying
James is fun

Jim can't beat MSU or OSU
James took over a program that everyone thought would never ever be good again (This was stupid, by the way)
 
B

Buff-alo

Sophomore
Feb 28, 2006
522
146
0
If Jim gets a shot at an NFL job he will walk. He wears out his welcome where ever he goes. I think Jim is a salesman that gets everyone to buy in, but then people figure how damn weird he is and his act wears out really fast. He won't let them fire him, he will walk and if this season continues to tank he is gone at the end of the year. Just not sure if there is an NFL team that will roll the dice on him.
 
L

litespeedhuskerfan_rivals19671

All-American
Aug 27, 2006
27,799
5,563
0
He has under performed at Michigan to date, but he has a pretty great resume overall. He will absolutely get a job in the NFL if he wants one. This year or next, but he will get one, IF, that"s what he wants.
 
T

TheBeav815

All-American
Feb 19, 2007
18,955
5,101
0
rss428 said:
He tried this in his first few years at Michigan. It failed horribly because it's just too outdated. You're never going to beat OSU that way.
Click to expand...
I think he's in that purgatory now where they can't commit to something long enough to get the right guys to run it and get good at doing it. Eventually you lose faith in the whole process. They look like a team that has quit on everything.
 
CornHub

CornHub

Heisman
Apr 12, 2017
24,090
29,828
113
TheBeav815 said:
I think he's in that purgatory now where they can't commit to something long enough to get the right guys to run it and get good at doing it. Eventually you lose faith in the whole process. They look like a team that has quit on everything.
Click to expand...
I would blame it on the defense. Don Brown's scheme has been exposed, but he has done nothing to change it.
 
CornHub

CornHub

Heisman
Apr 12, 2017
24,090
29,828
113
TheBeav815 said:
Well we at NU wouldn't know anything about that.
Click to expand...
Nebraska's scheme looks fine to me. Michigan's is too dependent on their corners playing man coverage. You just can't ask that of your corners in college football.
 
V

vic.valiant

Sophomore
Jun 9, 2010
654
134
0
The connected wealthy Alumni wont force it and the AD won't do it.

I believe his contract is up next year.

He may gracefully exit for the NFL at the end of this season if they work it out behind the scenes.

In the end the choice will be Harbaugh's.

The football culture at Michigan is gutless.

Go Blue!
 
V

vic.valiant

Sophomore
Jun 9, 2010
654
134
0
huskerhooligansdotcom said:
Harbaugh and Michigan DID beat Ohio State that one year... but the refs gave Ohio State a first down on 4th down when they were clearly short. I think his tenure would look a lot different if he had that one win against Ohio State.
Click to expand...
Word is that Harbaugh's meltdown during that game earn him a talking to from Jim Sr. who informed him that Harbaughs do not behave thus.

He hasn't been the same since.

Go Blue!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom