Whether or not Emmert can be objective is irrelevant. He has zero involvement with waiver decisions.
I know people like to portray Emmert as some boogeyman orchestrating corrupt dealings, but the reality is that he has pretty limited power in most situations.
The guy has proven himself to be pretty inept at times and yet has managed to stay securely employed and that’s because of what’s probably the primary responsibility of the NCAA President at this point. He’s there to serve as a human shield and limit the amount of criticism directed towards the schools.
He’s not a visionary. He’s not even a sound administrator. But there’s one thing he excels at and that is he’s a magnet for criticism that sometimes should be directed at university presidents instead of the NCAA.
As long as remains easy to hate, his job will likely be safe, but you also don’t have to worry about him interring with UK. That’s not why the schools keep him around.
If Sarr isn't declared eligible I'm going to lose a lot of my love for college basketball. I'm 26 and have been a die hard since I was 9-10, but i can't continue to invest so much personal interest in a sport that just seems to want to f**k us.
I'll still watch and continue to root for the cats every game but it's tiring investing so much when you know they're trying to screw you.
Sarr better be eligible.
If Sarr isn't declared eligible I'm going to lose a lot of my love for college basketball. I'm 26 and have been a die hard since I was 9-10, but i can't continue to invest so much personal interest in a sport that just seems to want to f**k us.
I'll still watch and continue to root for the cats every game but it's tiring investing so much when you know they're trying to screw you.
Sarr better be eligible.
I don’t think it’s cynical! Heck, look at how many schools that have been caught and only UL has been punished for anything! Duke, UNC, Memphis, LSU, Auburn, Arizona, NCState, and Creighton to name a few!My love for college basketball has really waned over the years. It’s just not the same game as it was when I was your age (90’s). I know there was corruption back then, but when programs got caught, they paid for it. Today, it seems like the NCAA has one set of rules for some programs and a different set for others. Part of it I’m sure is just me being more cynical as I get older. I will always root for the Cats, but I can’t get into watching other games like I use to.
Okay, so I get it, Emmert doesn't literally make every ruling in every situation that gets placed at the feet of the NCAA, but you can't tell me he doesn't get a vote, have a final say, or make time to step in and make a ruling.It’s not naive, it’s an informed opinion based on a clear understanding of NCAA governance. Ultimately, all NCAA decisions are made by the various committees, which consist of representatives from the member schools and conferences.
None of them work for the NCAA and none of them are accountable to Emmert. There’s a reason why Emmert felt he had to convince the Board to bypass the infractions process for Penn State. Emmert wanted them punished severely and he knew that if it went through the normal process, then he would have zero ability to influence that.
There’s also a bit of an issue with your understanding of some of the underlying facts here that seems to be coloring your view of things.
Emmert didn’t intervene regarding UK’s celebration of Cal’a 500th win. That was Dennis Thomas, chair of the Committee of Infractions and at the time, commissioner of the MEAC. That entire debacle had nothing to do with Emmert. Emmert’s done plenty of stupid things but that wasn’t one of them.
In terms of Kanter, go back and read the rules that were in place at that time. The NCAA applied the rules correctly, there were simply some issue with those. But for anyone to suggest it was some vengeful act perpetrated upon UK because Kanter didn’t attend Washington is frankly pretty absurd. By rule, Kanter received money in excess of limits set by the rules and both UK and the Kanter’s did not challenge this fact. Case closed.
They tried to argue that the Kanter’s didn’t want the money and that they held it without spending it, but those are completely irrelevant points based on the rules at that time. What mattered was did they receive excess money in the first place and the answer to that was yes. At the moment the money was transferred, Kanter’s eligibility was compromised and simply holding the money without spending it did not undo the damage according to the rules.
You can criticize the rules or the process that was put into place to guide decision making. Those are certainly fair game. But if you think this was a situation where UK was being specifically targeted, then you’re simply choosing to see whatever it is that you want to believe is true.
I like you, but I think you're wrong here. Emmert is the president of the NCAA, but you're saying he has no influence or pull??? Yeah, I don’t buy that for a second.If you thought I was defending Emmert, then you didn’t understand my point.
Emmert’s inept. Let’s get that out of the way right up front.
What I was responding to is the fact that a lot of UK fans think he’s pulling strings behind the scenes to help some schools or hurt others. Those fans are significantly over estimating how much power Emmert really has (and likely have never personally dealt with the NCAA on anything).
Emmert is an administrator and figure head who also provides the added bonus of being a nice, juicy target for criticism so that university presidents don’t have to deal with it. But he’s not exerting all of this influence behind the scenes because at the end of the day, he really doesn’t have that much power.
Representatives from the schools and conferences call the shots and they’re not taking orders from Emmert. They don’t answer to him nor to they hold him in high enough respect to give his opinion that much weight. That’s the reality of the situation.
If Sarr isn't declared eligible I'm going to lose a lot of my love for college basketball. I'm 26 and have been a die hard since I was 9-10, but i can't continue to invest so much personal interest in a sport that just seems to want to f**k us.
I'll still watch and continue to root for the cats every game but it's tiring investing so much when you know they're trying to screw you.
Sarr better be eligible.
UNCheat escaping without even a scolding is a scandal in itself, but let’s see what happens with KU, LSU, Memphis, etc. first.I don’t think it’s cynical! Heck, look at how many schools that have been caught and only UL has been punished for anything! Duke, UNC, Memphis, LSU, Auburn, Arizona, NCState, and Creighton to name a few!
That will happen.There is an SEC rule that says a player transferring into the conference must have two years of Eligibility remaining so Sarr will need a waiver from the SEC as well as the NCAA
[laughing]Free Sarr? Heck I would pay for Sarr at this point.
Why wait 2 months to tell UK? All the other transfers have been approved, so It's screw UK for as long as we can, then create a roadblock-temporary- we can't beat em but we can slow em down. If they knew this earlier why didn't they tell us? Screw the NCAA, one of these days they are gonna drive their last nail, and I hope I can be in the line to pee on their grave.There is an SEC rule that says a player transferring into the conference must have two years of Eligibility remaining so Sarr will need a waiver from the SEC as well as the NCAA
Wow. You’re older than your 90’s?My love for college basketball has really waned over the years. It’s just not the same game as it was when I was your age (90’s).
There is an SEC rule that says a player transferring into the conference must have two years of Eligibility remaining so Sarr will need a waiver from the SEC as well as the NCAA
That will happen.
Why wait 2 months to tell UK? All the other transfers have been approved, so It's screw UK for as long as we can, then create a roadblock-temporary- we can't beat em but we can slow em down. If they knew this earlier why didn't they tell us? Screw the NCAA, one of these days they are gonna drive their last nail, and I hope I can be in the line to pee on their grave.
Why wait 2 months to tell UK? All the other transfers have been approved, so It's screw UK for as long as we can, then create a roadblock-temporary- we can't beat em but we can slow em down. If they knew this earlier why didn't they tell us? Screw the NCAA, one of these days they are gonna drive their last nail, and I hope I can be in the line to pee on their grave.